Otto Neurath's Concepts of Socialization and Economic Calculation and his Socialist Critics

  • Günther Chaloupek
Part of the Vienna Circle Institute Yearbook book series (VCIY, volume 13)

Otto Neurath was one of the most active participants in the debate about socialization that developed after the First World War. As far as this part of Neurath’s work is concerned, his name is mentioned most prominently in the context of two issues: “total socialization”/“Vollsozialisierung” (as opposed to partial socialization), and “in kind accounting”/“Naturalrechnung”. In both respects he is mostly seen as an advocate of strategies and concepts which aimed at changes in the economic system of a much more radical sort than those proposed by the main-stream social-democratic parties in Germany and Austria. Neurath maintained this position despite the early failure of “revolutionary” political experiments in Bavaria and Saxony in his contributions to the socialization debate which he continued to publish until 1925. In the later 1920s, when chances for realization of socialization more or less disappeared, socialization also vanished as a theoretical issue.

This contribution is confined to the debate between Neurath and his critics from the Social Democratic parties of Germany and Austria – to the part of the debate that took place “inside” the socialist movement. It makes only occasional references to contributions from “outside”, which are of course much better known nowadays due to the prominence which the interventions of Mises and Schumpeter came to acquire later.


Socialist Economy Economic Calculation Common Unit Socialist Society Social Democratic Party 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Bauer, Helene, 1923a, Geld, Sozialismus und Otto Neurath, in: Der Kampf 16, pp. 195-202Google Scholar
  2. Bauer, Helene, 1923b, Sozialistische Wirtschaftrechnung, in: Der Kampf 16, pp. 321-325Google Scholar
  3. Bauer, Otto, 1919, Der Weg zum Sozialismus, Verlag der Wiener Volksbuchhandlung, WienGoogle Scholar
  4. Böhm-Bawerk, Eugen von, 1896/1962, Unresolved Contradiction in the Marxian Economic System, in: Shorter Classics of Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, Vol. I, Libertaruan Press, South Holland, pp. 201-302Google Scholar
  5. Chaloupek, Günther, 1987, Die schwere Geburt der Mixed Economy, in: Gerhard Fink/Günther Pöll/Martin Riese (eds.), Economic Theory, Political Power and Social Justice, Festschrift Kazimierz Laski, Springer-Verlag, Wien-New York, pp. 407-425Google Scholar
  6. Chaloupek, Günther, 1990, The Austrian Debate on Economic Calculation in a Socialist Economy, in: History of Political Economy 22, pp. 659-675Google Scholar
  7. Diewert, W. E., 1987, Index Number, in: John Eatwell/Murray Milgate/Peter Newman (eds.), The New Palgrave, Macmillan, London-New York-Tokyo, Vol. 2, pp. 767-780Google Scholar
  8. Engels, Friedrich, 1894, Herrn Eugen Dührings Umwälzung der Wissenschaft, Verlag J. H. W. Dietz Nachf., Stuttgart, 3rd editionGoogle Scholar
  9. Fischer, Georg, and Peter Rosner, 1987, Politische ökonomie und Wirtschaftspolitik im Austromarxismus, österreichischer Bundesverlag, WienGoogle Scholar
  10. Kautsky, Benedikt, 1926, Rezension von Neurath, Wirtschaftsplan und Naturalrechnung, in: Die Gesellschaft 2, pp. 92-96Google Scholar
  11. Kautsky, Karl, 1922, Die proletarische Revolution und ihr Programm, J.H.W. Dietz-Verlag, Stuttgart-BerlinGoogle Scholar
  12. Kautsky, Karl, 1930, Der Bolschewismus in der Sackgasse, Verlag J.H.W. Dietz Nachfolger, Berlin Klein, Judy L., Mary S. Morgan (eds.), 2001, The Age of Economic Measurement, Duke University Press, Durham and LondonGoogle Scholar
  13. Lederer, Emil, 1921, Sozialisierung, in: Ignaz Jezower (ed.), Die Befreiung der Menschheit, Verlagshaus Bong, Berlin-Leipzig-Wien-Stuttgart, part 2, pp. 159-167Google Scholar
  14. Leichter, Otto, 1923, Die Wirtschaftsrechnung in der sozialistischen Gesellschaft, Verlag der Wiener Volksbuchhandlung, WienGoogle Scholar
  15. Mänicke-Gyöngyösi, Krisztina, 1981, Nachwort, in: Alexander W. Tschajanow, Reise meines Bruders Alexej ins Land der bäuerlichen Utopie, Syndikat-Verlag, FrankfurtGoogle Scholar
  16. Martinez-Alier, Juan, 1995, Political Economy, Distributional Conflicts, and Economic Incommensurability, in: New Left Review 21, pp. 70-87Google Scholar
  17. Mises, Ludwig, 1922, Die Gemeinwirtschaft, Gustav Fischer-Verlag, JenaGoogle Scholar
  18. Neurath, Otto, 1919, Wesen und Weg der Sozialisierung, in: Neurath 1979, pp. 242-261Google Scholar
  19. Neurath, Otto, 1920a, Ein System der Sozialisierung, in: Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft und Sozialpolitik 48 (1920/1921), English translation in: Neurath 2005, pp. 345-370Google Scholar
  20. Neurath, Otto, 1920b, Vollsozialisierung. Eugen Diederichs Verlag, Jena 1920, English translation in Neurath 2005, pp. 370-404Google Scholar
  21. Neurath, Otto, 1923a, Geld und Sozialismus, in: Der Kampf 16, pp. 145-157Google Scholar
  22. Neurath, Otto, 1923b, Geld, Sozialismus, Marxismus, in: Der Kampf 16, pp. 283-288Google Scholar
  23. Neurath, Otto, 1925a, Wirtschaftsplan und Naturalrechnung, Berlin, partly reprinted in Neurath 1979, pp. 262-287, English translation in Neurath 2005, pp. 405-465Google Scholar
  24. Neurath, Otto, 1925b, Sozialistische Nützlichkeitsrechnung und kapitalistische Reingewinnrechnung, in: Der Kampf 18, pp. 391-395, English translation in Neurath 2005, pp. 466-472Google Scholar
  25. Neurath, Otto, 1931a/1979, Empirische Soziologie, Vienna 1931, partly reprinted in Neurath 1979, pp. 145-234Google Scholar
  26. Neurath, Otto, 1931b/2005, Das gegenwärtige Wachstum der Produktionskapazität der Welt, lecture before the World Social Economic Congress, Amsterdam 1931, English translation in Neurath 2005, pp. 475-505Google Scholar
  27. Neurath, Otto, 1979, Wissenschaftliche Weltauffassung, Sozialismus und Logischer Empirismus, ed. R. Hegselmann, Suhrkamp-Verlag, FrankfurtGoogle Scholar
  28. Neurath, Otto, 2004, Economic Writings. Selections 1904-1945, with an introduction by Thomas Uebel, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht-Boston-LondonGoogle Scholar
  29. Nordhaus, William, James Tobin, 1972, Is Growth Obsolete?, in: Economic Growth. Volume V of the Fiftieth Anniversary Colloquia Series of the National Bureau of Economic Research, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  30. Pigou, A. C., 1920, The Economics of Welfare, Macmillan, LondonGoogle Scholar
  31. Pribram, Karl, 1918, Die Grundgedanken der Wirtschaftspolitik der Zukunft, Verlag Leuschner und Lubenski, Graz und LeipzigGoogle Scholar
  32. Rathenau, Walther, 1918, Die neue Wirtschaft, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  33. Stolper, Gustav, 1921, Deutsch-österreich als Sozial- und Wirtschaftsproblem, Drei MaskenVerlag, MünchenGoogle Scholar
  34. Uebel, Thomas, 2004, Introduction: Neurath’s Economics in Critical Context, in: Neurath, Otto, 2004, pp. 1-108Google Scholar
  35. Uebel, Thomas, 2005, Incommensurability, Ecology, and Planning: Neurath in the Socialist Calculation Debate, 1919-1928, in: History of Political Economy 37, pp. 309-342Google Scholar
  36. Uebel, Thomas, 2006, Philosophy of Social Science in Early Logical Empiricism: The Case of Radical Physicalism (unpublished manuscript)Google Scholar
  37. Weber, Fritz, 1982, Otto Neurath und die Sozialisierung, in: Fritz Stadler (ed.), Arbeiterbildung in der Zwischenkriegszeit, Otto Neurath Gerd Arntz, Löcker-Verlag, Wien-München, pp. 133-139Google Scholar
  38. Weissel, Erwin, 1976, Die Ohnmacht des Sieges. Arbeiterschaft und Sozialisierung nach dem Ersten Weltkrig in österreich, Europaverlag, WienGoogle Scholar
  39. Wissel, Rudolf, 1920, Die Planwirtschaft, HamburgGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science + Business Media B.V 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  • Günther Chaloupek
    • 1
  1. 1.Chamber of LabourAustria

Personalised recommendations