Abstract
This chapter introduces the main methodological issues in the formation and development of the History of Management Thought (HMT). Here are the main questions that the history of management thought should answer: “Why and for What purpose has one or another management idea been proposed?” Why was it proposed at specifically this time and place? “Which conditions and circumstances have affected the emergence of a new management idea?” Here emphasis is being made on the relevance of increasing scientific validity in management decisions, the general and specific characteristics of HMT as a scientific, applied and educational discipline, the role and place of HMT in the history of science, issues of organization of research and methods of HMT development, source study and other issues of HMT are disclosed. Here the reader will get acquainted with the three main concepts of management thought—the models of the police, legal, and cultural states.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
See the materials of conferences on the HMT&B on the website of the Faculty of Economics of Lomonosov Moscow State University: https://www.econ.msu.ru/science/conferences/mciumb/.
- 2.
Bowden Bradley. Work, Wealth & Postmodernism: The Intellectual Conflict at the Heart of Business Endeavour. Palgrave Macmillan, 2018.
- 3.
One of the seminars on the topic of “Problems of historical development of planned economic management” was held in January 1986, at which the author of the tutorial made a presentation titled “Methodological problems of historical and management research” (see [2]).
- 4.
Marshev V.I. On methodological issues of social production management science. News of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Economics Series, 1985, № 5, pp. 3–16.
- 5.
Marshev V.I. History of management thought. Moscow, MGIAI, 1987 (see [3]).
- 6.
Vikhansky O.S. The historical experience of the development of the USSR national economy management system // Educational-methodical manual. Moscow: Moscow State University, 1988.
- 7.
In 1988 at the intersection of two specialties 08.00.05 and 08.00.02 (History of economic doctrines).
- 8.
Vikhansky O.S. on the topic “The content and logic of development of public production management systems”.
- 9.
Marshev V.I. on the topic “Development of views on the management of the Russian economy (1861–1900)”.
- 10.
10.24. History of management thought. The emergence and development of views on management within individual scientific schools. The relationship between the development of theoretical understanding of management and processes taking place in economic systems.
10.25. Historical development of management systems. The logic of development of management systems, factors that determine dynamics and direction of evolution of control systems. Comparative analysis of management systems in different socio-cultural and political environments. Historical experience of development of management systems in selected countries.
- 11.
Plato. Republic. Thesis: In 4 vol. М.: Thought, 1994, vol. 3, p. 130.
- 12.
Aristotle. Nikomakhova ethics. Thesis.: In 4 vol. М.: Thought, 1983, vol. 4., p. 259.
- 13.
As written in annotations by the editor of Aristotle’s (ibid, p.696).
- 14.
ibid, p.238.
- 15.
Almost by Socrates.
- 16.
In a game-theoretic meaning, i.t. individuals or legal entities.
- 17.
The term “structure” means a combination of elements and links between them.
- 18.
Or in a “Responsibility statement” with a written scope of authority and duties.
- 19.
Making and implementing of managerial decisions, communication, conflicts, leadership and business processes.
- 20.
The creator of the term “cyclicality” of three forms of state government is considered the ancient Greek philosopher Polybius (see, his treatise “Universal History”, second century BC [8]).
- 21.
Person or legal entity.
- 22.
In the form of a verbal or non-verbal command or decision.
- 23.
The following types of responsibility of the decision maker are identified: moral, material, legal, political.
- 24.
And much more complex, but with less risk of achieving, as achievable.
- 25.
Some examples will be given below.
- 26.
For example, family marriages registered in Civil Registry Offices and/or marriage unions registered in notary offices.
- 27.
- 28.
What many analysts, following Joseph Schumpeter, see the progressive refreshment of the market as a result of the disappearance of companies leading “economically useless lives”.
- 29.
- 30.
Peter Lawrence J. The Peter Principle, or Why things always go wrong. M.: Popurri; 2003.
- 31.
Ibid., p.2.
- 32.
Ibid., p.8.
- 33.
