Airline Deregulation and Market Performance: The Economic Basis for Regulatory Reform and Lessons from the US Experience

  • Theodore E. Keeler

Abstract

Ever since airline deregulation was first proposed for the United States, it has been the cause of controversy. Proponents have seen little but benefits from it, yet opponents have found much to criticise. The purpose of this paper is to survey the evidence from the United States with the following set of questions in mind.

Keywords

Europe Transportation Income Assure Expense 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abrahams, Michael B. (1983) ‘A Service Quality Model of Air Travel Demand: An Empirical Study’, Transportation Research A, 17A, no.5, pp.385–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bailey, Elizabeth E. and J.C. Panzar (1981) ‘The Contestability of Airline Markets during the Transition to Deregulation’, Law and Contemporary Problems, 44 (Winter) pp. 125–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bailey, Elizabeth E. and Jeffrey R. Williams (1988) ‘Sources of Economic Rent in the Deregulated Airline Industry’, Journal of Law and Economics, 31 (April) pp. 173–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bailey, Elizabeth E., D. Graham and D. Kaplan (1985) Deregulating the Airlines (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press).Google Scholar
  5. Bain, Joe S. (1951) ‘Relation of Profit Rate to Industry Concentration: American Manufacturing’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 65 (August) pp.293–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bain, Joe S. (1956) Barriers to New Competition (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bator, Francis (1958) ‘The Anatomy of Market Failure’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 83 (August) pp. 22–59.Google Scholar
  8. Baumol, William J. (1982) ‘Contestable Markets: An Uprising in the Theory of Industry Structure’, American Economic Review, 72 (March) pp. 1–15.Google Scholar
  9. Baumol, William J., John C. Panzar and Robert D. Willig (1982) Contestable Markets and the Theory of Industry Structure (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich).Google Scholar
  10. Becker, Gary S. (1983) ‘A Theory of Competition among Pressure Groups for Political Influence’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 98, pp. 371–400.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Borenstein, Severin (1985) ‘Price Discrimination in Free-Entry Markets’, Rand Journal of Economics 16 (Autumn) pp. 380–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Borenstein, Severin (1988) ‘Hubs and High Fares: Airport Dominance and Market Power in the U.S. Airline Industry’, University of Michigan Institute of Public Policy Studies Discussion Paper, March.Google Scholar
  13. Brozen, Yale (1982) Concentration, Mergers, and Public Policy (New York: Macmillan).Google Scholar
  14. Business Week, ‘The Sky’s the Limit in Luring the Frequent Flyer’ 2759 (18 October 1982) p. 153.Google Scholar
  15. Button, Kenneth J. (1989a) ‘The Deregulation of U.S. Interstate Aviation: An Assessment of Causes and Consequences: Part I’, Transport Reviews, 9, pp. 99–118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Button, Kenneth J. (1989b) ‘The Deregulation of U.S. Interstate Aviation: An Assessment of Causes and Consequences: Part II’, Transport Reviews, 9, pp. 189–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Call, Gregory D. and Theodore E. Keeler (1985) in A.F. Daughety (ed.), Analytical Studies in Transport Economics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) ch.9.Google Scholar
  18. Capelli, Peter (1985) ‘Competitive Pressure and Labor Relations in the Airline Industry’, Industrial Relations (Fall) pp. 316–38.Google Scholar
  19. Card, David (1986) The Impact of Deregulation on the Employment and Wages of Airline Mechanics’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review (July) pp.527–38.Google Scholar
  20. Carlin, Alan and R.E. Park (1970) ‘Marginal Cost Pricing of Airport Runway Capacity’, American Economic Review, 60 (June) pp. 310–19.Google Scholar
  21. Carlton, Dennis, William Landes and Richard Posner (1980) ‘Benefits and Costs of Airline Mergers: A Case Study’, Bell Journal of Economics, 11 (Spring) pp. 65–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Carron, Andrew S. (1981) Transition to a Free Market: Deregulation of the Air Cargo Industry (Washington: The Brookings Institution).Google Scholar
  23. Caves, Richard E. (1962) Air Transport and Its Regulators (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press).Google Scholar
  24. Caves, Douglas, Laurits R. Christensen and Michael W. Tretheway (1984) ‘Economies of Density versus Economies of Scale: Why Trunk and Local Service Airline Costs Differ’, Rand Journal of Economics, 15 (Winter) pp.471–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Caves, Douglas, Laurits R. Christensen, Michael W. Tretheway and Robert J. Windle (1987) ‘An Assessment of the Efficiency Effects of U.S. Airline Deregulation via an International Comparison’, in Elizabeth E. Bailey (ed.), Public Regulation: New Perspectives on Institutions and Policies (Cambridge, Mass.: Massachussets Institute of Technology Press) pp. 285–320.Google Scholar
  26. Chalk, Andrew (1987) ‘Air Travel: Safety Through the Market’, CATO Policy Report, 9 (July–August) p. 15.Google Scholar
  27. Chance, Don M. and Stephen M. Ferris (1987) ‘The Effect of Aviation Disasters on the Air Transport Industry: A Financial Market Perspective’, Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 21 (May) pp. 151–65.Google Scholar
  28. Clark, J.M. (1940) ‘Toward a Concept of Workable Competition’, American Economic Review, 30 (June) pp. 241–56.Google Scholar
  29. Crandall, Robert and Theodore E. Keeler (1987) ‘Policy and the Private Auto’, in R. Gordon, H. Jacoby and M. Zimmerman (eds), Essays in Honor of Morris A. Adelman (Cambridge, Mass.: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press) pp. 137–60.Google Scholar
  30. Cunningham, Lawrence F., Myron B. Slovin, Wallace R. Wood and Janis K. Ziama (1988) ‘Systematic Risk in the Deregulated Airline Industry’, Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 22 (Spring) pp. 345–54.Google Scholar
  31. Douglas, George W. and James C. Miller (1974) Economic Regulation of Domestic Air Transport (Washington: Brookings Institution).Google Scholar
  32. Eads, George C. (1971) The Local Service Airline Experiment (Washington: The Brookings Institution).Google Scholar
  33. Eads, George C. (1975) ‘Competition in the Domestic Trunk Airline Industry: Too Much or Too Little?’, in Almarin Phillips (ed.), Promoting Competition in Regulated Markets (Washington: The Brookings Institution) pp.13–54.Google Scholar
  34. Fisher, Franklin M. (1987) ‘Horizontal Mergers, Triage and Treatment’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1 (Fall) pp. 23–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Frank, Robert (1983) ‘When Are Price Differentials Discriminatory?’, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 2 p. 238.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Gillen, David W., Tae H. Oum and Michael W. Tretheway (1985) Airline Costs and Performance: Implications for Public and Industry Policies (Vancouver: University of British Columbia).Google Scholar
  37. Hurdle, Gloria J., Richard L. Johnson and Andrew S. Joskow (1988) ‘Concentration, Potential Entry, and Performance in the Airline Industry’, US Department of Justice, Economic Analysis Discussion Paper, February.Google Scholar
  38. Jordan, William (1970) Airline Regulation in America (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press).Google Scholar
  39. Kahn, Alfred E. (1970) The Economics of Regulation: Principles and Institutions: Volume I: Principles and Volume II: Institutions (New York: John Wiley).Google Scholar
  40. Kahn, Alfred E. (1988a) ‘Airline Deregulation: A Mixed Bag, but a Clear Success Nevertheless’, Transportation Law Journal, 16, pp. 229–51.Google Scholar
  41. Kahn, Alfred E. (1988b) ‘Surprises of Airline Deregulation’, American Economic Review, 78 (May) pp. 316–22.Google Scholar
  42. Kanafani, Adib and Theodore E. Keeler (1989a) ‘The Safety of New Entrants in the Airline Industry under Deregulation’, in L. Moses and I. Savage (eds), Deregulation and Safety in Transportation (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Google Scholar
  43. Kanafani, Adib and Theodore E. Keeler (1989b) ‘Air Deregulation and Safety-Some Econometric Evidence from Time Series’, unpublished paper, Institute of Transportation Studies, University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
  44. Keeler, Theodore E. (1970) ‘Airport Costs and Congestion’, American Economist, 14 (Spring) pp. 47–63.Google Scholar
  45. Keeler, Theodore E. (1971a) ‘The Economics of Passenger Trains”, Journal of Business (April, 1971), pp. 144–172.Google Scholar
  46. Keeler, Theodore E. (1971b) ‘Resource Allocation in Intercity Passenger Transportation’, PhD dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.Google Scholar
  47. Keeler, Theodore E. (1972) ‘Airline Regulation and Market Performance’, Bell Journal of Economics, 3 (Autumn) pp. 399–424.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Keeler, Theodore E. (1978) ‘Domestic Airline Regulation: An Economic Evaluation’, in L. Weiss and M. Klass (eds), Study on Federal Regulation, US Senate, Committee on Governmental Affairs, volume VII (Washington: US Government Printing Office) pp. 77–160.Google Scholar
  49. Keeler, Theodore E. (1980) ‘Comments on Bailey and Panzar’ (1981, listed above) presented at Duke University Conference on the Transition to Deregulation, May.Google Scholar
  50. Keeler, Theodore E. (1984) ‘Theories of Regulation and the Deregulation Movement’, Public Choice, 44 pp. 103–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Keeler, Theodore E. and Michael B. Abrahams (1981) ‘Market Structure, Pricing, and Service Quality in the Airline Industry under Deregulation’, in W. Sichel and T. Gies (eds), Applications of Economic Principles in Public Utility Industries (Ann Arbor: Michigan Business Studies, vol.2, no. 3) pp. 103–20.Google Scholar
  52. Keyes, Lucille B. (1949) ‘National Policy Toward Commercial Aviation — Some Basic Problems’, Journal of Air Law and Commerce, 16, p. 280.Google Scholar
  53. Labich, Kenneth (1989) ‘Should Airlines Be Reregulated?’, Fortune 119 (19 June) pp. 82–90.Google Scholar
  54. Levine, Michael E. (1965) ‘Is Regulation Necessary? California Air Transportation and National Regulatory Policy’, Yale Law Review, 74 (July) pp. 1416–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Levine, Michael E. (1969) ‘Landing Fees and the Airport Congestion Problem’, Journal of Law and Economics, 12 (April) pp. 79–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Levine, Michael E. (1987) ‘Airline Competition in Deregulated Markets: Theory, Firm Strategy, and Public Policy’, Yale Journal on Regulation, 4 (Spring) pp.393–494.Google Scholar
  57. Markham, Jesse (1950) ‘An Alternative Approach in the Concept of Workable Competition’, American Economic Review, 40 (June) pp.349–61.Google Scholar
  58. McMullen, B. Starr (1985) ‘Trunk Airline Financial Requirements and Economic Performance’, in T. Keeler (ed.), Research in Transportation Economics (Greenwich, CT.: JAI Press) pp. 121–48.Google Scholar
  59. Meyer, John R. and Clinton V. Oster (1987) Deregulation and the Future of Intercity Passenger Travel (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press).Google Scholar
  60. Moore, Thomas G. (1986) ‘U.S. Airline Deregulation: Its Effects on Passengers, Capital, and Labour’, Journal of Law and Economics, 29 (April) pp. 1–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Morrison, Steven, A. (1983) ‘Estimation of Long-run Prices and Investment Levels for Airport Runways’, in T. Keeler (ed.), Research in Transportation Economics, Vol. I (Greenwich, CT.: JAI Press) pp. 103–30.Google Scholar
  62. Morrison, Steven and Clifford Winston (1985) ‘An Econometric Analysis of the Demand for Intercity Passenger Transportation’, in T. Keeler (ed.), Research in Transportation Economics, Vol.II (Greenwich, CT.: JAI Press) pp. 213–38.Google Scholar
  63. Morrison, Steven C. and Clifford Winston (1986) The Economic Effects of Airline Deregulation (Washington: The Brookings Institution).Google Scholar
  64. Morrison, S. and C. Winston (1987) ‘Empirical Implications and Tests of the Contestability Hypothesis’, Journal of Law and Economics, 30 (April) pp.53–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Morrison, Steven and Clifford Winston (1988) ‘Air Safety, Deregulation and Public Policy’, Brookings Review (Winter) pp. 10–15.Google Scholar
  66. Morrison, S. and C. Winston (1989) ‘Enhancing the Performance of the Deregulated Air Transportation System’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, (Microeconomic Issue) pp. 61–112.Google Scholar
  67. Northrup, Herbert R. (1983) ‘The New Employee-Relations Climate in Airlines’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review (January) pp. 167–81.Google Scholar
  68. Panzar, John C. (1979) Regulation, Service Quality, and Market Performance: A Model of Airline Rivalry (New York: Garland Publishing Company).Google Scholar
  69. Peltzman, Sam (1976) ‘Toward a More General Theory of Regulation’, Journal of Law and Economics (August) pp. 211–40.Google Scholar
  70. Peoples, James (1987) ‘Deregulation and Wage Levels in the Airline Industry’, unpublished paper, Rutgers University.Google Scholar
  71. Posner, Richard A. (1971) ‘Taxation by Regulation’, Bell Journal of Economics, 2 (Spring) pp. 22–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Pulsifer, Roy, Lucille S. Keyes, Paul Eldridge, James A McMahon and Willard Demory (1975) Report of the CAB Special Staff on Regulatory Reform (Washington: US Civil Aeronautics Board).Google Scholar
  73. Ramirez, Anthony (1989) ‘Boeing’s Happy, Harrowing Times’, Fortune, 120 (17 July) pp. 40–8.Google Scholar
  74. Reiss, Peter C. and Pablo T. Spiller (1988) ‘Competition and Entry in Small Airline Markets’, presented at the FTC Conference Empirical Approaches to Market Power, Washington, DC, August.Google Scholar
  75. Rose, Nancy L. (1988) ‘Profitability and Product Quality: Economic Determinants of Airline Safety Performance’, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Sloan Working Paper 2032–88.Google Scholar
  76. Saunders, Lisa F. (1987) ‘Wages, Workrules, and Cost-efficient firms in the Deregulated Airline Industry’, Berkeley, University of California, Institute of Transportation Studies, Dissertation Series UCB-ITS-DS-87-5.Google Scholar
  77. Scherer, F.M. (1980) Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance (New York: Rand McNally).Google Scholar
  78. Schmalensee, Richard (1989) ‘Intra-Industry Profitability Differences in U.S. Manufacturing, 1953–83’, Journal of Industrial Economics, 37 (June) pp.337–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Shepard, Andrea (1990) ‘Pricing Behaviour and Vestual Constraints in Retail Markets’, American Economic Review, Paper and Proceedings (May) pp. 427–31.Google Scholar
  80. Stigler, George J. (1971) ‘The Economic Theory of Regulation’, Bell Journal of Economics, 2 (Spring) pp. 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. 1.
    Strassman, Diana L. (1986), ‘Contestable Markets and Dynamic Limit Pricing in the Deregulated Airline Industry: An Empirical Test’, Rice University, February.Google Scholar
  82. US Senate, Committee on Administrative Practices and Procedures (1975) Civil Aeronautics Board Practices and Procedures (Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office).Google Scholar
  83. Waterson, Michael (1984) Economic Theory of the Industry (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  84. Whinston, Michael D. and Scott C. Collins (1988) ‘Entry, Contestability, and Deregulated Airline Markets: An Event Study Analysis’, unpublished, Harvard University.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© David Banister and Kenneth Button 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • Theodore E. Keeler

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations