Abstract
From 1806 on, polytechnic schools were founded in various European states. According to traditional historiography, and in particular to the Festschriften of these institutions published at some anniversary, these schools took the École polytechnique in Paris as a model, with descriptive geometry as a key teaching discipline. A closer investigation shows, however, that these schools began at a rather low educational level, often as commercial schools and dependent on the ministry of commerce, and taught quite elementary mathematics. The only institution projected at the level of higher education in the first half of nineteenth century Europe was a Polytechnic Institute in Berlin: its rationale was to be mathematics teacher education. It was only in the second half of the nineteenth century that these institutions, after steady rise in the status and level of formation provided, succeeded in attaining the level of higher education and in offering demanding mathematical courses. The question is hence why a structure, which proved so successful in France, was not viable in other countries—at least in the first half of the nineteenth century.
What is crucial proves to be the character of applications of mathematics as demanded and as practiced in the respective countries. The paper will study these differences in the level and degree of development of applications of mathematics in these countries on the one hand and, on the other hand, the differing demands in these countries for such applications and, in particular, of the requisite geometrical knowledge and the functions being realised by descriptive geometry. This investigation reveals a very specific and telling pattern that enabled the functioning of the École polytechnique in a unique way.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
“Cette science est indispensable à tous les services auquels on destine les élèves de l’ecole polytechnique.”
- 2.
“Il est donc essentielle que cette science ne dégénere pas dans la nouvelle Ecole.”
- 3.
“le choix d’un professeur de Géometrie descriptive est de la plus haute importance pour la prospérité de l’école, mais qu’il est extrémement difficile à faire.”
- 4.
The Royal Naval College at Greenwich was founded as late as 1873.
- 5.
“Realistic” as translation for the not translatable German “Real-”.
- 6.
It should be noted that schools founded in several countries, for which one might claim a polytechnic character, were in reality “mono”-technic: the schools founded in Spain and in Russia were schools for forming “ponts et chaussées” engineers (see Ausejo, Chap. 5 and Gouzevitch et al., Chap. 13, this volume)—thus not having the characteristic pattern of providing a broad mathematical basis for various professions.
- 7.
Antônio Paulo Souza is a subject of research by Vinicius Mendes, one of my doctoral student at the Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro.
References
Publications
Abdeljaouad, Mahdi. 2012. Teaching European mathematics in the Ottoman Empire during the 18th and 19th centuries: Between admiration and rejection. ZDM - The International Journal on Mathematics Education 44 (4): 483–498.
Crozet, Pascal. 2008. Les sciences modernes en Egypte. Transfert et appropriation, 1805–1902. Paris: Geuthner.
Dhombres, Jean. 1987. Histoire de l’École Polytechnique – Réédition de Fourcy 1828, avec une introduction [et quelques additifs]. Paris: Belin.
Fourcy, Ambroise. 1828. Histoire de l’École Polytechnique. Paris: chez l’auteur.
Hensel, Susann. 1987. Die Auseinandersetzungen um die mathematische Ausbildung der Ingenieure an den Technischen Hochschulen Deutschlands Ende des 19. Jahrhunderts. Dissertation A, Universität Leipzig.
Hoepke, Klaus-Peter. 2007. Geschichte der Fridericiana. Stationen in der Geschichte der Universität Karlsruhe (TH) von der Gründung 1825 bis zum Jahr 2000. Karlsruhe: Universitätsverlag.
Jacobi, Carl Gustav Jacob. 1835/1891. Über die Pariser polytechnische Schule. In C. G. J. Jacobi, Gesammelte Werke, Band 7, ed. by Carl Weierstraß, 355–370. Berlin: Reimer.
Manegold, Karl-Heinz. 1970. Universität, Technische Hochschule und Industrie: ein Beitrag zur Emanzipation der Technik im 19. Jahrhundert unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Bestrebungen Felix Kleins. Berlin: Duncker und Humblot.
Neuwirth, Joseph. 1915. Die K.K. Technische Hochschule in Wien 1815–1915. Gedenkschrift. Wien: Gerold.
Padilha, Rodrigo Bastos. 2009. A formação científica e humanística de Antônio Francisco de Paula Souza, o fundador da Escola Politécnica de São Paulo. Dissertação de mestrado em história da ciéncia, Pontifícia Universidade Católica de São Paulo.
Papperitz, Erwin. 1899. Die Mathematik an den deutschen technischen Hochschulen: Beitrag zur Beurteilung einer schwebenden Frage des hoeheren Unterrichtswesens. Leipzig: Veit.
Paul, Matthias. 1980. Gaspard Monges “Géométrie Descriptive” und die Ecole Polytechnique. Eine Fallstudie úber den Zusammenhang von Wissenschafts- und Bildungsprozeß. Materialien und Studien des IDM der Universität Bielefeld, Band 17. Bielefeld: IDM.
Sakarovitch, Joël. 1994. La géométrie descriptive, une reine déchue. In La formation polytechnicienne: 1794–1994, ed. Bruno Belhoste, Amy Dahan Dalmedico, Antoine Picon, 77–93. Paris: Dunod.
——–. 1998. Épures d’architecture: de la coupe des pierres à la géométrie descriptive XVIe - XIXe siècles. Basel: Birkhäuser.
Saraiva, Luis. 2007. The beginnings of the Royal Military Academy of Rio de Janeiro. Revista Brasileira de História da Matemática 7 (13): 19–41.
Schubring, Gert. 1981. Mathematics and teacher training: Plans for a polytechnic in Berlin. Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences 12/1: 161194.
——–. 1989. Pure and applied mathematics in divergent institutional settings in Germany: The role and impact of Felix Klein. In The History of Modern Mathematics. Volume II: Institutions and Applications, ed. David Rowe, John McCleary, 171–220. Boston: Academic Press.
——–. 2004. Le Retour du Refoulé. Der Wiederaufstieg der synthetischen Methode an der École Polytechnique. Reihe Algorismus, No. 46. Augsburg: Erwin Rauner.
Stark, Franz. 1906. Die k.k. Deutsche Technische Hochschule in Prag, 1806-190. Festschrift zur Hundertjahrfeier. Prag: Deutsche Technische Hochschule.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Additional information
Sources
Archives de l’École polytechnique, Palaiseau (France) [AEP] AEP I: X2C 29—[1816] Conseil de perfectionement da l’école polytechnique le 12 décembre. Quelques reflexions sur la Géométrie Déscriptive et sur le professorat de cette partie.
Archiv der Eidgenössischen Technischen Hochschule, Zürich (Switzerland) [AETH] AETH I: ETH-Bibliothek, Archive, SR2: Anhang 1861, Programm der eidgenössischen polytechnischen Schule für das Schuljahr 1861/ 62. beziehungsweise für das erste Halbjahr. AETH II: EZ_Rek_1/1/387 Paul de Souza, Ant. Francisco.
Archiv der Technischen Universität Karlsruhe [AKIT]. AKIT I: Technische Hochschule Karlsruhe, “Einschreibebücher der Studierenden”, Band 2: Studienjahre 1860/61 bis 1865/66. Signatur 10001, 1644 (for the year 1866/67).
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2019 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Schubring, G. (2019). The Myth of the Polytechnic School. In: Barbin, É., Menghini, M., Volkert, K. (eds) Descriptive Geometry, The Spread of a Polytechnic Art. International Studies in the History of Mathematics and its Teaching. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-14808-9_22
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-14808-9_22
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-14807-2
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-14808-9
eBook Packages: EducationEducation (R0)