Ethics and Taxation pp 323-358 | Cite as
Countermeasures to Tax Fraud, Evasion and Avoidance: A Critical Review
- 292 Downloads
Abstract
After an overview of size and methods of tax evasion and avoidance, I provide an ethical evaluation of a number of controversial enforcement methods used to coerce compliance with tax laws: creating third-party liability for lost VAT; the abuse of law doctrine as developed by the Court of Justice of the European Union; blacklisting of tax havens; public shaming of tax avoiders; and imposing mandatory, third-party, cross-border reporting. The results of the evaluation are mixed but, generally, not positive. Third-party liability is reasonably applied in the EU when it comes to persons acting in good faith but the standards applied to those acting with some degree of mala fides are less satisfactory. Blacklisting is an ethically unacceptable effort to pressure low-tax countries, while violating their sovereignty, towards revising their policies and adhering to a higher rate of taxation and tax policy standards developed without their input or consent. Public shaming is an inefficient and misleading effort to coerce multinational companies to terminate tax planning strategies. FATCA has triggered a development into global information exchange which raises questions as to the protection of civil liberties. Although, the subject measures are not judged positively, this does not diminish the indispensable role of tax law enforcement as a constituent component of the equilibrium model. Policymakers are advised to ensure that tax law enforcement measures meet the equilibrium test, i.e., the required proportionality, because that would not only enhance voluntary compliance but encourage taxpayers to include ethical considerations when deciding on tax planning; and it may lead to a synergetic relationship between taxpayers and tax agencies.
Keywords
Tax fraud Avoidance Evasion Rule of law FATCA Global information exchange Public shaming Abuse of law Civil liberties BlacklistingReferences
- ActionAid. 2011. Addicted to tax havens. The secret life of the FTSE 100. Available at: http://www.actionaid.org/pub-lications/addicted-tax-havens-secret-life-ftse-100.
- Bach, Stefan and Nadja Dwenger. 2007. Unternehmensbesteuerung: Trotz hoher Steuersätze mäßiges Aufkommen. Wochenbericht des DIW Berlin 74(5): 57–65.Google Scholar
- Baskaran, Thushyanthan and Mariana Lopes da Fonseca. 2014. The Economics and Empirics of Tax Competition: A Survey and Lessons for the EU. 1 ELR: 3–12.Google Scholar
- Beer, Sebastian, Ruud de Mooij, and Li Liu. 2018. International Corporate Tax Avoidance: A Review of the Channels, Effect Sizes, and Blind Spots. IMF Working Paper 18/168. Washington, DC: IMF.Google Scholar
- Blank, Joshua D. 2009. What’s Wrong with Shaming Corporate Tax Abuse? Tax Law Review 62: 541–592.Google Scholar
- Blank, Joshua D., and Ruth Mason. 2014. Exporting FATCA. Tax Notes 142: 1245.Google Scholar
- Borselli, Fabrizio. 2011. Organised Vat Fraud: Features, Magnitude, Policy Perspectives. Policy Perspectives. Bank of Italy Occasional Paper No. 106. Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=1966015.