See materials of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development-2018 and the XI International Forum “AtomEXPO-2019” of the Rosatom State Corporation together with the “WorldSkilssRussia” Union and the BCG company: https://worldskills.ru/media-czentr/novosti/rosatom,-worldskills-russia-i-bcg-obedinyayut-usiliya-dlya-resheniya-globalnoj-problemyi-kadrovogo-deficzita.html and https://news.ru/economics/eksperty-poschitali-chislo-izbytochnyh-rabotnikov-v-rf/.
- 34.
- 35.
Further, we generalize and substantially supplement the similar theoretical considerations of K. Clausewitz, expressed by him about military historical experience in the treatise “On War” ([69], pp. 113–114).
- 36.
that is — life.
- 37.
Just like music or sports.
- 38.
First edition in 1954: Maslow, Abraham. Motivation and Personality. N.Y., Harper & Brothers, 1954.
- 39.
Since 1840, at the initiative of the famous mathematician, rector of the Kazan University Nikolai Lobachevsky.
- 40.
About H. Emerson will be discussed in more detail in Sect. 6.2 of the textbook.
- 41.
Who emigrated to the USA in 1906.
- 42.
See [114].
- 43.
- 44.
References
Trudy mezhdunarodnyh konferencij po Istorii upravlencheskoj mysli i biznesa EF MGU ((pod nauchnoj red. V.I.Marsheva). M.: Izd-vo MGU, 1996, 1998, 2000–2005, 2008–2019 gg. https://www.econ.msu.ru/science/conferences/mciumb/
Marshev VI (1986) Metodologicheskie problemy istoriko-upravlencheskih issledovanij. V sb. tezisov dokladov simpoziuma “Problemy istoricheskogo razvitiya planovogo upravleniya ekonomikoj” (15-17 yanvarya 1986 g.). Pushkino, Izd-vo Ekonomicheskij fakul’tet MGU, ss 3–6
Marshev VI (1987) Istoriya upravlencheskoy mysli. M., MGIAI
Mintzberg H (2009) Management. M. : EXMO
Leavitt HJ (1965) Applied organizational change in industry. In: March JG (ed) Handbook of organizations. Rand McNally, New York
Fayol’ A (1924) Obschee i promyshlennoe upravlenie. L.-M.
Polybius (1890–1899) Vseobshchaya istoriya. Perevod i primechaniya F.G.Mishchenko. SPb
Milyukov PN (1993) Ocherki po istorii russkoy kul’tury. M., Progress, T.1., s. 47
Penrose E (1952) Biological analogies in the theory of the firm. Am Econ Rev 42 (5):r 808
Greiner LE (1967) Patterns of organizational change. Harvard Business Review, May-June
Adizes Ickhak (2007) Upravlenie zhiznennym ciklo korporacii. M.: PITER
Kapecio Piter (2005) Komandy, kotorye vyigryvayut: kak iz gruppy absolyutno nepohozhih lyudej sozdat’ sverheffektivnuyu komandu. Izdatel’stvo: AST, Astrel’
Mintzberg H (2008) Managers not MBA’s. M., Olimp-Bizness
Sorokin P (2000) Sotsial’naya i kul’turnaya dinamika. SPb, s. 731 i dalee
Taleb N (2007) Chernyj lebed’. Pod znakom nepredskazuemosti. M., Kolibri
Taleb NN (2014) Antihrupkost’. Kak izvlech’ vygodu iz haosa. M.: Izd. Kolibri, Azbuka-Attikus
Whitrow GJ (1961) The natural philosophy of time. Thomas Nelson, London
Uitrou Dzheral’d (2003) Estestvennaya filosofiya vremeni. M.: Editorial URSS, 400s
Gerodot. Istoriya. Perevod G. A. Stratanovskogo, Leningrad, Nauka, 1972
Hvostov V (1919) Teoriya istoricheskogo processa. Moskva
Whewell W (1837) History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present times, vol 1. J.W. Parker, London
Kun T (1977) Struktura nauchnyh revolyutsiy. M
George CS (1972) The history of management thought (1st edn, 1968; 2nd edn). Prentice-Hal, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Marshev VI (1987) Razvitie vzglyadov na upravlenie hozyajstvom Rossii(1861-1900 gg.). Avtoreferat dissertacii na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni doktora ekonomicheskih nauk. Moskva, MGU imeni M.V. Lomonosova
Ivanovskiy VV (1883) Vstupitel’naya lektsiya v kurs ucheniya o vnutrennem upravlenii. Kazan’
Teylor F. Upravlenie predpriyatiem. M., 1903; Printsipy nauchnogo upravleniya. M., 1911; Administrativno-tekhnicheskaya organizatsiya promyshlennyh predpriyatiy. SPb, 1912; Nauchnye osnovy organizatsii promyshlennyh predpriyatiy. SPb, 1912
Gol’tsev V (1880) Uchenie ob upravlenii. ZH-l YUridicheskiy vestnik, Spb, №6, p 263
Stein L (1863–1868) Die Verwaltungslehre. Bd. I – VII, Stuttgart
fon Shteyn L (1874) Uchenie ob upravlenii i pravo upravleniya s sravneniem literatury i zakonodatel’stv Frantsii, Anglii i Germanii. (Per. s nemetskogo I. Andreevskogo). Spb
De la Mare (1722–1738) Traite de la Police. I–IV, Paris
Yusti GG (1772) Osnovaniya sily i blagosostoyaniya tsarstv, ili Podrobnoe nachertanie vsekh znanij, kasayushchihsya do gosudarstvennogo blagochiniya. CH. I-IV. SPb
Zonnenfel’s I (1787) Nachal’nye osnovaniya politsii ili blagochiniya. M
Zimmermann G (1848–1849) Die deutsche Polizei des neuzehnten Yahr hunderts. Hannover: Schlüter, Bd I–III
Rozhdestvenskiy NN (1840) Osnovaniya gosudarstvennogo blagoustroystva s primeneniem k rossiyskim zakonam. SPb
Platonov I (1856) Vstupitel’nye ponyatiya v uchenie o blagoustroystve i blagochinii gosudarstvennom. Har’kov
Leshkov VN (1885) Drevnyaya russkaya nauka o narodnom bogatstve i blagosostoyanii. M
Babst IK (1872) Izlozhenie nachal narodnogo hozyaystva. M
Andreevskiy IE (1883) Lektsii po istorii politseyskogo prava i zemskih uchrezhdeniy v Rossii. Spb
Chicherin BN (1903) Istoriya politicheskih ucheniy. M
Berendts EN (1913) O proshlom i nastoyaschem russkoy administratsii. Spb
Gorbunov AV (1899) Metodologicheskie osnovy ucheniya Lorentsa fon SHteyna ob upravlenii. ZH-l M-va yustitsii. Spb, yanvar’
Ivanovskiy VV (1899) Vstupitel’naya lektsiya v kurs ucheniya ob upravlenii. Odessa, 1893; Voprosy gosudarstvovedeniya, sotsiologii i politiki. Kazan’
Gastev AK (1927) Industrial’nyy mir. Har’kov, 1919. Ustanovka proizvodstva metodom TSITa. M
Tugan-Baranovskiy M (1922) Russkaya fabrika v proshlom i nastoyaschem. M., Moskovskiy rabochiy
Ermanskiy OA (1922) Nauchnaya organizatsiya truda i sistema Teylora. M
Vitke NA (1925) Organizatsiya upravleniya i industrial’noe razvitie. M
Dobrynin VV (1926) Osnovy nauchnogo upravleniya predpriyatiyami i uchrezhdeniyami. L
Dunaevskij FR (1928) Kompleksnost’ v organizacii. Predposylki racional’noj organizacii. V sb: Trudy Vseukrainskogo instituta truda. Vyp. 2. Har’kov, ss 3–92
Deyneko OA (1967) Nauka upravleniya v SSSR. M
Berkovich DM (1973) Formirovanie nauki upravleniya obschestvennym proizvodstvom. M
Kruk DM (1974) Razvitie teorii i praktiki upravleniya proizvodstvom v SSSR. M
Lavrikov YUA, Koritskiy EB (1982) Problemy razvitiya teorii upravleniya sotsialisticheskim proizvodstvom. L
Gvishiani DM (1998) Organizatsiya i upravlenie. (2-e izd). M
Koritskiy E, Nintsieva G, Shetov V (1999) Nauchnyy menedzhment. Rossiyskaya istoriya. SPb, Piter
Koritskiy EB, Lavrikov YUA, Omarov AM (1990) Sovetskaya upravlencheskaya mysl’ 20-h godov. Moskva, Ekonomika
Latfullin GR, Radchenko YAV (1998) Organizatsionnye idei upravleniya v Rossii i ih znachenie dlya sovremennosti/ Trudy Pervoy mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii po istorii upravlencheskoy mysli i biznesa (pod red. V.I. Marsheva). M, MGU, TEIS, ss 49–54
Bobryshev DN, Sementsov SN (1985) Istoriya upravlencheskoy mysli. M
Dzhek Dunkan U (1996) Osnovopolagayuschie idei v menedzhmente. M., Delo
Witzel M (2012) A history of management thought. Routledge, London
Wren DA, Bedeian AG (2018) The evolution of management thought. Wiley
Bedeian A (2018) Management laureates (in 6 volumes)
Wren DA (1980) Scientific management in the USSR, with particular reference to the contribution of Walter N. Polakov. Acad Manag Rev 5(1):11
Wren DA, Bedeian A (2004) The Taylorization of Lenin: rhetoric or reality? Int J Soc Econ 31(3):287–299
Vidmer RF (1980) Management science in the USSR. The role of “Americanizers”. Int Stud Q 24(3):392–414
Kravchenko AI (2000) Istoriya menedzhmenta. M., Akademicheskiy proekt
Korotkov EM (2007) i dr. Vseobschaya istoriya menedzhmenta. M., Elima
Makashov IN, Ovchinnikova NV (2007) Vsemirnaya istoriya upravlencheskoy mysli. M., RGGU
Klauzevits K (1932) O voyne. M.-L.
Kuznetsova NI (1982) Nauka v ee istorii. M
Staros’cyak E (1965) Elementy nauki upravleniya. Pod redakciej YAmpol’skoj C.A. Perevod s pol’skogo. M, Progress
Vindel’band V (1904) Prelyudii, SPB
Pikkept G (1905) Granicy estestvenno-nauchnogo obrazovaniya ponyatij, SPB
Chuprov AA (1910) Ocherki po teorii statistiki, 2 izd., SPB
Alekseev NN (1919) Ocherki po obshchej teorii gosudarstva. Osnovnye predposylki i gipotezy gosudarstvennoj nauki. Moskovskoe nauchnoe izdatel’stvo
Maslou AG (2001) Motivaciya i lichnost’. Sankt-Peterburg: Evraziya, 425c
Aristotel’. Sochinenia: v 4 t.M., 1981, T3. S. 87
K. Marks, F. Engel’s Polnoe sobranie sochinenij (v 50 tomah) (1955–1981) M.: Politizdat
Vysochajshe utverzhdennoe polozhenie ob ustrojstve S.Peterburgskogo prakticheskogo tekhnologicheskogo instituta // Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossijskoj imperii, sobranie vtoroe. — SPb.: Tipografiya II otdeleniya Sobstvennoj Ego Imperatorskogo Velichestva kancelyarii, 1830. — T. III, 1828, № 2463. — S 1034—1038
Ivanov AI (1912) Materialy po kitayskoy filosofii. Perevod Han’-Feya. SPb
Arthashastra. M.-L., 1959
Zakoni Manu. Moskva, Izdatelstvo vostochnoi literature, 1960
Krizhanich Yuriy (1997) Politika ili besedy o pravlenii. M., Novyy svet
Kotoshihin Gr. O Rossii v tsarstvovanie Alekseya Mihaylovicha. Spb, 1906
Pososhkov I (1842) Kniga o skudosti i bogatstve. Sochineniya, chast’ 1, M
Breker EG (1828) Mneniya o politsii, nauke politseyskoy i politicheskom prave. Severnyy arhiv. SPb, №5
Ushinskij KD (1848) O kameral’nom obrazovanii. Moskva
Bogomolova Elena (1985) Issledovanie opyta podgotovki kadrov upravleniya v Rossii v XIX veke. Dissertaciya kandidata ekonomicheskih nauk. — M.: MGU
Speranskij MM (1809) Vvedenie k ulozheniyu gosudarstvennyh zakonov. Plan vseobshchego gosudarstvennogo preobrazovaniya. SPb
Speranskij MM (1961) Proekti i zapiski. M.-L.
Inama-Shterneg KT (1870) Kratkoe uchenie ob upravlenii. Vena
Gumplovich L (1892) Sotsiologiya i politika. Leyptsig
Levitskiy VF (1893) Predmet i metod nauki politseyskogo prava. Har’kov, s 12
Tarasov IT (1908–1915) Osnovnye polozheniya L.SHteyna po politseyskomu pravu v svyazi s ego ucheniem ob upravlenii. Kiev, 1864; Lektsii po politseyskomu (administrativnomu) pravu. V 3-h tt. M
De Bernando (1883–1893) La amministrazione pubblica e la sociologia. Roma
Vacelli C. La scienza della amministrazione come scienza autonoma. Roma, 1893; Le basi psihologiche del diritto pubblica. Roma, 1896
Barthelemy G (1901) Traite du droit administrative. Paris
Persico F (1890) Principi di diritto amministrativo. Napoli
Ducrocq T (1861) Cours de droit administrative. Paris (на с.70 русской версии ИУМ-2020)
Hauriou M (1907) Précis de droit administratif et de droit public. Sirey, Paris
Vsemirnaya istoriya ekonomicheskoy mysli (nauchnyi redactor Victor Cherkovetz)/v 6 tomah. M., Mysl’, 1987–1997 gg
Babbage C (1832) On the economy of machinery and manufactures. Charles Knight, London
Ure A (1835) The philosophy of manufactures: on an exposition of the scientific, moral, and commercial economy of the factory system of Great Britain. Charles Knight, London
Towne HR (1886) Engineer as an economist. Trans Am Soc Mech Eng:428–432
Promyshlennost’. ZH-l manufaktur i torgovli. Spb, 1861 g. i dalee
Trudy Komissii dlya osmotra fabrik i zavodov. Izd. Obschestva dlya sodeystviya russkoy promyshlennosti i torgovli. Spb, 1872 g
Trudy torgovo-promyshlennogo s”ezda, sozvannogo Obschestvom dlya sodeystviya russkoy promyshlennosti i torgovle v Moskve, v iyule 1882 g. Spb, 1883
Zhurnal “Tekhnicheskoe i kommercheskoe obrazovanie”. Spb, 1892 g. i dalee
Time IA (1883–1885) Osnovy mashinostroeniya. Organizatsiya mashinostroitel’nyh fabrik v tekhnicheskom i ekonomicheskom otnosheniyah i proizvodstvo mekhanicheskih rabot. V 2-h tt., M
Bedeian AG, Phillips CR (1990) Scientific management and Stakhanovism in the Soviet Union: a historical perspective. Int J Soc Econ 17:28–35
Traub R (1978) Lenin and Taylor: the fate of ‘scientific management’ in the (early) Soviet Union. Telos 37:82–92
Kelly DJ (2004) Marxist Manager amidst the Progressives: Walter N Polakov and the Taylor Society. J Ind Hist 6(2):61–75
Polakov WN (1932) Myths and realities about Soviet Russia. Harv Bus Rev 11:1–13
Donaldson T (1999) Ties that bind. A social contracts approach to business ethics. HBS Press, Boston
Luthans F (2010) Organizational behavior: an evidence-based approach (12th edn). McGraw-Hill/Irwin, New York
Luthans F, Youssef-Morgan CM, Avolio BJ (2015) Psychological capital and beyond. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Luthans F, Youssef-Morgan CM (2017) Psychological capital: an evidence-based positive approach. Annu Rev N4:17.1–17.28
Additional Literature
Allen J. A critical history of management thought of Witzel Morgen. http://libcom.org/library/critical-history-management-thought
Antologiya sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoy mysli v Rossii (20-30-e gody HKH veka). M., Academia, 2001
Boddi D, Pejton R (1999) Osnovy menedzhmenta. SPb., PITER
Bowden B (2018) Work, wealth & postmodernism: the intellectual conflict at the heart of business endeavour. Palgrave Macmillan
Boyett DG, Boyett DT (2001) Putevoditel’ po tsarstvu mudrosti. Luchshie idei masterov upravleniya. M., Olimp-biznes
Chandler AD Jr (1977) The visible hand: the managerial revolution in American business. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Cummings S (2005) Recreating strategy. SAGE, London
Foster R, Kaplan S (2005) Sozidatel’noe razrushenie. M., Al’pina Biznes buks
Friedslieb (1614) Prudentia politica christiana. Goslar
Hazhinski A (2002) Guru menedzhmenta. SPb, Piter
Hodgetts RM (1975) Management: theory process and practice. Philadelphia
Iskusstvo upravleniya. Izbrannye glavy iz knigi “Han’ Fey-tszy”. Novye perevody V.V.Malyavina. M., Astrel’, 2003
Istoriya politicheskih i pravovyh ucheniy. V 3-h kn. M., Nauka, 1985, 1986, 1989 gg
Kollinz Dzh (2001) Ot horoshego k velikomu. Stokgol’mskaya shkola ekonomiki v SPeterburge
Kollinz D, Porras D (2008) Postroennye navechno. M., Mann, Ivanov i Ferber
Kozlovoy OV (pod red) (1983) Teoriya upravleniya sotsialisticheskim proizvodstvom . M
Kuz’michev AD (2007) Luchshie knigi dlya biznesa. M., Dobraya kniga
Lenin VI (1967) Razvitie kapitalizma v Rossii. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij (v 54 tomah), M.: Izdatel’stvo politicheskoj literatury, T.3
Luchshie idei 2019, Harvard Business Review Rossiya, yanvar’-fevral’ 2019. https://hbr-russia.ru/
Mayo GE (1933) The human problems of an industrial society. Macmillan, New York
Metodologicheskie problemy istoriko-nauchnyh issledovaniy. M., 1982
Mikulinskiy SR(1976) Sovremennoe sostoyanie i teoreticheskie problemy istorii estestvoznaniya kak nauki. M
Obrecht G (1617) Funff unter schiedliche secreta fon Austellung. Strassburg
Platon. Gosudarstvo. Soch. v 4-h tt., T.3. M., Mysl’, 1994
Popova GH (pod red) (1984) Organizatsiya upravleniya obschestvennym proizvodstvom. M
Roethlisberger FJ (1968) Man-in-organizations. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Rosenberg N (1969) The American system of manufactures (1854-1855). University of Edinburgh Press, Edinburgh, Scotland
Scheglov NP (1829) O pol’ze soedineniya s zemledeliem manufakturnoy i zavodskoy promyshlennosti. Spb
Shafritz JM, Ott JS (2001) Classics of organization theory. Harcourt, Fort Worth, TX
Smetanin SI (2002) Istoriya predprinimatel’stva v Rossii. M., Paleotip
Starostin BA (1982) K voprosu o nachale istoriografii znaniya. M
Uornera M (pod red) (2001) Klassiki menedzhmenta. SPb, Piter
Valovogo DV (pod red) (1997) Istoriya menedzhmenta. M., Infra-M
Waterman Jr RH, Peters TJ, Phillips JR (1980) Structure is not organization. Bus Horiz 14–26
Wren DA (1972) The evolution of management thought. New York
Zubov VP (1956) Istoriografiya estestvennyh nauk v Rossii. M
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2021 Moscow State University Lomonosov
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Marshev, V.I. (2021). Issues of Historical and Managerial Research. In: History of Management Thought. Contributions to Management Science. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-62337-1_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-62337-1_1
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-62336-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-62337-1
eBook Packages: Business and ManagementBusiness and Management (R0)