# Yield Models - Comparative Study

Chapter

## Abstract

Yield models have been developed, analyzed, evaluated and discussed since the early 1960’s. Despite such a long and very often hot discussion [29,30,78] until now there has been no consensus as to which of them are the best, which are accurate enough and which of them possess adequate predictive capabilities. This situation is due, among other things, to the fact that yield models are very often evaluated by using very different, and not always explicitly defined, evaluation criteria. The goal of this paper is to indicate a number of simple yield model characteristics which could be used to improve comparison of different yield models.

## Keywords

Yield Model Yield Loss Integrate Circuit Defect Tolerance Defect Density## Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

## Bibliography

- [1]W.G. Ansley, “Computation of Integrated-Circuit Yield From the Distribution of Slice Yields for the Individual Devices,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, Vol. ED-15, pp. 405–406, June 1968.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [2]J. Bernard, “The IC Yield Problem: A Tentative Analysis for MOS/SOS Circuits,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-25, no.8, pp.939–944, Aug. 1978.MathSciNetCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [3]H. Bolouri and M. Lea, “ULSI and WSI Yield Estimation: An Empirical Approach” in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly, A. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [4]R.P. Cenker et al., “A Fault Tolerant 64K Dynamic Random Access Memory,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. ED-26, no. 6, pp. 853–860, June 1979.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [5]I. Chen and A.J. Strojwas, “Realistic Yield Simulation for VLSIC Structural Failures”, IEEE Transactions on CAD of ICAS, (CAD—6), 1987.Google Scholar
- [6]A.J. Dingwall, “High Yield-Processed Bipolar LSI Arrays,” in 1968 Int. Electron Device Meeting Technical Digest, p. 82, 1968.Google Scholar
- [7]J. Doi, W. Maly, and M.E. Thomas, “Detection and Physical Characterization of Spot Defects in Metal IC Interconnections,” 172nd Electrochemical Society Meeting, p. 837, Honolulu, Hawaii, 1987.Google Scholar
- [8]S.S. Eaton et al., “A 100 ns 64K Dynamic RAM Using Redundancy Techniques,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Solid State Circuits Conf., pp. 84-85, Feb. 1981.Google Scholar
- [9]F.J. Ferguson, “Inductive Fault Analysis of VLSI Circuits,” Ph.D. Dissertation, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, 1987.Google Scholar
- [10]A.V. Ferris-Prabhu, “A Cluster-Modified Poisson Model for Estimating Defect Density and Yield,” IBM Burlington Technical Bulletin, March 1989.Google Scholar
- [11]A.V. Ferris-Prabhu, “Defects, Faults and Semiconductor Device Yield,” Proceedings of the IEEE International Workshop on Defect and Fault Tolerance in VLSI Systems, pp. 1.1-1-1.1-2, October 1988.Google Scholar
- [12]A.V. Ferris-Prabhu et al., “Radial Yield Variations in Semiconductor Wafers,” IEEE Circuits and Devices Magazine, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 42–47, March 1987.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [13]A.V. Ferris-Prabhu, “Defect Size Variations and Their Effect on the Critical Area of VLSI Devices”, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits, pp. 874-878, SC-20(4), 1985.Google Scholar
- [14]A.V. Ferris-Prabhu, “Modeling of Critical Area in Yield Forecasts”, Journal of Solid-State Circuits, SC-20 (4), pp. 878–880, 1985.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [15]A.V. Ferris-Prabhu, “Role of Defect Size Distributions in Yield Modeling,” IEEE Trans. on Electron Devices, vol. ED-32, no. 9, pp. 1727–1736, September 1985.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [16]V. Flack Foard, “Introducing Dependency into IC Yield Models,” Solid-State Electronics, vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 555–559, June 1985.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [17]K. Fuchs et al., “The Impact of Parallel Architecture Granularity on Yield” in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly, A. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [18]D.S. Fussell and P.J. Varman, “Fault Tolerant Wafer Scale Architectures for VLSI,” in Proc. IEEE 9th Symp. on Computer Architectures, pp. 190-198, April 1982.Google Scholar
- [19]J. Gailay et al., “Physical Versus Logical Fault Models for MOS LSI Circuits: Impact on Their Testability,” IEEE Trans. Comput., vol. C-29. no.6, pp.527–531, June 1980.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [20]S. Gandemer et al., “A Method for Determining Critical Areas and Critical Levels for IC Yield Estimation”, in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly and A.J. Strojwas), pp. 101-110, Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [21]P. Genestier and G. Saucier, “Reconfiguration Strategies for Yield Improvement of Complex Nodes in WSI of 2D Processors Arrays”, ICTC Conference Limerick, Ireland, September 1986.Google Scholar
- [22]M.R. Gulett, “A Practical Method of Predicting IC Yields,” Semiconductor International, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 87–94, March 1981.Google Scholar
- [23]A. Gupta, et al., “Defect Analysis and Yield Degradation of Integrated Circuits”, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits, SC-9(3), pp. 96–103, 1974.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [24]A. Gupta and J.W. Lathrop, “Yield Analysis of Large Integrated Circuit Chips,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-7, no.5, pp. 389–395, Oct. 1972.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [25]A. Gupta and J.W. Lathrop, “Comments on ‘Influence of Epitaxial Mounds on the Yield of Integrated Circuits’,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 58, no. 12, pp. 1960–1961, December 1970.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [26]W.E. Ham, “Yield-Area Analysis: Part 1-A Diagnostic Tool for Fundamental Integrated Circuit Process Problems,” RCA Review, vol. 39, pp. 231–349, June 1978.Google Scholar
- [27]R.S. Hemmert, “Poisson Process and Integrated Circuit Yield Prediction,” Solid-State Electronics, Vol. 24, No. 6, pp. 511–515, June 1981.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [28]M. Howells and V. Agarwal, “A Cluster-Proof Scheme for Improving Yield and Reliability of Large Area Binary Tree Architectures”, in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly, A. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [29]S.M. Hu, “On Yield Projection for VLSI and Beyond: I. Analysis of Yield Formulas,” Electron Devices, no. 69, pp. 4-7, March 1984.Google Scholar
- [30]S.M. Hu, “Yield Projection for VLSI and Beyond: II. A Computer Experiment,” Electron Devices, no. 69, pp. 8-10, March 1984.Google Scholar
- [31]S.M. Hu, “Some Considerations on the Formulation of IC Yield Statistics,” Solid-State Electronics, vol. 22, pp. 205–211, 1979.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [32]A.C. Ipri, “Impact of Design Rule Reduction on Size, Yield and Cost of Integrated Circuits,” Solid State Technol., pp. 85-91, Feb 1979.Google Scholar
- [33]S. Jones, “Influence of Defects and Defect Clustering on the Silicon-Efficiency of a Hierarchically-Organized Wafer-Scale Parallel Processor” in Yield Modeling and Defect Tolerance in WSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly, A. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [34]M.B. Ketchen, “Point Defect Yield Model for Wafer Scale Integration,” IEEE Circuits and Devices Magazine, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 24–34, July 1985.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [35]K. Kokkonen et al., “Redundancy Techniques for Fast Static RAMs,” in Proc. Int. Solid State Circuits Conf., pp 80-81 February 1981.Google Scholar
- [36]C. Kooperberg, “Circuit Layout and Yield,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 887–892, August 1988.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [37]I. Koren, “The Effect of Scaling on the Yield of VLSI Circuits”, in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by: W. Moore, W. Maly and A.J. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [38]I. Koren and M.A. Breuer, “On Area and Yield Considerations for Fault-Tolerant VLSI Processor Arrays”, IEEE Transactions on Computers, Vo. C-33, no. 1., pp. 21–27, January 1984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [39]H.T. Kung and M.S. Lam, “Wafer-Scale Integration of Systolic Arrays,” J. Parallel Distrib. Comput., vol. 1, pp. 32–63, 1984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [40]S. Magdo, “Yield Model for Yield Projection From Test Site,” Proceedings of the IEEE International Workshop on Defect and Fault Tolerance in VLSI Systems, pp. 3.4-1-3.4-9, October 1988.Google Scholar
- [41]C.L. Mallory et al., “Spatial Yield Analysis in Integrated Circuit Manufacturing,” Solid State Technology, vol. 26, no. 11, pp. 121–127, November 1983.Google Scholar
- [42]W. Maly, “Computer Aided Design for VLSI Circuit Manufacturability”, to appear in Proc. of IEEE, March 1990.Google Scholar
- [43]W. Maly, A.J. Strojwas and S.W. Director, “VLSI Yield Prediction and Estimation: Unified Framework”, IEEE Transactions on Computer-Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and Systems, pp. 114-130, CAD-5(1), 1986.Google Scholar
- [44]W. Maly et al., “Yield Loss Mechanisms and Defect Tolerance” in Yield Modelling and Fault Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by: W. Maly, W. Moore and A J. Strojwas, Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [45]W. Maly et al., “Characterization of Type, Size and Density of Spot Defects in the Metallization Layer” in Yield Modelling and Fault Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly and A.J. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [46]W. Maly, “Design Methodology for Defect Tolerant Integrated Circuits,” Custom Integrated Circuits Conference, pp. 27.5.1-27.5.4, Rochester, NY, May 1988.Google Scholar
- [47]W. Maly et al., “Yield Diagnosis Through Interpretation of Tester Data”, Proceedings of the International Test Conference, pp. 10-20, 1987.Google Scholar
- [48]W. Maly et al., “Double-Bridge Test Structure for the Evaluation of Type, Size and Density of Spot Defects, Research Report CMUCAD-87-2, SRC-CMU Center for Computer-Aided Design, Carnegie Mellon University, 1987.Google Scholar
- [49]W. Maly, “Modeling of Lithography Related Losses for CAD of VLSI Circuits”, IEEE Transactions on Computer-Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and Systems, pp. 166-177, CAD-4(4), 1985.Google Scholar
- [50]W. Maly et al., “Systematic Characterization of Physical Defects for Fault Analysis of MOS IC Cells”, IEEE International Test Conference Proceedings, pp. 390-399, 1984.Google Scholar
- [51]W. Maly and J. Deszczka, “Yield Estimation Model for VLSI Artwork Evaluation”, Electronics Letters, pp. 226-227, 19(6), 1983.Google Scholar
- [52]T.E. Mangir, “Sources of Failures and Yield Improvement for VLSI and Restructurable Interconnects for RVLSI and WSI,” Proc.IEEE, vol. 72, pp. 690-706, pt. I (June) and pp. 1687-1694, pt. II (Dec.) 1985.Google Scholar
- [53]T. Mangir, “Sources of Failures and Yield Improvement for VLSI and Restructurable Interconnects for RVLSI and WSI: Part I — Sources of Failures and Yield Improvements for VLSI,” Proceedings of the IEEE, 72(6), pp. 690-708.Google Scholar
- [54]T. Mangir and A. Avizienis, “Fault-Tolerant Design for VLSI: Effect of Interconnect Requirements on Yield Improvement of VLSI Designs”, IEEE Transactions on Computers, C-31(7), pp. 609-615, 1982.Google Scholar
- [55]O. Minato et al., “A Hi-CMOSII 8K X 8 Bit Static RAM,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-17, no. 5, pp. 793–798, Oct. 1982.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [56]M.A. Mitchell, “Defect Test Structures for Characterization of VLSI Technology,” Solid State Technology, vol. 28, no. 5, pp. 207–213, May 1985.Google Scholar
- [57]G. Moore, “What Level of LSI is Best for You?”, Electronics, 43(4), pp. 126–130, 1970.Google Scholar
- [58]W.R. Moore, “Yield Enhancement of Large Memories”, IFIP Workshop on WSI, Grenoble, March 1986.Google Scholar
- [59]W.R. Moore, “A View of Fault Tolerant Techniques for the Enhancement of Integrated Circuit Yield”, Proceedings of the IEEE, 74(5) pp. 584-698, 1986.Google Scholar
- [60]W.R. Moore and M.J. Day, “Yield-Enhancement of a Large Systolic Array Chip,” Microelectron, Reliab., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 511–526, 1984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [61]E.I. Muehldorf, “Fault Clustering: Modeling and Observation on Experimental LSI Chips,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-10, no. 4, pp. 237–244, 1975.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [62]B. Murphy, Comments on “A New Look at Yield of Integrated Circuits”, Proceedings of the IEEE, 59(8), pp. 1128, 1971.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [63]B.T. Murphy, “Cost Size Optima of Monolithic Integrated Circuits,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 52, pp. 1537–1545, 1964.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [64]T. Okabe et al., “Analysis of Integrated Circuits and a New Expression for the Yield”, Electrical Engineering in Japan, 92:135–141, 1972.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [65]O. Paz and T.R. Lawson, “Modification of Poisson Statistics: Modeling Defects Induced by Diffusion,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-12, no.5, pp. 540–546, Oct. 1977.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [66]L.L. Pesotchinsky, “A Model for IC Yield Analysis and Process Control,” Solid-State Electronics, vol. 25, pp. 1253–1265, 1986.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [67]J. Price, “A New Look at Yield of Integrated Circuits”, Proceedings of the IEEE 58(8), pp. 1290–1291, 1970.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [68]U. Ramacher, “A Cost Orientated Redundancy Model for Defect-Tolerant VLSI/WSI Systems” in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly and A. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [69]M. Rivier, “Random Yield Simulation Applied to Physical Circuit Design”, in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI, (edited by W. Moore, W. Maly and A.J. Strojwas), Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [70]R.D. Rung, “Determining IC Layout Rules for Cost Minimization,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-16, no. 1, pp. 35–43, February 1981.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [71]S.E. Schuster, “Multiple Word/Bit Line Redundancy for Semiconductor Memories”, IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, Vo. SC-13, pp. 698–703, October 1978.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [72]R.B. Seeds, “Yield, Economic, and Logistic Models for Complex Digital Arrays,” in 1967 IEEE Int. Conf. Rec., pt. 6, pp. 61-66, April 1967.Google Scholar
- [73]R.B. Seeds, “Yield and Cost Analysis of Bipolar LSI”, in IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting October, 1967.Google Scholar
- [74]S.C. Seth and V.D.A. Agrawal, “Characterizing the LSI Yield Equation from Wafer Test Data,” IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. CAD-3, pp. 123-126, Apr. 1984.Google Scholar
- [75]J.P. Shen, W. Maly, and F.J. Ferguson, “Inductive Fault Analysis of MOS Integrated Circuits,” IEEE Design and Test, pp. 13-26, December 1985.Google Scholar
- [76]J. Shier, “A Statistical Model for Integrated-Circuit Yield with Clustered Raws,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 524–525, April 1988.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [77]J. Sredni, “Use of Power Transformations to Model the Yield of ICs as a Function of Active Circuit Area,” in 1975 IEEE Int. Electron Device Meeting, no. 64, pp. 123-125, December 1975.Google Scholar
- [78]C.H. Stapper, “Fact and Fiction in Yield Modeling “, IBM Technical Report, TR.90420, February 1989.Google Scholar
- [79]C.H. Stapper, “Productivity Optimization of VLSI DRAM Chips with Redundant Circuits”, in Yield Modelling and Defect Tolerance in VLSI”, Adam Hilger, 1988.Google Scholar
- [80]C.H. Stapper, “Yield Statistics for Large Area ICs”, in IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conference Digst of Technical Papers, pp. 168-169, 1986.Google Scholar
- [81]C.H. Stapper, “The Defect-Sensitivity Effect of Memory Chips,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. SC-21, no. 1, pp. 193–198, February 1986.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [82]C.H. Stapper, “On Yield, Fault Distributions and Clustering of Particles,” IBM J. Res. Dev., vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 326–338, May 1986.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [83]C.H. Stapper, “The Effects of Wafer to Wafer Defect Density Variations on Integrated Circuit Defect and Fault Distributions”, IBM Journal of Research and Development, 29(1), pp. 87–97, 1985.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [84]C.H. Stapper, “Yield Models for Fault Clusters Within Integrated Circuits,” IBM J. Res. Develop, vol. 28, pp. 636–640. Sept. 1984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [85]C.H. Stapper, “Modelling of Defects in Integrated Circuit Photolithographic Patterns,” IBM J. Res. Develop. vol. 28, no. 4/5 pp. 461–474, July 1984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [86]C.H. Stapper et al., “Integrated Circuit Yield Statistics,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 71, no. 4, pp. 453–470, Apr. 1983.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [87]C.H. Stapper, “Modeling of Integrated Circuit Defect Sensitivities”, IBM Journal of Research and Development, 27(6), pp. 549–557, November 1983.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [88]C.H. Stapper, “Yield Model for 256K RAMs and Beyond,” 1982 IEEE Internationale Solid-State Circuits Conference, Digst of Technical Papers, pp. 12-13, February 1982.Google Scholar
- [89]C.H. Stapper and R.J. Rosner, “A Simple Method for Modeling VLSI Yields,” Solid-State Electronics, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 487–489, June 1982.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [90]C.H. Stapper et al., “Evolution and Accomplishments of VLSI Yield Management at IBM,” IBM J. Res. Dev., vol. 26, no. 5, pp. 532–545, September 1982.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [91]C.H. Stapper, “Comments on Some Considerations in the Formulation of Yield Statistics,” Solid-State Electron., vol. 24, pp. 127–132, 1981.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [92]C.H. Stapper et al., “Yield Model for Productivity Optimization of VLSI Memory Chips with Redundancy and Partially Good Product,” IBM J. Res. Dev., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 398–409, May 1980.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [93]C.H. Stapper, “LSI Yield Modeling and Process Monitoring”, IBM Journal of Research and Development, 20(3), pp. 228–234, 1976.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [94]C.H. Stapper, “On a Composite Model to the IC Yield Problem”, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits, SC-10(6), pp. 537–539, 1975.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [95]C.H. Stapper et al., “Size Dependence of Photolithographic Defect Density Distribution,” Manuscript submitted for publication March 1974, rejected for publication July 1975.Google Scholar
- [96]C.H. Stapper, “Defect Density Distribution for LSI Yield Calculations”, IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, ED-20(7), pp. 655–657, 1973.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [97]H. Stopper, “A Wafer with Electrically Programmable Interconnections,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Solid State Circuits Conf., pp. 268-269, Feb. 1985.Google Scholar
- [98]M.E. Thomas and W. Maly, “Multilevel Interconnect Yield Estimates Using the Double Bridge Test Structure,” Proceedings of the Fifth International IEEE VLSI Multilevel Interconnect Conference, pp. 220-237, June 1988.Google Scholar
- [99]A.P. Turley and D.S. Herman, “LSI Yield Projections Based Upon Test Pattern Results: An Application to Multilevel Metal Structures,” IEEE. Trans. Parts, Hybrids, Packag., vol. PHP 10, no. 4, pp. 230–234, December 1974.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [100]J. Von Bank, “An Alternative Integrated Circuit Yield Model,” IEEE Trans. on Reliability, vol. R-35, no. 4, p. 385–390, October 1986.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [101]H. Walker, “Yield Simulation for Integrated Circuits”, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1987.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [102]H. Walker and S.W. Director, “VLASIC: A Catastrophic Fault Yield Simulator for Integrated Circuits”, IEEE Transactions on Computer-Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and Systems, CAD 5(4), pp. 541–556, 1986.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [103]T.J. Wallmark, “Design Considerations for Integrated Electron Devices,” Proc. IRE, vol. 48, no. 3, pp. 293–300, March 1960.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [104]R.M. Warner, “A Note on IC Yield Statistics,” Solid-State Electronics, vol. 24, no. 11, pp. 1045–1047, December 1981.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [105]R.M. Warner, “Applying a Composite Model to the IC Yield Problem”, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits, SC-9(3), pp. 86–95, 1974.MathSciNetCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [106]T. Yanagawa, “Yield Degradation of Integrated Circuits Due to Spot Defects”, IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, ED-19(2), pp. 190–197, 1972.MathSciNetCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- [107]T. Yanagawa, “Influence of Epitaxial Mounts on the Yield of Integrated Circuits,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 57, pp. 1621–1628, 1969.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

## Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 1990