Human Rights in Southeast Asia: Rhetoric and Reality

  • Geoffrey Robinson
Part of the International Political Economy Series book series (IPES)

Abstract

It was not so long ago that powerful western governments preferred to treat the appalling human rights records of their Southeast Asian allies and trading partners as unpleasant secrets among friends. The killing of more than 500,000 people in the aftermath of the 1965 Indonesian coup, the 1975 invasion of East Timor and the subsequent decimation of a third of its population, raised scarcely a murmur of protest, and still less in the way of concrete action. On the face of it, the situation has changed rather dramatically in the past few years. International reactions to the November 1991 massacre in East Timor, to the re-pression of the peaceful opposition in Myanmar (Burma) from 1988, and to a lesser extent the 1992 killing of scores of pro-democracy protesters in Bangkok, for example, were usually swift and strong.

Keywords

Europe Expense Dition Arena Dinated 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. AFP (Agence France Presse) (1992) ‘Forcing Foreign Values on Other Countries Violates Human Rights: Soeharto’, 13 February.Google Scholar
  2. AIPO (ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Organization) (1993) ‘Kuala Lumpur Declaration on Human Rights’.Google Scholar
  3. Amnesty International (1991a) Philippines: ‘Disappearances’ in the Context of Counter-Insurgency (February, ASA 35/05/91).Google Scholar
  4. Amnesty International (1991b) Philippines: Human Rights Violations and the Labour Movement (June, ASA 35/16/91).Google Scholar
  5. Amnesty International (1991c) Malaysia: Administrative Detention of Sabahans (October, ASA 28/09/91).Google Scholar
  6. Amnesty International (1991d) East Timor: The Santa Cruz Massacre (November, ASA 21/23/91).Google Scholar
  7. Amnesty International (1991e) East Timor: After the Massacre (November, ASA 21/24/91).Google Scholar
  8. Amnesty International (1992a) Indonesia/East Timor: Santa Cruz–The Government Response (February, ASA 21/03/92).Google Scholar
  9. Amnesty International (1992b) Philippines: The Killing Goes On (February, ASA 35/01/92).Google Scholar
  10. Amnesty International (1992c) East Timor: ‘In Accordance with the Law’–Statement before the UN Special Committee on Decolonization (July, ASA 21/11/92).Google Scholar
  11. Amnesty International (1992d) Myanmar: ‘No Law at All’ - Human Rights Violations Under Military Rule (October, ASA 16/11/92).Google Scholar
  12. Amnesty International (1992e) Facing up to Failures: Proposals for Improving the Protection of Human Rights by the United Nations (December, IOR 41/16/92).Google Scholar
  13. Amnesty International (1993a) Indonesia/East Timor: A New Order? Human Rights in 1992 (February, ASA 21/03/93).Google Scholar
  14. Amnesty International (1993b) Cambodia: Human Rights Concerns July to December 1992 (February, ASA 23/01/93).Google Scholar
  15. Amnesty International (1993c) Oral intervention by Amnesty International, before the World Conference on Human Rights, Regional Meeting for Asia, 29 March 1993.Google Scholar
  16. Amnesty International (1993d) Letter to H.E. Squadron Leader Prasong Soonsiri, Minister of Foreign Affairs, 31 March 1993.Google Scholar
  17. Amnesty International (1993e) ‘Asian Governments Defensive on Human Rights’ (2 April, IOR 41/WU 04/93).Google Scholar
  18. Amnesty International (1993f) Open letter to heads of state and government from Amnesty International’s Secretary General (19 April, IOR 41/15/93).Google Scholar
  19. Amnesty Internationalaa(1993g) Indonesia: ‘Shock Therapy’–Restoring Order in Aceh, 1989–1993 (July, ASA 21/07/93).Google Scholar
  20. Amnesty International (1993h) Cambodia: Arbitrary Killings of Ethnic Vietnamese (September, ASA 23/05/93).Google Scholar
  21. Amnesty International (1993i) Myanmar: The Climate of Fear Continues, Members of Ethnic Minorities and Political Prisoners Still Targeted (October, ASA 16/06/ 93).Google Scholar
  22. Amnesty International (1993j) Papua New Guinea: Under the Barrel of a Gun (November, ASA 34/05/93).Google Scholar
  23. Amnesty International (1993k) Socialist Republic of Vietnam: Continuing Concerns (October, ASA 41/06/93).Google Scholar
  24. Amnesty International (1994a) Kingdom of Cambodia: Human Rights and the New Constitution (January, ASA 23/01/94).Google Scholar
  25. Amnesty International (1994b) Myanmar: Human Rights Developments July to December 1993 (January, ASA 16/03/94).Google Scholar
  26. Amnesty International (1994c) Peace-keeping and Human Rights (January, IOR 40/01/94).Google Scholar
  27. Amnesty International (1994d) Indonesia and East Timor: Fact and Fiction: Implementing the Recommendations of the UN Commission of Human Rights (16 February, ASA 21/05/94).Google Scholar
  28. Amnesty International (1994e) East Timor: Who Is To Blame? Statement Before the UN Special Committee on Decolonization (13 July, ASA 21/31/94).Google Scholar
  29. Amnesty International (1994f) Indonesia and East Timor: Power and Impunity - Human Rights Under the New Order (28 September, ASA 21/17/94).Google Scholar
  30. Amnesty International (1994g) Myanmar: Human Rights Still Denied (1 November, ASA 16/ 18/94).Google Scholar
  31. Amnesty International (1994h) Indonesia: ‘Operation Cleansing’–Human Rights and APEC (3 November, ASA 21/50/94).Google Scholar
  32. Amnesty International (1994i) Indonesia and East Timor: The 12 November Protests (15 November, ASA 21/53/94).Google Scholar
  33. Amnesty International (1994j) Indonesia and East Timor: Update on the 12 November Protests (23 November, ASA 21/56/94).Google Scholar
  34. Amnesty International (1995a) Indonesia and East Timor: Political Prisoners and the ‘Rule of Law’ (January, ASA 21/01/95).Google Scholar
  35. Amnesty International (1995b) Indonesia and East Timor: Human Rights in 1994: A Summary (January, ASA 21/03/95).Google Scholar
  36. Amnesty International (1995c) Kingdom of Cambodia: Human Rights and the New Government (14 March, ASA 23/02/95).Google Scholar
  37. Anderson, Benedict (1977) ‘Withdrawal Symptoms: Social and Cultural Aspects of the October 6 Coup’, Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 13–30.Google Scholar
  38. Arase, David (1993) ‘Japanese Policy Toward Democracy and Human Rights in Asia’, Asian Survey, vol. XXXIII, no. 10 (October, pp. 935–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. ASEAN (1993) Joint Communiqué of the Twenty-sixth ASEAN Ministerial Meeting, Singapore, 23–24 July 1993.Google Scholar
  40. Asiawatch (1992) Indonesia: Charges and Rebuttals Over Labor Rights Practices (23 January).Google Scholar
  41. Buszynski, Leszek (1992) ‘Southeast Asia in the Post-Cold War Era: Regionalism and Security’, Asian Survey, vol. XXXII, no. 9 (September), pp. 830–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Dagg, Christopher J. (1992) ‘Human Rights and Aid: A Canadian Perspective’, Indonesian Quarterly, vol. XXI, no. 1, pp. 38–48.Google Scholar
  43. European Parliament (1991) ‘Resolution on the Situation in South-East Asia’ in Minutes of Proceedings of the Sitting of Thursday, 12 September 1991.Google Scholar
  44. European ParliamentEE(1992a) Committee on External Economic Relations, ‘Report by Mr Ben Visser, Rapporteur on Relations with the ASEAN Countries, on his Mission to Indonesia, 19–24 December 1991’.Google Scholar
  45. European Parliament (1992b) ‘Resolution on East Timor’ (17 December).Google Scholar
  46. Heinz, Wolfgang S. (1993) ‘Concepts of Democracy, Development and Human Rights in Asian Political Thinking. The Examples of China and ASEAN’, paper prepared for the Conference on Nationalism and the Ethnicity in Southeast Asia, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, October.Google Scholar
  47. Islam, Shada (1991) ‘Values for Money: ASEAN, EC clash on human-rights criteria’, Far Eastern Economic Review, June, pp. 9–10.Google Scholar
  48. Islam, Shada (1992) ‘Stumbling Block: Indonesia–EC Agreement Ditched by Timor Issue’, Far Eastern Economic Review, 30 July, pp. 9–10.Google Scholar
  49. Lev, Daniel S. (1990) ‘Human Rights NGOs in Indonesia and Malaysia’, in Claude E. Welch Jr and Virginia E. Leavy (eds) Asian Perspectives on Human Rights (Boulder: Westview Press), pp. 142–61.Google Scholar
  50. Lord, Winston (1993) Statement by US Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs before the Senate on 31 March 1993, reprinted in the Jakarta Post, 13 and 14 April.Google Scholar
  51. Lubis, T. Mulya (1992) ‘Human Rights Standard Setting in Asia: Problems and Prospects’, Indonesian Quarterly, vol. XXI, no. 1, pp. 25–37.Google Scholar
  52. Mauzy, Diane and R. S. Milne (1995) ‘Human Rights in ASEAN States: a Canadian Policy Perspective’, in Amitav Acharya and Richard Stubbs (eds) New Challenges for ASEAN (Vancouver: UBC Press).Google Scholar
  53. Muntarbhorn, Vitit (1993) ‘Law and State: The Human Rights Challenge in Thailand’, a study prepared for the Asian Studies Centre, St Antony’s College, Oxford University.Google Scholar
  54. NAM (Non-Aligned Movement) (1992a) ‘Tenth Conference of Heads of State or Government of Non-Aligned Countries, Jakarta, 1–6 September 1992’, Indonesia News (London), vol. 20, no. 37 (15 October).Google Scholar
  55. NAM (Non-Aligned Movement) (1992b) ‘The Jakarta Message: A Call for Collective Action and the Democratization of International Relations’, Indonesia News (London), vol. 20, no. 37 (15 October), Appendix.Google Scholar
  56. Newsletter on Aid (Japan) (1993). NGO Declaration on Human Rights. Bangkok, April 1993.Google Scholar
  57. Republic of Indonesia (1992a) ‘Indonesia Rejects Dutch Aid’, press release, 25 March.Google Scholar
  58. Republic of Indonesia (1992b) Statement of the Minister of the Interior… Concerning the Ban on Receipt of Dutch Aid by Social Organizations and Institutions. (24 April). (Unofficial translation)Google Scholar
  59. Republic of Indonesia (1992c) Address by President Suharto of the Republic of Indonesia at the Inaugural Session of the Tenth Conference of Heads of State or Government of Non-Aligned Countries, Jakarta, 1 September 1992. Indonesia News (London), vol. 20, no. 37 (15 October), pp. 1–13.Google Scholar
  60. Republic of Indonesia (1993a) Statement by H. E. Mr S. Wiryono before the Regional Meeting for Asia of the World Conference on Human Rights, Bangkok (29 March).Google Scholar
  61. Republic of Indonesia (1993b) Statement by H. E. Mr Ali Alatas, Minister for Foreign Affairs, before the Second World Conference on Human Rights, Vienna (June).Google Scholar
  62. Robinson, Geoffrey (1993) ‘Some Thoughts on Political Violence in Indonesia and East Timor’, paper prepared for the Annual Meeting of the Association of Asian Studies, Los Angeles (March).Google Scholar
  63. Shawcross, William (1993) ‘A New Cambodia’, New York Review of Books, 12 August.Google Scholar
  64. United Nations (1992) Report of the Special Rapporteur on Torture on his Visit to Indonesia and East Timor in November 1991 (UN Doc. E/CN 4/ 1992/17/Add. 1).Google Scholar
  65. United Nations (1995) Report of the Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions on his Mission to Indonesia and East Timor in July 1994 (UN Doc. E/CN 4/1995/61/Add. 1).Google Scholar
  66. Vatikiotis, Michael (1992) ‘Coping with the Critics’, Far Eastern Economic Review, 29 October, p. 28.Google Scholar
  67. Wanandi, Jusuf (1992) ‘Asia, Too, Should Have a Human Rights Forum’, International Herald Tribune, 20 October.Google Scholar
  68. Woolcott, Richard (1992) ‘Reality and an Asian Neighbour’, Time, 7 September, p. 76.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited 1996

Authors and Affiliations

  • Geoffrey Robinson

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations