Wanted and Welcome?

Part of the series Immigrants and Minorities, Politics and Policy pp 123-143


Pointless: On the Failure to Adopt an Immigration Points System in the United States

  • Gary P. FreemanAffiliated withUniversity of Texas Email author 
  • , David L. LealAffiliated withUniversity of Texas
  • , Jake OnyettAffiliated withUniversity of Texas

* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.

Get Access


When bipartisan efforts to adopt comprehensive immigration reform (CIR) legislation collapsed in the U.S. Congress in June 2007, proposals for a merit-based “points system” to select prospective immigrants died with it. We explain why comprehensive reform did not pass and show that points system proposals did not enhance prospects for reform.