Special Cases: Sick Doctors and Ethnic Presentations of Psychological Illness

  • Ali Haggett
Open Access
Part of the Mental Health in Historical Perspective book series


By the 1980s, two particular concerns had begun to catch the attention of those interested in mental health. The first was the realisation that medical professionals (and GPs in particular) appeared to be particularly vulnerable to mental ill health and addiction to drugs and alcohol. The second was a growing concern about the psychological health of those who had emigrated to Britain in the decades following the Second World War. They are explored here because together they are illustrative of many of the broad themes already explored in this book, and serve to advance the core arguments put forward in earlier chapters. Concerns, for example, surrounded the working practice of doctors and the provision of support should they require it. Alcohol consumption among doctors, too, heavily influenced the approaches taken towards patients who presented with possible alcohol addiction. Among ethnic minorities, discussions explored sickness absence and absenteeism, reflecting many of the debates explored in Chapter 2. Among both groups, in different ways, the ability (or otherwise) to recognise psychological illness and the willingness to report it further elucidate our knowledge of male psychological illness. Although their experiences are very different, their stories bring together much of what has been revealed thus far.


  1. 1.
    M. F. a’Brook, J. D. Hailstone and E. J. McLauchlan, ‘Psychiatric illness in the medical profession’, British Journal of Psychiatry (1967), 113, 1013–23, on 1013.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. 3.
    Robin M. Murray, ‘Psychiatric illness in male doctors and controls: An analysis of Scottish hospitals in-patient data’, British Journal of Psychiatry (1977), 131, 1–10, on 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. 4.
    M. M. Glatt, ‘Alcoholism, an occupational hazard for doctors’, Journal of Alcoholism (1976), 11, 85–91 on 85.Google Scholar
  4. 14.
    R. A. Franklin, ‘One hundred doctors at the retreat: A contribution to the subject of mental disorder in the medical profession’, British Journal of Psychiatry (1977), 131, 11–14, on 12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. 20.
    S. E. D. Short, ‘Psychiatric illness in physicians’, Journal of the Canadian Medical Association (1979), 121, 283–8, on 287.Google Scholar
  6. 24.
    See for example the account from Robin M. Murray, ‘The alcoholic doctor’, British Journal of Hospital Medicine (1977), 18, 144–9, on 147.Google Scholar
  7. 30.
    John C. Duffy and Edward M. Litin, ‘Psychiatric morbidity of physicians’, Journal of the American Medical Association (1964), 189, 989–92, on 990.Google Scholar
  8. 38.
    Ash Samanta and Jo Samanta, ‘Regulation of the medical profession: Fantasy, reality and legality’, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine (2004), 97, 211–18, on 211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. 42.
    B. Marien and F. Mckinna, Editorial, ‘The elephant in the room’, Clinical Oncology (2012), 24, 654–6, on 654.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. 49.
    J. L. Evans, ‘Psychiatric illness in the physician’s wife’, American Journal of Psychiatry (1965), 122, 159–63, cited in a’Brook, ‘Psychiatric illness in the medical profession’, 1018.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. 52.
    S. E. D. Short, Review Article, ‘Psychiatric illness in physicians’, Journal of the Canadian Medical Association (1979), 121, 238–88, on 284.Google Scholar
  12. 71.
    Panikos Panayi, An Immigration History of Britain: Multicultural Racism since 1800 (Harlow, Pearso, 2010), p. 23.Google Scholar
  13. 75.
    C. C. Baker and S. J. Pocock, ‘Ethnic differences in certified sickness absence’, British Journal of Industrial Medicine (1982), 39, 277–82, on 277.Google Scholar
  14. 76.
    Charles Zwingmann and Maria Pfister-Ammende, Uprooting and After (New York, Springer Verlag, 1973), pp. 2–3. Studies prior to this were confined to lunatic asylums in the US during the nineteenth century.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. 79.
    Jatinder Bains, ‘Race, culture and psychiatry: A history of transcultural psychiatry’, History of Psychiatry (2005), 16 (2), 139–54, on 139. Theories about the association between the ‘civilising process’ and insanity have a much longer history dating back to the nineteenth century, leading subsequently to late nineteenth-century ideas about the ‘inferior’ intelligence of primitive people within the context of social Darwinism.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. See Ana Maria G Raimundo Oda et al., ‘Some origins of cross-cultural psychiatry’, History of Psychiatry (2005), 16 (2), 155–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. 82.
    Simon Dein and Kamaldeep Singh Bhui, ‘The crossroads of anthropology and epidemiology: Current research in cultural psychiatry in the UK’, Transcultural Psychiatry (2013), 50 (6), 769–91, on 771.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. 85.
    A. G. Mezey, ‘Psychiatric aspects of human migrations’, International Journal of Social Psychiatry (1960), 5, 245–60, on 245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. 95.
    D. J. Smith, Racial Disadvantage in Britain (Harmondsworth, Penguin, 1977), cited in Littlewood and Lipsedge, Aliens and Alienists, p. 129.Google Scholar
  20. 96.
    Early international studies include: C. P. Collins, ‘Sickness absence in the three principal ethnic divisions of Singapore’, British Journal of Industrial Medicine (1962), 19, 116–22Google Scholar
  21. and WHO, Health Aspects of Labour Migration: Report on a Working Group Convened by the Regional Office for Europe of the WHO, Algiers, 1973 (Copenhagen, WHO 1974).Google Scholar
  22. 122.
    Wayne Katon, Arthur Kleinman and Gary Rosen, ‘Depression and somatisa-tion: A review’, part 1 The American Journal of Medicine (1982), 72, 127–35, on 131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. 125.
    Department of Health, Invisible Patients: Report of the Working Group on the Health of Health Professionals (2010), p. 7.Google Scholar
  24. 136.
    Kwame McKenzie, ‘Improving mental healthcare for ethnic minorities’, Advances in Psychiatric Treatment (2008), 14, 285–91, on 287.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Ali Haggett 2015

Open Access This Chapter is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License, which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ali Haggett
    • 1
  1. 1.University of ExeterUK

Personalised recommendations