Community Systems Collide and Cooperate: Control of Deviance by the Legal and Mental Health Systems

  • Virginia Aldigé Hiday
Part of the Handbooks of Sociology and Social Research book series (HSSR)


For most of history, society controlled mentally disordered behavior informally; but with ­modernization it developed formal organizational controls for the behavior it recognized as mentally disordered. This chapter examines relatively recent formal attempts by two systems, the legal and mental health systems, to define and execute control over persons with mental illness whose behavior violates societal norms. It begins with a brief history of the posture of the legal and mental health systems toward mentally disordered persons prior to the mid-twentieth century. It then describes the collision which occurred following civil rights reforms which made the legal system the arbiter of the mental health system’s decisions in treatment and hospitalization, especially involuntary treatment and hospitalization. It describes societal forces beyond the two systems which brought about conditions leading to their cooperation. It then examines the new cooperation that is beginning to occur, giving some detail to one promising program of cooperation. Finally, it discusses directions for future inquiry by researchers who study the two systems’ efforts in controlling deviance of persons with mental illness.


Mental Illness Legal System Mental Health System Mental Hospital Revolving Door 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


  1. Abramson MF (1972) The criminalization of mentally disordered behavior: possible side-effects of a new mental health law. Hosp Community Psychiatry 23:101–105Google Scholar
  2. Appelbaum PS (1986) Outpatient commitment: the problems and the promise. Am J Psychiatry 143:1270–1272Google Scholar
  3. Appelbaum PS (1994) Almost a revolution: mental health law and the limits of change. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. Appelbaum PS, Gutheil TG (1980) The Boston state hospital case: ‘involuntary mind control’, the constitution and the ‘right to rot’. Am J Psychiatry 137:720–723Google Scholar
  5. Bloom JD, Rogers JL, Manson SM, Williams MH (1986) Lifetime police contacts of discharged psychiatric security review board clients. Int J Law Psychiatry 8:189–202CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bonnie RJ, Monahan J (1996) Mental disorder, work disability, and the law. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, ILGoogle Scholar
  7. Bonta J, Law M, Hanson K (1998) The prediction of criminal and violent recividism among mentally disordered offenders: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull 123:123–142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Boothroyd RA, Poythress NG, McGaha A, Petrila J (2003) The Broward mental health court: process, outcomes, and service utilization. Int J Law Psychiatry 26:55–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Borum R, Deane MW, Steadman HJ, Morrissey J (1998) Police perspectives on responding to mentally ill people in crisis: perceptions of program effectiveness. Behav Sci Law 16:393–405CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Broner N, Lattimore PK, Cowell AJ, Schlenger WE (2004) Effects of diversion on adults with co-occurring mental illness and substance use: outcomes from a national multi-site study. Behav Sci Law 22:519–541CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Christy A, Poythress NG, Boothroyd RA, Petrila J, Mehra S (2005) Evaluating the efficiency and community safety goals of the Broward County mental health court. Behav Sci Law 23:227–243CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Consensus Project (2008)
  13. Cosden M, Ellens J, Schnell J, Yamini-Diouf Y, Wolfe M (2003) Evaluation of a mental health treatment court with assertive community treatment. Behav Sci Law 21:415–427CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Cosden M, Ellens J, Schnell J, Yamini-Diouf Y (2005) Efficacy of a mental health treatment court with assertive community treatment. Behav Sci Law 23:199–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cuellor AE, Snowden LM, Ewing T (2007) Criminal records of persons served in the public mental health system. Psychiatr Serv 58:114–120Google Scholar
  16. Dershowitz A (1974) The origins of preventive confinement in Anglo-American law – Part I: the English experience. Univ Cincinnati Law Rev 43:1–60Google Scholar
  17. Desai RA, Lam J, Rosenheck RA (2000) Childhood risk factors for criminal justice involvement in a sample of homeless people with serious mental illness. J Nerv Ment Dis 188:324–332CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dietz PE (1977) Social discrediting of psychiatry: the protasis of legal disenfranchisement. Am J Psychiatry 134:1356–1370Google Scholar
  19. Ditton PM (1999) Mental health and treatment of inmates and probationers. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Washington, DC, NCJ 174463Google Scholar
  20. Draine J, Blank A, Kottsieper P, Solomon P (2005) Contrasting jail diversion and in-jail services for mental illness and substance abuse: do they serve the same clients? Behav Sci Law 23:171–181CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Engel RS, Silver E (2001) Policing of disordered suspects: a reexamination of the criminalizatrion hypothesis. Criminology 39:225–252CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Fisher W, Barreira PJ, Geller JL, White AW, Lincoln AK, Sudders M (2001) Long State patients in state psychiatric hospitals at the end of the 20th century. Psychiatr Serv 52:1051–1056CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Fisher W, Silver E, Wolff N (2005) Beyond criminalization: toward a criminologically informed mental health policy and services research. Adm Policy Ment Health 33:544–547CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Fisher W, Roy-Bujnowski K, Grudzinskas AJ, Clayfield JC, Banks SM, Wolff N (2007) Arrest in a mental health service use cohort. Psychiatr Serv 57:1623–1628CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Goffman E (1961) Asylums. Anchor Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  26. Gottfredson DC, Kearley BW, Najaka SS, Rocha CM (2007) How drug treatment courts work: an analysis of mediators. J Res Crime Delinq 44:3–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Grob GN (1994) The mad among us: a history of the care of America’s mentally ill. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  28. Grob GN (2008) Mental health policy in the liberal state: the example of the United States. Int J Law Psychiatry 31:89–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Halleck SL (ed) (1979) Coping with the legal onslaught. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CAGoogle Scholar
  30. Hartwell SW (2004a) Comparison of offenders with mental illness only and offenders with dual diagnosis. Psychiatr Serv 55:145–149CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hartwell SW (2004b) Triple stigma: persons with mental illness and substance abuse problems in the criminal justice system. Crim Justice Policy Rev 15:89–99Google Scholar
  32. Herinckx HA, Swart SC, Ama SM, Dolezal CD, King S (2005) Rearrest and linkage to mental health services among clients of the Clark County mental health court program. Psychiatr Serv 56:853–857CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hiday VA (1982) The attorney’s role in involuntary civil commitment. North Carol Law Rev 60:1021–1056Google Scholar
  34. Hiday VA (1983) Sociology of mental health law. Sociol Soc Res 67:111–128Google Scholar
  35. Hiday VA (1988) Civil commitment: a review of empirical research. Behav Sci Law 6:15–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hiday VA (1991) Hospitals to jails: arrests and incarceration of civil commitment candidates. Hosp Community Psychiatry 42:729–734Google Scholar
  37. Hiday VA (1992a) Civil commitment and arrests: an investigation of the criminalization thesis. J Nerv Ment Dis 180:184–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hiday VA (1992b) Coercion in civil commitment: process, preferences, and outcome. Int J Law Psychiatry 15:359–377CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Hiday VA (1999) Mental illness and the criminal justice system. In: Horwitz A, Scheid TL (eds) The handbook of the sociology of mental health. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 508–525Google Scholar
  40. Hiday VA (2003) Outpatient commitment: the state of empirical research on its outcomes. Psychol Public Policy Law 9:8–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hiday VA, Goodman RR (1981) The least restrictive alternative to involuntary hospitalization, outpatient commitment: its use and effectiveness. J Psychiatry Law 10:81–96Google Scholar
  42. Hiday VA, Markell SJ (1981) Components of dangerousness: legal standards in civil commitment. Int J Law Psychiatry 3:405–419CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Hiday VA, Scheid-Cook T (1987) The North Carolina experience with outpatient commitment: a critical appraisal. Int J Law Psychiatry 10:215–232CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Hiday VA, Scheid-Cook T (1991) Outpatient commitment for “revolving door” patients: compliance and treatment. J Nerv Ment Dis 179:85–90Google Scholar
  45. Hiday VA, Smith LN (1987) Effects of the dangerousness standard in civil commitment. J Psychiatry Law 15:433–454Google Scholar
  46. Hiday VA, Wales HW (2003) Civil commitment and arrests. Curr Opin Psychiatry 16:575–580CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Hoge SK, Sachs G, Appelbaum PS, Greer A, Gordon C (1988) Limitations on psychiatrists’ discretionary civil commitment authority by the Stone and dangerousness criteria. Arch Gen Psychiatry 45:764–769Google Scholar
  48. James DJ, Glaze LE (2006) “Mental health problems of prison and jail inmates. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Washington, DC, NCJ 213600Google Scholar
  49. Jencks C (1994) The homeless. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  50. Junginger J, Claypoole K, Laygo R, Crisanti A (2006) Effects of serious mental illness and substance abuse on criminal offenses. Psychiatr Serv 57:879–882CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Kahle LR, Sales BD, Nagel S (1978) On unicorns blocking commitment law reform. J Psychiatry Law 6:89–105Google Scholar
  52. Keilitz I, Hall T (1985) State statutes governing involuntary civil commitment. Ment Phys Disabil Law Rep 9:378–397Google Scholar
  53. Kittrie NN (1971) The right to be different. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MDGoogle Scholar
  54. La Fond JQ, Durham ML (1992) Back to the asylum: the future of mental health law and policy in the United States. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  55. Lamb HR (ed) (1984) The homeless mentally ill: a task force report of the American Psychiatric Association. American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  56. Lamb HR, Weinberger LE (2005) The shift of psychiatric inpatient care from hospitals to jails and prisons. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 33:529–534Google Scholar
  57. Lamb HR, Weinberger LE, Gross BH (1999) Community treatment of severely mentally ill offenders under the jurisdiction of the criminal justice system: a review. Psychiatr Serv 50:907–913Google Scholar
  58. Manderscheid RW, Henderson MJ, Witkin MJ, Atay JE (1999) Contemporary mental health systems and managed care. In: Horwitz AV, Scheid TL (eds) A handbook for the study of mental health. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 412–426Google Scholar
  59. Marlowe DB, Festinger DS, Foltz C, Lee PA, Patapis NS (2005) Perceived deterrence and outcomes in drug court. Behav Sci Law 23:183–198CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. McCafferty G, Dooley J (1990) Involuntary outpatient commitment: an update. Ment Phys Disabil Law Rep 14:276–287Google Scholar
  61. McGarry AL (1976) The holy legal war against state hospital psychiatry. N Engl J Med 294:318–320CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. McNiel D, Binder RL (2007) Effectiveness of a mental health court in reducing criminal recidivism and violence. Am J Psychiatry 164:1395–1403CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Mechanic D (1999) Mental health and social policy: the emergence of managed care. Allyn and Bacon, Boston, MAGoogle Scholar
  64. Mechanic D (2007) Truth about health care: why reform is not working in America. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJGoogle Scholar
  65. Monahan J, Calderia C, Friedlander HD (1979) Police and the mentally ill: a comparison of committed and arrested persons. Int J Law Psychiatry 2:509–518CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Moore ME, Hiday VA (2006) Mental health court outcomes: a comparison of re-arrest and re-arrest deverity between mental health court and traditional court participants. Law Human Behav 30:659–674CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Morrissey J, Meyer P, Cuddeback G (2007) Extending assertive community treatment to criminal justice settings: origins, current evidence and future directions. Community Ment Health J 43:527–544CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Petrila J (2001) From constitution to contracts: mental disability law at the turn of the century. In: Frost LA, Bonnie RJ (eds) The evolution of mental health law. American Psychological Association, Washington, DC, pp 75–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Petrila J, Ayers K (1994) Enforcing the fair housing amendments act to benefit people with mental disability. Psychiatr Serv 45:156–160Google Scholar
  70. Petrila J, Christy A (2008) Florida’s outpatient commitment law: a lesson in failed reform? Psychiatr Serv 59:21–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Rachlin S, Pam AK, Milton J (1975) Civil liberties versus involuntary hospitalization. Am J Psychiatry 132:189–191Google Scholar
  72. Ridgely MS, Engberg J, Greenberg MD, Turner S, DeMartini C, Dembosky JW (2007) Justice, treatment, and cost: an evaluation of the fiscal impact of Allegheny county mental health court. RAND No. TR-439-CSG. RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CAGoogle Scholar
  73. Rochefort DA (1997) From poorhouses to homelessness: policy analysis and mental health care, 2nd edn. Auburn House, Westport, CNGoogle Scholar
  74. Rothman DJ (1980) Conscience and convenience: the asylum and its alternatives in progressive America. Little Brown, Boston, MAGoogle Scholar
  75. Sadoff RL (1979) Changes in the mental health law: progress for patients – problems for psychiatrists. In: Halleck SL (ed) Coping with the legal onslaught. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA, pp 1–12Google Scholar
  76. Scheid TL (2005) Stigma as a barrier to employment: psychiatric disability and the impact of the American with disabilities act. Int Acad Psychiatry Law 28:670–690CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Scheid TL, Greenberg G (2007) An organizational analysis of mental health care. In: Avison WR, McLeod JD, Pescosolido BA (eds) Mental health, social mirror. Springer, New York, pp 379–406CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Steadman HJ, Monahan J (eds) (1982) Mentally disordered offenders: perspectives from law and social science. Plenum, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  79. Steadman HJ, Morris S, Dennis D (1995) The diversion of mentally ill persons from jails to community based services: a profile of programs. Am J Public Health 85:1630–1635CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Stone AA (1975) Mental health and the law: a system in transition. NIMH, Center for Studies of Crime and Delinquency, Rockville, MDGoogle Scholar
  81. Swaminath RS, Mendonca JD, Vidal C, Chapman P (2002) Experiments in change: pretrial diversion of offenders with mental illness. Can J Psychiatry 47:450–458Google Scholar
  82. Swartz JP, Lurigio AJ (2007) Severe mental illness and arrest: the generalized mediating effect of substance use. Crime Delinq 53:581–609CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Teplin LA (1984) Criminalizing mental disorder: the comparative arrest rate of the mentally ill. Am Psychol 39:794–803CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Teplin LA (1990a) The prevalence of severe mental disorder among male urban jail detainees: comparison with the Epidemiological Catchment Area Program. Am J Public Health 80:663–669CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Teplin LA (1990b) Detecting disorder: the treatment of mental illness among jail detainees. J Consult Clin Psychol 58:233–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Teplin LA, Pruett NS (1992) Police as street corner psychiatrists: managing the mentally ill. Int J Law Psychiatry 15:157–170CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Teplin LA, Abram KM, McClelland GM (1996) The prevalence of psychiatric disorder among incarcerated women. Ann Gen Psychiatry 53:505–512Google Scholar
  88. Treffert DA (1973) Dying with their rights on. Am J Psychiatry 130:1041Google Scholar
  89. Wales HW, Hiday VA (2006) PLC or TLC: is outpatient commitment the/an answer? Int J Law Psychiatry 29:451–468CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Warren CAB (1984) Court of last resort. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, ILGoogle Scholar
  91. Watson AC, Angell B (2007) Applying procedural justice theory to law enforcement’s response to persons with mental illness. Psychiatr Serv 58:787–793CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Wexler D (1981) Mental health law: major issues. Plenum, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  93. Wexler D (2008) Two decades of therapeutic jurisprudence. Touro Law Rev 24(1):17–29Google Scholar
  94. Wexler D, Winick BJ (eds) (1996) Law in a therapeutic key: developments in therapeutic jurisprudence. Carolina Academic Press, Durham, NCGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of SociologyNorth Carolina State UniversityRaleighUSA

Personalised recommendations