Does Distance Matter in Banking?

Abstract

Deregulation and technological change have reduced the transaction costs that led to the dominance of local financial service suppliers, leading some to question whether distance still matters in banking. This debate has been particularly acute in small business banking, where transactions costs are believed to be particularly high. This paper provides a detailed review of the literature on distance in banking markets, highlighting the reasons why geographic proximity is believed to be important and examining the changes that may have affected its importance. Relying on new data from the 2003 Survey of Small Business Finances, we examine how distances between small firms and their financial service suppliers changed over the 1993–2003 decade. Our analysis reveals that distances increased, though the extent varied substantially across financial services and supplier types. Generally, increases were observed in the early half of the decade, while distances declined in the following 5 years. There was also a trend toward less in person interaction between small firms and their suppliers of financial services. Nevertheless, most relationships remained local, with a median distance of 5 miles in 2003. The results suggest that distance, while perhaps not as tyrannical as in the past, remains an important factor in banking.

References

  1. Adams RM, Brevoort KP, Kiser EK (2007) Who competes with whom? The case of depository institutions. Journal of Industrial Economics 55(1):141–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Almazan A (2002) A model of competition in banking: Bank capital vs. expertise. Journal of Financial Intermediation 11:87–121CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Alessandrini P, Croci M, Zazzaro A (2005) The geography of banking power: The role of functional distance. Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review LVIII(235):129–167Google Scholar
  4. Alessandrini P, Presbitero AF, Zazzaro A (2009) Banks, distances and firms’ financing constraints. Review of Finance 13:261--307Google Scholar
  5. Amel DF, Brevoort KP (2005) The perceived size of small business banking markets. Journal of Competition Law and Economics 1(4):771–784CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Amel DF, Starr-McCluer M (2002) Market definition in banking: Recent evidence. The Antitrust Bulletin 47(1):63–89Google Scholar
  7. Amel DF, Kennickell AB, Moore KB (2008) Banking market definition: Evidence from the survey of consumer finances. Finance and Economics Discussion Series No. 2008-35Google Scholar
  8. Berger AN, Udell GF (2002) Small business credit availability and relationship lending: The importance of bank organizational structure. Economic Journal 112:F32–F53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Berger AN, Frame WS, Miller NH (2005) Credit scoring and the availability, price, and risk of small business credit. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 37(2):191–222CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2006) Report to the Congress on practices of the consumer credit industry in soliciting and extending credit and their effects on consumer debt and insolvencyGoogle Scholar
  11. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2007) Report to the Congress on credit scoring and its effects on the availability and affordability of creditGoogle Scholar
  12. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2008) Surveys of Small Business Finances. http://www.federalreserve.gov/pubs/oss/oss3/nssbftoc.htm. Accessed 14 October 2008
  13. Bostic RW, Canner GB (1998) New information on lending to small businesses and small farms: The 1996 CRA data. Federal Reserve Bulletin 84:1–21Google Scholar
  14. Brevoort KP (2006) An empirical examination of the growth of out-of-market commercial lending: The changing competitive landscape and the role of asymmetric information. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, MimeoGoogle Scholar
  15. Brevoort KP, Hannan TH (2006) Commercial lending and distance: Evidence from Community Reinvestment Act Data. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 38(8):1991–2012CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Chiappori P-A, Perez-Castrillo D, Verdier T (1995) Spatial competition in the banking system: Localization, cross subsidies and the regulation of deposit rates. European Economic Review 39(5):889–918CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Cowan CD, Cowan AM (2006) A survey based assessment of financial institution use of credit scoring for small business lending. SBA Office of Advocacy Report, NovemberGoogle Scholar
  18. Degryse H, Ongena S (2004) The impact of technology and regulation on the geographical scope of banking. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 20(4):571–590CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Degryse H, Ongena S (2005) Distance, lending relationships, and competition. Journal of Finance 60(1):231–266CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Degryse H, Laeven L, Ongena S (2006) The impact of organizational structure and lending technology on banking competition. Tilburg University Center for Economic Research Discussion Paper 67Google Scholar
  21. Dell’Ariccia G (2001) Asymmetric information and the structure of the banking industry. European Economic Review 45(10):1957–1980CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Dell’Ariccia G, Marquez R (2004) Information and bank credit allocation. Journal of Financial Economics 72(1):185–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dell’Ariccia G, Friedman E, Marquez R (1999) Adverse selection as a barrier to entry in the banking industry. The RAND Journal of Economics 30(3):515–534CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. DeYoung R, Glennon D, Nigro PJ (2006) Borrower-lender distance, credit scoring, and the performance of small business loans. FDIC Center for Financial Research Working Paper No. 2006-04Google Scholar
  25. DeYoung R, Frame WS, Glennon D, McMillen DP, Nigro PJ (2007a) Commercial lending distance and historically underserved areas. Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper No. 2007-11aGoogle Scholar
  26. DeYoung R, Frame WS, Glennon D, Nigro PJ (2007b) What’s driving small borrower-lender distance? Working paperGoogle Scholar
  27. Dick AA (2008) Demand estimation and consumer welfare in the banking industry. Journal of Banking and Finance 32(8):1661--1676Google Scholar
  28. Elliehausen GE, Wolken JD (1990) Banking markets and the use of financial services by small and medium-sized businesses. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System Staff Study No. 160Google Scholar
  29. Frame WS, Padhi M, Woosley L (2004) Credit scoring and the availability of small business credit in low- and moderate-income areas. Financial Review 39(1):35–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Frame WS, Srinivasan A, Woosley L (2001) The effect of credit scoring on small-business lending. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 33(3):813–825CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Grzelonska P (2006) Benefits from branch networks: Theory and evidence from the summary of deposits data. Working paperGoogle Scholar
  32. Hannan TH (2003) Changes in non-local lending to small business. Journal of Financial Services Research 24:31–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hannan TH, Hanweck GA (2007) Bank branching and market characteristics. Working PaperGoogle Scholar
  34. Hauswald R, Marquez R (2006) Competition and strategic information acquisition in credit market. The Review of Financial Studies 19(3): 967–1000CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Hester DD, Calcagnini G, de Bonis R (2001) Competition through innovation: ATMs in Italian banks. Rivista Italiana Degli Economisti, 3(2):359–382, DecemberGoogle Scholar
  36. Ishii J (2008) Compatibility, competition, and investment in network industries: ATM networks in the banking industry. Working paperGoogle Scholar
  37. Kallberg JG, Udell GF (2003) The value of private sector business credit information sharing: The US case. Journal of Banking and Finance 27(3):449–469CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Khan B (2004) Consumer adoption of online banking: Does distance matter? University of California at Berkeley Department of Economics Working Paper No. E04-338, MayGoogle Scholar
  39. Kwast ML, Starr-McCluer M, Wolken JD (1997) Market definition and the analysis of antitrust in banking. The Antitrust Bulletin 42(4):973–995Google Scholar
  40. Mach TL, Wolken JD (2006) Financial services used by small businesses: Evidence from the 2003 survey of small business finances. Federal Reserve Bulletin 23:A167–A195Google Scholar
  41. Mester LJ (1997) What’s the point of credit scoring? Federal Reserve Bank of Philedelphia Business Review, September/October:3–16Google Scholar
  42. Park K, Pennacchi G (2003) Harming depositors and helping borrowers: The disparate impact of bank consolidation. Working PaperGoogle Scholar
  43. Petersen MA, Rajan RG (2002) Does distance still matter? The information revolution in small business lending. Journal of Finance 57:2533–2570CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Shaffer S (1998) The winner’s curse in banking. Journal of Financial Intermediation, October: 7(4)359–392Google Scholar
  45. United States Government Accountability Office (2007) Additional measures needed to assess 7(a) loan program’s performance. GAO Report GAO-07-769Google Scholar
  46. Villas-Boas JM, Schmidt-Mohr U (1999) Oligopoly with asymmetric information: Differentiation in credit markets. The RAND Journal of Economics 30(3):375–296CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Wolken JD, Rohde D (2002) Changes in the location of small businesses’ financial services suppliers between 1993 and 1998. Federal Reserve Board MemoGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Division of Research and StatisticsWashingtonUSA

Personalised recommendations