Computer-Aided Orthopedic Surgery: Incremental Shift or Paradigm Change?
Computer-aided orthopedic surgery (CAOS) is now about 25 years old. Unlike neurosurgery, computer-aided surgery has not become the standard of care in orthopedic surgery. In this paper, we provide the technical and clinical context raised by this observation in an attempt to elucidate the reasons for this state of affairs. We start with a brief outline of the history of CAOS, review the main CAOS technologies, and describe how they are evaluated. We then identify some of the current publications in the field and present the opposing views on their clinical impact and their acceptance by the orthopedic community worldwide. We focus on total knee replacement surgery as a case study and present current clinical results and contrasting opinions on CAOS technologies. We then discuss the challenges and opportunities for research in medical image analysis in CAOS and in musculoskeletal radiology. We conclude with a suggestion that while CAOS acceptance may be more moderate than that of other fields in surgery, it still has a place in the arsenal of useful tools available to orthopedic surgeons.
KeywordsComputer-aided orthopedic surgery Image-guided surgery Medical robotics
This chapter was modified from the paper published by our group in Medical Image Analysis (Joskowicz and Hazan 2016; 33:84–90). The related contents are reused with permission.
- 8.Liebergall M, Joskowicz L, Mosheiff R (2015) Computer-aided orthopaedic surgery in skeletal trauma. In: Bucholz R, Heckman J (eds) Rockwood and green’s fractures in adults, 8th edn. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, pp 575–607Google Scholar
- 14.Cartiaux O, Jenny J-Y, Joskowicz L (2016) Accuracy in orthopaedic surgery assisted by navigation systems, robots and 3D printers: how is it defined, how could It be measured experimentally, and how should it be analyzed from a clinical perspective? J Bone Bone Surg 99(e39):1–8Google Scholar
- 16.Walker R, Monda M, Chauhan S (2010) Focus on: navigation for TKR. J Bone Joint SurgGoogle Scholar
- 18.Ritacco LE, Milano FE, Chao E (2016) Computer-assisted musculoskeletal surgery: thinking and executing in 3D. ISBN: 978-3-319-12942-6, Print, 978-3-319-12943-3, Online Book, Springer.Google Scholar
- 19.BCC Research (2015) Medical robotics and computer aided surgery report, http://www.bccresearch.com