Abstract
Abuse of human rights in conservation initiatives, such as REDD+, wildlife conservation, etc., has raised concern in many project reviews. Few studies have, however, examined the human rights dimensions of conservation and climate change. In this chapter the authors address this gap by showing how outsiders, with the assistance of the state, attempted to control areas historically governed by local residents in the name of conservation and climate change policy initiatives in the Mafia Island and Rufiji Delta, Southern Tanzania. The interventions were implemented with the old-fashioned premise that the villagers were destructive and extravagant resource users. The authors also try to illustrate how the international linkages to worldwide conservation narratives and to development aid by rich countries promoting climate measures in poor countries to try to absolve their carbon emissions revealed the ways in which such vested interests attempted “to misuse their money, power, and influence.”
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
A primary school teacher at Jibondo Island in the Mafia Island Marine Park
- 2.
The army also conducted violent actions against other villagers, and CHRAGG also conducted inquiries in Kilindoni and Kiegeani (Kilindoni is the small town in Mafia Island outside of MIMP, and Kiegeani village is within MIMP).
- 3.
See the Report of the Commission on Human Rights and Good Governance, 2012, at page 3.
- 4.
Chief Secretary in the President’s Office, the Private Secretary to the President, the Chairperson of Jibondo Village, the Village Executive Officer of Jibondo Village, the Minister of Livestock and Fisheries Development, the Director of Fisheries, the DC of Mafia Island, and the Warden in Charge of MIMP, and the Norwegian Embassy in Tanzania
- 5.
Mr. Kalango (the District Executive Secretary), Mr. Kahundi (Acting District Executive Director), Mr. Upunda (Head of the Prisons for Mafia District), Mr. Chambe (Head of Police for Mafia District), Mr. Hemedi (Acting Bureau Chief and District Chief of the Army, Militia and Security), Mr. Kugopya (District Fisheries Officer), and all senior officials from MIMP (Mr. Msumi, Mr. Melele, Mr. Mahala, and Ms. Msumange)
- 6.
Chris Maina Peter is also a member of the UN International Law Commission (ILC), a legal body elected by the UN General Assembly. Maina Peter previously served as a member of the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of the Racial Discrimination (CERD), one of the treaty bodies under the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.
- 7.
The Constitution has to be read together with Human Rights and Good Governance Act, 2001 (Act No. 7 of 2001) which details the working of the Commission.
- 8.
These complaints were made during the public hearing in the villages of Kilindoni, Jibondo, and Kiegeni between February 14 and 16, 2012. See the Report of the Commission on Human Rights and Good Governance, 2012 at pages 4 to 14.
- 9.
Beymer-Farris received her PhD from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in the Department of Geography.
- 10.
The panel was titled “Biodiversity, Livelihoods, and Conservation: Emerging Trends, Challenges, and Responses” with influential panelists from the policy and academic arena including top officials from the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), Tom Dillon, a key representative from USAID, a representative from the Department of State, Alan Thornhill, as well as representatives from the National Science Foundation (NSF).
- 11.
One of these meetings was held at Nyamisati Village in the Rufiji Delta (also referred to as Salale Ward) on 23rd of June, 2013.
- 12.
A sample of these highly controversial and disputed contracts is reproduced in Commission for Human Rights and Good Governance, Report on Public Inquiry on the Land Dispute in Salale Ward in Rufiji, Coast Region, 2013, page 17.
- 13.
Public hearing is one of the mandates of the Commission under the Human Rights and Good Governance Act, 2001 (Act No. 7 of 2001) to establish if there has been human rights violations in a situation following complaints by the citizens.
- 14.
Some produced original receipts of Poll Tax they had paid from around 1930 indicating longevity of having lived in this area and thus making the whole question of licensing them to use the same land ridiculous.
References
Beymer-Farris BA, Bassett TJ (2012) The REDD menace: resurgent protectionism in Tanzania’s mangrove forests. Glob Environ Chang 22(2):332–341
Beymer-Farris BA, Bassett TJ (2013) Environmental narratives and politics in Tanzania’s Rufiji Delta: a reply to Burgess et al. Glob Environ Chang 23(5):1355–1358
Bistandsaktuelt, no. 1 of 2012 (2012, January) Risbonder mistete hus og levebrod. Norway: Bistandsaktuelt Publication
Bryceson I, Jiddawi J, Kamukuru A, Kulindwa K, Mwaipopo R, Onyango P, Sebastian M, (2006) Fisheries Study in Tanzanian Coastal Waters: the effects of trial export of finfish from Mafia Island on ecological–social resilience and vulnerability. Report to the Ministry of Natural Resources and Tourism, Government of Tanzania. 82 pages.
CHRAGG, Commission on Human Rights and Good Governance (2012) Report of the Public Inquiry done in Mafia District in the Villages of Kilindoni, Jibondo, and Kiegeani from 14th–17th February, 2012. Dar es Salaam: Tanzania Commission on Human Rights and Good Governance
CHRAGG, Tanzanian Commission on Human Rights and Good Governance (2017) Report on Public Inquiry on the Land Dispute in Salale Ward in Rufiji Coast Region. Dar es Salaam: Tanzania Commission on Human Rights and Good Governance
CIHR (2018) The Conservation Initiative on Human Rights: Promoting the Integration of Human Rights in Conservation Policy and Practice. Retrieved from http://www.thecihr.org, July 20
Francis J, Machumu E (2014) Marine Protected Areas on Mainland Tanzania: What is their Future? In Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) in relation to Fisheries Management: Challenges and Experiences from Developing Countries, edited by Francis, J. and I. Bryceson, pp 153–178, Chapter Nine
Garcia SM, Kolding J, Rice J, Rochet MJ, Zhou S, Arimoto T, Beyer JE, Borges L, Bundy A, Dunn D, Fulton EA (2012) Reconsidering the consequences of selective fisheries. Science 335(6072):1045–1047
George L (2010) Villager killed in botched bid to impound illegal fishing nets. Retrieved from http://www.ippmedia.com/frontend/?l=20193, August 24
Hansson R (2012) Faglig Flopp om Tanzania: WWF var absolutt ikke involvert i tvangsflytting av folk i Rufiji. Retrieved from https://www.aftenposten.no/meninger/i/lAjke/Faglig-flopp-om-Tanzania, January 16
Horrill JC, Darwall W, Ngoile M (1996) Development of a marine protected area: Mafia Island, Tanzania. Ambio 25(1):50–57
ICSF, International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (2008) The Zanzibar Workshop Proceedings. Asserting Rights, Defining Responsibilities: Perspectives from Small-scale Fishing Communities on Coastal and Fisheries Management in Eastern and Southern Africa. ICSF, Chennai, India, 69 pp
Jansen E (2009) U4, Monitoring Aid: Lessons from a Natural Resources Programme in Tanzania. Retrieved from U4 Anti-Corruption Resource Centre: https://www.u4.no/publications/monitoring-aid-lessons-from-a-natural-resources-programme-in-tanzania
Kamat VR (2014) “The ocean is our farm”: marine conservation, food insecurity, and social suffering in Southeastern Tanzania. Hum Organ 73(3):289–297
Keenlyside PJ, Costenbader J, Parker C (2016) Managing fiduciary risk in REDD+. In: Voigt C (ed) Research handbook on REDD+ and international law, research handbooks in climate law series. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, Massachusetts, USA, pp 325–346
Kolding J, van Zwieten PA (2011) The tragedy of our legacy: how do global management discourses affect small scale fisheries in the south? Forum Develop Stud 38(3):267–297
Makoye K, Zachrisen G (2012) Rufiji-bondene avviser nye miljokrav. Norway: Bistandsaktuelt Publication, March 2
Marine Parks and Reserves Unit (MPRU) (2006) Consolidated Annual Physical Progress Report From July, 2005 to June, 2006. Dar es Salaam: Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries
McClanahan TR, Ateweberhan M, Muhando CM, Maina J, Mohammed SM (2007) Effects of climate and seawater temperature variation on coral bleaching and mortality. Ecol Monogr 77:503–525
Moshy VH, Bryceson I (2016) Seeing through fishers’ lenses: exploring marine ecological changes within Mafia Island Marine Park, Tanzania. SAGE Open 6(2):1–18
Moshy VT, Masenge TJ, Bryceson I (2013) Undernutrition among under-five children in two fishing communities in Mafia Island Marine Park, Tanzania. J Sustain Dev 6(6):1–14
Obura D (2012) The diversity and biogeography of Western Indian Ocean reef-building corals. PLoS One 7(9):e45013
Parker C, Mitchell A, Trivedi M, Mardas N, Sosis K (2009) The Little REDD+ Book. Global Canopy Programme, Oxford
Pauly D (2018) A vision for marine fisheries in a global blue economy. Mar Policy 87:371–374
Pauly D, Zeller D (2017) Comments on FAOs state of world fisheries and aquaculture (SOFIA 2016). Mar Policy 77:176–181
Rubens J (2004) Loans for the future. Retrieved from http://wwf.panda.org/wwf_news/?12125/Loans-for-the-future
Salvesen and Gedde-dahl (2012) Forskere: Norske klimapenger kan bidra til tvangsflytting. Retrieved from https://www.aftenposten.no/norge/i/P9OG6/Forskere-Norske-klimapenger-kan-bidra-til-tvangsflytting, January 10
Shivji I (1989) The concept of human rights in Africa. Codesria Book Series, London
UN Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner (2018) Human Rights and Climate Change. Retrieved from https://www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/HRAndClimateChange/Pages/HRClimateChangeIndex.aspx, July 20
United Republic of Tanzania (2015) National livestock and fisheries development policy. Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries Development, Dar es Salaam
Warioba J (2014) “Debate on Union structure inevitable, insists Warioba”. Dar es Salaam: The Guardian/IPP Media, August 5
Wells S, Burgess N, Ngusaru A (2007) Towards the 2012 marine protected area targets in Eastern Africa. Ocean Coast Manag 50(1–2):67–83
Woodroffe SA, Horton BP (2005) Holocene sea-level changes in the Indo-Pacific. J Asian Earth Sci 25(1):29–43
WWF (2018) Overfishing. Retrieved from https://www.worldwildlife.org/thrgeats/overfishing, July 25
WWF and MFA (2010) Contract between the Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) and the World Wide Fund for Nature Tanzania Country Office (WWF TCO) regarding Enhancing Tanzanian Capacity to Deliver Short and Long Term Data on Forest Carbon Stocks Across the Country, available at http://www.norway.go.tz/PageFiles/253880/WWF_contract.pdf
WWF Webposting (2012) WWF Comments in Review of Beymer-Farris, B.A., Bassett, T.J., The REDD Menace: Resurgent Protectionism in Tanzania’s mangrove forests” with prefix title “Environment and Development Assistance in Researchers’ Violence”. Retrieved from_3.pdf and http://www.wwf.no/bibliotek/nyheter_fakta/?35187, January 13
Acknowledgments
We express our sincere thanks to the people of Mafia and Rufiji for sharing their knowledge and insights with us and for all the inspiration and hospitality they have given us. We give our special thanks go to the elected leaders of key villages: Ahamada Mahmoud Ngokoro, Chairperson of Mchinga village, Rufiji; Ahmadi Selemani Kidagaa, former Chairperson of Juani village, Mafia; Ali Haruni, Chairperson of Kiegeani village, Mafia; Fakhi Ali Hassan, Chairperson of Jibondo village, Mafia; Hamisi Yusuf Mtimba, former Chairperson of Kiomboni, Rufiji; Jumanne Kikumbi, Chairperson of Nyamisati village, Rufiji; Maburuki Sadiki, former Chairperson of Chole village, Mafia; Makame Mohamed, former Chairperson of Banja village, Mafia; Miwadi Mmadi Mwinyi, Chairperson of Juani village, Mafia; Mohamedi Haji Tuki, Chairperson of Jimbo village, Mafia; Omari Hemedi Upindo, former Chairperson of Kiomboni village, Rufiji; Saidi Seifu, former Chairperson of Kiegeani village, Mafia; Shehari Ahmad, Chairperson of Chole village, Mafia; Yahaya Akungwa, Chairperson of Kiomboni village, Rufiji; Yusuf Swale Mamboka, Chairperson of Mfisini village, Rufiji.
We are very indebted to the staff of the Tanzanian Commission for Human Rights and Good Governance and especially to the following outstanding individuals: Hon. Commissioner (Retired) Ali Hassan Rajabu (Former Commissioner), Hon. Justice (Retired) Amiri Ramadhani Manento (Former Chair); Hon. Bahame Tom Nyanduga (Former Chair); Ms. Mary Massay (Secretary to the Commission); and Mr. Francis Nzuki (Director for Human Rights). Moreover, we are highly grateful to many individuals in the Tanzanian Government state institutions, including the late Mr. Geofrey Nanyaro (Former Director of Fisheries) as well as Professor Pius Yanda and other key persons at the University of Dar es Salaam and the State University of Zanzibar, and to very many others.
For support in arranging numerous workshops and seminars, we are very grateful to the Western Indian Ocean Marine Science Association (WIOMSA), the International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF), and the International Foundation for Science (IFS). For research funding, we thank the Norwegian Programme for Development, Research and Education (NUFU), the Norwegian Programme for Capacity Development in Higher Education and Research for Development (NORHED), and the National Science Foundation (NSF). We also thank Thomas Bassett and Rod Smolla as well as the University of Kentucky, the Norwegian University of Life Sciences, and the University of Dar es Salaam for support in our research.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2019 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Beymer-Farris, B.A., Bryceson, I., Peter, C.M. (2019). The Human Rights Dimensions of Conservation and Climate Change Initiatives in Coastal Tanzania: Examples of Villagers’ Successful Struggles for Their Rights. In: Yanda, P., Bryceson, I., Mwevura, H., Mung'ong'o, C. (eds) Climate Change and Coastal Resources in Tanzania. Springer Climate. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-04897-6_9
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-04897-6_9
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-04896-9
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-04897-6
eBook Packages: Earth and Environmental ScienceEarth and Environmental Science (R0)