From “Taiwan Independence” to “Hong Kong Independence”: How Hong Kong Followed the Steps of Taiwan on the Road of Separatism

  • Jie Zhu
  • Xiaoshan Zhang


In November 2015, during the Fifth District Council election, some candidates publicly put forward political program of “Hong Kong Nation”; on 8 February 2016, a riot broke out in Mong Kok, which later disclosed by the media, was plotted by radical nativism groups; on 21 April 2016, the young and mid-aged democrats in Hong Kong released a Resolution on Hong Kong’s Future, alleging that the political status of Hong Kong should be determined by Hong Kong people by “internal self-determination”… All these signs indicate that “Hong Kong Independence” is not limited to “venting of emotions” and that “Hong Kong Independence” has evolved from an aimless trick to a well-targeted separatist movement. The wolf of “Hong Kong Independence” is really coming! Ever since the rout of “Umbrella Movement,” the appeal for “true democracy” fell through; some radical democrats turned to separatism, hence the establishment of all sort of pro-independence organizations and miscellaneous “Hong Kong Independence” slogans and theories. To be fair, the outburst of “Hong Kong Independence” has only been a few years. Whereas, these slogans and theories of “Hong Kong Independence” are of little novelty, just a few decades ago, the same kind of theory and movement were just as popular in Taiwan. As a matter of fact, by comparison of the theory of “Hong Kong Independence” with that of the “Taiwan Independence,” we can see the great influence of the latter on the former. The point of studying the separatist theory in both Taiwan and Hong Kong, or inspecting the “demonstration effect” of “Taiwan Independence” on “Hong Kong Independence,” lies within, for one, by comparing and revealing the similarities in the two: we could invoke the past experience in fighting “Taiwan Independence” to refute “Hong Kong Independence”; and for another, by disclosing the difference between Taiwan and Hong Kong, we could show the irrationality of “Hong Kong Independence” following the steps of “Taiwan Independence,” which contributes to the correction of “Hong Kong Independence” discourse.


  1. Anonymous (2015) National consciousness and mass movement, Undergrad, vol 6, pp 45–48Google Scholar
  2. Brian Leung (2014) CSSA restriction revocation dispute and local political community, Undergrad, vol 2, pp 24–26Google Scholar
  3. Chan Ya-ming (2014) An outburst of the age: Hong Kong democratic independence, Undergrad, Sept Issue, pp 30–32Google Scholar
  4. Chen Kongli (2013) Taiwan popular will and group identification. Jiuzhou Publishing House, Beijing, p 13Google Scholar
  5. Chin Wan (2012) Hong Kong City-State. Enrich Publishing, Hong Kong, pp 56, 59, 218Google Scholar
  6. Di Chengguang (2007) Formation and development of Deng Xiao- ping’s ‘One Country, Two Systems’ conception. Hist Res Anhui 3:69–76Google Scholar
  7. Huang Yuexi (2016) ‘Hong Kong City-State’, ‘Hong Kong Nation’ and their negative effects, Expanding Horizons, pp 38–42Google Scholar
  8. Hung Ho-fung (2014) Incomplete state nation, self-determined city-state: Hong Kong issue under the Chinese nation state construction dilemma in the 20th century, in HKUSU ed. Hong Kong Nation, p 125Google Scholar
  9. Jack Lee (2014) Should Hong Kong have the right of national self-determination?, Undergrad, vol 2, pp 34–37Google Scholar
  10. Joseph Lian Yi-zheng (2012) Passport and nationality: on Hong Kong people becoming national minority, Hong Kong Eco J, 2012-01-06Google Scholar
  11. Lau Siu-kai (2013) How to understand Hong Kong nativism, Ta Kong Po, 2013-05-30 (A14)Google Scholar
  12. Liao Wen-i (1994) Taiwan civilianism, cf. Ng Chiau-tong, post-war Taiwan independence movement and the development of Taiwan nationalism. In: Shih Cheng-feng (ed) Taiwan Nationalism. Avanguard Press, Taipei, p 200Google Scholar
  13. Lin Jin (1990) The guiding ideology and theoretical characteristics of the current overseas Taiwan independence movement. Taiwan Res Q 1:17–24Google Scholar
  14. Lin Jin (1992) The proposition of ‘Taiwan Self-determination’ and the future of Taiwan. Taiwan Res Q 4:16–26Google Scholar
  15. Shen Huiping (2009) A brief analysis on the contemporary ‘Taiwanese Nationalism. Guizhou Ethnic Stud 5:7–13Google Scholar
  16. Shi Ming (1994) Taiwan nation: formation and development, cf. Ng Chiau-tong, post-war Taiwan independence movement and the development of Taiwan nationalism. In: Shih Cheng-feng (ed) Taiwan Nationalism. Avanguard Press, Taipei, p 209Google Scholar
  17. Shih Cheng-feng (2002) Self-determination: a nationalist viewpoint of Taiwan independence, cf. Zhu Songling, Xu Chongde, Yi Saijian (2010) criticism of the theoretical source of ‘Jurisprudent Independence of Taiwan’. J Fujian Normal Univ Philos Soc Sci Edn 3:7–15Google Scholar
  18. Shih Ming (1980) Modern history of Taiwanese in 400 years. Paradise Culture Associates, Taipei, p 688Google Scholar
  19. Su Ge (1997) Tracking the source of ‘Unresolved Status of Taiwan’ theory. Taiwan Stud 2:48–54Google Scholar
  20. Su Ge (1998) America’s China policy and the issue of Taiwan. World Affairs Press, Beijing, p 27Google Scholar
  21. Sun Yinghao (2006) Five theories of ‘Taiwan Independence’ aim at secession. Ideol Polit Educ Res 3:16–18Google Scholar
  22. Tian Feilong (2015) Transition of social movements and the evolution of the basic law in Hong Kong. China Law Rev 3:67–74Google Scholar
  23. Tian Feilong (2016) ‘Self-determination’ misunderstood the Hong Kong basic law, shall never go anywhere, Ta Kung Pao, 2016-05-04 (A12)Google Scholar
  24. Timothy Wong Ka-ying (2004) More defiance than obedience: Hong Kong and Taiwan’s response to the China factor under electoral politics, Twenty-First Century, vol 1, pp 20–25Google Scholar
  25. Tso Hiu-nok (2014) Behind Hong-Konger is the whole cultural system, Undergrad, Feb Issue, pp 31–33Google Scholar
  26. Victor Zheng, Wan Po-san (2014) The local consciousness of Hong Kong people: social-economic and political perspective on identity. Hong Kong Macao J 3:66–78Google Scholar
  27. Victor Zheng, Wong Siu-lun (2008) Identity: a comparative study of Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau. Mod China Stud:127–141Google Scholar
  28. Wang Jianmin (2015) Similarities and differences between the political developments in Hong Kong and Taiwan. Reunification Forum 3:9–13Google Scholar
  29. Wong Chun-kit (2014) Nativism is the only way for Hong Kong people’s struggle, Undergrad, Feb Issue, pp 27–30Google Scholar
  30. Yau Lop-poon (2015) Hong Kong independence, Taiwan independence, Historical Amnesia, Lianhe Zaobao, 2015-04-10Google Scholar
  31. Yuan Wei (2003) On the abuse of ‘Taiwanese Nation. Taiwan Stud 2:31–35Google Scholar
  32. Zhang Li (2007) A study on the “Referendum” of Taiwan. Jiuzhou Publishing House, Beijing, pp 72, 76–132Google Scholar
  33. Zhao Yong (2008) Political transition in Taiwan and secession. Central Compilation & Translation Press, Beijing, p 232Google Scholar
  34. Zhu Jie (2015) Democratic independence: Taiwan’s story and Hong Kong’s future. Hong Kong Macao J 4:29–38Google Scholar
  35. Zhu Songling, Xu Chongde, Yi Saijian (2010) Criticism of the theoretical source of ‘Jurisprudent Independence of Taiwan’. J Fujian Normal Univ Philos Soc Sci Edn 3:7–15Google Scholar
  36. Zhu Weidong (1996) An analysis of the ‘Taiwan Independence’ theories. Soc Sci J Hainan Univ 3:86–94Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jie Zhu
    • 1
  • Xiaoshan Zhang
    • 1
  1. 1.School of LawWuhan UniversityWuhanChina

Personalised recommendations