Advertisement

Protecting the East Rennell World Heritage Site: Legislation

  • Stephanie Clair Price
Chapter
Part of the Palgrave Series in Asia and Pacific Studies book series (PSAPS)

Abstract

This chapter considers the potential for East Rennell to be protected under the Protected Areas Act 2010, and identifies key issues that may arise if the Act is implemented there. It argues that the relationship between the legislation and customary law must be carefully considered in the preparation of the site’s management plan and the selection of its management committee. Other legislation relevant to the conservation of East Rennell is also analysed, including laws concerning logging, mining, fishing, and biosecurity. The chapter explores the legal, economic, and cultural factors that affect the ability and willingness of the government and customary landowners to utilise these laws to protect World Heritage. Some suggestions for strengthening East Rennell’s protection under legislation are provided.

References

Articles, Books and Reports

  1. Allen, Matthew, ‘The Political Economy of Logging in Solomon Islands’ in Ron Duncan (ed), The Political Economy of Economic Reform in the Pacific (Asian Development Bank, 2011) 277Google Scholar
  2. Allen, Matthew, Sinclair Dinnen, Daniel Evans and Rebecca Monson, Justice Delivered Locally: Systems, Challenges and Innovations in Solomon Islands (World Bank, 2013)Google Scholar
  3. Asia Pacific Investment Development Ltd, Rennell Island Bauxite Project, Renbel Province: Environment Impact Statement (2014)Google Scholar
  4. Baines, Graham, Solomon Islands is Unprepared to Manage a Minerals-Based Economy, State, Society and Governance in Melanesia Discussion Paper 2015/6 (Australian National University, 2015)Google Scholar
  5. Banks, Glenn, ‘Mining’ in Moshe Rapaport (ed), The Pacific Islands: Environment and Society (University of Hawai’i Press, 2013) 379Google Scholar
  6. Bennett, Judith, ‘Forestry, Public Land, and the Colonial Legacy in Solomon Islands’ (1995) 7(2) Contemporary Pacific 243Google Scholar
  7. Bennett, Judith, Pacific Forest: A History of Resource Control and Contest in Solomon Islands, c 1800–1997 (Brill Academic Publishers Inc, 2000)Google Scholar
  8. Bennett, Judith, Roots of Conflict in Solomon Islands – Though Much is Taken, Much Abides: Legacies of Tradition and Colonialism, State, Society and Governance in Melanesia Discussion Paper (Australian National University, 2002)Google Scholar
  9. Boer, Ben, Solomon Islands: Review of Environmental Law (SPREP, 1993)Google Scholar
  10. Boer, Ben, ‘Solomon Islands’ in Ben Boer (ed), Environmental Law in the South Pacific: Consolidated Report of the Reviews of Environmental Law in the Cook Islands, Federated States of Micronesia, Kingdom of Tonga, Republic of the Marshall Islands and Solomon Islands (South Pacific Regional Environment Programme and IUCN Environmental Law Centre, 1996) 189Google Scholar
  11. Boer, Ben and Pepe Clarke, Legal Frameworks for Ecosystem-Based Adaptation to Climate Change in the Pacific Islands (SPREP, 2012)Google Scholar
  12. Brown, Chris, Regional Study: The South Pacific, Asia-Pacific Forestry Sector Outlook Study (Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, 1997)Google Scholar
  13. Cordonnery, Laurence, ‘Environmental Law Issues in the South Pacific and the Quest for Sustainable Development and Good Governance’ in Anita Jowitt and Tess Newton Cain (eds), Passage of Change: Law, Society and Governance in the Pacific (ANU Press, 2010) 233Google Scholar
  14. Corrin, J C, ‘Abrogation of the Rights of Customary Land Owners by the Forest Resources and Timber Utilisation Act’ (1992) 3 Queensland University of Technology Law Journal 131Google Scholar
  15. Corrin, Jennifer, ‘Customary Land and the Language of the Common Law’ (2008) 37 Common Law World Review 305Google Scholar
  16. Dingwall, Paul, Report on the Reactive Monitoring Mission to East Rennell, Solomon Islands, 21–29 October 2012 (IUCN, 2013)Google Scholar
  17. Dinnen, Sinclair, ‘State-Building in a Post-Colonial Society: The Case of Solomon Islands’ (2008) 9 Chicago Journal of International Law 51Google Scholar
  18. Dinnen, Sinclair, ‘The Solomon Islands Intervention and the Instabilities of the Post-Colonial State’ (2008) 20(3) Global Change, Peace and Security (formerly Pacific Review: Peace, Security and Global Change) 338Google Scholar
  19. Dyer, Michelle, ‘Eating money: Narratives of equality on customary land in the context of natural resource extraction in Solomon Islands’ (2017) 28 The Australian Journal of Anthropology 88Google Scholar
  20. Elbert, Samuel H and Torben Monberg, From the Two Canoes: Oral Traditions of Rennell and Bellona Islands (Danish National Museum and University of Hawaii Press, 1965)Google Scholar
  21. Environment and Conservation Division (Solomon Islands Ministry of Environment, Climate Change, Disaster Management, and Meteorology) Lake Tegano World Heritage Site, East Rennell, Rennell-Bellona Province: A Report on Community Consultation Visit on the Status of East Rennell World Heritage Site, 5–12 October 2011 (SIG, 2012)Google Scholar
  22. Evans, Daniel, ‘Tensions at the Gold Ridge Mine, Guadalcanal, Solomon Islands’ (2010) 25(3) Pacific Economic Bulletin 121Google Scholar
  23. Fardin, Joe, Mining Law and Agreement Making in Solomon Islands (Public Solicitor’s Office, Solomon Islands Government, 2011)Google Scholar
  24. Farran, Sue, ‘Timber Extraction in Solomon Islands: Too Much, Too Fast; Too Little, Too Late’ in Emma Gilberthrope and Gavin Hilson (eds), National Resource Extraction and Indigenous Livelihoods: Development Challenges in an Era of Globalisation (Routledge, 2014) 179Google Scholar
  25. Feridhanusetyawan, Tubagus and Shanaka J Peiris, Solomon Islands: Selected Issues, IMF Country Report 11/360 (International Monetary Fund, 2011)Google Scholar
  26. Forsyth, Miranda, ‘Beyond Case Law: Kastom and Courts in Vanuatu’ (2004) 35 Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 427Google Scholar
  27. Frazer, Ian, ‘The Struggle for Control of Solomon Island Forests’ (1997) 9(1) Contemporary Pacific 39Google Scholar
  28. Gay, Daniel (ed), Solomon Islands Diagnostic Trade Integration Study 2009 Report (Solomon Islands Government, 2009) 48Google Scholar
  29. Giraud-Kinley, Catherine, ‘The Effectiveness of International Law: Sustainable Development in the South Pacific Region’ (1999–2000) 12 Georgetown Environmental Law Review 125Google Scholar
  30. Graham, Tom, ‘Flexibility and the Codification of Traditional Fisheries Management Systems’, SPC Traditional Marine Resource Management and Knowledge Information Bulletin 3 (1994) 2Google Scholar
  31. Greenpeace Pacific, Caught Between Two Worlds: A Social Impact Study of Large and Small Scale Development in Marovo Lagoon, Solomon Islands (2001)Google Scholar
  32. Hales, Robert James, John Rynne, Cathy Howlett, Jay Devine and Vivian Hauser, ‘Indigenous Free Prior Informed Consent: A Case for Self Determination in World Heritage Nomination Processes’ (2013) 19(3) International Journal of Heritage Studies 270Google Scholar
  33. Heywood, Mike and Kasia Gabrys, Evaluation Report on Training in Community-Based Natural Resources Management (2009)Google Scholar
  34. Hou, Douglas, Elaine Johnson and Stephanie Price, ‘Defending the Forest in the Clouds: Public Interest Law in Solomon Islands’ (2013) 15 Asia Pacific Journal of Environmental Law 167Google Scholar
  35. Hughes, Tony and Ali Tuhanuku, Logging and Mining in Rennell: Lessons for Solomon Islands. Report to the World Bank and Solomon Islands Government (2015)Google Scholar
  36. Johannes, R E and F R Hickey, Evolution of Village-Based Marine Resource Management in Vanuatu Between 1993 and 2001, Coastal Region and Small Island Papers 15 (UNESCO, 2004)Google Scholar
  37. Kabutaulaka, Tarcisius Tara, ‘Rumble in the Jungle: Land, Culture and (Un)sustainable Logging in Solomon Islands’ in Antony Hooper (ed), Culture and Sustainable Development in the Pacific (ANU E Press and Asia Pacific Press, 2005) 88Google Scholar
  38. Kafo, Teddy, ‘Proposed logging threatens World Heritage Lake Tegano’, The Solomon Star, 24 February 2015Google Scholar
  39. Kuemlangan, Blaise, Creating Legal Space for Community-Based Fisheries and Customary Marine Tenure in the Pacific: Issues and Opportunities (Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, 2004)Google Scholar
  40. Lausche, Barbara, Guidelines for Protected Area Legislation (IUCN, 2011)Google Scholar
  41. Lindsay, Jonathan M, Creating Legal Space for Community-Based Management: Principles and Dilemmas (Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, 1998)Google Scholar
  42. Macintyre, Martha and Simon Foale, ‘Global Imperatives and Local Desires: Competing Economic and Environmental Interests in Melanesian Communities’ in Victoria Lockwood (ed), Globalisation and Culture Change in the Pacific Islands (Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004) 149Google Scholar
  43. Marnell, John, ‘Concerns Raised Over East Rennell Logging Application’, Sunday Isles, 25 March 2012, 9Google Scholar
  44. McDonald, Jan, Marine Resource Management and Conservation in Solomon Islands: Roles, Responsibilities and Opportunities (Griffith Law School, 2010)Google Scholar
  45. McDonnell, Siobhan, Joseph Foukana and Alice Pollard, Building a Pathway for Successful Land Reform in Solomon Islands (2015)Google Scholar
  46. McDougall, Debra, ‘Church, Company, Committee, Chief: Emergent Collectivities in Rural Solomon Islands’ in Mary Patterson and Martha Macintyre (eds), Managing Modernity in the Western Pacific (University of Queensland Press, 2011) 121Google Scholar
  47. Mukherjee, Pampa, ‘Community Rights and Statutory Laws: Politics of Forest Use in Uttrakhand Himalayas’ (2004) 50 Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 161Google Scholar
  48. Mumma, Albert, ‘Legal Aspects of Cultural Landscape Protection in Africa’ in Cultural Landscapes: The Challenges of Conservation, World Heritage Papers 7 (UNESCO, 2003) 156Google Scholar
  49. Mumma, Albert, ‘The Link Between Traditional and Formal Legal Systems’ in Webber Ndoro and Gilbert Pwiti (eds), Legal Frameworks for the Protection of Immoveable Cultural Heritage in Africa, ICCROM Conservation Studies 5 (ICCROM, 2005) 22Google Scholar
  50. Pacific Horizon Consultancy Group, Solomon Islands State of Environment Report (Solomon Islands Government, 2008)Google Scholar
  51. Pituvaka, Francis, ‘Dolphins Freed After Raid’, The Solomon Star (online), 1 November 2016 http://www.solomonstarnews.com/news/national/11645-dolphins-freed-after-raid
  52. Price, Stephanie, Adam Beeson, Joe Fardin and Jennifer Radford, Environmental Law in Solomon Islands (Public Solicitor’s Office, Solomon Islands Government, 2015)Google Scholar
  53. PT Mega Bintang Borneo Ltd, Environment Impact Statement: Central Rennell Bauxite Mining Project (2014)Google Scholar
  54. Ruddle, K, E Hviding and R E Johannes, ‘Marine Resources Management in the Context of Customary Tenure’ (1992) 7 Marine Resource Economics 249Google Scholar
  55. Ruddle, Kenneth, ‘The Context of Policy Design for Existing Community-Based Fisheries Management Systems in the Pacific Islands’ (1998) 40 Ocean and Coastal Management 105Google Scholar
  56. Smith, Anita, ‘East Rennell World Heritage Site: Misunderstandings, Inconsistencies and Opportunities in the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention in the Pacific Islands’ (2011) 17(6) International Journal of Heritage Studies 592Google Scholar
  57. Smith, Anita, ‘The World Heritage Pacific 2009 Programme’ in Anita Smith (ed), World Heritage in a Sea of Islands: Pacific 2009 Programme, World Heritage Papers 34 (UNESCO, 2012) 2Google Scholar
  58. Solomon Islands Government, State Party Report on the State of Conservation of the East Rennell World Heritage Area (Solomon Islands) (SIG, 2013)Google Scholar
  59. Solomon Islands Government, State Party Report on the State of Conservation of the East Rennell World Heritage Area (Solomon Islands) (SIG, 2014)Google Scholar
  60. Solomon Islands Government, State Party Report on the State of Conservation of East Rennell (Solomon Islands) (SIG, 2017)Google Scholar
  61. Solomon Islands Office of the Auditor General, An Auditor-General’s Insights into Corruption in Solomon Islands Government, National Parliament Paper 48 (2007)Google Scholar
  62. Techera, Erika, Local Approaches to the Protection of Biological Diversity: The Role of Customary Law in Community Based Conservation in the South Pacific, Macquarie Law Working Paper 2007-2 (2007)Google Scholar
  63. Turton, Steve, East Rennell World Heritage Area: Assessment of the State of Conservation of World Heritage Values. Final Field Report (James Cook University, 2014)Google Scholar
  64. Wairiu, Morgan, ‘History of the Forestry Industry in Solomon Islands: The Case of Guadalcanal’ (2007) 42(2) Journal of Pacific History 233Google Scholar
  65. Wingham, Elspeth J, Nomination of East Rennell, Solomon Islands by the Government of Solomon Islands for Inclusion in the World Heritage List Natural Sites (1997)Google Scholar
  66. Wingham, Elspeth J and Ben Devi, ‘The Involvement of Local People in the Management of a Proposed World Heritage Site at East Rennell, Solomon Islands’ in Hans D Thulstrup (ed), World Natural Heritage and the Local Community: Case Studies from Asia Pacific, Australia and New Zealand (UNESCO, 1999) 79Google Scholar
  67. Zorn, Jean and Jennifer Corrin Care, “Barava Tru’: Judicial Approaches to the Pleading and Proof of Custom in the South Pacific’ (2002) 51 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 612Google Scholar

Cases

  1. Alevangana v Kegu [2012] SBHC 1Google Scholar
  2. Linear Perspective Ltd v Attorney General [2011] SBHC 18Google Scholar
  3. SMM Solomon Ltd v Attorney General; Bogotu Minerals Ltd v Attorney General [2014] SBHC 91Google Scholar
  4. Tovua v Meki [1989] SBHC 3; [1988–1989] SILR 74Google Scholar

Legislation and Bills: Fiji

  1. Heritage Bill 2016 (No. 10 of 2016)Google Scholar

Legislation and Bills: Marshall Islands

  1. Endangered Species Act 1975 Google Scholar

Legislation and Bills: Solomon Islands

  1. Biosecurity Act 2013 Google Scholar
  2. Biosecurity Regulations 2015 Google Scholar
  3. Choiseul Province Preservation of Culture Ordinance 1999 Google Scholar
  4. Environment Act 1998 Google Scholar
  5. Environment Regulations 2008 Google Scholar
  6. Fisheries Act 1998 Google Scholar
  7. Fisheries Management Act 2015 Google Scholar
  8. Fisheries Management Regulations 2017 Google Scholar
  9. Fisheries Ordinance 1972 Google Scholar
  10. Fisheries (Prohibition of Export of Dolphins) Regulations 2013 Google Scholar
  11. Fisheries Regulations 1972 Google Scholar
  12. Forest and Timber Amendment Act 1977 Google Scholar
  13. Forest Resources and Timber Utilisation Act (Cap. 40) Google Scholar
  14. Forest Resources and Timber Utilisation (Felling Licences) Regulations 2005 Google Scholar
  15. Interpretation and General Provisions Act (Cap. 85)Google Scholar
  16. Land and Titles Act (Cap. 133) Google Scholar
  17. Lake Tegano Natural Heritage Park Ordinance 2009 (draft)Google Scholar
  18. Makira Preservation of Culture and Wildlife Ordinance 1985 Google Scholar
  19. Mines and Minerals Act (Cap. 42) Google Scholar
  20. Mines and Minerals Regulations 1996 Google Scholar
  21. Protected Areas Act 2010 Google Scholar
  22. Protected Areas Regulations 2012 Google Scholar
  23. Protection of Wrecks and War Relics Act (Cap. 150) Google Scholar
  24. Solomon Islands Independence Order 1978, sch (Constitution of Solomon Islands)Google Scholar
  25. Town and Country Planning Act (Cap. 154) Google Scholar

Legislation and Bills: Vanuatu

  1. Environmental Management and Conservation Act (Cap. 283) Google Scholar

Conventions

  1. Convention on the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage, opened for signature 17 October 2003, 2368 UNTS 3 (entered into force 20 April 2006)Google Scholar

United Nations Documents

  1. Barbados Programme of Action for the Sustainable Development of Small Island Developing States, UN Doc A/CONF.167/9 (October 1994)Google Scholar
  2. Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention, UN Doc WHC.16/01 (26 October 2016)Google Scholar
  3. Rio Declaration on Environment and Development, Report of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, UN Doc A/CONF.151/6/Rev.1 (1992)Google Scholar
  4. State of Conservation of Properties Inscribed on the World Heritage List, WHC 41st sess, UN Doc WHC/17/41.COM/7A.Add (2 June 2017) 26 (East Rennell, Solomon Islands)Google Scholar
  5. State of Conservation of the Properties Inscribed on the List of World Heritage in Danger, WHC 42nd sess, UN Doc WHC/18/42.COM/7A.Add.2 (15 June 2018) 17 (East Rennell, Solomon Islands)Google Scholar
  6. WHCRes 29 COM 7B.10, WHC 29th sess, UN Doc WHC-05/29.COM/22 (9 September 2005) 45Google Scholar
  7. WHCRes 31 COM 7B.21, WHC 31st sess, UN Doc WHC-07/31.COM/24 (31 July 2007) 58Google Scholar
  8. WHC Res 33 COM 7B.19, WHC 33rd sess, UN Doc WHC-09/33.COM/20 (20 July 2009) 68Google Scholar
  9. WHC Res 34 COM 7B.17, WHC 34th sess, UN Doc WHC-10/34.COM/20 (3 September 2010) 71Google Scholar
  10. WHC Res 37 COM 7B.14, WHC 37th sess, UN Doc WHC-13/37.COM/20 (5 July 2013) 68Google Scholar
  11. WHC Res 38 COM 7A.29, WHC 38th sess, UN Doc WHC-14/38.COM/16 (7 July 2014) 39Google Scholar
  12. WHC Res 41 COM 7A.19, WHC 41st sess, UN Doc WHC-17/41.COM/18 (12 July 2017) 35Google Scholar

Theses

  1. Price, Stephanie Clair, Strengthening World Heritage Protection in the Pacific: An Exploration of Solomon Islands’ Implementation of the World Heritage Convention (PhD Thesis, University of Western Australia, 2017)Google Scholar
  2. Tagini, Phillip Iro, The Search for King Solomon’s Gold: An Examination of the Policy and Regulatory Framework for Mining in Solomon Islands (PhD Thesis, The Australian National University, 2007)Google Scholar

Internet Materials

  1. Solomon Islands Government, Fisheries Acts and Supporting Regulations http://www.fisheries.gov.sb/fisheries-acts

Interviews

  1. Interview by the author with an officer in the Ministry of Culture (Honiara, 26 July 2013)Google Scholar
  2. Interview by the author with a conservation officer in the Ministry of Environment (Honiara, 2 August 2013)Google Scholar
  3. Interview by the author with Joe Horokou, Director of the Environment and Conservation Division of the Ministry of Environment (Honiara, 15 August 2013)Google Scholar

Other

  1. Solomon Islands National Climate Change Policy: 2012–2017 (2012)Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Stephanie Clair Price
    • 1
  1. 1.University of Western AustraliaCrawleyAustralia

Personalised recommendations