- Brederode, Robert F. van. 2008. Third Party Risks and Liabilities in Case of VAT Fraud in the EU. International Tax Journal 34 (1): 43–50.Google Scholar
- Brederode, Robert F. van. 2014. A Normative Evaluation of Tax Law Enforcement: Legislative and Political Responses to Tax Avoidance and Evasion. Intertax 42(12): 764–783.Google Scholar
- Brederode, Robert F. van, and Gerard Meussen. 2017. The European Union. In Legal Interpretation of Tax Law, 2nd ed, ed. Robert F. van Brederode and Richard Krever. The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International.Google Scholar
- Brooks, Neil. 1997. The Responsibility of Judges in Interpreting Tax Legislation. In Tax Avoidance and the Rule of Law, ed. Graeme S. Cooper, 93. Amsterdam: IBFD.Google Scholar
- Byrnes, William and Robert Munro. 2016. Background and Current Status of FATCA. In Guide to FATCA Compliance, 4th ed. Dayton, OH: LexisNexis.Google Scholar
- Christians, Allison. 2013. The Dubious Legal Pedigree of IGAs (and Why it Matters). Tax Notes International 69 (6): 565–568.Google Scholar
- Christopher, Anthony. 1979. The Law is the Law is the Law…. In Tax Avoision: The Economic, Legal and Moral Inter-Relationships Between Avoidance and Evasion, ed. Alfred R. Ilersic and Arthur Seldon, 75. London: IEA.Google Scholar
- Clausing, Kimberley. 2009. Multinational Firm Tax Avoidance and Tax Policy. National Tax Journal 62: 703–725.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Cockfield, Arthur J. 2014. FATCA and the Erosion of Canadian Taxpayer Privacy, A Report Prepared for the Privacy Commission of Canada, April 2014; available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=2433198.
- De Simone, Lisa, Rebecca Lester, and Kevin Markle. 2018. Transparency and Tax Evasion: Evidence from the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA). Stanford University Graduate School of Business Research Paper No. 17-62 (last revised version June 2018). Available online: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id = 3037426. Accessed on 2 Nov 2018.
- Dharmapala, Dhammika. 2014. What Do We Know About Base Erosion and Profit Shifting? A Review of the Empirical Literature, Illinois Public Law Research Paper No. 14, 15 June 2014, 8–12.Google Scholar
- Easson, Alex J. 2014. Harmful Tax Competition: An Evaluation of the OECD Initiative. Tax Notes International 34: 1037.Google Scholar
- Fehr, Ernst, and Simon Gächter. 2000. Fairness and Retaliation: The Economics of Reciprocity. Journal of Economic Perspectives 14 (3): 159–181.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Füst, Clemens and Nadine Riedel. 2010. Tax Evasion and Tax Avoidance in Developing Countries: The Role of International Profit Shifting. Working Paper 10/12, Oxford: Oxford University Centre for Business Taxation.Google Scholar
- Global Financial Integrity. 2012. Illicit Financial Flows from Developing Countries: 2001–2010. Washington, DC: GFI.Google Scholar
- Government Accountability Office (GAO). 2018. Workplace Retirement Accounts. GAO-18–19 (Jan 2018).Google Scholar
- Graville, Jane G. 2015. Tax Havens: International Tax Avoidance and Evasion. Washington, DC: CRS.Google Scholar
- Gribnau, Hans, and Ave Jallai. 2017. Good Tax Governance: A Matter of Moral Responsibility and Transparency. Nordic Tax Journal 5: 70–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Grubert, Harry, and Rosanne Altshuler. 2008. Corporate Taxes in the World Economy. In Fundamental Tax Reform: Issues, Choices, and Implications, ed. John W. Diamond and George R. Zodrow. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Hall, Macer. 2013. Margaret Hodge the MP who risks undermining the UK’s economic recovery. Dailey Express, 18 Oct 2013.Google Scholar
- Harvey, J. Richard. 2012. FATCA – a Report From the Front Lines, Tax Analysts, 9 Aug. 2012 (available at http://www.taxanalysts.com/www/features.nsf/Articles/7FE9806866554F5985257A5500712E6D?OpenDocument).
- Hatfield, Michael W. 2017. Privacy in Taxation. Florida State University Law Review 44 (2): 579–633.Google Scholar
- Heckemeyer, Jost H., and Christoph Spengel. 2008. Ausmaß der Gewinnverlagerung multinationaler Unternehmen—Empirische Evidenz und Implikationen für die deutsche Steuerpolitik. Perspektiven der Wirtschaftspolitik 9: 37–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Heeder, Oliver. 1998. Fraus Legis: Eine rechtsvergleichende Untersuching über den Vorbehalt der Gesetzesumgebung in Deutschland, Österreich, der Schweiz, Frankreich und Belgien unter besondere Berücksichtigung des Internationalen Privatrechts. Germany: Peter Lang Publishing.Google Scholar
- HM Revenue and Customs. 2005. Measuring Indirect Tax Losses.Google Scholar
- House of Commons, Committee of Public Accounts. 2012. Tax Avoidance by multinational companies, 3 Dec 2012. http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201213/cmselect/cmpubacc/716/71605.htm.
- House of Commons, Committee of Public Accounts. 2013. Tax Avoidance-Google, Ninth Report of Session 2013–14 (London: The Stationary Office Limited, 13 June 2013).Google Scholar
- James, Vaughn E. 2002. Twenty First Century Pirates of the Caribbean: How the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development Robbed Fourteen CARICOM Countries of Their Tax and Economic Policy Sovereignty. University of Miami Inter-American Law Review 34: 1.Google Scholar
- Jansky, Petr and Alex Prats. 2013. Multinational Corporations and the Profit-Shifting Lure of Tax Havens. Christian Aid Occasional Paper Number 9, Mar 2013.Google Scholar
- Kahan, Dan M. 2003. The Logic of Reciprocity: Trust, Collective Action and Law. Mich. L. Rev. 102: 71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kirchler, Erich, Erik Hoelzl, and Ingrid Wahl. 2008. Enforced Versus Voluntary Tax Compliance: The “Slippery Slope” Framework. Journal of Economic Psychology 29: 210–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Klinter, Scott, Chuck Collins, and Holly Sklar. 2010. Unfair Advantage: The Business Case Against Overseas Tax Havens. Available at: http://www.financialtaskforce.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/Unfair-Advantage-The-Business-Case-Against-Overseas-Tax-Havens.pdf.
- Kogels, Han. 2016. The Destination Principle Lost and Double Taxation Justified in the Battle against VAT Fraud. International VAT Monitor 27 (4): 156–157.Google Scholar
- Krasner, Stephen. 1993. Sovereignty, Regimes, and Human Rights. In Regime Theory and International Relations, ed. Volker Rittberger, 139. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Kudrle, Robert T. 2005. U.S. Defection from the OECD “Harmful Tax Competition” Project: Rhetoric and Reality, Working Paper 2005–14, Ridgway Center for International Security Studies, University of Pittsburgh.Google Scholar
- Magalhães, T. Diniz. 2018. What Is Really Wrong with Global Tax Governance and How to Properly Fix It. World Tax Journal 10(4).Google Scholar
- Margolis, Adrienne. 2012. ‘Fair Shares’, Lawyers for Better Business (L4BB), 2012, citing tax barrister David Quentin. http://www.l4bb.org/pages/Features.php?selected_feature=17.
- McBarnet, Doreen. 1998. Law, Policy, and Legal Avoidance: Can Law Effectively Implement Egalitarian Policies? J.L. Soc’y 15: 113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Morriss, Andrew P., and Lotta Moberg. 2012. Cartelizing Taxes: Understanding the OECD’s Campaign against “Harmful Tax Competition”. Columbia Journal of Tax Law 4: 3–64.Google Scholar
- Niessen, R.E.C.M. 1985. Richtige Heffing en Fraus Legis. Arnhem: Gouda Quint.Google Scholar
- OECD. 1998. Harmful Tax Competition: An Emerging Global Issue. Paris: OECD Publishing.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- OECD. 2014. Standard for Automatic Exchange of Financial Account Information in Tax Matters. Paris: OECD Publishing. http://www.keepeek.com/Digital-Asset-Management/oecd/taxation/standard-for-automatic-exchange-of-financial-account-information-for-tax-matters_9789264216525-en.
- O’Shea, Tom. 2012–2013. CFC Reforms in the UK—Some EU Law Comments. ECTJ 13(1): 65–89.Google Scholar
- Parillo, Kristien A. 2013. Could A FATCA Agreement Be Vulnerable To A Canadian Constitutional Challenge. Tax Notes International 72: 1031–1936.Google Scholar
- Poniatowski, Grzegorz, et al. 2017. Study and Reports on the VAT Gap in the EU-28 Member States. 2017 Final Report, No. 492. Warsaw: Center for Social and Economic Research.Google Scholar
- Prebble, Zoe M., and John Prebble. 2010. The Morality of Tax Avoidance. Creighton Law Review 43 (3): 693–745.Google Scholar
- Putniņš, Talis J. and Arnis Sauka. 2011. Size and determinants of shadow economies in the Baltic States. Baltic Journal of Economics 11(2): 5–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Putniņš, Talis J. and Arnis Sauka. 2014a. Measuring the shadow economy using company managers. Journal of Comparative Economics [online] http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jce.2014.04.001. Accessed 20 Nov 2018.
- Putniņš, Talis J. and Arnis Sauka. 2014b. SSE Riga Shadow Index for the Baltic Countries 2009–2013. SSE Riga, Riga.Google Scholar
- Rani, Uma, Patrick Belser, Martin Oelz, and Setareh Ranjbar. 2013. Minimum Wage Coverage and Compliance in Developing Countries. International Labour Review 152 (3–4): 381–410.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rixen, Thomas. 2008. The Political Economy of International Tax Governance: Transformation of the State. Basingstoke/New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sanders, Jan. 2017. The ECJ Decision in Italmoda in the Light of the Settled Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights. International VAT Monitor 28 (1): 421–425.Google Scholar
- Seldon, Arthur. 1979. Avoision: The Moral Blurring of a Legal Distinction Without an Economic Difference. In Tax Avoision: The Economic, Legal and Moral Inter-relationships between Avoidance and Evasion, ed. Alfred R. Ilersic and Arthur Seldon, 3. London: IEA.Google Scholar
- Schneider, Friedrich. 2013. Size and Development of the Shadow Economy of 31 European and 5 Other OECD Countries from 2003 to 2013: A Further Decline [online] http://www.econ.jku.at/members/Schneider/files/publications/2013/ShadEcEurope31_Jan2013.pdf. Accessed 6 Nov 2014.
- Sharman, Jason C. 2006. Havens in a Storm: The Struggle for Global Tax Regulation. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
- Smith, Patrick J. 2014. District Court Misapplies APA in Florida Bankers Association. Tax Notes: 745–748.Google Scholar
- Sullivan, Martin. 2007. Shifting Profits Offshore Costs U.S. Treasury $10 Billion or More. Tax Notes: 1477–1481.Google Scholar
- Sullivan, Martin. 2008. U.S. Multinationals Shifting Profits Out of the United States. Tax Notes: 1078–1082.Google Scholar
- Syal, Rajeev. 2012. Amazon, Google and Starbucks Accused of Diverting UK Profits’. The Guardian, 12 Nov 2012.Google Scholar
- Syal, Rajeev and Patrick Wintour. 2012. MPs attack Amazon, Google and Starbucks over tax avoidance, The Guardian, 2 Dec 2012.Google Scholar
- Tax Justice Network. 2005. Tax Us If You Can, Sept 2005.Google Scholar
- Tax Justice Network. 2012. Estimating the Price of Offshore, 22 July 2012, at http://www.taxjustice.net/cms/front_content.php?idcat=148.
- Tiebout, Charles. 1956. A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures. The Journal of Political Economy 64: 416.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Treanor, Jill. 2009. Avoiding tax robs our public services declares minister. The Observer, 19 Sept 2009.Google Scholar
- UNCTAD. 2015. World Investment Report 2015. New York and Geneva: United Nations.Google Scholar
- Webb, Michael C., and Kenneth Stewart. 2006. International Competition in Corporate Taxation. Economic Policy 45: 53–201.Google Scholar
- Williams, Colin C. 2013. Evaluating cross-national variations in the extent and nature of informal employment in the European Union. Industrial Relations Journal 44 (5–6): 479–494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar