Technology Transfer, Imitation and Local Production: The Soap Industry in Early Twentieth-Century Tianjin
Abstract
The first Chinese-owned modern soap factory was established in Tianjin in 1903, and by the 1930s Tianjin was home to more than 30 large and small soap factories that served markets all over North China. Soap was one of the most important of the new daily use commodities whose import in the late 19th–early 20th centuries triggered efforts by Chinese manufacturers to produce imitations. Frank Dikötter described the process by which factories and workshops in China came to produce such daily use items as “copy culture.” As many of the chapters in this book argue, copying often led to disputes over brand names, and Chinese and other Asian producers were accused of producing “fakes.” The Tianjin soap industry is an unusual example of an industry that developed out of a top-down government initiative to promote light industry in cooperation with a foreign competitor—i.e. Japan. The first part of the paper charts the rise of the Tianjin soap industry, beginning from a government training school that sent apprentices to work in Japanese soap making factories, through the founding of the first soap factory, and the creation over several decades of more than 30 smaller factories. The proliferation of manufacturers and the hyper-competition that resulted led to lower prices, which helped to spread the consumption of soap. The second part of the paper looks at the creation of the market for soap, describing the ways people washed clothes and washed their bodies. Finally it turns to the question of how soap was marketed in North China.
Keywords
Copy culture Soap Technology transfer Washing bodies Washing clothesReferences
- Baihuoju, Shangyebu. 1989. Zhongguo baihuo shangye (Chinese commerce in general goods). Beijing: Beijing Daxue Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Dikötter, Frank. 2006. Exotic commodities: Modern objects and everyday life in China. NY: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
- Editorial Committee for the Tianjin Shanghui Archives. 1992. Tianjin Shanghui dang’an huibian, part 2, 1912–1928 (Selections from the Tianjin Chamber of Commerce archives, 1912–1928). Tianjin: Tianjin Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Gamble, Sidney. 1954. Ting Hsien: A north China rural community. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
- Guoji Laodong Xiaoxi (International Labor News). 1933. Report on laundry workers strikes, quoted from Da Gong Bao. 5-3: 68–69.Google Scholar
- Guojia Tushuguan Chubanshe (ed.). 2009. Qingmo guanbao huibian (Reprint collection of late Qing government gazettes). Beijing: Guojia Tushuguan Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Hebei Shengli Gongye Xueyuan Gongye Jingji Xuehui. 1935. Tianjin zaoyi gongye zhuangkuang fu yizao zhizao fangfa jianshu (The current state of the Tianjin soap industry with an appendix on soap manufacturing methods). Cited as TJZGZ.Google Scholar
- Hebei-sheng Sheng-li Zhengding Zhongxue Xiaokan (Journal of Hebei Provincial Zhengding Middle School). 1934. Zhengding.Google Scholar
- Jianren. 1943. Beijing Sishinianqian Zaotangye (Beijing bathhouses 40 years ago). Liyan Huakan (Performances Pictorial) 254: 15.Google Scholar
- Jinan-shi shizheng yuekan (Jinan city government monthly). 1930. Guiding pinmin xiyi banfa (Regulations on clothes washing by the poor). 3 (2): 112–113.Google Scholar
- Jiang, Pei. 2005. Liu-Ri xuesheng, dong you guan-shen yu Zhilisheng de jindaihua jncheng, 1900–1928 (Overseas students who studied in Japan and officials and gentry who went on missions to Japan and modernization projects in Zhili Province, 1900–1908). Shixue Yuekan (Journal of Historical Science) 5: 56–66.Google Scholar
- LaCouture, Elizabeth. 2010. Modern homes for modern families in Tianjin, China, 1860–1949. PhD dissertation in history. Columbia University.Google Scholar
- Li, Jiyang. 1921. Tianjin xiyi gongren de bagong fengchao (Labor strikes by Tianjin laundry workers). Minguo Ribao-Juewu (Minguo Newspaper, Juewu Revue) 7 (20): 3.Google Scholar
- Li, Jinghan. 1935. Beiping jiaowai zhi xiangcun jiating (Rural families in suburban Beiping). Reprinted in Li Wenhai (ed.). 2005. Minguo shiqi shehui diaocha congbian, xiangcun shehui juan (Republican period social surveys, on rural society), 460–530. Fuzhou: Fujian Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Li, Jinghan. [1933] 1986. Dingxian shehui gaikuang diaocha (A social survey on conditions in Ding County). Beijing: Zhongguo Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Liu, Guhou. 1929. Tianjin zhizao yizao gongye (Tianjin soap manufacturing industry). [Tianjin] Shehui Kexue (Social Science) 1 (3/4): 1–12.Google Scholar
- Meng, Qingchun. 2011. Mao Zedong de huanghui rensheng he weilai xinyuan (Mao Zedong’s brilliant life and unfinished mission). Dangdai Zhongguo Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Nankai Economic Research Institute. 1935–37. Gaoyang Social Survey Materials, original field research notes.Google Scholar
- Nakasone, Yumio. 2007. Sekken, senzai no gijutsu hatten no keitō chōsa hōkoku (A survey report on technological development of soap and detergent). Kokuritsu Kagaku Hakubutsukan (National Science Museum) 9.Google Scholar
- Nankai Zhoukan (Nankai Weekly). 1922. Article on price increase for laundry. 39: 19–20.Google Scholar
- Ōsato, Hiroaki, and Ansoku Son. 2002. Chūgokujin ryūgakushi kenkyū no gendankai (The current state of research on the history of overseas study by Chinese). Tokyo: Ochanomizu Shobō.Google Scholar
- Qingdao Zizhi Zhoukan (Qingdao self-government weekly). 1936. Jinzhi zai jingyan jiyi taoran (Prohibition on washing clothes around wells) 215: 2.Google Scholar
- Qinghua [Tsinghua] Zhoukan (Tsinghua Weekly). 1918. Issue 143.Google Scholar
- Ren, Peiyuan. 1936. Zhongguo zilaishuiye jingying gaikuang (An outline of the status of piped water systems in China). Shehui Kexue Zazhi (Social Science Journal) 7 (2): 267–286.Google Scholar
- Rogaski, Ruth. 2004. Hygienic modernity: Meanings of health and disease in treaty-port China. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Schneider, Helen M. 2011. Keeping the nation’s house: Domestic management and the making of modern China. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
- Soap industry in China. 1921. Journal of the Royal Society of Arts 69 (3597): 831 (October 28).Google Scholar
- Song, Dechen. 2009. Zhenxing gongyi—Qingmo youmin jiuye gongcheng (Promotion of handicraft—Late Qing Training Programs for the Unemployed). Shijie Bolan (World Vision) 3: 61–63.Google Scholar
- Sun, Meiyun, and Zhang Huan. 2005. Jindai Tianjin gongye yu qiye zhidu (Modern Chinese industry and the enterprise system). Tianjin: Tianjin Shehuikexueyuan Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Sun, Reibang. 1929. Tianjin zaoyi gongsi diaocha baogao (A report on a survey of the Tianjin soap company). Hebeisheng Guohuo Chenlieguan Yuekan (Hebei Provincial National Products Exhibition Hall Monthly) 1: 120–123.Google Scholar
- Sun, Xuemei. 2001. Qingmo Minchu Zhongguoren de Ribenguan: Yi Zhilisheng wei zhongxin (Chinese views of Japan during the late Qing and early Republic—focusing on Zhili Province). Tianjin: Tianjin Renmen Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Tianjin Difangshizhi Editorial Committee. 1987. Tianjin jindai renwulü (Biographies of modern Tianjin individuals). Tianjin: Tianjinshi Defangshizhi Bianxiu Weiyuanhui Zongbianzji.Google Scholar
- Tianjin Municipal Archives. 1930s. Archives of the Heng Yuan Company.Google Scholar
- Tobe, Ken. 2015. Kindai Tenshin no ‘shakai kyōiku’—kyōiku to senden no aida (Social education in modern Tianjin–between education and propaganda). Tokyo: Kyūko Shoin.Google Scholar
- Wang, Yaorong, and Jiali Guan. 2002. Zaoshi Dezhou zaotangye (The early years of the bath house industry in Dezhou). Zongheng (Across Time and Space) 2: 43–45.Google Scholar
- Xu, Jingxing. 1999. Shangjie qicai Song Zejiu (Commercial wizard Song Zejiu). In Jindai Tianjin Shida Shiyejia (The ten most important entrepreneurs in Tianjin), ed. Tianjin Zhengxie, 37–85. Tianjin: Tianjin Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
- Yang, Yi. 1943. Tianjin zaotangzi (Tianjin Bathhouses). Sanliujiu Huabao (369 Pictorial) 20 (11): 16, 20 (12): 18.Google Scholar
- Yoneda, Yūtarō. 1941. Shina kōkoku senden no gijutsu (Advertising techniques in China). Tokyo: Kyōzaisha.Google Scholar
- Zhou, Errun. 1907. Zhili gonyizhi chubian, baogaolei (First edition of the Zhili Gongyi Gazetteer, reports). Tianjin: Zhili Gongyiju Printing Office.Google Scholar
- Zhu, Qiao. 1937. Xiangcun xiaoxue jiaoshi de xiyi wenti (Problem of washing clothes for an elementary school teacher). Jinxiu Banyuekan (Training Bi-Monthly) 6 (12): 42.Google Scholar
- Zhou, Xiaojuan. 1997. Zhou Xuexi zhuanji huibian (Collected accounts of Zhou Xuexi). Lanzhou: Gansu Wenhua Chubanshe.Google Scholar