Michal Kalecki’s Contributions to the Theory and Practice of Socialist Planning

  • D. M. Nuti

Abstract

Michal Kalecki’s contributions to the economics of socialism — less widely known but no less important than his pioneering contributions to the economics of capitalism — span the period 1946-70 and are affected by the development and performance of the Polish system, and coloured by his views on capitalist dynamics. These contributions comprise a coherent model of the socialist economy and its functioning, characterised by centralised economic planning and political decentralisation with a limited role for markets; a well-developed theory of socialist dynamics, emphasising exogenous constraints to growth and accumulation policy, which were neglected by Polish leaders with dramatic consequences; and a number of planning procedures and guidelines of practical use for the selection of investment projects, consumption planning and the construction of long-term plans.

Keywords

Europe Income Explosive Expense Tempo 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Brus, W. (1977) ‘Kalecki’s economics of socialism’, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 39 (1) (Michat Kalecki Memorial Issue).Google Scholar
  2. Chilosi, A. (1971) ‘The theory of growth of a socialist economy of M. Kalecki’, Economics of Planning, 11 (3).Google Scholar
  3. Feinstein, C. (ed.) (1967) Socialism, Capitalism and Economic Growth, Essays in honour of Maurice Dobb (Cambridge:Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  4. Feldman, G. A. (1928) ‘K teorii tempov narodnogo dokhoda’ (On the theory of growth rates of national income), Planovoe Khoziaistvo, 11 and 12 (November and December); English trans from Russian in Spulber (ed.) (1964).Google Scholar
  5. Feldman, G. A. (1929) ‘0 limitakh industrializatsii’ (On limits to indus-trialisation), Planovoe Khoziaistvo, 2 (February); English trans from Russian in Spulber (ed.), (1964).Google Scholar
  6. Granick, D. (1970) Enterprise Guidance in Eastern Europe (Princeton: Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
  7. Hahn, F. H. and R. C. O. Matthews (1964) ‘The theory of economic growth: a survey’, Economic Journal, 74, (December).Google Scholar
  8. Horvat, B. (1958) ‘The optimum rate of investment’, Economic Journal, LxvIII (272) (December).Google Scholar
  9. Jeffries, I. (ed.) (1981) The Industrial Enterprise in Eastern Europe (Lon-don: Praeger).Google Scholar
  10. Jozefiak, C. (1971) Optimum techniczo-renowacjine w gospodarce socjalis-tycznej (Optimum technical choice in the socialist economy) (Warsaw: PWN).Google Scholar
  11. Kalecki, M. (1942) ‘Basic preconditions for a democratic planned economy’, Labour Discussion Notes, 35 (September), The Socialist Clarity Group, London (Polish version in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  12. Kalecki, M. (1946a) ‘Uwagi o racjonowaniu i systemie cen’ (Observations on rationing and the price system) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  13. Kalecki M. (1946b) ‘Uwagi o oszczednosciach i obiegu pienieznym w Polsce’ (Observations on savings and monetary circulation in Poland) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  14. Kalecki M. (1946c) ‘Plany finansowe na II polrocze 1946 r. i na I polrocze 1947 r’ (Financial plans for the second semester of 1946 and the first semester of 1947) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  15. Kalecki, M. (1956a) ‘Liberalizacja zarzadzania drobnym przemyslem’ (Liberalisation of management in small-scale industry) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  16. Kalecki, M. (1956b) ‘Rady robotnicze a centralne planowanie’ (Workers’ councils and central planning), Nowe Drogi, 11–12, (November-Decem-ber) pp. 38–45 (also in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  17. Kalecki, M. (1956c) ‘Dynamika inwestycji i dochodu narodowego w gospo-darcze socjalistycznej’ (The Dynamics of Investment and National Income in Socialist Economy), Ekonomista, pp. 61–70.Google Scholar
  18. Kalecki, M. (1957a) ‘Nie przeceniac roli modelu’ (The role of the model should not be overestimated), Trybuna Ludu, 33 (3 February) (also in Kalecki, 1981).Google Scholar
  19. Kalecki, M. (1957b) ‘Koncern pionowy?’ (A Vertical Concern? The Eco-nomic Proposals) Polityka, 8 (17–23 April) (also as ‘Koncern pionowy jako element nowego modelu gospodarczego’ (Vertically integrated enterprise groups as an element of the new economic model) in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  20. Kalecki, M. (1957c) ‘Zmiany modelu gospodarczego w zakresie bodzcow ekonomicznych’ (Changes of the economic model in the area of economic incentives) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  21. Kalecki, M. (1957d) ‘Schemat nowego systemu bodzcow i nakazow’ (Scheme of the new system of incentives and orders), Zycie Gospodarcze 29 (21 July 1957) p. 1 (also in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  22. Kalecki, M. (1957e) ‘Uwagi o methodzie prac nad planem perspektywicznym’ (Notes on the perspective plan methodology) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  23. Kalecki, M. (1958a) ‘Bodzce zainteresowania materialnego w gospodarce socjalistycznej’ (Material incentives in the socialist economy), in the proceedings of a conference on the same subject in January 1956, Szkice Ekonomiczne (Warsaw: ZNE PAN) (also in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  24. Kalecki, M. (1958b) ‘Centralisticko odredivanje cena kao bitni elemenat socijalisticke economike’ (Centralised price formation as an essential element of the socialist economy), Medzunarodni Problemi, 3, pp. 137–40 (Polish translation in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  25. Kalecki, M. (1958c) ‘Czynniki okreslajace tempo wzrostu gospodarki soc-jalistycznej’ (Factors limiting the growth rate of a socialist economy), Gospodarka Planowa, 8, pp. 1–5.Google Scholar
  26. Kalecki, M. (1958d) ‘0 wspolczynniku zamrozenia’ (On the freezing coef-ficient), Ekonomista, pp. 1393–1400.Google Scholar
  27. Kalecki, M. (1958e) ‘Plan perspektiwyczny na lata 1961–75’ (The perspec-tive plan for 1961–75), Nowe Drogi, 8 (August) (English trans in Polish Perspectives, 3, 1959).Google Scholar
  28. Kalecki, M. (1962) ‘Problemy wlasnej bazy cen krajow RWPG’ (Problems of the own price basis for CMEA countries) (first published in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  29. Kalecki, M. (1963a) Zarys teorii wzrostu gospodarki socjalistycznej (Out-line of a theory of growth of the socialist economy) (Warsaw: PWN) (English trans in Kalecki, 1972).Google Scholar
  30. Kalecki, M. (1963b) ‘Zagadnienie optymalnej struktury spozycia’ (The problem of optimum consumption structure), Gospodarka Planowa (July) (also in Kalecki, 1984; English trans in Mathematical Studies in Economics and Statistics in the USSR and Eastern Europe, I (4) 1966).Google Scholar
  31. Kalecki, M. (1963c) ‘An outline of a method of constructing a perspective plan’, SGPiS.Google Scholar
  32. Kalecki, M. (1963d) ‘0 podstawowych zasadach planowania wieloletniego’ (On the general principles of long term planning), Zycie Gospodarcze, 24 (in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  33. Kalecki, M. (1965) ‘Krzywa produkcji a rachunek efektywnosci inwestycji’ (Production curve and the evaluation of investment effectiveness), Eko-nomista, 1 (English trans in Feinstein (ed.) (1967)).Google Scholar
  34. Kalecki, M. (1971a) Selected Essays on the Dynamics of the Capitalist Economy 1933–1970 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  35. Kalecki, M. (1971b) ‘Zakres stosowania rachunku efektywnosci inwestycji w gospodarce socjalistycznej’ (The scope of the evaluation of investment efficiency in a socialist economy), Gospodarka Planowa, 5 (English trans in Kalecki, 1972).Google Scholar
  36. Kalecki, M. (1972) Selected Essays on the Economic Growth of the Socialist and the Mixed Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  37. Kalecki, M. (1982) Dzielu, tom 3: Socyalizm - Funkcjonowanie i wielolet-nie planowanie (Collected Works on ’Socialism - Functioning and Long-Term Planning’, Vol. 3, J. Osiatynski (ed.) (Warsaw: PWN)).Google Scholar
  38. Kalecki, M. (1984) Dzielu, tom 4: Socjalizm - Wzrost gospodarczy i efek-tywnosc inwestycji (Collected Works on ‘Socialism - Economic Growth and Investment Effectiveness’, Vol. 4, J. Osiatynski (ed.) (Warsaw: PWN))Google Scholar
  39. Kalecki, M. and S. Polaczek (1957a) ‘Uwagi w sprawie metody ustalania cen surowcow podstawowych’ (Notes on a method for fixing the prices of basic raw materials), Gospodarka Planowa, 4, pp. 18–22 (also in Kalecki, 1982). cen surowcow podstawowych’ (Notes on a method for fixing the prices of basic raw materials), Gospodarka Planowa, 4, pp. 18–22 (also in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  40. Kalecki, M. and S. Polaczek (1957b) ‘Dyskusja o cenach surowcow podsta-wowych’ (The debate on the prices of basic raw materials), Gospodarka Planowa, 9 pp. 66–8 (also in Kalecki, 1982).Google Scholar
  41. Kalecki, M. and M. Rakowski (1959), ‘Uogolnienie wzoru ekonomicznej efektywnosci inwestycji’ (A generalised formula of investment effective-ness), Gospodarka Planowa, 11 (English trans in A. Nove and A. Zauber-man (eds) (1964)).Google Scholar
  42. KPpRM - Komisia Planowania przy Radzie Ministrow (1962) Instrukcja ogolna w sprawie metodyki badan ekonomicznej efektywnosci inwestycji (General instruction on the methodology for determining the economic effectiveness of investment) (Warsaw).Google Scholar
  43. Lange, O. (1956) ‘Budowa nowego modelu gospodarczego musi oprzec sie na dynamice klasy robotniczej i socjalistycznej inteligencji’ (The construc-tion of the new economic model must be based on the dynamics of the working class and the socialist intelligentzia), Nowy Drogi, 11–12.Google Scholar
  44. Laski, K. (1965) Zarys teorii reprodukcji socjalistycznej (Outline of a theory of socialist reproduction) (Warsaw: PWN).Google Scholar
  45. Little, I. M. D. (1949) ‘A reformulation of the theory of consumers’ behaviour’, Oxford Economic Papers, 1 (1) (January).Google Scholar
  46. Melzer, M. (1981) ‘Combine formation and the role of the enterprise in East German industry’, in Jeffries (ed.) (1981).Google Scholar
  47. Nove A. and A. Zauberman (eds) (1964) Studies on the Theory of Repro-duction and Prices (Warsaw: PWN).Google Scholar
  48. Nuti, D. M. (1970) ‘Capitalism, socialism and steady growth’, Economic Journal,Lxxx (March).Google Scholar
  49. Nuti, D. M. (1971) ‘The evolution of Polish investment planning’, Jahr-buch der Wirtschaft Osteuropas, 3 (Munich and Vienna).Google Scholar
  50. Nuti, D. M. (1973) ‘The political economy of socialism - orthodoxy and change in Polish texts’, Soviet Studies, xxv (October) pp. 244–70.Google Scholar
  51. Nuti, D. M. (1977) ‘Large corporations and the reform of Polish industry’, Jahrbuch der Wirtschaft Osteuropas, 7 (Munich and Vienna) pp. 345–405.Google Scholar
  52. Rakowski, M. (ed.) (1963) Efektywnosc Inwestycji (Investment efficiency), (Warsaw: PWN) (English trans, 1966 (Warsaw: PWN)).Google Scholar
  53. Samuelson, P. (1947) Foundations of Economic Analysis, (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press).Google Scholar
  54. Samuelson, P. (1948) The consumption theory in terms of revealed prefer-ences, Economica, xv (60) (November).Google Scholar
  55. Sawyer, M. C. (1985) The Economics of Michat Kalecki, (London: Mac-millan).Google Scholar
  56. SGPiS (1963) Essays on Planning and Economic Development, Teaching Materials, 8 (Warsaw).Google Scholar
  57. Spulber, N. (ed.) (1964) Foundations of Soviet Strategy for Economic Growth - Selected Soviet Essays 1924–1930, (Bloomington: Indiana Uni-versity Press).Google Scholar
  58. Wolf, T. A. (1985) ‘Economic stabilisation in planned economies’, IMF Staff Papers, 32 (1) (March).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Mario Sebastiani 1989

Authors and Affiliations

  • D. M. Nuti

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations