US and Canadian trucking policy

  • Garland Chow

Abstract

Canada and the United States moved in opposite directions with respect to economic regulation of the intercity trucking industry in 1977. In that year the US Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) began relaxing entry and rate controls while most of the Canadian provisions maintained strict entry regulations and a mixture of rate controls. A decade later, Canada removed many of its entry controls over the trucking industry and the economic regulations governing the trucking industry in both countries again began to converge. What occurred in the intervening 10 or so years is a lesson in market dynamics and political economy. US deregulation had both a direct and indirect effect on Canadian transportation markets and inevitably on the Canadian regulatory system. This chapter traces the regulatory reform events in both countries as pertaining to the North American trucking industry. It is a case study of how regulatory policy in adjacent and interdependent market economies are linked by its market effects. An examination of these effects is useful when considering similar regulatory changes in other geographic environments.

Keywords

Europe Transportation Amid Expense Tate 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abruzzese, L. (1989) ‘ICC Decides for Hover in Mich. Transport Case’ Journal of Commerce, March 16, p. 26.Google Scholar
  2. Allen, B. (1990) ‘$750 Million Worth of Rules’ Journal of Commerce, April 25, p.8a.Google Scholar
  3. American Trucking Associations Inc. (1982) Comments before the Interstate Commerce Commission on Ex Parte No. MC-157. Investigation Into Canadian Law and Policy Regarding Applications of American Motor Carriers for Canadian Operating Authority (Washington, D. C.).Google Scholar
  4. American Trucking Associations Inc. (1988) American Trucking Trends 1987 (Alexandria, Va.).Google Scholar
  5. Baker, D. W. 1987 Update of General Survey of Regulation of Motor Carriers by Individual States.Google Scholar
  6. Balileo, J. R. (1989) ‘State of the States: An Overview of Trucking Regulations by the States’ Transportation Executive Update November/December, pp. 16, 17, 33.Google Scholar
  7. Chow, G. (1980) ‘Studies of Intra-state Trucking Regulation — A Critique’ Transportation Journal, Summer, pp.23–32.Google Scholar
  8. Chow, G. (1983) ‘How Much Longer Can We Live with Regulation of Canada’s Trucking Industry?’ The Canadian Business Review, vol. 10(1), Spring, pp.45–52.Google Scholar
  9. Chow, G. (1990) ‘The First Year Impact of the Motor Vehicle Transport Act, 1987 (MVTA) on the Trucking Industry of British Columbia,’ Working Paper 90-TRA-002, (University of British Columbia: Faculty of Commerce and Business Administration).Google Scholar
  10. Chow, G. and McRae, J. J. (1989) ‘Non-Tariff Barriers and the Structure of the US — Canadian (Trans-border) Trucking Industry,’ paper presented before the Transportation and Public Utilities Group, American Economics Association, Dec. 29, 1989, Working Paper 90-TRA-001. (University of British Columbia: Faculty of Commerce and Business Administration).Google Scholar
  11. Economic Council of Canada (1981) Reforming Regulation, (Ottawa: M.S.S.).Google Scholar
  12. Ettorre, J. J. (1988) ‘Feds May Be Out of Trucking Regulation’ Transportation and Distribution, April, pp. t19–t22.Google Scholar
  13. Glaskowsky, N. (1987) Effects of Deregulation on Motor Carriers (Westport, Conn.: ENO Foundation for Transportation Inc.).Google Scholar
  14. Harbridge House (1981) Survey of the Impact Transportation Deregulation on Major U.S. Manufacturing Firms (Boston: Harbridge House).Google Scholar
  15. Harkins, J. (1988) Statement of Regular Common Carrier conference on Behalf of the Less-Than-Truckload General Freight Industry, before the House Committee on Public Works and Transportation, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, (Oversight Hearings on the Motor Carrier Act of 1980, March 16).Google Scholar
  16. Haseltine, P. W. (1987) Prepared Statement of Philip W. Haseltine, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Policy and International Affairs, US Department of Transportation, before the House Public Works and Transportation Committee, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation (March 26).Google Scholar
  17. Interdepartmental Committee on Competition and Regulation Transportation (1982) Competition and Regulation in Intercity Trucking, (Ottawa: Transport Canada).Google Scholar
  18. Locklin, D. P. (1973) Economics of Transportation (Homewood, Il., Richard D. Irwin, Inc.).Google Scholar
  19. Motor Carrier Rate-making Study Commission (1983) Collective Rate-making in the Trucking Industry (Washington, D. C.).Google Scholar
  20. National Transportation Agency (1989) Annual Review 1988, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services).Google Scholar
  21. National Transportation Agency (1990) Annual Review 1989, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services).Google Scholar
  22. Owen, D. S. (1988) Deregulation in the Trucking Industry (Washington, D. C.: Federal Trade Commission).Google Scholar
  23. Pollock, J. (1986) Transportation Reforms Must Keep Balance’, Bus and Truck, March, p. 36.Google Scholar
  24. Public Commercial Vehicles Act Review Committee (1983) Responsible Trucking, (Toronto: Province of Ontario).Google Scholar
  25. Schultz, R. (1971) ‘Intergovernmental Cooperation, Regulatory Agencies and Transportation Regulation in Canada: The Case of Part III of the National Transportation Act,’ Canadian Public Administration, vol. 19 (2), Summer, p.186.Google Scholar
  26. Skorochod, P. and Bergervin, R. P. (1984) ‘Issues in Transportation/Distribution for the Small/New Exporter,’ Canadian Transportation Research Forum, (19th Annual Meeting), pp.831–853.Google Scholar
  27. Stanbury, W. T. and Thompson, F. (1982) ‘The Prospects for Regulatory Reform in Canada: Political Models and the American Experience,’ Osgoode Hall Law Review, vol. 20 (4), pp. 708–09.Google Scholar
  28. Statistics Canada (1989) Trucking in Canada, 1987, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services, Catalogue 53–222).Google Scholar
  29. Statistics Canada (1990a) Exports-Merchandise Trade, 1988, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services, Catalogue 65–202).Google Scholar
  30. Statistics Canada (1990b) Imports-Merchandise Trade, 1988, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services, Catalogue 65–203).Google Scholar
  31. Thompson, S. J. and Lenore Sek (1986) Surface Transport Carriers: Deregulation Effects and Prospects, Congressional Research Service Report No. 86–65 E (Washington D. C.: Library of Congress).Google Scholar
  32. Transport Canada (1988) Statistical Profile of the Canadian Trucking Industry — 1987, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services).Google Scholar
  33. Wilson, G. W. (1980) Economic Analysis of Intercity Freight Transportation, (Bloomington, IN.: Indiana University Press).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kenneth Button and David Pitfield 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • Garland Chow

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations