Does Reducing College Costs Improve Educational Outcomes for Undocumented Immigrants? Evidence from State Laws Permitting Undocumented Immigrants to Pay In-State Tuition at State Colleges and Universities
Ten states, beginning with Texas and California in 2001, have passed laws permitting undocumented students to pay the in-state tuition rate—rather than the more expensive out-of-state tuition rate—at public universities and colleges. We exploit state-time variation in the passage of the laws to evaluate the effects of these laws on the educational outcomes of Hispanic childhood immigrants who are not US citizens. Specifically, through the use of individual-level data from the 2001–2005 American Community Surveys supplemented by the 2000 US Census, we estimate the effect of the laws on the probability of attending college for 18- to 24-year-olds who have a high school degree and the probability of dropping out of high school for 16- to 17-year-olds. We find some evidence suggestive of a positive effect of the laws on the college attendance of older Mexican men, although estimated effects of the laws, in general, are not significantly different from zero. We discuss various reasons for the estimated zero effects. Two important considerations are that little time has elapsed since the state laws were passed and that unchanged federal policy on financial aid and legalization for undocumented students may dampen the state laws’ benefits. Thus, the longer-run effects of the laws may well differ from the short-run effects presented in this chapter.
KeywordsEducational Outcome American Community Survey High School Degree Undocumented Immigrant College Attendance
We thank Peter Mieszkowski, Stephen Trejo, and the participants in the IUPLR Conference in April 2007 for helpful comments and discussion. We also thank Aly Capetillo, Serguei Chervachidze, and Parul Mathur for research assistance. Financial support from Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy is gratefully acknowledged. The authors bear sole responsibility for the content of this chapter.
- 1.Passel, Jeffrey S. 2005. “Unauthorized Migrants: Numbers and Characteristics.” Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center. http://pewhispanic.org/files/reports/46.pdf (accessed September 2006).
- 3.U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. 2003. Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System, “IPEDS State Tables 2003.” http://nces.ed.gov/das/library/tables_listings/state2003_price.asp (accessed September 2006).
- 4.Krueger, Carl. 2006. “In-state Tuition for Undocumented Immigrants.” Education Commission of the States State Notes: Tuition and Fees, August. http://www.ecs.org/clearinghouse/61/00/6100.htm (accessed October 2006).
- 5.Lewis, Raphael. 2005. “In-State Tuition Not a Draw for Many Immigrants.” Boston Globe, November 9.Google Scholar
- 6.Institute of Public and International Affairs, University of Utah. 2006. “Mexico and Utah: The Complex Relationship.” http://www.ipia.utah.edu/programs/utah_mexico/full_text.pdf (accessed September 2006).
- 7.Martin, Jack. 2005. “Breaking the Piggy Bank: How Illegal Immigration is Sending Schools into the Red.” Federation for American Immigration Reform Report. http://www.fairus.org/site/PageServer?pagename=research_researchf6ad (accessed December 2005).
- 8.Capps, Randy, Michael Fix,and Jane Reardon-Anderson. 2003. “Children of Immigrants Show Slight Reductions in Poverty, Hardship.” In Snapshots of American Families III, No13. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.Google Scholar
- 9.Card, David, John DiNardo, and Eugena Estes. 2000. “The More Things Change: Immigrants and the Children of Immigrants in the 1940s, the 1970s, and the 1990s.” In Issues in the Economics of Immigration, ed. George J. Borjas, 227–270. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- 10.Grogger, Jeffrey, and Stephen J. Trejo. 2002. “Falling Behind or Moving Up? The Intergenerational Progress of Mexican Americans.” San Francisco, CA: Public Policy Institute of California.Google Scholar
- 14.Dynarski, Susan M. 2000. “Hope for Whom? Financial Aid for the Middle Class and Its Impact on College Attendance.” National Tax Journal, 53(3): 629–661.Google Scholar
- 15.Dynarski, Susan M. 2008. “Building the Stock of College-Educated Labor.” Journal of Human Resources, 43(3): 576–610Google Scholar
- 16.Hansen, W. Lee. 1983. “The Impact of Student Financial Aid on Access.” In The Crisis in Higher Education, ed. Joseph Froomkin, 84–96. New York: Academy of Political Science.Google Scholar
- 17.Kane, Thomas J.1995. “Rising Public College Tuition and College Entry: How Well Do Public Subsidies Promote Access to College.” NBER Working Paper 5164.Google Scholar
- 18.Seftor, Neil, and Sarah Turner. 2003. “Back to School: Federal Student Aid Policy and Adult College Enrollment.” Journal of Human Resources, 37(2): 591–617.Google Scholar
- 19.Jordan, Miriam. 2005. “Illegal Immigrants’ New Lament: Have Degree, No Job.” The Wall Street Journal, April 26: Section B, 1 and 7.Google Scholar
- 23.Ruggles, Steven, Matthew Sobek, Trent Alexander, Catherine A. Fitch, Ronald Goeken, Patricia Kelly Hall, Miriam King, and Chad Ronnander. 2004. “Integrated Public Use Microdata Series: Version 3.0.” Minneapolis, MN: Minnesota Population Center. http://www.ipums.org (accessed October 2006).
- 24.Hoxby, Caroline M., ed. 2004. College Choices: The Economics of Where to Go, When to Go, and How to Pay for It. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- 25.Education Commission of the States. 2006. “Recent State Policies/Activities, Tuition and Fees – In-state Tuition for Undocumented Immigrants.” Education Commission of the States State Policy Database.http://www.ecs.org/ecs/ecscat.nsf/WebTopicView?OpenView&count=-300&RestrictToCategory=Tuition/Fees–In–State+Tuition+for+Undocumented+Immigrants (accessed October 2006).