Abstract
Although the relationship between trade and culture has been described as one of those new issues that pose “serious practical and theoretical challenges ... to present understanding of the trade regime,”1 trade conflicts concerning cultural goods and services are not in fact a new phenomenon. Such conflicts go back to the 1920’s when European countries, following the First World War, began resorting to screen quotas in order to protect their film industry from a sudden influx of American films that was perceived as a threat to their cultural expression.2 The American motion picture industry responded by developing closer relations with the U.S. government. After the Second World War, through governmental arrangements such as the Blum-Byrnes agreement of 1946 which granted generous import quotas to American films as part of the settlement of the French war debt, or arrangements negotiated directly between the Motion Picture Export Association of America and various governments, it succeeded in reversing the tide.3 In 1947, a compromise solution appeared to have been reached with the inclusion of Article IV in the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) which recognized the specificity of cultural products, at least in the case of films, without removing them from the disciplines of the agreement.4 However, in the early 1960s, the dispute resumed when the United States asked the GATT to investigate the restrictions imposed on its television programs by a number of countries, including Canada. A special group was constituted to look at the matter but was unable to reach an agreement.5
since 1969; Dean of the Faculty of Law from 1981 to 1985; Director of the Quebec Centre of International Relations 1986 to 1993.
Jeffrey L. Dunoff, The Death of the Trade Regime, 10 European Journal of International Law 733 (1998)
Film quotas were adopted by Austria, Czechoslovakia, Denmark, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy and the United Kingdom.
On this development between the two wars, see Film Europe and Film America: Cinema, Commerce and Cultural Exchange 1920–1939, 346–385 (eds: Andrew Higson and Richard Maltby, 1999); see also T. Guback, Non Market Factors in the International Distribution of American Films, in 1 Current Research in Films: Audiences, Economics and Law 111, 114–115 (1985); Laurent Burin des Roziers, Du cinema au multimedia. Une brève histoire de l’exception culturelle, Institut français des relations internationales, Notes de l’IFRI No 5, (1998).
Article IV of GATT, as explained below, specifically authorizes screen quotas but also makes them subject to negotiations.
GATT Doc. L/1741 (1962).
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Bibliography
Acheson, Keith, Maule, Christopher J., Canada’s Cultural Exemption—Insulator or Lightning Road ? 20 World Competition (1996)
Atkinson, Dave, Mondialisation culturelle et accords commerciaux internationaux: un enjeux démocratique, in Bellavance, Guy, ed., Démocratisation de la culture ou démocratie culturelle?, Institut québécois de recherche sur la culture, Québec, 113 (1999)
Baker, Edwin, C., An Economic Critique of Free Trade in Media Products, 78 North Carolina Law Review 1358 (2000)
Bernier, Ivan, Lamoureux, Jean-François, Les politiques du Canada et du Québec, l’Organisation mondiale du commerce (OMC) et l’Accord de libre-échange nord-américain (ALENA), in Sauvageau, Florian, ed., Les politiques culturelles à l’épreuve. La culture entre l’État et le marché, Institut québécois de recherche sur la culture, Presse de l’Université Laval, 1996, p. 13
Bishop, Thomas, France and the Need for Cultural Exception, 29 Journal of International Law and Politics 187 (1997
Browne, Dennis, ed., The Culture/Trade Quandary: Canada’s Policy Options (1998).
Carmody, Chi, When ‘Cultural Identity Was not at Issue’: Thinking About Canada—Certain Measures Concerning Periodicals, 30 Law and Policy in International Business 231, 255 (1999).
Carlson, Andrew M., The Country Music Television Dispute: An Illustration of the Tensions Between Canadian Cultural Protectionism and American Entertainment Exports, 30 Law and Policy in International Business 585 (1997).
Cone, Sidney, The Appellate Body and Harrowsmith Country Life, 32(2) Journal of World Trade 103 (1998)
Eberschlag, Robert, Culture Clash: Canadian periodical Policies and the World trade Organization, 26 Manitoba Law Journal 65 (1998)
Ezetah, Chinedu R., Canadian Periodicals: Certain Measures Concerning Periodicals II. Review of the Case, 9 European Journal of International Law (1998)
Filipek, Jon, Culture Quotas: The Trade Controversy over the European Community’s Broadcasting Directive, 28 Stanford Journal of International Law 323, 340–342 (1992).
Gottselig Glen A., Canada and Culture: Can Current Cultural Policies be Sustained in the Current Trade Regime?, 5 International Journal of Communications Law and Policy 1 (2000)
Graber, Chistoph Beat, Handel und Kultur im Audiovisionsrecht der WTO. Völkerrechtliche, ökonomische und kulturpolitische Grundlagen einer globalen Medienordnung, Stämpfli Verlag, Bern, 2003.
Grant, Peter and Wood, Chris, Blockbusters and Trade Wars, Popular Culture in a Globalized World, Douglas & McIntyre, Vancouver, 2004.
Kakabadse, Mario A., The WTO and the Commodification of Cultural Products: Implications for Asia, 22(2) Media Asia 71–77 (1995)
Hahn, Michael J., Eine kulturelle Bereichausnahme im Recht der WTO?, 56 Zeitschrift für ausländisches und öffentliches Recht und Volkerrecht 315 (1996)
Higson, Andrew and Maltby, Richard, eds. “Film Europe” and “Film America”: “Cinema, Commerce and Cultural Exchange 1920–1939” (1999)
Hyun-Kyung, Carolyn Kim, Building the Korean Film Industry’s Competitiveness: Abolish the Screen Quota and Subsidize the Film Industry, 9 Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal 71 (2000).
Hubin, Cécile, Politique culturelle et GATT. À propos des mesures canadiennes en faveur de l’industrie des périodiques, 2 Revue de droit des affaires internationales 245 (1998)
Kaplan, Laurence G.C., The European Community’s TelevisionWithout Frontiers Directive: Stimulating Europe to Regulate Culture, 8 Emory International Law Review 225, 311–318 (1994).
Knight, Trevor, The Dual Nature of Cultural Products: An Analysis of the World Trade Organization’s Decisions Regarding Canadian Periodicals, 57 University Of Toronto Faculty of Law Review 165, 179–80 (1999).
Landsman, Michael L., Restricting Foreign Television Programming in Europe: The European Community’s Television Quota Reappraised, 8 Media Law and Policy 29 (1999).
Lehman, Amy E., The Canadian Cultural Exception Clause and the Fight to Maintain an Identity, 23 Syracuse Journal of International Law and Commerce (1997)
MacMillan, Joanne, Trade and Culture: Conflicting Domestic Policies and International Trade Obligations, 9 Windsor Review of Legal and Social Issues 5 (1999)
Matheny III, Richard L., In the Wake of the Flood: ‘Like Products’ and Cultural Products after the World Trade Organization’s Decision in Canada—Certain Measures Concerning Periodicals, 147 University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 245, 264 (1998).
Ming Shao, W. “Is There No Business Like Show Business? Free Trade and Cultural Protectionism”, 20 Yale Journal of International Law, 105, 121–122 (1995)
Murray, Thomas M., The U.S. French Dispute Over GATT Treatment of Audiovisual Products and the Limits of Public Choice Theory: How an Efficient Market Solution was “Rent-Seeking”, 21 Maryland Journal of International Law and Trade 203 (1997).
O’Keefe, R., The Right “to Take Part in the Cultural Life” under Article 15 of the ICESCR, 47 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 904 (1998)
Paul, J.R., Cultural Resistance to Global Governance, 22 Michigan Journal of International Law 82 (2000–2001)
Polka, S.E., Canada’s Cultural Industries, the United States and Trade Law: tensions, conflicts and possibilities, 10 Windsor Review of Legal and Social Issues 105 (2000)
Prowda, Judith Beth, U.S. Dominance in the “Market Place of Culture” and the French “Cultural Exception”, 29 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 193 (1997)
Puentes, A.T., The Politics of Music and Film: the Validity of a Local Government Embargo on Cuba, 31 Miami Inter-American Law Review 253 (2000)
Ragosta, John, The Information Revolution—Culture and Sovereignty—A U.S. Perspective, 24 Canada-U.S. Law Journal 155 (1998)
Raboy, Marc, Bernier, Ivan, Sauvageau, Florian and Atkinson, Dave, Cultural Development and the Open Economy: A Democratic Issue and a Challenge to Public policy, 19 Canadian Journal of Communication 291 (1994)
Rothkopf, David, In Praise of Cultural Imperialism, 107 Foreign Policy 38 (Summer 1997)
Sauvé, Pierre and Steinfatt, Karsten, Towards multilateral rules on trade and culture: protective regulation or efficient protection?, in Productivity Commission and Australian National University, Conference on Achieving Better Regulation of Services, Canberra, 2000: http://www.pc.gov.au/research/confproc/abros/paper13.pdf
Schwanen, Daniel, A Room of Our Own: Cultural Policies and Trade Agreements, 7(4) Choices IRPP, Institute for Research on Public Policy, Montreal, 2001
Scow, Aaron, The Sports Illustrated Canadian Controversy: Canada’ strikes Out’ in Its Bid to Protect Its Periodical Industry from U.S. Split-Run Periodicals, 7 Minnesota Journal of Global Trade 245, 277 (1998)
Sinclair, John, Culture and Trade: Some Theoretical and Practical Considerations, in McAnany, Emile G. and Wilkinson, Kenton T., Mass Media and Free Trade—NAFTA and the Cultural Industries, University of Texas Press, 30 (1996)
Van Harpen, Robin L., Mamas, Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Cowboys: Reconciling Trade and Cultural Independence, 4 Minnesota Journal of Global Trade 167 (1995).
Venturelli, Shalini, FROM THE INFORMATION ECONOMY TO THE CREATIVE ECONOMY; Moving Culture to the Centre of International Public Policy, Washington DC, Centre for Arts and Culture, 2001, 40 p.
Warnier, Jean-Paul, La mondialisation de la culture, Éditions La Découverte, Paris, 1999.
WTO (World Trade Organization) ‘Audiovisual services, Background note by the Secretariat’, Sectoral Paper S/C/W/40, Council for Trade in Services, WTO, Geneva, 1998.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2005 Springer Science+Business Media, Inc.
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Bernier, I. (2005). Trade and Culture. In: Macrory, P.F.J., Appleton, A.E., Plummer, M.G. (eds) The World Trade Organization: Legal, Economic and Political Analysis. Springer, Boston, MA. https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-22688-5_64
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-22688-5_64
Publisher Name: Springer, Boston, MA
Print ISBN: 978-0-387-22685-9
Online ISBN: 978-0-387-22688-0
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawLaw and Criminology (R0)