Advertisement

Sensory Assessment of Appearance—Methodology

  • John B. Hutchings

Abstract

There are many reasons for sensory testing. In-house applications range from the development of new products, product matching and improvement, cost reduction, process or raw material change, to quality control, testing of storage stability, and product grading. The other major area of sensory testing seeks consumer opinion, and judgements of product acceptability and preference. Product appearance is involved in all sensory testing through:
  • its intrinsic importance in the total mix of product properties; or

  • the necessity for its concealment so that judges can concentrate on flavour or texture; or

  • its halo effect tending to influence judges’ opinions of other sensory properties which are more subtle or difficult to score.

Keywords

Sensory Evaluation Halo Effect Taste Threshold Sensory Assessment Food Tech 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adams Grace Kinkle (1923) An experimental study of memory colour and related phenomena. Am J Psychol 34 359–407Google Scholar
  2. Allison R I, Uhl K (1964) Influence of beer brand identification on taste perception. J Marketing Res 1 36–39Google Scholar
  3. Anthoney Kurt, Ennis Daniel, Cook Peter (1984) Lemon juice color evaluation—sensory and instrumental studies. J Food Sci 49 1435–1437Google Scholar
  4. ASTM (1982) Committee D 1, Standard Practice for Visual Evaluation of Color Differences of Opaque Materials. ASTM D 1729–82Google Scholar
  5. ASTM (1984) Committee D 13, Standard Practice for Lighting Cotton Classing Rooms for Color Grading. ASTM D 1684–84Google Scholar
  6. ASTM (1985) Committee D 1, Standard Method for Visual Evaluation of Gloss Differences Between Surfaces of Similar Appearance. ASTM D 4449–85Google Scholar
  7. Berger Arthur Asa (1979) Reflections on the American diet. J Am Culture 2 433–435Google Scholar
  8. Berlin Brent, Kay Paul (1969) Basic Color Terms [Berkeley: University of California Press]Google Scholar
  9. Booth D A (1987) Objective measurement of determinants of food acceptance, sensory, physiological and psychosocial. In Food Acceptance and Nutrition, eds J Solms, D A Booth, R M Pangborn, O Raunhardt [New York: Academic Press] 1–27Google Scholar
  10. Brien C J, May P, Mayo O(1987) Analysis of judge performance in wine-quality evaluations. J Food Sci 52 1273–1279Google Scholar
  11. BS (1967) Standard Specification for Artificial Daylight for the Assessment of Colour, Part 1 Illuminant for Colour Matching and Colour Appraisal. BS950:partlGoogle Scholar
  12. Burnam R W, Onley J W, Witsel R F (1970) Exploratory investigation of perceptual color scaling. J Opt Soc Am 60 1410–1414Google Scholar
  13. Butcher K N (1988) Flavour—in the mind or matter?. In Proceedings of the Second Aviemore Conference on Malting Brewing and Distilling, eds I Cambell, F G Priest [London: Institute of Brewing] 371–374Google Scholar
  14. Cardello Armand V, Segars Ronald R (1989) Effects of sample size and prior mastication on texture judgements. J Sens Stud 4 1–18Google Scholar
  15. Chipping Campden (1988) Campden Imported Canned Food Specification— Canned corned beefGoogle Scholar
  16. Christensen Carol M (1983) Effects of color on aroma flavor and texture judgements of foods. J Food Sci 48 787–790Google Scholar
  17. Christensen Carol M (1985) Effect of color on judgements of food aroma and flavor intensity in young and elderly adults. Perception 14 755–762Google Scholar
  18. Clydesdale F M, Gover R, Philipsen D H, Fugardi C (1992) The effect of colour on thirst quenching, sweetness, acceptability and flavor intensity in fruit punch flavored beverages. J Food Qual 15 19–38Google Scholar
  19. Cole M, Scribner S (1974) Culture and Thought—A Psychological Introduction [New York: Wiley]Google Scholar
  20. Dethmers A E (chairman) (1981) Sensory evaluation guide for testing food and beverage products. Food Tech 35 50–59Google Scholar
  21. DuBose C N, Cardello A V, Maller O (1980) Effects of colorants and flavorants on identification, perceived flavor intensiffy and hedonic quality of fruit-flavored beverages and cake. J Food Sci 45 1393–1399,1415Google Scholar
  22. Eggert Jean, Zook Katherine eds (1986) Physical Requirement Guidelines for Sensory Evaluation Laboratories. ASTM PCN 04–913000–36Google Scholar
  23. Fellers Paul J, Barron Rodger W (1987) A commercial method for recovery of natural pigment granules from citrus juices for color enhancement purposes. J Food Sci 52 994–995,1005Google Scholar
  24. Fellers P J, de Jager G, Poole M J (1986) Quality of retail Florida-packed frozen concentrated orange juice as determined by consumers and physical and chemical analyses. J Food Sci 51 1187–1190Google Scholar
  25. Fletcher T O T (1980) Lighting of Horticultural Packing Houses [London: Ministry of Agriculture & Fisheries]Google Scholar
  26. Fletcher Leah, Heymann Hildegarde, Ellersieck Mark (1991) Effects of visual masking techniques on the intensity rating of sweetness of gelatins and lemonades. J Sensory Stud 6 179–191Google Scholar
  27. Foster Tracey, Kilcast David (1988) Sensory panels: the Leatherhead advantage. Food Manuf 63 (Nov) 45–46Google Scholar
  28. Galanter E K, Messick S (1961) The relationship between category and magnitude scales. Psychophys Rev 68 363–372Google Scholar
  29. Gallwey T J (1982) Selection tests for visual inspection on a multiple fault type task. Ergonomics 25 1077–1092Google Scholar
  30. Gatchalian Miflora M, de Leon Sonia Y, Yano Toshimasa (1991) Control chart technique—a feasible approach to measurement of panelist performance in product profile development. J Sensory Stud 6 236–254Google Scholar
  31. Gifford S R, Clydesdale F M (1986) The psychophysical relationship between colour and sodium chloride concentrations in model systems. J Food Prot 49 977–982Google Scholar
  32. Gifford Sandra R, Clydesdale Fergus M, Damon Richard A Jr (1987) The psychophysical relationships between color and salt concentrations in chicken flavored broths. J Sensory Stud 2 137–147Google Scholar
  33. Griffiths Paul (1978) Catalogue de couleurs. The Musical Times 119 1035–1037Google Scholar
  34. Halstead (1992) Private communication of the results of CIE British Panel TC3.2, annex 6 to circular 1/79Google Scholar
  35. Harper Rowland (1977) Our senses and how we use them. In Proceedings of a Sensory Quality Control Conference, eds H W Symons, J J Wren [Birmingham: University of Aston] 4–18Google Scholar
  36. Helm C E (1964) J Opt Soc Am 54 256; quoted in Wish and Caroll (1973)Google Scholar
  37. Heymann H, Hedrick H B, Karrasch M A, Eggeman M K, Ellersieck M R (1990) Sensory and chemical characteristics of fresh pork roasts cooked to different endpoint temperatures. J Food Sci 55 613–617Google Scholar
  38. Howard A (1976) Psychometric scaling of sensory texture attributes of meat. J Text Stud 7 95–107Google Scholar
  39. Howgate P (1977) Measurement of fish freshness by an objective sensory method. In Proceedings of a Sensory Quality Control Conference, eds H W Symons, J J Wren [Birmingham: University of Aston] 41–48Google Scholar
  40. Indow T (1973) Handbook of Perception, eds EC Carterette, MP Friedman [New York: Academic Press]Google Scholar
  41. Indow T, Kanazawa K (1960) Multidimensional mapping of colours varying in hue, value and chroma. J Exp Psychol 59 330–336Google Scholar
  42. Indow T, Uchizono T (1960) Multidimensional mapping of colours varying in hue and chroma. J Exp Psychol 59 321–329Google Scholar
  43. Ishihara Charts,Tokyo: Kanehara ShuppanGoogle Scholar
  44. Jellinek Gisela (1985) Sensory Evaluation of Food [Chichester: Ellis Horwood]Google Scholar
  45. Jellinek J S (1988) Perfumes and colors, a European consumer attitude study. Dragaco Report (1) 14–29Google Scholar
  46. Johnson J, Clydesdale F M (1982) Perceived sweetness and redness in colored sucrose solutions. J Food Sci 47 747–752Google Scholar
  47. Jones Richard C, Dransfield Eric, Crosland Adrian R, Francombe Mariko A (1989) Sensory characteristics of British sausages—relationships with composition and mechanical properties. J Sci Food Agric 48 63–85Google Scholar
  48. Kostyla Aurora Saulo (1978) The Psychophysical Relationships Between Color and Flavor. University of Massachusetts ThesisGoogle Scholar
  49. Kostyla Aurora S, Clydesdale Fergus M (1978) The psychophysical relationships between color and flavor. CRC Crit Rev Food Sci and Nut 10 303–319Google Scholar
  50. Larmond Elizabeth (1977) Laboratory Methods for Sensory Evaluation of Food. Canada Department of Agriculture, publication 1637Google Scholar
  51. Little Angela C (1964) Color measurement of translucent food samples. J Food Sci 29 782–789Google Scholar
  52. Lowe Martin (1979) Influence of changing lifestyles on food choice. In Nutrition and Lifestyles, ed Michael Turner [London: Applied Science] 806Google Scholar
  53. Lozano Roberto Daniel (1989) Colour in foods. In Proceedings of the Sixth Congress of the International Colour Association,Buenos Aires, 1 115–139Google Scholar
  54. Lundgren B (1981) Effect of nutritional information on consumer responses. In Criteria of Food Acceptance Symposium Proceedings, eds J Solms, R L Hall [Zurich: Forster] 27–33Google Scholar
  55. Lyon B G (1988) Descriptive profile analysis of cooked, stored and reheated chicken patties. J Food Sci 53 1086–1090Google Scholar
  56. MacDougall Douglas B, Moncrieff Clive B (1988) Influence of flattering and triband illumination on preferred redness-pinkness of bacon. In Food Acceptability, ed David M H Thomson [London: Elsevier]Google Scholar
  57. MacKinney G, Little Angela C, Brinner Lisa (1966) Visual appearance of foods. Food Tech 20 1300, 1302, 1304–1306Google Scholar
  58. Maga J A (1974) Influence of color on taste thresholds. Chem Senses and Flavor 1 115–119Google Scholar
  59. Marks Lawrence E (1975) Synesthesia. Psychology Today 9 48–52Google Scholar
  60. Martin Derek (1990) The impact of branding and marketing on perception of sensory qualities. Food Sci and Tech Today 4 (1) 44–49Google Scholar
  61. McBride R L (1985) Stimulus range influences intensity and hedonic ratings of flavour. Appetite 6 125–131Google Scholar
  62. McBride R L (1986) Hedonic rating of food, single or side by side presentation? J Food Tech 21 355–364Google Scholar
  63. McLaren K (1985) Newton’s indigo. Color Res and Appl 10 225–229Google Scholar
  64. Meilgaard Morten, Civille Gail Vance, Carr B Thomas (1987) Sensory Evaluation Techniques, 1 and 2 [Boca Raton Florida: CRC Press]Google Scholar
  65. Meiselman Herbert L, Hirsch Edward S, Popper Richard D (1988) Sensory, hedonic and situational factors in food acceptance and consumption. In Food Acceptability, ed David H Thomson [London: Elsevier] 77–87Google Scholar
  66. Moir H C (1936) Some observations on the appreciation of flavour in foodstuffs. Chem Ind 55 145–148Google Scholar
  67. Morris N, van der Reis A P (1980) The transferability of rating scale techniques to an African population. Technology Transfer and Res 11 417–436Google Scholar
  68. Moskowitz Howard R (1977) Magnitude estimation, notes on what, how, when and why to use it. J Food Qual 3 195–227Google Scholar
  69. Moskowitz Howard R (1983) Product Testing and Sensory Evaluation of Foods [Westport Conn: Food & Nutrition Press]Google Scholar
  70. Moskowitz Howard R (1985) New Directions for Product Testing and Sensory Analysis of Foods [Westport Conn: Food & Nutrition Press]Google Scholar
  71. Moskowitz H R, Jacobs B E (1986) The relative importance of sensory attributes for food acceptance. Acta Alimentaria 15 29–38Google Scholar
  72. Naes Tormod, Solheim Ragnhild (1991) Detection and interpretation of variation within and between assessors in sensory profiling. J Sensory Studies 6 159–177Google Scholar
  73. Nelson G, Smith D L (1977) Sensory evaluation in the confectionery industry. In Proceedings of Sensory Quality Control Conference, eds H W Symons and J J Wren [Birmingham: University of Aston] 85–87Google Scholar
  74. Noel P, Goutedonega R (1985) Saucisses thermiques de type francfort a base de proteines vegetales—stabilite et coloration de l’emulsion. In Proceedings of the 31st Eur Meet Meat Res Work, Albena, Bulgaria, 786–789Google Scholar
  75. O’Mahony Michael (1979) Psychophysical aspects of sensory analysis of dairy products—a critique. J Dairy Sci 62 1954–1962Google Scholar
  76. O’Mahony M, Thieme U, Goldstein L R (1988) The warm up effect as a means of increasing the discriminability of sensory difference tests. J Food Sci 53 1848–1850Google Scholar
  77. Ough C S, Amerine M A (1970) Effect of subjects sex, experience and training on their red wine color-preference patterns. Perceptual and Motor Skills 30 395–398Google Scholar
  78. Peleg M (1983) The semantics of rheology and texture. Food Tech 37 (11) 54–61Google Scholar
  79. Pinkerton Elizabeth, Humphrey N K (1974) The apparent heaviness of colours. Nature 250 164–165Google Scholar
  80. Presswood J B (1977) Butter and cheese grading. In Proceedings of Sensory Quality Control Conference, eds H W Symons and J J Wren [Birmingham: University of Aston] 54–59Google Scholar
  81. Resurreccion A V A, Heaton E K (1987) Sensory and objective measures of quality of early harvested and traditionally harvested pecans. J Food Sci 52 1038–1058Google Scholar
  82. Rhodes D N (1970) Meat quality—the influence of fatness of pigs on the eating quality of pork. J Sci Food Agric 21 572–575Google Scholar
  83. Roth H A, Radle L J, Gifford S R, Clydesdale F M (1988) Psychophysical relationships between perceived sweetness and color in lemon and lime flavored drinks. J Food Sci 53 1116–1119,1162Google Scholar
  84. Sallis R E, Buchalew L W (1984) Relation of capsule color and perceived potency. Perceptual and Motor Skills 58 897–898Google Scholar
  85. Sanford K A, Gullett E A, Roth V J (1988) Optimization of the sensory properties of frozen peas by principal components analysis and multiple regression. Can Inst Food Sci Tech J 21 174–181Google Scholar
  86. Scheide J (1976) Flavour and medium, mutual effects and relationship. Ice Cream & Frozen Confect 228–230Google Scholar
  87. Scholes Percy A (1965) The Oxford Companion to Music, 9th edn [Oxford University Press] 200–208Google Scholar
  88. Scott Rosemary (1976) The Female Consumer [London: Associated Business Programmes]Google Scholar
  89. Severino G G, McBride R L, Cox B M (1987) People prefer coloured flavours. CSIRO Research Quarterly 47 (3) 64–65Google Scholar
  90. Sheen Margaret R, Drayton Jennifer L (1988) Influence of brand label on sensory perception. In Food Acceptability, ed David H Thomson [London: Elsevier]Google Scholar
  91. Shepherd R, Griffiths N M (1987) Preferences for eggs produced under different systems assessed by consumer and laboratory panels. Lebensm-Wiss u-Tech 20 128–132Google Scholar
  92. Shepherd R, Griffiths N M, Smith K (1988) The relationship between consumer preferences and trained panel responses. J Sensory Stud 3 19–35Google Scholar
  93. Siegel Stephen F, Risvik Einar (1987) Cognitive set and food acceptance. J Food Sci 52 825–826Google Scholar
  94. Stevens S S (1975) Psychophysics. Introduction to Its Perceptual, Neural and Social Prospects [New York: Wiley]Google Scholar
  95. Stone Herbert (1988) Using sensory resources to identify successful products. In Food Acceptability, ed David Thomson [London: Elsevier] 283–297Google Scholar
  96. Swatland Howard J (1988) Carotene reflectance and the yellowness of bovine adipose tissue measured with a portable fibre-optic spectrophotometer. J Sci Food Agric 46 195–200Google Scholar
  97. Tabachnick B G, Fidell L S (1983) Using Multivariate Statistics [New York: Harper & Row]Google Scholar
  98. Teghtsoonian R, Teghtsoonian M (1982) Perceived effect in sniffing. Percept and Psychophys 31 324–329Google Scholar
  99. Teghtsoonian R, Teghtsoonian M, Berglund B, Berglund U (1978) Invariance of odor strength with sniff vigor. J Exp PsycholHuman Percept and Perform 4 144–149Google Scholar
  100. Theobald D J (1977) Sensory evaluation in tea buying and blending. In Proceedings of a Sensory Quality Control Conference, eds H W Symons, J J Wren [Birmingham: University of Aston] 69–72 & 76–77Google Scholar
  101. Thomson David (1989) Recent advances in sensory and affective methods. Food Sci and Tech Today 3 83–88Google Scholar
  102. Timberlake Colin F (1982) Colours in beverages. Food Flavourings Ingredients Proc and Packaging 4 (7) 14–17Google Scholar
  103. Trant A S, Pangborn R M (1983) Discrimination, intensity and hedonic responses to color, aroma, viscosity and sweetness of beverages. Lebensm-Wiss u-Tech 16 147–152Google Scholar
  104. Truscott T G, Hudson J E, Anderson S K (1984) Differences between observers in assessment of meat colour. Proc of the Australian Society of Animal Production 15 762Google Scholar
  105. van Ooyen M H F, van der Weijgert J A C, Begemann S H A (1987) Preferred luminances in offices. J Ilium Eng Soc 16 152–156Google Scholar
  106. Vickers Zata (1988) Sensory specific satiety in lemonade using a just right scale for sweetness. J Sensory Stud 3 1–8Google Scholar
  107. Whorf B L (1956) Language,Thought and Reality [New York: Wiley]Google Scholar
  108. Williams Anthony A, Langren Steven P, Timberlake Colin F, Bakker Johanna (1984) Effect of colour on the assessment of ports. J Food Tech 19 659–671Google Scholar
  109. Williams A A, Baines C R, Finnie M S (1986) Optimization of colour in commercial port blends. J Food Tech 21 451–461Google Scholar
  110. Wish Myron, Carroll J Douglas (1973) Concepts and applications of multidimensional scaling. In Sensory Evaluation of Appearance of Materials, STP545, eds R S Hunter, P N Martin [American Society for Testing and Materials] 91–108Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 1994

Authors and Affiliations

  • John B. Hutchings
    • 1
  1. 1.ColmworthBedfordUK

Personalised recommendations