Advertisement

Torture, Truth, Repression and Archaeology

  • Alejandro F. Haber
Chapter
Part of the Contributions To Global Historical Archaeology book series (CGHA)

Abstract

During the most recent military dictatorship in Argentina, torture committed in pozos (clandestine detention centers) was not only aimed at obtaining information but at getting prisoners’ self-narratives in accordance with the executioners’ rules. As a consequence, torture involved the establishment of a certain regime of truth. Although this regime was necessarily authoritarian, it did not include passive descriptions (DuBois 1990). DuBois defined torture as the ultimate domination of bodies and – above anything else – ideas. From this point of view, torture did not limit itself to the extermination of enemies. On the contrary, it tried to impose a particular interpretation of history; that is to say, a particular “truth” in the struggle for understanding. Taking into account the undeniable disparity between the number of combatants and the number of people imprisoned and tortured during the military government, DuBois’ thesis brought to the foreground the enormous social cost of establishing “truth”.

If archaeology has the potential to reveal the traces of state terrorism, and dictatorship depends on torture as the guardian of a certain regime of truth, then it is possible to ask: What is the relationship that archaeology establishes between truth and self-narrative?

Keywords

Indigenous People Collective Memory Historical Narrative Objectual Domain Archaeological Remains 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Notes

Acknowledgements

The members of the research group and the survivors of El Pozo clandestine detention center allowed me to share their experiences in the project. Several colleagues, such as Patricia Bernardi, Silvia Bianchi, Luis Fondebrider, Cristóbal Gnecco, Jacko Jackson, Darío Olmo, Bob Paynter, Claire Smith, Myriam Tarragó and Martin Wobst, contributed with ideas, suggestions and experiences that – for better or for worse – were written here. I would like to thank Pedro Funari and Andrés Zarankin for the opportunity to publish this article, and Melisa Salerno for the translation.

References

  1. Bellelli, C., and Tobin, J., 1985, Archaeology of the Desaparecidos. Society for American Archaeology Bulletin 14(2):6–7.Google Scholar
  2. Bianchi, S. 2008, “El Pozo” (ex Servicio de Informaciones). Un Centro Clandestino de Detención, Desaparición, Tortura y Muerte de Personas de la Ciudad de Rosario, Argentina. Antropología Política del Pasado Reciente. Prohistoria, Rosario.Google Scholar
  3. Bozzuto, D., Diana, A., Di Vruno, A., Dolce, V., and Vázquez, V., 2004, “Mansión Seré”: Debates y Reflexiones. Resúmenes del XV Congreso Nacional de Arqueología Argentina, p. 207. Universidad Nacional de Río Cuarto, Río Cuarto.Google Scholar
  4. Cohen Salama, M., 1992, Tumbas Anónimas. Informe sobre la Identificación de Restos de Víctimas de la Represión Ilegal. Equipo Argentino de Antropología Forense. Catálogos, Buenos Aires.Google Scholar
  5. DuBois, L., 1990, Torture and the Construction of an Enemy: The Case of Argentina 1976–1982. Dialectical Anthropology 15:317–328.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Duviols, P., 1977, La Destrucción de las Religiones Andinas (Conquista y Colonia). Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, México D.C.Google Scholar
  7. Duviols, P., 1986, Cultura Andina y Represión. Procesos y Visitas de Idolatrías y Hechicerías. Cajatambo, Siglo XVII. Centro de Estudios Rurales Andinos Bartolomé de Las Casas, Cusco.Google Scholar
  8. Equipo Argentino de Antropología Forense, 1992, Excavando la Violencia: Arqueología y Derechos Humanos en el Cono Sur. In Arqueología en América Latina, Hoy, edited by G. Politis, pp. 160–166. Biblioteca del Banco Popular, Buenos Aires.Google Scholar
  9. Equipo de Investigación por la Memoria Política Cultural, 2004, La Ronda: Aaportes para una Construcción Colectiva del Conocimiento. Paper presented at the XV Congreso Nacional de Arqueología Argentina. Río Cuarto.Google Scholar
  10. Farberman, J., 2005, Las Salamancas de Lorenza. Magia, Hechicería y Curanderismo en el Tucumán Colonial. Siglo XXI, Buenos Aires.Google Scholar
  11. Gnecco, C., 1999, Multivocalidad Histórica. Hacia una Cartografía Poscolonial de la Arqueología. Universidad de Los Andes, Bogotá.Google Scholar
  12. Haber, A., 1994, Theory and Practice in Northwestern Argentine Archaeology. In Relationship Between Archaeological Theory and Practice, edited by I. Hodder, B. Molineaux and K. Paddayya. World Archaeological Congress 3, New Delhi.Google Scholar
  13. Haber, A., 1995, Supuestos Teórico-Metodológicos de la Etapa Formativa de la Arqueología de Catamarca (1875–1900). Publicaciones del CIFFyH – Arqueología (1992–1994) 47:31–54.Google Scholar
  14. Haber, A. and Scribano, A., 1993, Hacia una Comprensión de la Construcción Científica del Pasado: Ciencia y Arqueología en el Noroeste Argentino. Alteridades 3(6):39–46.Google Scholar
  15. Lafone Quevedo, S., 1891, Las Huacas de Chañar Yaco (Provincia de Catamarca). Revista del Museo de La Plata II:353–360.Google Scholar
  16. Moreno, F., 1990, Exploración Arqueológica de la Provincia de Catamarca. Primeros Datos sobre su Importancia y Resultados. Revista del Museo de La Plata 1:199–221.Google Scholar
  17. Todorov, T., 1987, La Conquista de América. El Problema del Otro. Siglo XXI, Buenos Aires.Google Scholar
  18. Vollet, M., 2001, La Vana Europeización de los Bárbaros. El Aspecto Autoreferencial de la Discusión Española sobre la Conquista. In Concepciones de la Conquista. Aproximaciones Interdisciplinarias, edited by F. Castaneda and M. Vollet, pp. 119–133. Uniandes, Bogotá.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.(Universidad Nacional de Catamarca & Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas) National University of Catamarca & National Council for Scientific and Technical ResearchCatamarcaArgentina

Personalised recommendations