Advertisement

Approximate reasoning in the modeling of consensus in group decisions

  • Luisa Mich
  • Mario Fedrizzi
  • Loris Gaio
Conference paper
Part of the Lecture Notes in Computer Science book series (LNCS, volume 695)

Abstract

In this paper we propose an approach to consensus reaching based on linguistically expressed individual opinions and on so-called opinion changing aversion. We operate within this basic context: there is a group of experts which must choose a preferred alternative from a finite set of admissible ones according to several criteria. Each expert is called upon evaluate linguistically the alternatives in terms of their performance with respect to each criterion. The task of the experts is to reach some agreement during a consensus reaching process directed by a third person called the moderator. The experts are expected subsequently to change their testimonies until sufficient agreement (consensus) has been reached. The measure of consensus depends on a function estimated for each expert according to his/her aversion to opinion change.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. [BOAT91]
    Boatto, V., Fedrizzi, M., Furlani, P., Povellato, A.: Fuzzy logic in group decisions: an application to problems of environmental policies. Land and Resources Use Policy (1991) 62–82Google Scholar
  2. [BONI82]
    Bonissone, P.P.: A fuzzy sets linguistic approach: theory and applications. In: Gupta, M.M., Sanchez, E. (Eds.) Approximate Reasoning in Decision Analysis. North-Holland (1982) 329–339Google Scholar
  3. [BORT85]
    Bortolan, G., Degani, R.: A review of some methods for ranking fuzzy subsets. Fuzzy Sets and Systems. North-Holland 1 (1985) 1–19Google Scholar
  4. [BUI 87]
    Bui, T.X.: A Group Decision Support System for Cooperative Multicriteria Group Decision Making. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Springer-Verlag 290 (1987)Google Scholar
  5. [CARL92]
    Carlsson, C., Ehrenberg, D., Eklund, P., Fedrizzi, M., et al.: Consensus in distributed soft environments. European Journal of Operational Research 61 (1992) 165–185Google Scholar
  6. [DESA87]
    Desanctis, G., Gallupe, B.: A foundation for the study of group decision support systems. Management Science 33 (1987) 589–609Google Scholar
  7. [DREZ87]
    Dreze, J.M.: Essays in Economic Decisions under Uncertainty. Cambridge University Press (1987)Google Scholar
  8. [DUBO82]
    Dubois, D., Prade, H. The use of fuzzy numbers in decision analysis. In: Gupta, M.M., Sanchez, E. (Eds.) Fuzzy Information and Decision Processes. North-Holland (1982) 309–321Google Scholar
  9. [DUBO87]
    Dubois, D., Prade, H.: Fuzzy numbers: an overview. In: Bezdek, J.C. (Ed.) Analysis of Fuzzy Information. CRC Press (1987) 3–39Google Scholar
  10. [EOM 90]
    Eom, H.B., Lee, S.M., Suh, E.-H.: Group decision support systems: an essential tool for resolving organizational conflicts. International Journal of Information Management 10 (1990) 215–227Google Scholar
  11. [FEDR88]
    Fedrizzi, M., Kacprzyk, J., Zadrozny, S.: An interactive multiuser decision support system for consensus reaching processes using fuzzy logic with linguistic quantifiers. Decision Support Systems 4 (1988) 313–327Google Scholar
  12. [FEDR91]
    Fedrizzi, M., Mich, L.: Decision using production rules. In: Proc. of Annual Conference of the Operational Research Society of Italy (AIRO'91). September 18–10. Riva del Garda. Italy (1991) 118–121Google Scholar
  13. [FEDR92]
    Fedrizzi, M., Fuller, R.: Stability under fuzzy production rules. In: Proc. of 11th European Meeting on Cybernetics and Systems Research (EMCSR'92). April 21–24. Vienna. Austria (1992)Google Scholar
  14. [FILE91]
    Filev, D.P., Yager, R.R.: A generalized defuzzification method via bad distributions. International Journal of Intelligent Systems 6 (1991) 687–697Google Scholar
  15. [GARI88]
    Garigliano, R., Long, D., Bokma, A.: A model for learning by source control. In: Bouchon, Saitta and Yager (Eds.) Uncertainty and Intelligent Systems. LNCS 313. Springer-Verlag (1988)Google Scholar
  16. [GARI92]
    Garigliano, R., Bokma, A.: Heuristics for knowledge extraction in Source Control. International Conference on Information Processing and Management of Uncertainty (IPMU'92). July 6–10. Mallorca. Spain (1992) To be published in a LNCS volumeGoogle Scholar
  17. [GRAY87]
    Gray, P.: Group decision support systems. Decision Support Systems 3 (1987) 233–242Google Scholar
  18. [HELL93]
    Hellendoorn, H.: Design and development of fuzzy systems at Siemens R&D. Second IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems. March 28–April 1. San Francisco. USA (1993) 1365–1370Google Scholar
  19. [HUBE84]
    Huber, G.P.: Issues in the design of group decision support systems. MIS Quarterly 8 (1984) 195–204Google Scholar
  20. [JACO92]
    Jacob, V.S., Pirkul, H.: A framework for supporting distributed group decision-making. Decision Support Systems 8 (1992) 17–28Google Scholar
  21. [KACP88]
    Kacprzyk, J., Fedrizzi, M.: A 'soft’ measure of consensus in the setting of partial (fuzzy) preferences. European Journal of Operational Research 34 (1988) 316–325Google Scholar
  22. [KARN87]
    Karni, E.: Generalized expected utility analysis of risk aversion with state-dependent performances. International Economic Review 28 (1987) 229–240Google Scholar
  23. [KELS92]
    Kelsey, D.: Risk and risk aversion for state-dependent utility. Theory and Decision 33 (1992) 71–82Google Scholar
  24. [KOWI80]
    Kowitz, A.C., Knutson, T.J.: Decision Making in Small Groups. Allyn and Bacon. Boston (1980)Google Scholar
  25. [KRAE88]
    Krämer, K.L., King, J.L.: Computer based systems for cooperative work and group decision making. ACM Computing Surveys 20 (1988) 115–146Google Scholar
  26. [LEE 83]
    Lee, N.: Environmental impact assessment: a review. Applied Geography 3 (1983)Google Scholar
  27. [LEFO77]
    Lefons, E., Pazienza, M.T., Silvestri, A., Tangorra, F., Corfiati, L., De Giacomo, P.: An algebraic model for systems of psychically interacting subjects. In: Dubuisson, B. (Ed.) Information and Systems. Oxfor. Pergamon Press (1977) 155–163Google Scholar
  28. [LEVI74]
    Levi, I.: On indeterminate probabilities. Journal of philosophy 71 (1974) 391–418Google Scholar
  29. [LOEW85]
    Löwer, B. (Guest ed.): Special Issue on Consensus. Synthese 62 (1985)Google Scholar
  30. [MART86]
    Martel, J.M., D'Avignon, G.R., Coillard, J.: A fuzzy outranking relation in multicriteria decision making. European Journal of Operational Research 25 (1986) 258–271Google Scholar
  31. [NUNA91]
    Nunamaker, J.F., Dennis, A.R., Valachic, J.S., Vogel, D.R., George, J.F.: Electronic meeting systems to support group work. Communications of the ACM 34 (1991) 40–61Google Scholar
  32. [ROY 77]
    Roy, B.: Partial preference analysis and decision aid: the fuzzy outraning relation concept. In: Bell, D., Keeney, R., Raiffa, H. (Eds.) Conflicting objectives in decision. AC-Press (1977)Google Scholar
  33. [RUNK93]
    Runkler, T.A., Glesner, M.: A set of axioms for defuzzification strategies — towards a theory of rational defuzzification operators. Second IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems. March 28–April 1. San Francisco. USA (1993) 1161–1166Google Scholar
  34. [SAAD92]
    Saade, J.J., Schwarzlauder, H.: Ordering fuzzy sets over the real line: an approach Bbased on decision making under uncertainty. Fuzzy Sets and Systems 50 (1992) 237–246Google Scholar
  35. [SHAK91]
    Shakun, M.: Airline buyout: evolutionary system design and problem restructurinh in group decision and negotiation. Management Science 37 (1991) 1291–1303Google Scholar
  36. [SILV87]
    Silvestri, A., Mich, L., Pereira Gouveia, O., Ferreira Pinto, C.: Simulation of the development of individual interactional patterns. Cybernetics and Systems: An International Journal 18 (1987) 489–515Google Scholar
  37. [TAKA92]
    Takahara, Y., Iijima, J., Shiba, N.: A hyerarchy of decision making concepts: conceptual foundation of decision support systems. International Journal of General Systems 20 (1992) 359–378Google Scholar
  38. [TONG80]
    Tong, R.M., Bonissone, P.P.: A linguistic approach to decision making with fuzzy sets. IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics 10 (1980) 716–723Google Scholar
  39. [ZADE73]
    Zadeh, L.: Outline of a new approach to the analysis of complex systems and decision processes. IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics 3 (1973) 28–44Google Scholar
  40. [ZADE75]
    Zadeh, L.: The concept of a linguistic variable and its application to approximate reasoning. Information Sciences (Part I) 8 (1975) 199–249 (Part II) 8 301–357 (Part III) 9 (1976) 43–80Google Scholar
  41. [ZIMM91]
    Zimmermann, H.J.: Fuzzy Set Theory and its Applications, 2nd Ed., Kluwer, Dordrecht-Boston, 1991Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1993

Authors and Affiliations

  • Luisa Mich
    • 1
  • Mario Fedrizzi
    • 1
  • Loris Gaio
    • 1
  1. 1.Dipartimento di Informatica e Studi AziendaliUniversità di TrentoTrentoItalia

Personalised recommendations