The Limits of Reconciliation in Criminal Sentencing

  • Thalia AnthonyEmail author


Indigenous people in Australia are vastly over-represented in police custody and prisons. This paper argues that there is a judicial responsibility to take notice of systemic and prejudicial post-colonial circumstances affecting Indigenous people to reduce imprisonment. This may represent a step on the path to reconciliation in the legal system. By eschewing this reconciliatory gesture, Australian courts are complicit in the over-representation of Indigenous people in prisons. By contrast, Canadian judiciaries and legislatures have taken notice of the systemic disadvantage imposed by the legal system and broader colonial society on First Nations people and have sought to promote non-prison sentences for Aboriginal people. But is it enough for Australian courts to adopt the Canadian approach? This chapter draws on the ideas of Alfred (Response, responsibility and renewal: Canada’s truth and reconciliation journey. Aboriginal Healing Foundation, Ottawa: 179–187, 2009) that reconciliation absolves and entrenches colonial injustice by maintaining the dominance of postcolonial jurisdictions, processes and criminogenic assumptions. Resurgence, restitution and regeneration concepts that Alfred introduces as counterpoints to reconciliation, are essential for breaking down the postcolonial structures that subordinate Indigenous people. In the legal system, measures to privilege Indigenous perspectives and knowledges through Indigenous sentencing courts and Indigenous community pre-sentence reports challenge the whiteness of legal discourse and process. However, they are not a substitute for the resurgence of Indigenous governance and ongoing jurisdictional claims that push the limits of reconciliatory gestures in criminal sentencing.


Indigenous nations Criminal justice Colonial relations Usurpation Resurgence Decolonisation Indigenous justice strategies 



  1. Bugmy v The Queen (2013) 249 CLR 571.Google Scholar
  2. Bugmy [No 2] [2014] NSWCCA 322.Google Scholar
  3. Elias v The Queen; Issa v The Queen [2013] HCA 31.Google Scholar
  4. Fernando (1992) 76 A Crim R 58.Google Scholar
  5. R v Fuller-Cust [2002] VSCA 168,Google Scholar
  6. Ipeelee [2012] 1 SCR 433.Google Scholar
  7. Mabo v State of Queensland (No. 2) (1992) 175 CLR 1.Google Scholar
  8. Milirrpum v Nabalco Pty Ltd (1971) 17 FLR 141.Google Scholar
  9. Munda v Western Australia (2013) 302 ALR 207.Google Scholar
  10. R v Gladue [1999] 1 SCR 688.Google Scholar
  11. R v Minor (1992) 105 FLR 180.Google Scholar
  12. R v Murrell & Bummaree [1836] NSWSC 35 (5 February 1836).Google Scholar
  13. Re. Anthony (2004) 142 A Crim R 440.Google Scholar
  14. The Queen v Sims & Walker [2012] NTSC (Unreported, 27 February).Google Scholar
  15. Walker v State of New South Wales (1994) 182 CLR 45.Google Scholar
  16. Wong v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 584.Google Scholar

Secondary materials

  1. Aboriginal Provisional Government. (1990). Towards Aboriginal Sovereignty. Online article. Aboriginal Provisional Government.
  2. Alfred, T. (1999). Peace, power, righteousness: An Indigenous manifesto. Ton Mills, ON: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  3. Alfred, T. (2005). Wasáse: Indigenous pathways of action and freedom. Peterborough, ON: Broadway Press.Google Scholar
  4. Alfred, T. (2009). Restitution is the real pathway to justice for Indigenous peoples. In G. Younging, J. Dewar, & M. DeGagné (Eds.), Response, responsibility and renewal: Canada’s truth and reconciliation journey (pp. 179–187). Ottawa: Aboriginal Healing Foundation.Google Scholar
  5. Alfred, T., & Corntassel, J. (2005). Being Indigenous: Resurgences against contemporary colonialism. Government and Opposition, 40(4), 597–614.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Anthony, T. (2009). Indigenous people, crime and punishment. Oxford: Routledge.Google Scholar
  7. Anthony, T. (2013). Commentaries on colonialism: Australian judicial interpretation. In W. Prest (Ed.), Blackstone and his commentaries biography, law, history (pp. 129–150). Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
  8. Anthony, T., & Blagg, H. (2013). STOP in the name of who’s law? Driving and the regulation of contested space in central Australia. Social & Legal Studies, 22(1), 43–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Anthony, T., & Chapman, R. (2008). Unresolved tensions: Warlpiri law, police powers and land rights. Indigenous Law Bulletin, 7(5), 9–18.Google Scholar
  10. Anthony, T., & Crawford, W. (2014). Northern Territory Indigenous community sentencing mechanisms: An order for substantive equality. Australian Indigenous Law Review, 17(2), 79–99.Google Scholar
  11. Anthony, T., Bartels, L., & Hopkins, A. (2015). Lessons lost in sentencing: Welding individualised justice to Indigenous justice. Melbourne University Law Review, 39(1), 47–76.Google Scholar
  12. April, S., & Orsi, M. (2013). Gladue practices in the provinces and territories. Ottawa: Department of Justice.Google Scholar
  13. Ashworth, A. (2002). Sentencing. In M. Maguire, R. Morgan, & R. Reiner (Eds.), Oxford handbook of criminology (3rd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  14. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2015). Prisoners in Australia (No. 4517.0). Canberra, ACT: Author.Google Scholar
  15. Australian Institute of Criminology. (2014). Australian crime: Facts and figures. Canberra: Author.Google Scholar
  16. Banks, A. (2015, August 14) Aboriginal court gets the chop. Western Australian.Google Scholar
  17. Behrendt, L. (2002). Aboriginal women and the criminal justice system. Judicial Officers’ Bulletin, 16(6), 41–44.Google Scholar
  18. Beranger, B., Weatherburn, D., & Moffatt, S. (2010). Reducing indigenous contact with the court system. Crime and Justice Statistics Bureau Brief, 54, 1–4.Google Scholar
  19. Blagg, H. (2008). Colonial critique and critical criminology: Issues in aboriginal law and aboriginal violence. In T. Anthony & C. Cunneen (Eds.), The critical criminology companion (pp. 129–146). Sydney: Hawkins Press.Google Scholar
  20. Blokland, J. (2007, September 7). The Northern Territory experience. Paper presented at Australian Institute of Judicial Administration Indigenous Courts Conference at Mildura. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Judicial Administration.Google Scholar
  21. Borowski, A. (2011). In Courtroom 7—The children’s Koori Court at work: Findings from an evaluation. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 55(7), 1110–1134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Borowski, A. (2010). Indigenous participation in sentencing young offenders: Findings from an evaluation of the children’s Koori Court of Victoria. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 43(3), 465–484.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. British House of Commons. (1837). Report of the Select Committee on Aborigines. British Parliamentary Papers No 15.Google Scholar
  24. Burgess, C., Johnston, F., Bowman, D., & Whitehead, P. (2005). Healthy country: Healthy people? Exploring the health benefits of Indigenous natural resource management. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 29(2), 117–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Central Land Council. (2013). Kurdiji building opening day. Online report. Central Land Council.
  26. Corntassel, T. (2012). Re-envisioning resurgence: Indigenous pathways to decolonization and sustainable self-determination. Decolonization: Indigeneity Education & Society, 1(1), 86–101.Google Scholar
  27. Coulthard, G. (2014). Red Skin, White Masks: Rejecting the politics of recognition. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Cultural and Indigenous Research Centre Australia. (2008). Evaluation of circle sentencing program. Sydney: NSW Attorney General’s Department.Google Scholar
  29. Cuneen, C. (2016). How ‘tough on crime’ politics flouts death-in-custody recommendations. Online article. The Conversation.
  30. Cunneen, C. (2001). Conflict, politics and crime: Aboriginal communities and the police. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
  31. Cunneen, C., Baldry, E., Brown, D., Schwartz, M., Steel, A., & Brown, M. (2013). Penal culture and hyperincarceration: The revival of the prison. Oxon: Routledge.Google Scholar
  32. Dick, D. (2006, February 10–12). Circle sentencing of aboriginal offenders. Paper presented at the Conference on Sentencing: Principles, Perspectives and Possibilities, Canberra. Sydney: Indigenous Justice Clearinghouse.Google Scholar
  33. Edney, R. (2005). Imprisonment as a last resort for Indigenous offenders: Some lessons from Canada? Indigenous Law Bulletin, 6(12), 23–26.Google Scholar
  34. Eggleston, E. (1976). Fear, favour or affection: Aborigines and the criminal law in Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia. Canberra: Australian National University Press.Google Scholar
  35. Fitzgerald, J. (2009). Why are indigenous imprisonment rates rising? Crime and Justice Statistics Issues Paper, 41, 1–6.Google Scholar
  36. Fitzgerald, J. (2008). Does circle sentencing reduce aboriginal offending? Crime and Justice Bulletin: Contemporary Issues in Crime and Justice, 115, 1–12.Google Scholar
  37. Gaykamangu, J. (2012). Ngarra law: Aboriginal customary law from Arnhem Land. Northern Territory Law Journal, 2(4), 236–248.Google Scholar
  38. Gaymarani, G. (2011). An introduction to the Ngarra Law of Arnhem Land. Northern Territory Law Journal, 1, 283–304.Google Scholar
  39. Gondarra, D. (2006). Traditional law is keeping the peace on aboriginal lands. Media Release. Aboriginal Resource and Development Services, Accessed June 25, 2007.
  40. Gondarra, D. (2011, March 3). Assent law of the first people: Views from a traditional owner. National Indigenous Times, p. 24.Google Scholar
  41. Hannah-Moffat, K., & Maurutto, P. (2010). Recontextualising pre-sentence reports: Risk and race. Punishment and Society, 12(3), 262–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Hannam, H. (2013, July 18). Current issues in delivering indigenous justice: Challenges for the courts. Paper presented to the Australian Institute of Judicial Administration Conference, Adelaide. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Judicial Administration.Google Scholar
  43. Harris, C. (1993). Whiteness as property. Harvard Law Review, 106(8), 1707–1791.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Hasluck, P. (1953). Native welfare in Australia. Perth: Patterson Brokenshaw.Google Scholar
  45. Hasluck, P. (1988). Shades of darkness: Aboriginal affairs 1925–1965. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.Google Scholar
  46. Haswell, M., Williams, M., Blignault, I., Grand Ortega, M., & Jackson Pulver, L. (2014). Returning home, back to community from custodial care: Learnings from the first year pilot project evaluation of three sites around Australia. Sydney: Muru Marri, UNSW Australia School of Public Health and Community Medicine.Google Scholar
  47. Hinton, R., Kavanagh, D. J., Barclay, L., Chenhall, R., & Nagel, T. (2015). Developing a best practice pathway to support improvements in Indigenous Australians’ mental health and well-being: A qualitative study. BMJ Open,. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-007938.Google Scholar
  48. Hogg, R. (2001). Penality and modes of regulating indigenous people in Australia. Punishment and Society, 3(3), 355–379.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Hudson, B. (2006). Punishing monsters, judging aliens: Justice at the borders of community. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 39(2), 232–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Hunyor, J. (2015). Imprison Me NT: Paperless arrests and the rise of executive power in the Northern Territory. Indigenous Law Bulletin, 8(21), 3–9.Google Scholar
  51. Jeffries, S., & Bond, C. (2009). Does indigeneity matter? Sentencing indigenous offenders in South Australia’s higher courts. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 42(1), 47–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Jeffries, S., & Stenning, P. (2014). Sentencing aboriginal offenders: Law, policy, and practice in three countries. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 56, 447–494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Karp, P. (2016, March 19). Indigenous organisations have been “disadvantaged” by grants program. The Guardian.Google Scholar
  54. Kurdiji—Lajamanu Law and Justice Group. (2014). Kurdiji. Online report. Lajamanu Visitor Guide
  55. Lockwood, K., Hart, T. C., & Stewart, A. (2015). First nations peoples and judicial sentencing: Main effects and the impact of contextual variability. British Journal of Criminology, 55(4), 769–789.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Loy, D. (2010). Bush law. Message Stick [Television programme]. Sydney, NSW: Australian Broadcasting Corporation.Google Scholar
  57. Luke, G., & Cunneen, C. (1998). Sentencing aboriginal people in the Northern Territory: A statistical analysis. Sydney: Institute of Criminology, Sydney University Law School.Google Scholar
  58. Marchetti, E. (2010). Indigenous sentencing courts and partner violence: Perspectives of court practitioners and elders on gender power imbalances during the sentencing hearing. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 43(2), 263–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Marchetti, E., & