Provision of National Health Insurance “Model Benefits” to Japan’s Prefectures

  • Tatsuo Hatta


Regional areas, in which land rents are relatively low, clearly possess a comparative advantage in the provision of elderly services. Nevertheless, regional municipalities do not welcome influxes of elderly residents, because such influxes disadvantage regional municipal governments by requiring them to shoulder a considerable financial burden for social security while providing virtually no increase in local tax revenues.

Influxes of elderly residents would be stimulated if the national government paid an amount corresponding to a “model benefit” for each insurance subscriber, based on the average per person benefit for that age cohort throughout the entire country.

The present chapter estimates that the model benefit would be 125,000 yen for each additional resident younger than 65, and 556,000 yen for each additional resident older than 65.


Efficient allocation of resources Inflow of elderly residents Model benefits National Health Insurance Reallocation of the number of hospital beds Social insurance for the elderly 


  1. Hatta, Tatsuo (1996), “Remark,” in Hatta, T. et al. (eds.), Fukushi wa Toushi Dearu (Welfare is an Investment), Nihon Hyoron Sha Press, pp. 172–173.Google Scholar
  2. Hatta, Tatsuo (2015a). ‘Chihososei wo Tou (Ge) –Iju no Shouheki-teppai koso Senketsu (Questioning Regional Revitalization (Part 2): Removing Barriers to Immigration Is the First Priority),’ Nihon Keizai Shimbun, Morning Edition, February 6, 2015 (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  3. Hatta, Tatsuo (2015b). “Kokudo no Kinkoaru-hatten’ Ron wa Nihon no Suitai wo Maneku (‘Balanced National Development’ Threatens Japan with Decline).’ Zenshiten: Jinko-kyugen to Jichitai-shometsu (The Issues in Question: Rapid Population Decline and the Disappearance of Small Municipalities in Japan), Jiji Press, Ltd., February 2015, pp. 64–67 (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  4. Hatta, Tatsuo (2016a). “Kokuho no “Moderu-kyuhugaku” Kokkohutanseido’ niyoru Chihososei (Regional Revitalization via a System for the Contribution of “Model Benefits” by the Government),’ Japanese Journal of Health Economics and Policy, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp. 71–84 (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  5. Hatta, Tatsuo (2016b). ‘Koreika to Chihozaisei (Aging Society and Local Government Finance).’ East Asian Economic Perspectives (Journal of AGI), December 2016, No.27, Vol.2, pp. 1–14 ( (in Japanese).
  6. Hayashi, Masayoshi (2012). Channels of stabilization in a system of local public health insurance: the case of the National Health Insurance in Japan. CIRJE-F-847. Google Scholar
  7. Hayashi, Masayoshi (2015). ‘Health Care, Long-term Care, and Local Public Finances.’ SPACE NIRA, Unit 01-B.Google Scholar
  8. Iwamoto, Yasushi (1996), “Shian: Iryohokenseido Ichigenka (Designing an Integration of Health Insurance Groups),” Nihon Keizai Kenkyu (JCER Economic Journal), No. 33, November, pp. 119–142 (included in Hatta, T. and Yashiro, N. (eds.) (1998), “Shakaihoken Kaikaku (Social Insurance Reforms),” Series Gendai Keizai Kenkyu Vol. 16 (Contemporary Economic Study Series Vol. 16), Nihon Keizai Shimbun) (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  9. Iwamoto, Yasushi (2015). ‘Designing New Systems through Risk Adjustment.’ SPACE NIRA, Unit 01-A.Google Scholar
  10. Kawabuchi, Koichi (2002). Iryo kaikaku –Itami wo kanjinai seidosekkei wo (Health Care Reform). Tokyo Keizai Shinposha (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  11. Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (2015). ‘Documents Prepared by National Health Insurance Division, Health Insurance Bureau, MHLW for “Zenkoku Koreishairyo Shukannka(bu) cho oyobi Kokuminkenko Hoken Shukanka(bu) cho narabini Koki-koreishairyo Koikirengo Jimukyokucho Kaigi (National Meetings for Department/Division Chiefs of Elderly Medical Service, Department/Division Chiefs of National Health Insurance and Secretary-generals of Wide Area Unions for the Late-stage Medical Care System for the Elderly)”’ (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  12. Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (2016). 2014 Land Price Research by Prefectural Governments.Google Scholar
  13. Okabe, Yoji (2014). ‘Kino shitenai byoshokisei no zenpai wo –Kitokukenneki wo hogosuru kyousouseigen seisaku (Abolishing the regulation for the number of hospital beds which failed to function – Competition-restrictive policies protecting vested interests).’ Kinyu Zaisei Business (Financial & Fiscal Businesss), 10392, pp. 12–17, Jiji Press, Ltd (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  14. Suzuki, Wataru (2010). Shakaihosho no ‘Futsugo na Shinjitu’ (‘Inconvenient Truth’ of Social Security). Nikkei Publishing Inc (in Japanese).Google Scholar
  15. Suzuki, Wataru (2015). ‘Local Government Financing of Health Insurance and Regional Revitalization—Facilitating Migration of the Elderly.’ SPACE NIRA, Unit 01 Kick-off paper.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Tatsuo Hatta
    • 1
  1. 1.Asian Growth Research InstituteKitakyushuJapan

Personalised recommendations