Abstract
We hope that this chapter, and indeed the book, will give the reader some idea of the wide range of psychological research relevant to the law. Our intention is to illustrate the sorts of questions which have interested psychologists and to indicate the kinds of findings which have been produced. The review is not intended to be exhaustive, for this would require a book rather than a chapter (for other reviews of this literature see Bermant et al., 1976; Tapp, 1976). Some of the topics mentioned here are reviewed in more detail in succeeding chapters. Although most of the research quoted is American, we have tried to pay special attention to British work.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
A. Bandura and F. J. McDonald, ‘Influence of social reinforcement and the behavior of models in shaping children’s moral judgments’, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, LXVII (1963) 274–81.
C. Banks, E. Maloney and H. D. Willcock, ‘Public attitudes to crime and the penal system’, British Journal of Criminology, XV (1975) 228–40.
A. A. Bartholomew, P. Badger and K. L. Milte, ‘The psychologist as an expert witness in the criminal courts’, Australian Psychologist, XII (1977) 133–50.
J. C. Baxter and R. M. Rozelle, ‘Nonverbal expression as a function of crowding during a simulated police-citizen encounter’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXII (1975) 40–54.
H. S. Becker, Outsiders (New York: Free Press, 1963).
K. S. Berg and N. Vidmar, ‘Authoritarianism and recall of evidence about criminal behavior’, Journal of Research in Personality, IX (1975) 147–57.
L. Berkowitz and N. Walker, ‘Laws and moral judgments’, Sociometry, XXX (1967) 410–22.
G. Bermant, C. Nemeth and N. Vidmar, ‘Psychology and the law: status and challenge’ in G. Bermant, C. Nemeth and N. Vidmar (Eds.) Psychology and the Law (Lexington Massachussetts: Lexington Books, 1976).
W. Bevan, R. S. Albert, P. R. Loiseaux, P. N. Mayfield and G. Wright, ‘Jury behavior as a function of the prestige of the foreman and the nature of his leadership’, journal of Public Law, VII (1958) 419–49
L. Bickman, ‘Bystander intervention in crime: the effect of a mass-media campaign’, journal of Applied Social Psychology, V (1975) 296–302.
L. Bickman and D. P. Rosenbaum, ‘Crime reporting as a function of bystander encouragement, surveillance and credibility’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXV (1977) 577–86.
D. Biles and B. F. McCoy, ‘Police attitudes to deviance in Victoria’, Australian and New Zealand journal of Sociology, IX (1973) 67–70.
E. Brown, K. Deffenbacher and W. Sturgill, ‘Memory for faces and the circumstances of encounter’, journal of Applied Psychology, LII (1977) 311–18.
R. Buckhout, A. Alper, S. Chern, G. Silverberg and M. Slomovits, ‘Determinants of eyewitness performance on a lineup’, Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, IV (1974) 191–2.
J. A. Burns and B. L. Kintz, ‘Eye contact while lying during an interview’, Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, VII (1976) 87–9.
R. M. Carroll, S. M. Pine, C.J. Cline and B. R. Kleinhans, ‘Judged seriousness of Watergate-related crimes’, journal of Psychology, LXXXVI (1974) 235–9.
S. Cohen and L. Taylor, Psychological Survival (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1972).
R. F. Cook and R. H. Fosen, ‘Pornography and the sex offender: patterns of exposure and immediate arousal effects of pornographic stimuli’, in U.S. President’s Commission on Obscenity and Pornography (Washington: Government Printing Office, 1970).
D. B. Cornish and R. V. G. Clarke, Residential Treatment and its Effects on Delinquency (London: HMSO, 1975).
P. O. Davidson, ‘Validity of the guilty-knowledge technique: the effects of motivation’, journal of Applied Psychology, LII (1968) 62–5.
G. Davies, H. Ellis and J. Shepherd, ‘Cue saliency in faces as assessed by the “Photofit” technique’, Perception, VI (1977) 263–9.
J. H. Davis, R. M. Bray and R. W. Holt, ‘The empirical study of social decision processes in juries’, in J. L. Tapp and F. J. Levine (Eds.), Law, justice and the Individual in Society (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1977).
D. A. Day and B. P. Rourke, ‘The role of attention in “lie-detection”’, Canadian journal of Behavioural Science, VI (1974) 270–6.
W. DeJong, W. N. Morris and A. H. Hastorf, ‘Effect of an escaped accomplice on the punishment assigned to a criminal defendant’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXIII (1976) 192–8.
M. C. Dertke, L.A. Penner and K. Ulrich, ‘Observer’s reporting of shoplifting as a function of thief’s race and sex’, journal of Social Psychology, XCIV (1974) 213–21.
E. Diener, S. C. Fraser, A. L. Beaman and R. T. Kelem, ‘Effects ofdeindividuation variables on stealing among Halloween trick-or-treaters’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXIII (1976) 178–83.
E. B. Ebbesen and V.J. Konecni, ‘Decision making and information integration in the courts: the setting of bail’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXII (1975) 805–21.
P. Ekman and W. V. Friesen, ‘Detecting deception from the body or face’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXIX (1974) 288–98.
D. P. Farrington, ‘Self-reports of deviant behavior: predictive and stable?’, journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, LXIV (1973) 99–110.
D. P. Farrington, ‘Criminological aspects of psychology’, in M. Wright (Ed.), Use of Criminology Literature (London: Butterworths, 1974).
D. P. Farrington, ‘The effects of public labelling’, British Journal of Criminology, XVII (1977) 112–25.
D. P. Farrington, ‘The effectiveness of sentences’, justice of the Peace, CXLII (1978) 68–71.
D. P. Farrington and B.J. Knight, ‘Two non-reactive field experiments on stealing from a “lost” letter’, British journal of Social and Clinical Psychology XVIII (1979) in press.
D. P. Farrington, S. G. Osborn and D.J. West, ‘The persistence of labelling effects’, British journal of Criminology, XVIII (1978) 277–84.
M. P. Feldman, Criminal Behaviour: a Psychological Analysis (London: Wiley, 1977).
C. A. Fenster and B. Locke, ‘The “dumb cop”: myth or reality? An examination of police intelligence’, Journal of Personality Assessment, XXXVII (1973) 276–81.
M. S. Folkard, A. J. Fowles, B. C. McWilliams, W. McWilliams, D. D. Smith, D. E. Smith and G. R. Walmsley, IMPACT: Intensive Matched Probation and After-Care Treatment. Vol s. The design of the probation experiment and an interim evaluation (London: HMSO, 1974).
M. S. Folkard, D. E. Smith and D. D. Smith, IMPACT. Vol 2. The results of the experiment (London: HMSO, 1976).
J. L. Freedman, S. A. Wallington and E. Bless, ‘Compliance without pressure: the effect of guilt’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, VII (1967) 117–24.
R. M. Friend and M. Vinson, ‘Leaning over backwards: jurors’ responses to defendants’ attractiveness’, journal of Communication, XXIV (1974) 124–9.
J. Gallatin and J. Adelson, ‘Legal guarantees of individual freedom: a cross-national study of the development of political thought’, in J. L. Tapp and F.J. Levine (Eds.), Law, justice and the Individual in Sociey (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1977).
D. M. Gelfand, D. P. Hartmann, P. Walder and P. Page, ‘Who reports shoplifters? A field-experimental study’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXV (1973) 276–85.
P. Gendreau, M. Irvine and S. Knight, ‘Evaluating response set styles on the MMPI with prisoners: faking good adjustment and maladjustment’, Canadian journal of Behavioural Science, V (1973) 183–94.
M. Gold, Delinquent Behavior in an American City (Belmont: Brooks Cole, 1970).
M. Gold and J. R. Williams, ‘National study of the aftermath of apprehension’, Prospectus: a Journal of Law Reform, III (1969) 3–12.
M. J. Goldstein, ‘A behavioral scientist looks at obscenity’, in B. D. Sales (Ed.) Perspectives in Law and Psychology. Vol r. The Criminal justice System (New York: Plenum, 1977).
D. B. Gray and R. D. Ashmore, ‘Biasing influence of defendants’ characteristics on simulated sentencing’, Psychological Reports, XXXVIII (1976) 727–38.
D. S. Greer, ‘Anything but the truth? The reliability of testimony in criminal trials’, British journal of Criminology, XI (1971) 131–54.
W. Griffitt and T. Jackson, ‘Simulated jury decisions: the influence of jury-defendant attitude similarity-dissimilarity’, Social Behavior and Personality, I (1973) 1–7.
H. Harari and J. W. McDavid, ‘Situational influence on moral justice: a study of “finking”’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XI (1969) 240–4.
H. F. Harlow, ‘The heterosexual affectional system in monkeys’, American Psychologist, XVII (1962) 1–9.
L. R. C. Haward, ‘The reliability of corroborated police evidence in a case flagrante delicto’, Journal of the Forensic Science Society, III (1962) 71–8.
L. R. C. Haward, ‘Admissibility of psychological evidence in obscenity cases’, Bulletin of the British Psychological Society, XXVIII (1975) 466–9.
L. R. C. Haward and B. McGann (Eds.) Psychiatry, Psychology and the Law Courts (Dublin: Institute of Psychology, 1972).
F. A. Hill, ‘Attribution of responsibility in a campus stabbing incident’, Social Behavior and Personality, III (1975) 127–31.
J. Hogarth, Sentencing as a Human Process (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1971).
B. C. Hoiberg and L. K. Stires, ‘The effect of several types of pretrial publicity on the guilt attributions of simulated jurors’, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, III (1973) 267–75
J. Hollender, ‘Moral values: personality and demographic correlates of attitudes toward crimes without victims’, Journal of Social Psychology, LXXXVII (1972) 279–85.
F. Horvath, ‘Detection of deception: a review of field and laboratory procedures and research’, Polygraph, V (1976) 107–45.
F. Horvath, ‘The effect of selected variables on interpretation of polygraph records’, Journal of Applied Psychology, LXII (1977) 127–36.
R. R. Izzett and W. Leginski, ‘Group discussion and the influence of defendant characteristics in a simulated jury setting’, Journal of Social Psychology, XCIII (1974) 271–9
I. Jacks, ‘Psychological testing in institutional rehabilitation centers: a gentle critique’, Crime and Delinquency, VIII (1962) 34–9.
C. B. Keasey and B. D. Sales, ‘Children’s conceptions of intentionality and the criminal law’, in B. D. Sales (Ed.), Psychology in the Legal Process (New York: Spectrum, 1977).
R. D. Laing, The Divided Self (London: Tavistock, 1960).
D. Landy and E. Aronson, ‘The influence of the character of the criminal and his victim on the decisions of simulated jurors’, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, V (1969) 141–52.
B. Latane and J. M. Darley, The Unresponsive Bystander: Why Doesn’t He Help? (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1970).
S. LaTour, P. Houlden, L. Walker and J. Thibaut, ‘Procedure: transnational perspectives and preferences’, Yale Law Journal, LXXXVI (1976) 258–90.
M.J. Lerner and G. Matthews, ‘Reactions to suffering of others under conditions of indirect responsibility’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, V (1967) 319–25.
I. Lieblich, G. Ben Shakhar and S. Kugelmass, ‘Validity of the guilty knowledge technique in a prisoners’ sample’, Journal of Applied Psychology, LXI (1976) 89–93
E. A. Lind, J. Thibaut and L. Walker, ‘Discovery and presentation of evidence in adversary and nonadversary proceedings’, Michigan Law Review, LXXI (1973) 1129–44.
D. B. Lindsley, ‘The psychology of lie detection’, in G.J. Dudycha (Ed.), Psychology for Law Enforcement Officers (Springfield: Thomas, 1955).
S. M. Lloyd-Bostock, ‘The ordinary man and the psychology of attributing causes and responsibility’, Modern Law Review (in press, 1979).
E. F. Loftus, ‘Incredible eyewitness’, Psychology Today, VIII (1974) 117–9.
E. F. Loftus, ‘Leading questions and the eyewitness report’, Cognitive Psychology, VII (1975) 560–72.
D. T. Lykken, ‘The GSR in the detection of guilt’, Journal of Applied Psychology, XLIII (1859) 385–8.
D. T. Lykken, ‘Psychology and the lie detector industry’, American Psychologist, XXIX (1974) 725–39.
S. Macaulay and E. Walster, ‘Legal structures and restoring equity’, in J. L. Tapp and F.J. Levine (Eds.), Law, Justice and the Individual in Society (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1977).
N. R. F. Maier and J. A. Thurber, ‘Accuracy of judgments of deception when an interview is watched, heard and read’, Personnel Psychology, XXI (1968) 23–30.
E. C. Main and T. G. Walker, ‘Choice shifts and extreme behavior: judicial review in the federal courts’, Journal of Social Psychology, XCI (1973) 215–221.
L. Mann, ‘Simulation of a protest demonstration: its effect on attitudes toward police and demonstrators’, Australian Psychologist, IX (1974) 6–18.
J. Marshall, Law and Psychology in Conflict (Indianapolis: Bobbs Merrill, 1966).
W. M. Marston, ‘Studies in testimony’, Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, XV (1924) 5–31.
H. E. Mitchell and D. Byrne, ‘The defendant’s dilemma: effects of jurors’ attitudes and authoritarianism on judicial decisions’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXV (1973) 123–9.
H. Munsterberg, On the Witness Stand (New York: Clark Boardman, 1938).
D. G. Myers and M. F. Kaplan, ‘Group-induced polarization in simulated juries’, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, II (1976) 63–6.
A. R. Nesdale and B. G. Rule, ‘The effects of an aggressor’s characteristics and an observer’s accountability on judgments of aggression’, Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, VI (1974) 342–51.
K. E. Patterson and A. D. Baddeley, ‘When face recognition fails’, Journal of Experimental Psychology—Human Learning and Memory, III (1977) 406–17.
K. Pease, J. Ireson, S. Billingham and J. Thorpe, ‘The development of a scale of offence seriousness’, International Journal of Criminology and Penology, V (1977a) 17–29.
K. Pease and M. Sampson, ‘Doing time and marking time’, Howard Journal, XVI (1977) 59–64.
K. Pease, R. Tarling and P. Meudell, ‘Decisions in the criminal justice process and signal detection theory: a note’, Quality and Quantity, XI (1977b) 83–9.
L. A. Penner, L. S. Summers, D. A. Brookmire and M. C. Dertke, ‘The lost dollar: situational and personality determinants of a pro- and anti-social behavior’, Journal of Personality, XLIV (1976) 274–93.
A. Pepitone and J. Sherberg, ‘Intentionality, responsibility, and interpersonal attraction’, Journal of Personality, XXV (1957) 757–66.
J. Phillips and K. O. Hawkins, ‘Some economic aspects of the settlement process: a study of personal injury claims’, Modern Law Review, XXXIX (1976) 497–515.
A. Podgorecki, W. Kaupen, J. Van Houtte, P. Vinke and B. Kutchinsky, Knowledge and Opinion About Law (London: Martin Robertson, 1973).
J. A. Podlesny and D. C. Raskin, ‘Physiological measures and the detection of deception’, Psychological Bulletin, LXXXIV (1977) 782–99.
N. M. Prentice, ‘The influence of live and symbolic modeling on promoting moral judgment of adolescent delinquents’, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, LXXX (1972) 157–61.
R. E. Prytula, H. D. Whiteside and P. L. Davidson, ‘Police experience and attribution of personal responsibility’, Psychological Reports, XXXVII (1975) 1346.
M. Rokeach and N. Vidmar, ‘Testimony concerning possible jury bias in a Black Panther murder trial’, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, III (1973) 19–29.
H. L. Ross, ‘Deterrence regained: the Cheshire Constabulary’s “Breathalyser Blitz”’, Journal of Legal Studies, VI (1977) 241–9.
H. L. Ross, D. T. Campbell and G. V. Glass, ‘Determining the social effects of a legal reform: the British “Breathalyser” crackdown of 1967’, American Behavioral Scientist, XIII (1970) 493–509.
M. G. Rumsey, ‘Effects of defendant background and remorse on sentencing judgments’, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, VI (1976) 64–8.
B. D. Sales (Ed.) Perspectives in Law and Psychology. Vol r. The Criminal Justice System (New York: Plenum, 1977).
J. C. Savitsky, R. Muskin, D. Czyzewski and J. Eckert, ‘The cheating and intention of a partner as determinants of evaluative decisions among juvenile offenders’, Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, IV (1976) 235–41.
A. P. Sealy and W. R. Cornish, ‘Juries and the rules of evidence’, Criminal Law Review, (1973) 208–23.
D. R. Shaffer, M. Rogel and C. Hendrick, ‘Intervention in the library: the effect of increased responsibility on bystanders’ willingness to prevent a theft’, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, V (1975) 303–19.
K. G. Shaver, ‘Defensive attribution: effects of severity and relevance on the responsibility assigned for an accident’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XIV (1970a) 101–13.
K. G. Shaver, ‘Redress and conscientiousness in the attribution of responsibility for accidents’, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology VI (1970b) 50–10.
D. J. Shoemaker, D. R. South and J. Lowe, ‘Facial stereotypes of deviants and judgments of guilt or innocence’, Social Forces, LI (1973) 427–33.
D. E. Silber, ‘Controversy concerning the criminal justice system and its implications for the role of mental health workers’, American Psychologist, XXIX (1974) 239–44.
R. J. Simon, “’Beyond a reasonable doubt” — an experimental attempt at quantification’, Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, VI (1970) 203–9.
A. B. Smith, B. Locke and A. Fenster, ‘Authoritarianism in policemen who are college graduates and non-college police’, Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science, LXI (1970) 313–5.
D. J. Steffensmeier and R. M. Terry, ‘Deviance and respectability: an obser- vational study of reactions to shoplifting’, Social Forces, LI (1973) 417–26.
C. Stephan, ‘Sex prejudice in jury simulation’, Journal of Psychology, LXXXVIII (1974) 305–12.
V. A. Stone, ‘A primacy effect in decision-making by jurors’, Journal of Communication, XIX (1969) 239–47.
L. A. Streeter, R. M. Krauss, V. Geller, C. Olson and W. Apple, ‘Pitch changes during attempted deception’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXV (1977) 345–50
T. S. Szasz, The Myth of Mental Illness (New York: Harper, 1961).
J. L. Tapp, ‘Psychology and the law: an overture’, Annual Review of Psychology, XXVII (1976) 359–404.
J. L. Tapp and L. Kohlberg, ‘Developing senses of law and legal justice’, in J. L. Tapp and F.J. Levine (Eds.), Law, Justice and the Individual in Society (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1977).
J. Thibaut and L. Walker, Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis (Hillsdale: Laurence Erlbaum Associates, 1975).
J. Thibaut, L. Walker, S. LaTour and P. Houlden, ‘Procedural justice as fairness’, Stanford Law Review, XXVI (1974) 1271–89.
J. Thibaut, L. Walker and E. A. Lind, ‘Adversary presentation and bias in legal decisionmaking’, Harvard Law Review, LXXXVI (1972) 386–401.
A. H. Tickner and E. C. Poulton, ‘Watching for people and actions’, Ergonomics, XVIII (1975) 35–51.
J. V. Torney, ‘Socialization of attitudes towards the legal system’, in J. L. Tapp and F.J. Levine (Eds.), Law, Justice and the Individual in Society (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1977).
A. Trankell, Reliability of Evidence (Stockholm: Beckmans, 1972).
G. B. Trasler, The Explanation of Criminality (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1962).
G. B. Trasler, ‘Criminal behaviour’, in H. J. Eysenck (Ed.), Handbook of Abnormal Psychology, 2nd ed. (London: Pitman, 1972).
G. B. Trasler, ‘The role of psychologists in the penal system’, in L. Blom-Cooper (Ed.), Progress in Penal Reform (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1974).
U. S. President’s Commission on Obscenity and Pornography (Washington: Government Printing Office, 1970).
A. C. Valenti and L. L. Downing, ‘Differential effects of jury size on verdicts following deliberation as a function of the apparent guilt of a defendant’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XXXII (1975) 655–63.
N. Vidmar, ‘Retributive and utilitarian motives and other correlates of Canadian attitudes toward the death penalty’, Canadian Psychologist, XV (1974) 337–56.
L. Walker and J. Thibaut, ‘An experimental examination of pretrial conference techniques’, Minnesota Law Review, LV (1971) 1113–37.
L. Walker, J. Thibaut and V. Andreoli, ‘Order of presentation at trial’, Yale Law Journal, LXXXII (1972) 216–26.
N. Walker and M. Argyle, ‘Does the law affect moral judgments?’, British journal of Criminology, IV (1964) 570–81.
E. Walster, ‘Assignment of responsibility for an accident’, journal of Personality and Social Psychology, III (1966) 73–9.
D. J. West and D. P. Farrington, Who Becomes Delinquent? (London: Heinemann, 1973).
D.J. West and D. P. Farrington, The Delinquent Way of Life (London: Heinemann, 1977).
M. Williams, ‘Aspects of the psychology of imprisonment’, in S. McConville (Ed.), The Use of Imprisonment (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1975).
D. W. Wilson and E. Donnerstein, ‘Legal and ethical aspects of nonreactive social psychological research’, American Psychologist, XXXI (1976) 765–73.
M. Yaffé, ‘Research survey’, in Pornography: The Longford Report (London: Coronet Books, 1972).
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 1979 David P. Farrington and Social Science Research Council
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Farrington, D.P., Hawkins, K. (1979). Psychological Research on Behaviour in Legal Contexts. In: Farrington, D.P., Hawkins, K., Lloyd-Bostock, S.M. (eds) Psychology, Law and Legal Processes. Oxford Socio-Legal Studies. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-04248-7_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-04248-7_1
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-04250-0
Online ISBN: 978-1-349-04248-7
eBook Packages: Palgrave Social & Cultural Studies CollectionSocial Sciences (R0)