The Leader pp 133-178 | Cite as

Woodrow Wilson Revisited

The Prepolitical Years
  • Joseph A. Bongiorno


Woodrow Wilson has fascinated and puzzled generations of students and scholars. On the one hand, he was a man of remarkable strengths and talents. He was a respected historian and political scientist, a prodigious worker, and—at his best—a brilliant leader and innovator, first as president of Princeton University (1902–10) and later as governor of New Jersey (1910–12) and president of the United States (1912–20). He developed rich life-long friendships, he was capable of humor (including humor about himself), and he was a devoted son, husband, and father. On the other hand, beginning in adolescence, he suffered several emotional breakdowns and near-breakdowns. At his worst as a leader, he lost his humor, demanded complete loyalty and compliance, refused compromise, stubbornly adhered to his causes, and thereby contributed greatly to his own defeats.


Bryn Mawr Editorial Note Theological Seminary Yacht Club Spiritual Capital 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. 1.
    Alexander and Juliette George, Woodrow Wilson and Colonel House (New York: Dover, 1964)Google Scholar
  2. Sigmund Freud and William Bullitt, Thomas Woodrow Wilson: a Psychological Study (Boston: Houghton Mifflin; Cambridge: The Riverside Press, 1967)Google Scholar
  3. Fdwin A. Weinstein, Woodrow Wilson: A Medical and Psychological Biography (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1981).Google Scholar
  4. 2.
    Primary materials are published in Arthur S. Link, John W. Davidson, David H. Hirst et al eds. The Papers of Woodrow Wilson, 46 vols. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1966-), hereafter cited as Papers. In the footnotes, I use the following abbreviations for individuals: WW = Woodrow Wilson, JWW = Janet Woodrow Wilson, JRW = Joseph Ruggles Wilson, ELA = Ellen Louise Axson, and EAW = Ellen Axson Wilson.Google Scholar
  5. 3.
    Background information on JWW: Weinstein gives the most convincing portrait of JWW in the extensive Wilson literature. See Weinstein, pp. 10-13, 21-23, and 44-45. See also Ray Stannard Baker, Woodrow Wilson: Life and Letters, 8 vols. (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1927–39), I, p. 18. Representative letters of JWW to WW are those of May 20, 1874, Papers, I, p. 50; November 8, 1876, ibid., p. 223; February 6, 16, 28, and March 7, 1877, ibid., pp. 250-252. WW’s adult reminiscences: WW to William J. Hampton, September 13, 1917, quoted in Baker, I, p. 34.Google Scholar
  6. 4.
    I have summarized this account of JRW’s life from John M. Mulder, Woodrow Wilson: the Years of Preparation (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1978), pp. 3–28.Google Scholar
  7. 5.
    Earliest memory: “Address on Abraham Lincoln,” February 12, 1909, quoted in Baker, I, p. 28. Role of JRW in WW’s education: ibid., pp. 37-41. WW’s late learning as result of slow recovery of organized education: Mulder, p. 31; WW’s late learning as result of passive-aggression: George and George, pp. 6-7; WW’s late learning as result of mixed cerebral dominance: Weinstein, pp. 15-18. Cousins’s observations: George and George, p. 8.Google Scholar
  8. 6.
    Baker, I, p. 59.Google Scholar
  9. 7.
    Ibid., pp. 64-77 and Weinstein, pp. 23-24.Google Scholar
  10. 8.
    Baker, I, pp. 77-80. Editorial note, “Wilson’s Study and Use of Shorthand, 1872–92,” Papers, I, pp. 8-19.Google Scholar
  11. 9.
    Promotion: January 5, 1873, ibid., p. 22. List of officers: ibid., August 25, 1873, pp. 24-25. Civilian dress: ibid., September 1, 1873, p. 28. London Times article about HMS Renown: ibid., April 5, 1874, pp. 43-46. Yacht Club: ibid., July 1, 1874, pp. 54-56.Google Scholar
  12. 10.
    William B. Hale, Woodrow Wilson, The Story of His Life (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1912), pp. 44–46. Quoted in Papers, I, pp. 21-22. See also editorial note, “Wilson’s Imaginary World,” ibid., pp. 20-22.Google Scholar
  13. 11.
    D. W. Winnicott, “Ego Distortion in Terms of True and False Self,” in The Maturational Process and the Facilitating Environment (1960; rpt. New York: International Universities Press, 1965), pp. 140–152.Google Scholar
  14. 12.
    Idealization in self-development: Heinz Kohut, Tne Analysis of the Self (New York: International Universities Press, 1971) pp. 37–56 and 74-78.Google Scholar
  15. 13.
    “Turning point” and summary of oratory: Baker, I, pp. 86-93. Prayer meetings: diary entry of October 22, 1876, Papers, I, p. 215. Letter to father is cited in Baker, I, p. 89Google Scholar
  16. 14.
    WW to JRW, May 23, 1877, Papers, I, pp. 265-266.Google Scholar
  17. 15.
    Introspection and depression: JRW to WW, January 25, 1878, ibid., pp. 345-6; January 27, 1880, ibid., pp. 596-7. Overcoat: November 12, 1877, ibid., p. 318. Comments on style: March 27, 1877, ibid., pp. 254-5; July 26, 1877, ibid., p. 287; August 10, 1877, ibid., p. 288; November 5, 1877, ibid., p. 315. Fishbone: October 23, 1877, ibid., p. 304.Google Scholar
  18. 16.
    Hard work, self-denial, earning success and reaction to WW’s disappointment: JRW to WW, December 22, 1877, ibid., pp. 331-2; January 25, 1878, ibid., pp. 345-6.Google Scholar
  19. 17.
    Pleasure in friendship: JRW to WW, July 26, 1877, ibid., p. 287. New York papers: May 9, 1878, ibid., pp. 375-6.Google Scholar
  20. 18.
    Expectations: JRW to WW, March 27, 1877, ibid., p. 254; July 26, 1877, ibid., p. 287; October 22, 1878, ibid., pp. 421-2. Unity of interest: November 12, 1877, ibid., p. 318.Google Scholar
  21. 19.
    Symptoms: WW to Robert Bridges, January 1, 1881, Papers, II, p. 9; WW to Richard Heath Dabney, February 1, 1881, ibid., p. 17.Google Scholar
  22. 20.
    Work as apprentice clerk: Henry Wilkinson Bragdon, Woodrow Wilson: the Academic Years (Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1967), p. 91. Details of proposal: Editorial note, “Wilson’s Proposal to Hattie Woodrow,” Papers, II, pp. 84-85.Google Scholar
  23. 21.
    Poem: ibid., pp. 91-94.Google Scholar
  24. 22.
    WW to Robert Bridges, March 15, 1882, ibid., pp. 107-108.Google Scholar
  25. 23.
    Name and initials: Bragdon, p. 76.Google Scholar
  26. 24.
    Editorial note, “Wilson’s Practice of Law,” Papers, II, pp. 144-145. For WW’s feelings of disillusionment with law and eagerness to return to studies, see also WW to Robert Bridges, April 29, 1883, ibid., pp. 343-344. WW and ELA: Editorial notes, “Wilson’s Early Courtship of Ellen Axson” and “The Engagement,” ibid., pp. 361-363 and 426-427.Google Scholar
  27. 25.
    Weinstein makes the important comparison of WW’s letter to EAW with the correspondence between WW and his mother: Weinstein, pp. 63-65. WW’s description of unhappy moods: WW to EAW, November 1, 1884, Papers, III, pp. 393-394.Google Scholar
  28. 26.
    Homesickness: WW to ELA, October 2, 1883, Papers, II, p. 449. “Active sympathy”: March 5, 1885, Papers, IV, p. 335. Disposition would sour: January 9, 1885, Papers, III, p. 592. “Half a man”: November 12, 1884, ibid., p. 429.Google Scholar
  29. 27.
    Immortal work: WW to ELA, November 5, 1884, ibid., p. 405 and November 1, 1884, ibid., pp. 393-394. Love of family: January 9, 1885, ibid., p. 592 and April 4, 1885, Papers, IV, p. 451. Nature expanded: January 16, 1884, Papers, II, p. 660. Love as luxury: February 5, 1884, Papers, III, p. 10. Love gives completeness: March 3, 1885, Papers, IV, pp. 324-325. Expression of love: November 5, 1884, Papers, III, p. 406. ELA inside his innermost life: October 28, 1884, ibid., p. 383 (Copyright 1967 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  30. 28.
    Earlier dream: WW to ELA, October 2, 1883, Papers, II, pp. 449-450. Later dream: July 26, 1884, Papers, III, p. 261.Google Scholar
  31. 29.
    WW’s account of anxiety and his dream: WW to ELA, January 4, 1884, Papers, II, pp. 644-647. WW’s “indiscreet” letter: December 25, 1883, ibid., pp. 601-602. ELA’s teasing response: December 31, 1883, ibid., p. 614. The editors of the Papers document that WW received that letter on January 3, 1884 in footnote one, ibid., p. 657.Google Scholar
  32. 30.
    WW to ELA, January 8, 1884, ibid., pp. 653-655 (Copyright 1967 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  33. 31.
    Chronology of WW’s visit to ELA and his own family: editors’ footnote three, ibid., p. 662. JRW’s diagnosing “sickness of heart”: WW to ELA, January 28, 1884, ibid., pp. 663-664. Visitors and preference to stay in Wilmington: January 31, 1884, ibid., pp. 667-668. Account of medical consultation: February 2, 1884, Papers, III, p. 4. Recovery: February 7, 1884, ibid., p. 12.Google Scholar
  34. 32.
    Mirroring function: Kohut, pp. 105-42.Google Scholar
  35. 33.
    Sigmund Freud, “A Childhood Recollection from Dichtung und Wahrheit,” in The Standard Edition of The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, ed. James Strachey (1917; rpt. London: The Hogarth Press and The Institute for Psychoanalysis, 1955) XVII, p. 156.Google Scholar
  36. 34.
    Advice on depression: JRW to WW, January 27, 1880, Papers, I, pp. 596-597 (Copyright 1967 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press). See also October 19, 1880, ibid., pp. 685-686. Advice not to back down: November 19, 1879, ibid., pp. 585-586; August 20, 1882, Papers, II, pp. 135-136.Google Scholar
  37. 35.
    Reaction to acceptance of Congressional Government: JRW to WW, December 2, 1884, Papers, III, p. 505. The dedication is quoted in WW to EAW, December 1, 1884, ibid., p. 503. JRW’s response to the dedication: January 30, 1885, Papers, IV, p. 208 (Copyright 1968 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  38. 36.
    JRW to WW, December 22, 1879, Papers, I, p. 589 and June 7, 1880, ibid., p. 660.Google Scholar
  39. 37.
    “Cool water”: JRW to WW, April 17, 1880, ibid., p. 650 and August 20, 1882, Papers, II, p. 135. Fears: June 7, 1880, Papers, I, p. 660 and May 17, 1884, Papers, III, p. 183.Google Scholar
  40. 38.
    Superior temperament and Clarksville: JRW to WW, December 17, 1884, ibid., p. 549. Superior gifts and request for manuscripts: April 5, 1886, Papers, V, p. 152. Mulder also noted the change in JRW and WW’s relationship: p. 89. For an instance where Woodrow still did react to his father’s critique, see JRW to WW, September 6 and 12, 1887, Papers, V, p. 584 and pp. 587-588 and Editorial note, “Wilson’s Desire for a ‘Literary Life,’” ibid., pp. 474-475.Google Scholar
  41. 39.
    JRW to WW, November 15, 1886 and March 12, 1887, ibid., p. 391 and p. 467 (Copyright 1968 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  42. 40.
    JRW to WW, January 5, 1889, Papers, VI, p. 38. See also January 10, 1889 and March 6, 1889, ibid., pp. 47-48 and 137-138.Google Scholar
  43. 41.
    JRW to WW, October 5, 1889, ibid., pp. 400-401 (Copyright 1969 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  44. 42.
    “Hunger”: JRW to WW, March 27, 1890, ibid., pp. 560-561. October 13, 1891, Papers, VII, p. 311 (Copyright 1969 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  45. 43.
    Bronchitis: JRW to WW, January 10, 1889, Papers, VI, pp. 47-48. Fear of boring WW: October 5, 1889, ibid., pp. 400-401. Fear of WW forgetting him: March 7, 1891, Papers, VII, p. 174. Ghost of a chill: October 13, 1891, ibid., p. 311.Google Scholar
  46. 44.
    WW’s reaction to JRW’s female relationship: WW to EAW, February 7, 1894, Papers, VIII, pp. 462-3. JRW’s terminal symptoms: EAW to Mary Eloise Hoyt, December 15, 1902, Papers, XIV, p. 294.Google Scholar
  47. 45.
    WW to ELA, August 16, 1884, Papers, III, p. 293. WW to ELA, May 14, 1885, Papers, IV, p. 590. Concern for JRW after JWW’s death: WW to Richard H. Dabney, Papers, V, p. 726.Google Scholar
  48. 46.
    Bronchitis: WW to JRW, January 13, 1889, Papers, VI, pp. 48-49. Christmas letter: December 16, 1888, ibid., p. 30 (Copyright 1969 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  49. 47.
    Spiritual capital: WW to Payton H. Hoge, January 31, 1903, Papers, XIV, p. 336. Life-long friend: WW to Edith Gittings Reid, February 3, 1903, ibid., pp. 347-348. Chivalric devotion: WW to Daniel Moreau Barringer, February 2, 1903, Papers, XV, p. 581.Google Scholar
  50. 48.
    Idealization: Kohut, Analysis of the Self, pp. 37-56 and 74-78; John Gedo, “Forms of Idealization in the Analytic Transference, Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 23 (1975), pp. 485-505.Google Scholar
  51. 49.
    Arnold Goldberg, “A Fresh Look at Perverse behavior,” International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 56 (1975), pp. 335–342.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  52. 50.
    For the effects of similar but far more extreme narcissistic fixations of a parent on the self-formulation of a child, see Kohut, “Discussion of ‘Further Data and Documents in the Schreber Case’ by William G. Niederland,” (1960) in Paul H. Ornstein, ed., The Search for the Self: Selected Writings of Heinz Kohut (New York: International Universities Press, 1978) pp. 305–308. See also a summary of Kohut’s discussion of a paper by Augusta Bonnard inGoogle Scholar
  53. Jerome Kavka, “Meetings of the Chicago Psychoanalytic Society: A Report,” Bulletin of the Philadelphia Association for Psychoanalysis, 12 (1962), pp. 174–176. Quoted in Search for the Self, pp. 650-651, footnote twelve.Google Scholar
  54. 51.
    For the narrative portions of this section on Wilson’s Princeton years, I have relied heavily on Baker, II, pp. 129-357; Bragdon, pp. 269-384; Mulder, pp. 158-228, and Arthur S. Link, Wilson: the Road to the White House (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1947) pp. 59–91. I will cite references for the key passages from these secondary sources and for all primary materials, which are collected in Papers, Vols. XIV-XX. WW’s diagnoses and reactions to his illness: Weinstein, pp. 141-149 and 165-180; EAW to Mary Eloise Hoyt, June 12, 1906, Papers, XVI, pp. 423-424; EAW to Florence Stevens Hoyt, June 27, 1906, ibid., pp. 429-430; Baker, II, pp. 201-208. Healing value of affection: WW to Frederic and Emily Yates, November 6, 1906, ibid., p. 481.Google Scholar
  55. 52.
    Originally planned twenty-five years to implement: Baker, II, pp. 226-227. Welcomed fight: WW to C. H. Dodge, July 1, 1907, Papers, XVII, pp. 240-241. Disintegration quote: “A Supplementary Report to the Board of Trustees of Princeton University,” c. December 13, 1906, Papers, XVI, p. 525 (Copyright 1973 by Princeton University Press. Excerpt reprinted by permission of Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  56. 53.
    “Black mood”; Arthur Walwroth, Woodrow Wilson, 3rd ed. (New York: Norton, 1978), p. 112. Friends’ puzzlement: Bragdon, pp. 328-329. EAW on WW’s reaction to Hibben: Baker, II, p. 266.Google Scholar
  57. 54.
    Although some of Weinstein’s evidence extends beyond Wilson’s prepolitical years, to which I have limited this paper, his major arguments are important and deserve summary. The letters Ellen wrote to Woodrow in the summer of 1908 while he was vacationing alone in Europe are missing. It is possible Woodrow or a family member destroyed them because they contained some reference to the affair. Early that same vacation, Woodrow ended a letter to Ellen with a profuse apology (he did not specify the offense), intensely reassured her of his love, insisted it was more than emotional, and assured her that if she trusted him, all would “come right”—including what she did not understand (again, unspecified) (WW to EAW, July 20, 1908, Papers, XVIII, pp. 371-372). In his speeches for years thereafter, he stopped referring to the white of the American flag as a symbol of purity. In 1914, a year after Wilson became president of the United States, Ellen died of chronic nephritis. After a deep depression, Woodrow met and quickly fell in love with Edith Boiling Galt, who became his second wife in 1916. During Wilson’s engagement to Galt, one of his aides received an anonymous letter stating that Mary Peck was going to publicize a loan Wilson had made to her and was going to release to his political enemies some of his letters. In a panic, Wilson met with Galt and discussed his earlier relationship with Peck. Later that same evening he wrote to Galt that his relationship with Peck was “a folly long ago loathed and repented of,” for which he felt guilty and punished and which he had tried to expiate “by disinterested service and honorable, self-forgetful, devoted love.” (WW to Edith Boiling Galt, September 19, 1915, Papers, XXXIV, p. 451) Galt forgave him, he felt wonderfully freed after his confession, and thereafter he resumed referring to the white of the flag as a symbol of purity (Weinstein, pp. 181-194 and 291-293).Google Scholar
  58. 55.
    Difficult to keep up spirits: WW to C. H. Dodge, June 18, 1908, Papers, XVIII, pp. 337-338. For progress in freeing his mind of Princeton, see WW to EAW, July 10 and August 3, 1908, ibid., p. 357 and p. 388.Google Scholar
  59. 56.
    Letter which rejoined the battle: WW to Moses T. Pyne, December 25, 1909, Papers, XIX, pp. 628-631. Copies were sent to all the other trustees.Google Scholar
  60. 57.
    Editorial note, “Wilson at the Meeting of the Board of Trustees of January 13, 1909,” Papers, XX, pp. 6-9.Google Scholar
  61. 58.
    Bragdon, pp. 371-372.Google Scholar
  62. 59.
    Dreams and exhaustion: WW to EAW, February 17, 1910, Papers, XX, p. 133. Longing for letters: WW to EAW, February 20 and 21, 1910, ibid., pp. 144-145; WW to M. A. H. Peck, February 21, 1910, ibid., pp. 150-151.Google Scholar
  63. 60.
    Pew-rents: “Woodrow Wilson is for True Democracy,” Pittsburgh Gazette Times, April 17, 1910, quoted in Papers, XX, pp. 363-365. Fields of blood: “Disaster Forecast by Wilson,” Pittsburgh Dispatch, April 17, 1910, quoted in Papers, XX, pp. 366-368.Google Scholar
  64. 61.
    WW’s comment to his wife: quoted in Eleanor Wilson McAdoo, The Woodrow Wilsons (New York: MacMillan, 1937), p. 101. Irony of contributor solution: Mulder, p. 224.Google Scholar
  65. 62.
    Weinstein, Biography, pp. 141-168 and 176-180.Google Scholar
  66. 63.
    Juliette and Alexander George, “Woodrow Wilson and Colonel House: A Reply to Weinstein, Anderson, and Link,” Political Science Quarterly, 96 (Winter, 1981–1982), pp. 641–665. A letter from Dr. Marmor appears as an appendix to that paper. The paper to which the Georges are responding is: Edwin WeinsteinCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. James W. Anderson, and Arthur S. Link, “Woodrow Wilson’s Political Personality: A Reappraisal,” Political Science Quarterly, 93 (Winter, 1978), pp. 585–598. Weinstein’s other major earlier paper: “Woodrow Wilson’s Neurological Illness,” The Journal of American History, 57 (September, 1970), pp. 324-351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Michael F. Marmor, “Wilson, Strokes, and Zebras,” New England Journal of Medicine, 307 (August 26, 1982), pp. 528–535.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Jerrold M. Post, “Woodrow Wilson Re-examined: The Mind-Body Problem Redux and Other Disputations,” Political Psychology, 4 (1984), 289–306.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. 64.
    Weinstein, Biography, p. 178.Google Scholar
  71. 65.
    Ideals as compensatory structure: Kohut, The Restoration of the Self (New York: International Universities Press, 1977), pp. 3–4 and 82-83.Google Scholar
  72. 66.
    WW to EAW, December 7, 1884, Papers, III, p. 522.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 1985

Authors and Affiliations

  • Joseph A. Bongiorno

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations