Advertisement

Premenstrual Syndrome and Criminal Responsibility

  • Christopher Boorse

Abstract

In 1980-81, two British women escaped murder convictions by arguing that their legal responsibility was diminished by premenstrual syndrome (PMS). In a fit of rage Sandie Craddock, an East London barmaid with 45 prior convictions, stabbed a fellow barmaid three times through the heart ( Regina v. Craddock, 1981, 1 C.L. 49; see also Apodaca & Fink, 1984; Carney & Williams, 1983). Christine English, after a quarrel with her lover, crushed him to death against a utility pole with her car (Regina v. English, an unreported decision of the Norwich Crown Court on November 10, 1981; see also Apodaca & Fink, 1984, p. 54; Carney & Williams, 1983, p. 261). With the aid of testimony by Dr. Katharina Dalton, the world’s most prominent advocate for PMS victims, each woman was convicted only of manslaughter due to PMS-diminished responsibility. Most remarkably, neither woman was punished for her killing: Craddock received probation; English, a 12-month conditional discharge with a driving ban. About a year after her conviction, Craddock (now Smith) was re-arrested for an equivocal attempt to murder a policeman; convicted on three new charges, Smith again argued PMS to mitigate her sentence and again received probation. These judgments were approved on appeal. According to magazine stories and Dalton (see her chapter, this volume), Craddock and English are only two of the many British and Canadian defendants to reduce their criminal responsibility by pleading PMS.

Keywords

Criminal Responsibility Premenstrual Syndrome Expert Testimony Premenstrual Symptom Model Penal Code 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abraham, G. E., 1980. Premenstrual tension. Current Problems in Obstetrics and Gynecology 3 5–39.Google Scholar
  2. Allen, J., 1982. Premenstrual frenzy. New York ,November 1, pp. 36–42.Google Scholar
  3. Altschule, M. D. and J. Brem, 1963. Periodic psychosis of puberty. American Journal of Psychiatry 119 1176–1178.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Angier, N. and J. Witzleben, 1982. Dr. Jekyll and Ms. Hyde. Discover ,November, pp. 28–34.Google Scholar
  5. Apodaca, L. and L. Fink, 1984. Criminal law Premenstrual syndrome in the courts. Washburn Law Journal 24 54–77.Google Scholar
  6. Arenella, P., 1977. The diminished capacity and diminished responsibility defenses Two children of a doomed marriage. Columbia Law Review 77 827–865.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Aristotle (translated by M. Ostwald), 1962. Nicomachean Ethics, Book III, Chapter 1. Bobbs-Merrill Co., Indianapolis, IN.Google Scholar
  8. Benn, S. I., 1967. Punishment. In P. Edwards (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Vol. 7. Macmillan, New York, NY, pp. 29–36.Google Scholar
  9. Bentham, J. (J. H. Burns and H.L.A. Hart, eds.), 1970. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation [1789]. Athlone Press, London.Google Scholar
  10. Berlin, F. S., G. K. Bergey, and J. Money, 1983. Periodic psychosis of puberty A case report. American Journal of Psychiatry 139 119–120.Google Scholar
  11. Blackman, J. and E. Brickman, 1984. The impact of expert testimony on trials of battered women who kill their husbands. Behavioral Science and Law 2 413–422.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bloom, J. and J. Atkinson, 1983. Evidence of Love. Bantam Books, New York, NY.Google Scholar
  13. Brahams, D., 1983. Epilepsy and legal insanity R. v. Sullivan. The Practitioner 227 421–423.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Brahams, D., 1983. Premenstrual tension and criminal responsibility. The Practitioner 227 807–813.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  15. Buchele, B. J. and J. P. Buchele, 1985. Legal and psychological issues in the use of expert testimony on rape trauma syndrome. Washburn Law Journal 25 26–42.Google Scholar
  16. Carney, R. M. and B. D. Williams, 1983. Recent decisions Criminal law -premenstrual syndrome a criminal defense. Notre Dame Law Review 69 253–269.Google Scholar
  17. Chambers, M., 1982. Menstrual stresses as a legal defense. New York Times ,May 29, p. 46.Google Scholar
  18. Clark, M. and D. Shapiro, 1981. The monthly syndrome. Newsweek, May 4, p. 74.Google Scholar
  19. Cohen, S. S., 1981. The premenstrual syndrome. Mademoiselle ,October, pp. 57–58.Google Scholar
  20. Cross, M. B., 1982. The expert as educator A proposed approach to the use of battered woman syndrome expert testimony. Vanderbilt Law Review 35 741–768.Google Scholar
  21. Cumming, C., 1984. Singing the PMS blues. Women’s Sports ,January, p. 54.Google Scholar
  22. Dalton, K., 1979. Once A Month. Hunter House, Pomona, CA.Google Scholar
  23. Dalton, K., 1982. Legal implications of PMS. World Medicine ,April 17, pp. 93–94.Google Scholar
  24. Dalton, K., 1984. The Premenstrual Syndrome and Progesterone Therapy (second edition). Year Book Medical Publishers, Chicago, IL.Google Scholar
  25. Dennerstein, L., F. Judd, and B. Davies, 1983. Psychosis and the menstrual cycle. Medical Journal of Australia 1 524–526.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. Diamond, B. L., 1956. Isaac Ray and the trial of Daniel M’Naghten. American Journal of Psychiatry 112 651–656.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  27. Dixon, P. H., 1979. Evidence -admissibility of evidence -Frye standard of general acceptance for admissibility of scientific evidence rejected in favor of balancing test [U.S. v. Williams], Cornell Law Review 64 875–885.Google Scholar
  28. d’Orban, P. T., 1981. Premenstrual syndrome A disease of the mind The Lancet 2 1413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. D’Orban, P. T., 1983. Medicolegal aspects of premenstrual syndrome. British Journal of Hospital Medicine 30 404–409.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  30. D’Orban, P. T. and J. Dalton, 1980. Violent crime and the menstrual cycle. Psychological Medicine 10 353–359.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Eagan, A. B., 1983. The selling of premenstrual syndrome. Ms, October, p. 26.Google Scholar
  32. Endo, M., M. Daiguji, Y. Asano, I. Yamashita, and S. Takahashi, 1978. Periodic psychosis recurring in association with menstrual cycle. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 39 456–466.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  33. Erlinder, C. P., 1984. Paying the price for Vietnam Post-traumatic stress disorder and criminal behavior. British Columbia Law Review 25 305–347.Google Scholar
  34. Fingarette, H., 1972. The Meaning of Criminal Insanity. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.Google Scholar
  35. Fingarette, H. and A. F. Hasse, 1979. Mental Disabilities and Criminal Responsibility. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.Google Scholar
  36. Ford, J. R., 1983. In defense of the defenders The Vietnam vet syndrome. Criminal Law Bulletin 19 434–441.Google Scholar
  37. Frank, R. T., 1931. The hormonal causes of premenstrual tension. Archives of Neurology and Psychiatry 26 1053–1054.Google Scholar
  38. Gaylin, W., 1982. The Killing of Bonnie Garland A Question of Justice. Simon and Schuster, New York, NY.Google Scholar
  39. Giannelli, P. C., 1980. The admissibility of novel scientific evidence Frye v. U.S. ,a half-century later. Columbia Law Review 80 1197–1250.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Glick, 1. D. and D. Stewart, 1980. A new drug treatment for premenstrual exacerbation of schizophrenia. Comprehensive Psychiatry 21 281–287.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Goldstein, A., 1967. The Insanity Defense. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.Google Scholar
  42. Gonzalez, E. R., 1981. Premenstrual syndrome An ancient woe deserving of modern scrutiny. Journal of the American Medical Association 245 1393.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Gray, C., 1981. Raging female hormones in the courts. Maclean’s June 15, pp. 46–49.Google Scholar
  44. Hall, J., I960. General Principles of Criminal Law (second edition). Bobbs-Merrill Co., Indianapolis, IN.Google Scholar
  45. Hardyman, D., 1978–79. The diminished capacity defense in California An idea whose time has gone Glendale Law Review 3 311–321.Google Scholar
  46. Heneson, N., 1984. The selling of PMS. Science 84 ,May, pp. 66–71.Google Scholar
  47. Henig, R. M., 1982. Dispelling menstrual myths. New York Times Magazine ,March 7, pp. 64–65.Google Scholar
  48. Herbert, W., 1982. Premenstrual changes. Science News ,December 11, pp. 380–381.Google Scholar
  49. Herrmann, D.H.J., 1983. The Insanity Defense Philosophical, Historical, and Legal Perspectives. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL.Google Scholar
  50. Holtzman, E., 1984. Premenstrual syndrome The indefensible defense. Harvard Women’s Law Journal 7 1–3.Google Scholar
  51. Hook, S. (Ed.), 1958. Determinism and Freedom in the Age of Modern Science. New York University Press, New York, NY.Google Scholar
  52. Hopson, J. L. and A. Rosenfeld, 1984. PMS Puzzling monthly symptoms. Psychology Today ,August, pp. 30–35.Google Scholar
  53. Kadish, S. and M. Paulsen, 1975. Criminal Law and Its Processes (third edition). Little, Brown and Co., Boston, MA.Google Scholar
  54. Kane, Jr., F. J., 1980. Postpartum disorders. In H. I. Kaplan, A. M. Freedman, and B. J. Sadock (Eds.), Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry, Vol. 2. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD, pp. 1343–1348.Google Scholar
  55. Kane, Jr., F. J., R. J. Daly, M. H. Wallach, and M. H. Keeler, 1966. Amelioration of premenstrual mood disturbance with a progestational agent (Enovid). Diseases of the Nervous System 27 339–342.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  56. Krausz, F. R., 1983. The relevance of innocence Proposition 8 and the diminished capacity defense. California Law Review 71 1197–1215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. LaFave, W. R. and A. W. Scott, Jr., 1972. Criminal Law. West, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
  58. Lauersen, N. and E. Stukane, 1982. Premenstrual syndrome Can you win the hormone war Mademoiselle ,December, pp. 148–149.Google Scholar
  59. Lindman, F. T. and D. M. Mclntyre, 1961. The Mentally Disabled and the Law. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.Google Scholar
  60. Massaro, T. M., 1985. Experts, psychology, credibility, and rape The rape trauma syndrome issue and its implications for expert psychological testimony. Minnesota Law Review 69 395–470.Google Scholar
  61. McCormick, C., 1972. Handbook of the Law of Evidence (second edition by E. W. Cleary). West, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
  62. MN. McGarrell, E. F. and T. J. Flanagan (Eds.), 1985. Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics -1984. U.S. Department of justice,Google Scholar
  63. Washington, D.C. Meehl, P., 1977. Specific etiology and other forms of strong influence Some quantitative meanings. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 2 33–53.Google Scholar
  64. Minton, L. E., 1980. Expert testimony based on novel scientific techniques Admissibility under the federal rules of evidence. George Washington Law Review 48 774–790.Google Scholar
  65. Moennsen, A. A., 1984. Admissibility of scientific evidence -an alternative to the Frye rule. William and Mary Law Review 26 545–575.Google Scholar
  66. Moore, M. S., 1984. Law and Psychiatry Rethinking the Relationship. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  67. Moos, R. H., 1969. Typology of menstrual cycle symptoms. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 103 390 -402.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  68. Morgenbesser, S. and J. Walsh (Eds.), 1962. Free Will. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.Google Scholar
  69. Mulligan, N., 1983. Recent developments Premenstrual syndrome. Harvard Women’s Law Journal 6 219–227.Google Scholar
  70. Murphy, E. A., 1976. The Logic of Medicine. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD.Google Scholar
  71. Muse, K. N., N. S. Cetel, L. A. Futterman, and S.S.C. Yen, 1984. The premenstrual syndrome Effects of ’medical ovariectomy.’ New England Journal of Medicine 311 1345–1349.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Norris, R. and C. Sullivan, 1983. PMS Premenstrual Syndrome. Rawson Associates, New York, NY.Google Scholar
  73. O’Donovan, K., 1984. The medicalisation of infanticide. Criminal Law Review 1984 259–264.Google Scholar
  74. O’Roark, M. A., 1981. Your once-a-month mood changes. McCalls ,July, pp. 12–16.Google Scholar
  75. Ota, Y., T. Mukai, and K. Gotoda, 1954. Studies on the relationship between psychotic symptoms and sexual cycle. Folia Psychiatria et Neurologic a Japonic a 8 203–217.Google Scholar
  76. Packer, I. K., 1983. Post-traumatic stress disorder and the insanity defense A critical analysis. Journal of Psychiatry and Law 11 125–136.Google Scholar
  77. Pahl-Smith, C., 1985. Premenstrual syndrome as a criminal defense The need for a medico-legal understanding. North Carolina Central Law Journal 13 246–273.Google Scholar
  78. Platt, A. and B. L. Diamond, 1966. The origins of the right and wrong test of criminal responsibility and its subsequent development An historical survey. California Law Review 54 1227,CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Press, A., 1982. Not guilty because of PMS Newsweek ,Novemoer 8, p. 111.Google Scholar
  80. Press, M. P., 1983. Premenstrual stress syndrome as a defense in crminal cases. Duke Law Journal 1983 176–195.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Ray, I., 1838. A Treatise on the Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity. Little, Brown and Co., Boston, MA.Google Scholar
  82. Reid, R. L., 1985. Premenstrual syndrome. Current Problems in Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Fertility 8 1–57.Google Scholar
  83. Reid, R. L. and S.S.C. Yen, 1981. Premenstrual syndrome. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 139 85–104.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  84. Reiser, M. and L. Whisnant, 1980. Endocrine disorders. In H. 1. Kaplan, A. M. Freedman, and B. J. Sadock (Eds.), Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry III, Vol. 2. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD, pp. 1917–1929.Google Scholar
  85. Robinson, P., 1984. Criminal Law Defenses. West, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
  86. Rose, E. F., 1970. Criminal responsibility and competency as influenced by organic disease. Missouri Law Review 35 326–348.Google Scholar
  87. Rubinow, D. R. and P. Roy-Byrne, 1984. Premenstrual syndromes Overview from a methodologic perspective. American Journal of Psychiatry 141 163–172.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  88. Sommer, B., 1984. PMS in the courts Are all women on trial Psychology Today ,August, pp. 36–38.Google Scholar
  89. Stalker, D. and C. Glymour (Eds.), 1985. Examining Holistic Medicine. Prometheus, Buffalo, NY.Google Scholar
  90. Steiner, M., R. F. Haskett, and B. J. Carroll, 1980. Premenstrual tension syndrome The development of research diagnostic criteria and new rating scales. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 62 177–190.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Sutherland, H. and I. Stewart, 1965. A critical analysis of the premenstrual syndrome. The Lancet 1 1180–1183.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Switzer, E., 1983. PMS The return of raging hormones. Working Woman ,October, pp. 123–127.Google Scholar
  93. Taylor, L. and K. Dalton, 1983. Premenstrual syndrome A new criminal defense California Western Law Review 19 269–287.Google Scholar
  94. Taylor, R., 1967. Determinism. In P. Edwards (Ed.), The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Vol. 2. Macmillan, New York, NY, pp. 359–373.Google Scholar
  95. Teja, J. S., 1976. Periodic psychosis of puberty. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 162 52–57.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. Thar, A. E., 1982. The admissibility of expert testimony on battered wife syndrome An evidentiary analysis. Northwestern University Law Review 77 348–373.Google Scholar
  97. Vinocur, B. A., 1983. Help for premenstrual syndrome. Saturday Evening Post ,April, pp. 34–37.Google Scholar
  98. Walker, N., 1968. Crime and Insanity in England, Vol. 1. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
  99. Walker, N., 1973. Crime and Insanity in England, Vol. 2. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
  100. Wallach, A. and L. Rubin, 1971. The premenstrual syndrome and criminal responsibility. UCLA Law Review 19 209–311.Google Scholar
  101. Walter, P. D., 1982. Expert testimony and battered women Conflict among the courts and a proposal. Journal of Legal Medicine 3 267–294.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Weiner, H., 1980. Schizophrenia Etiology. In H. I. Kaplan, A. M. Freedman, and B. J. Sadock (Eds.), Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry III, Vol. 2. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD, pp. 1121–1152.Google Scholar
  103. Williams, E. Y. and L. R. Weekes, 1952. Premenstrual tension associated with psychotic episodes. Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases 116 321–329.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  104. Williams, G., 1961. Criminal Law -The General Part (second edition). Stevens, London.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Plenum Press, New York 1987

Authors and Affiliations

  • Christopher Boorse
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of PhilosophyUniversity of DelawareNewarkUSA

Personalised recommendations