Irreligious Movements in Britain and America during the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries

  • Colin Campbell
Part of the New Perspectives in Sociology book series


Secularism was the pre-eminent irreligious movement of the nineteenth century. It not only predated both the positivist and Ethical Culture movements but also surpassed them in extent and exceeded them in its impact on contemporary society. Also unlike these other movements, Secularism was an intimate part of the radical tradition in political and social reform; whereas ethicists and positivists might feel obliged to engage in public service and press for reform because of their convictions, the secularists’ views on religion were more likely to be an extension of the radicalism which they had already adopted in political matters. In this sense Secularism was a nineteenth-century inheritor of the tradition of total radicalism which had burst upon the European scene with the French Revolution.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. 5.
    E. Royle, ‘George Jacob Holyoake and the Secularist Movement in Britain, 1841–1861’, Ph.D. thesis (Christ’s College, Cambridge, 1968).Google Scholar
  2. 8.
    G. H. Taylor, ‘A Chronology of British Secularism’ (National Secular Society, 1957) p. 8.Google Scholar
  3. 28.
    R. Billington, ‘Leicester Secular Society, 1852–1920: A Study in Radicalism and Respectability’, unpublished dissertation (University of Leicester, 1968).Google Scholar
  4. 32.
    J. Eros, ‘Organised Freethought in Mid-Victorian England’, in ‘Sociological Review’, ii 1 (July 1954) 99.Google Scholar
  5. 37.
    Although Woodbridge Riley observed that the free-thinking societies in early nineteenth-century America suffered from being identified in the public mind with Freemasonry and as a result were attacked for their secrecy and presumed foreign allegiances. W. Riley, ‘Early Free-Thinking Societies in America’, in ‘Harvard Theological Review’, xi 3 (July 1918) 247–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. 43.
    N. R. Burr, ‘A Critical Bibliography of Religion in America’, 2 vols (Princeton U.P., 1961) ii 1143.Google Scholar
  7. 51.
    D. G. Charlton, ‘New Creeds for Old in Nineteenth Century France’, in ‘Canadian Journal of Theology’, iii 4 (1962) 260.Google Scholar
  8. 52.
    G. Bryson, ‘Early English Positivists and the Religion of Humanity’, in ‘American Sociological Review’, i 3 (June 1936) 344.Google Scholar
  9. 56.
    D. G. Charlton, ‘Secular Religions in France, 1815–1870’ (Oxford U.P., 1963).Google Scholar
  10. 57.
    J. E. McGee, ‘A Crusade for Humanity: The History of Organised Positivism in England’ (Watts, 1931); Simon, ‘European Positivism in the Nineteenth Century’; Charlton, ‘New Creeds for Old’, p. 264.Google Scholar
  11. In sharp contrast to this success in South America, the story of the Religion of Humanity on the North American continent is dismal indeed. The only American group devoted to the Religion of Humanity seems to have been that founded by an Englishman, Henry Edgar, in the utopian community of Modern Times on Long Island. This could hardly be described as a success for after five years of effort he had made only ten converts, four of whom were his wife and children. See R. L. Hawkins, ‘Positivism in the United States (1853–1861)’ (Harvard U.P., Cambridge, Mass., 1938) chap. 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. 61.
    R. Harrison, ‘Professor Beesly and the Working-Class Movement’, in Asa Briggs and John Saville (eds), ‘Essays in Labour History’, rev. ed. (Macmillan, 1967) pp. 205–41.Google Scholar
  13. 87.
    C. S. Braden, ‘These Also Believe’ (Macmillan, New York, 1949).Google Scholar
  14. 89.
    M. W. Meyerhardt, ‘The Movement for Ethical Culture at Home and Abroad’, in ‘American Journal of Religious Psychology and Education’, iii 1 (May 1905) 78.Google Scholar
  15. 104.
    G. Spiller, ‘The Ethical Movement in Great Britain’ (Farleigh Press, 1934).Google Scholar
  16. 107.
    S. K. Ratcliffe, ‘The Story of South Place’ (Watts, 1955).Google Scholar
  17. 108.
    W. S. Smith, ‘The London Heretics, 1870–1914 ’ (Constable, 1967) p. 134.Google Scholar
  18. 122.
    T. Tribe, ‘One Hundred Years of Freethought’ (Elek Books, 1967) p. 39.Google Scholar
  19. 135.
    J. W. Smith and A. L. Jamison, ‘The Shaping of American Religion’ (Princeton U.P., 1961); Burr, ‘A Critical Bibliography of Religion in America’.Google Scholar
  20. 136.
    S. Parsons, ‘Free Religion’ (Beacon Press, Boston, 1963) p. 153.Google Scholar
  21. 143.
    A. Gowans Whyte, ‘The Story of the R.P.A., 1899–1949’ (Watts, 1949) p. 12.Google Scholar
  22. 145.
    The background to this decision was given in F. J. Gould, ‘The Pioneers of Johnson’s Court: A History of the Rationalist Press Association from 1899 Onwards’ (Watts, 1929).Google Scholar
  23. 160.
    D. Ford, ‘The New Groups’, in ‘News and Notes’ (Aug 1955) pp. 3–4.Google Scholar
  24. 170.
    J. Huxley, ‘The Humanist Revolution’, in ‘The Human Crisis’ (Univ. of Washington Press, Seattle, 1963) p. 5.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Colin Campbell 1971

Authors and Affiliations

  • Colin Campbell

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations