How well does the American public understand the hazards of nuclear power? A poll of radiation health scientists* shows that 82% of them feel that the public’s fear of radiation is “substantially” or “grossly” exaggerated. Another poll* shows that 89% of all scientists, and 95% of all scientists involved in energy-related fields, favor proceeding with the development of nuclear power; among the public there is only a slight majority in favor.
KeywordsPublic Opinion Acid Rain Nuclear Energy Public Understanding Highway Safety
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.P. Slovic, B. Fischoff, S. Lichtenstein, “Rating the Risks,” Environment, 21, 14, April (1979).Google Scholar
- 2.Effects during our lifetime are summarized in Chapter 4. Longer-term effects are summarized in Chapter 6.Google Scholar
- 3.Union of Concerned Scientists, “The Risks of Nuclear Power Reactors,” Cambridge, Massachusetts (1977). They give 2.4 deaths/GWe-yr, which multiplied by 50 GWe, the total amount generated in the U.S., gives 120 deaths/yr.Google Scholar
- 4.Opinion Research Corp, Public Attitudes toward Nuclear Power vs. Other Energy Sources. ORC Public Opinion Index, Vol. 38(17), September (1980).Google Scholar
- 5.C. L. Comar and L. A. Sagan, “Health Effects of Energy Production and Conversion,” Annual Review of Energy, 1, 581 (1976); L. B. Lave and L. C. Freeburg, “Health Effects of Electricity Generation from Coal, Oil, and Nuclear Fuel,” Nuclear Safety, 14(5), 409, (1973); S. M. Barrager, B. R. Judd, and D. W. North, “The Economic and Social Costs of Coal and Nuclear Electric Generation,” Stanford Research Institute Report, March (1976); Nuclear Energy Policy Study Group, “Nuclear Power—Issues and Choices” (Ballinger, Cambridge, Massa-chusetts, 1977); National Academy of Sciences Committee on Nuclear and Al-ternative Energy Systems, “Energy in Transition, 1985–2010” (W. H. Freeman and Co., San Francisco, 1980); American Medical Association Council on Scientific Affairs, “Health Evaluation of Energy Generating Sources,” Journal of the American Medical Association, 240,2193 (1978); H. Inhaber, “Risk of Energy Production,” Atomic Energy Control Board Report AECB-1119, Ottawa (1978); R. L. Gotchy, “Health Effects Attributable to Coal and Nuclear Fuel Cycle Alternatives,” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document NUREG-0332 (1977); D. J. Rose, P. W. Walsh, and L. L. Leskovjan, “Nuclear Power- Compared to What?” American Scientist, 64, 291 (1976); Union of Concerned Scientists, “The Risks of Nuclear Power Reactors,” H. Kendall (Director), Cambridge, Massachusetts (1977); Science Advisory Office, State of Maryland, “Coal and Nuclear Power,” (1980); Norwegian Ministry of Oil and Energy, “Nuclear Power and Safety,” (1978); Ohio River Basin Energy Study (EPA), “Impacts on Human Health from Coal and Nuclear Fuel Cycles,” July (1980); United Kingdom Health and Safety Executive, “Comparative Risks of Electricity Production Systems,” (1980); Maryland Power Plant Siting Program, “Power Plant Cumulative Environmental Impact Report,” PPSP-CEIR-1 (1975); W. Ramsay, Unpaid Costs of Electrical Energy (Johns Hopkins Univ. Press, Baltimore, Maryland, 1979); Legislative Office of Science Advisor, State of Michigan, “Coal and Nuclear Power” (1980); B. L. Cohen, American Scientist, 64, 291 (1976); R. Wilson and W. J. Jones, Energy, Ecology, and the Environment (Academic Press, New York, 1974); H. Fischer etal., “Comparative Effects of Different Energy Technologies,” Brookhaven National Lab Report BNL 51491 (Sept. 1981); D. K. Myers and H. B. Newcombe, “Health Effects of Energy Development,” Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. Report AECL-6678 (1980).Google Scholar
- 6.H. Kendall, Physics Colloquium at Carnegie-Mellon University, 1980.Google Scholar
- 7.In answer to my question, Nader replied, “Maybe we can clean up coal, or maybe we shouldn’t burn coal either.”Google Scholar
- 8.B. L. Cohen, “How Dangerous is Radiation, ” Ascent Magazine, 2, (4), 9 (1981).Google Scholar
- 9.R. Kasperson, G. Berk, A. Sharaf, D. Pijawka, and J. Wood, ‘Public Opinion and Nuclear Energy: Retrospect and Prospect,’ Science, Technology, and Human Values, 11 Spring (1980).Google Scholar
- 10.S. Rothman and S. R. Lichter, “The Nuclear Energy Debate: Scientists, The Media, and the Public,” Public Opinion, August/September (1982), p. 47.Google Scholar
- 11.E. Sternglass, Secret Fallout: Low Level Radiation from Hiroshima to Three Mile Island ( McGraw Hill, New York, 1981 ).Google Scholar
- 12.J. W. Gofman, Radiation and Human Health ( Sierra Club Press, San Francisco, 1981 ).Google Scholar
- 13.H. Caldicott, Nuclear Madness ( Bantam, New York, 1981 ).Google Scholar