Oil Transport Management pp 27-62 | Cite as

# Oil Tanker Economics: A Case of Oligopsony or of Perfect Competition?

## Abstract

This chapter examines the economic structure and organization of the tanker industry, past, and present. It helps reader to understand the nature of the competition in the tanker industry. We therefore study: (a) the nature of the competition, (b) the structure of the industry, and (c) the practices adopted by oil companies as monopsonist in oil transport and as oligopolists in tanker ownership, and in the demand for tanker space. Many maritime economists believe that the supply of tankers operates under perfect competition. We may remember that ‘Pure competition’ means the complete absence of monopsony and monopoly or oligopoly and oligopsony, which means, therefore, that the tanker market is far from being purely competitive. According to economic theory, perfect competition implies perfect knowledge and frictionless capital mobility, neither of which is present in the tanker business either. Using Herfindahl index and the percent of world tonnage owned by the four biggest shipping companies, this paper shows that ownership is over-concentrated to be a competitive market. It is therefore concluded that the tanker market is monopsonistic.

### Keywords

Shipping Marketing Diesel Gasoline Volatility### References

- Arthur BW (1994) Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical small events. In: Arthur WB (ed) Increasing returns and path dependence in the economy. Michigan University Press, Ann Arbor, ISBN 0-472-06496-7Google Scholar
- Beenstock M, Vergottis A (1993) Econometric modelling of world shipping. In: Motamen-Scobie H (ed) Chapman and Hall. Kluwer Academic Publishers, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Berg-Andreassen JA (1997) The relationship between period and spot rates in international maritime markets. Marit Policy Manag 24(4):335–350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Bertrand J (1883) Review of cournot’s paper. J des Savants 68:499–508Google Scholar
- Besanko D, Dranove D, Shanley M, Schaefer S (2010) Economics of strategy. Wiley, New York. (Also 2004 edition)Google Scholar
- Bilas RA (1967) Microeconomic theory: a graphical analysis. McGraw-Hill Book Co, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Binkley VD, Bessler DA (1983) Expectations in bulk ocean shipping: an application of autoregressive modeling. Rev Econ statistics 65:516–520CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- BP (2008) Sustainability review. bp.com/sustainabilityGoogle Scholar
- Bulow J, Geanakopoulos J, Klemperer PD (1985) Multimarket oligopoly: a strategic substitutes and complements. J Pol Econ 93(3):488–511CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Button K (2005) Shipping economics: where we are and looking ahead from an institution economics perspective. Marit Policy Manag Int J 32(1):39–58 J-MMathSciNetCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Chandler AD Jr (1990) Scale and scope: the dynamics of industrial capitalism. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Chandler AD (1962) Strategy and structure. MIT Press, BostonGoogle Scholar
- Chamberlin EH (1933) The theory of monopolistic competition 7th edn. Harvard University Press, Cambridge Mass 1960Google Scholar
- Chen YS, Wang ST (2004) The empirical evidence of the leverage effect on volatility in international bulk shipping market. Marit Policy Manag 32(2):109–124CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Couper A (1998) The crisis decades. Marit policy Manag 25(3):207–211 Editorial notes for the 25 years of the journalCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Cournot A (1835, 1897) On the competition of producers, in research into the mathematical principles of the theory of Wealth, translated by Bacon NT. Macmillan, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Dikos G (2004) New building prices: demand inelastic or perfectly competitive? Marit Econ Logist 6:312–321CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Dikos G, Markus HS (2003) The term structure of second-hand prices: a structural partial equilibrium model. Marit Econ Logist 5:251–267CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Dikos G, Sgouridis SP (2008) On the optimal timing of the oil pollution act: is there more value in waiting than acting? Int J Ocean Syst Manag 1(3):100–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Dinwoodie J, Morris J (2003) Tanker forward freight agreements: the future of freight futures? Marit Policy Manag 30(1):45–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Dixit A, Pindyck R (1994) Investment under uncertainty. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
- Engelen S, Dullaert W, Vernimmen B (2009) Market efficiency within dry bulk markets in the short run: a multi-agent system dynamics Nash equilibrium. Marit Policy Manag 36(5):385–396CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Evans JJ, Marlow PB (1990) Quantitative methods in maritime economics, 2nd edn. Fairplay publications, SurreyGoogle Scholar
- Evans JJ (1994) An analysis of efficiency of the bulk shipping markets. Marit Policy Manag 21(4):311–329CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Evans JJ (1998) (Ed). Marit Policy Manag 25(4):1–3MATHGoogle Scholar
- Farthing B, Brownrigg M (1997) Farthing on international shipping, 3rd edn. Lloyds of London Press, London. ISBN 1-85978-159-4Google Scholar
- Fisher F (1991) Industrial organization, economics and the law. MIT press, BostonGoogle Scholar
- Geithman H, Marvel F, Weiss L (1981) Concentration, price, and critical concentration ratios. Rev Econ Stat 63:349–350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Georgantopoulos EA (1959) Sea transport. Leontis Editions, PiraeusGoogle Scholar
- Gilje TT, Dinwoodie J, Challacombe J (2002) Crude carrier consolidation and capital cost. Int J Marit Econ 4:35–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Glen DR, Martin BT (1998) Conditional modeling of tanker market risk using route specific freight rates. Marit Policy Manag 25(2):117–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Glen DR (1990) The emergence of differentiation in the oil tanker market. Marit Policy Manag 17(4):289–312CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Glen D, Owen M, Van der Meer R (1981) Spot and time charter rates for tanker 1970-1977. J Trans Econ Policy 1:45-58Google Scholar
- Goulielmos AM (2001) Matters of definition: maritime economics revisited, scientific yearbook in honor of late Professor D Kodosakis. Department of Business Administration. University of Piraeus, Greece, pp 211–228Google Scholar
- Goulielmos AM, Psifia M-E (2006) Shipping finance: time to follow a new track? Int J Marit Policy Manag 33(03):301–320CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Goulielmos AM, Psifia M-E (2009) Forecasting weekly freight rates for one year TC 65,000 dwt bulk carrier, 1989–2008, using nonlinear methods. Int J Marit Policy Manag 36(4):411–436CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Goulielmos AM (2005) Complexity theory: a science where historical accidents matter. Disaster Prev Manag Int J 14(4):533–547CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Goss RO (2002) An early history of maritime economics. Int J Marit Econ 4:390–404CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hawdon D (1978) Tanker freight rates in the short and long run. Appl Econ 10:203–217CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Heaver TD (1973) Commends in shipping management, In: Lorange P, Norman VD (eds) Institute Shipping Research. Bergen, Norway, Proceedings from a seminar in Bergen, August 23–26, 1972. Maritime Research Centre, The Hague, NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
- Henderson JM, Quandt RE (1958) Microeconomic theory: a mathematical approach. McGraw-Hill Book Co, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Hicks JR (1946) Value and capital: an inquiry into some fundamental principles of economic theory, 2nd edn. Oxford at the Clarendon Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Hirshleifer J, Glazer A (1992) Price theory and applications, 5th edn. Prentice-Hall Int., Inc., New JerseyGoogle Scholar
- Intertanko (1996) Current issues facing the tanker industry. discussion paper, OsloGoogle Scholar
- Intertanko (2000) Key tanker market figures with focus on European trades. OsloGoogle Scholar
- ISM (Code) (2002) International safety management code, IMO, SOLAS Chapter IX, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Kavussanos MG (1996) Measuring risk differences among segments of the tanker freight markets, Discussion paper No 18, ICSTF. City University, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Kavussanos MG (2003) Time varying risks among segments of the tanker freight markets. Marit Econ Logistics 5:227–250CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kavussanos M, Alizadeh MA (2002) Seasonality patterns in tanker shipping freight markets. Econ Model 19:747–782CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Keynes JM (1936) The general theory of employment, interest and money. Macmillan and Co Ltd, London, 1961 ReprintGoogle Scholar
- Koopmans TC (1939) Tanker freight rates and tankship building. In: De Erven F, Bohn NV Netherlands Economic Institute, Report no 27, HaarlemGoogle Scholar
- Kreps D, Scheikman J (1983) Quantity precommitment and Bertrand competition yield Cournot outcomes. Bell J Econ 14:326–337CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lyridis DV, Zacharioudakis P, Mitrou P, Mylonas A (2004) Forecasting tanker market using artificial neural networks. Marit Econ Logist 6:93–108CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McConville J (1999) Economics of maritime transport: theory and practice. Witherby & Co, LondonGoogle Scholar
- McDonald M, Dunbar I (1995) Market segmentation: a step-by-step approach to creating profitable market segments. Macmillan Business, UKGoogle Scholar
- McGee JS (1958) Predatory price cutting: the standard oil (NJ) case. J law Econ vol. IGoogle Scholar
- Merikas AG, Merika AA, Koutroubousis G (2008) Modelling the investment decisions of the entrepreneur in the tanker sector: choosing between a second-hand vessel and a newly built one. Marit Policy Manag 35(5)Google Scholar
- Metaxas BN (1971) The economics of tramp shipping. The Athlone Press of the University of London, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Muth JF (1961) Rational expectations and the theory of price movements. Econometrica 29:315–355CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Norman VD (1979) Economics of bulk shipping. Institute of Shipping Research Report, BergenGoogle Scholar
- OECD (1975) Maritime transport. France, ParisGoogle Scholar
- Pashigian BP (1995) Price theory and applications. McGraw-Hill, Inc., New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Pearson G (2009) The rise and fall of management: a brief history of practice, theory, and context. Ashgate Publishing Co, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Shefrin SM (1983) Rational expectations. CUP, UKGoogle Scholar
- Shimojo T (1979) Economic analysis of shipping freights. Kobe University, RIEBAGoogle Scholar
- Stigler G (1964) A theory of oligopoly. J Political EconGoogle Scholar
- Stopford M (2009) Maritime economics, 3rd edn. Routledge, Oxon. ISBN 978-0-415-27558-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Strandenes SP (1999) Is there potential for a two-tier tanker market? Marit Policy Manag 26(31):249–264CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Strandenes SP (2002) The economics of the market for ships, in handbook of maritime economics and business. LLP, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Sutcliffe CUS (2006) Stock index futures, 3rd edn. Ashgate, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Svendsen AS (1958) Sea transport and shipping economics, as in Tinbergen, Republished by Bremen Institute for Shipping and LogisticsGoogle Scholar
- Thorburn T (1960) Supply and demand of water transport. StockholmGoogle Scholar
- Tinbergen J (1959) In: Klaassen LH, Koyck N, Wittereen HJ, Holland N (eds) A shipbuilding cycle? Weltwirtschaftliches Arciv 34:152–164Google Scholar
- Tsolakis SD, Cridland C, Haralambides HE (2003) Econometric modelling of second-hand ship prices. Marit Econ Logistics 5:347–377CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Tsolakis SD, Hopp C (2004) Investment applications in the shipping industry. In: Proceedings of the 8th annual real options conference in Paris, FranceGoogle Scholar
- Varian HR (1990) Intermediate microeconomics: a modern approach, 2nd edn. Norton International Student Edition, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Veenstra AW, De La Fosse S (2006) Contributions to maritime economics-Zenonn S. Zannetos, The theory of oil tankship rates. Marit Policy Manag 33(1):61–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Veenstra AW (1999) Quantitative analysis of shipping markets. Delft University Press Postbus, The NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
- Wjilnost N, Wergeland T (1996) Shipping. Delft University Press, The NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
- Wright G (2000) Spot and period rates in the Wet Bulk shipping market: testing for long-run parity. J Trans Econ Policy 34:291–300Google Scholar
- Zannetos SZ (1966) The theory of oil tankship rates, MIT monographs in economic. MIT Press, BostonGoogle Scholar
- Zannetos SZ (1973) Market and cost structure in shipping. In: Lorange P, Norman VD (eds), Shipping Management. Institute shipping research, Bergen, Norway (proceedings from a seminar in Bergen, August 23–26, 1972, Maritime Research Centre, The Hague, Netherlands)Google Scholar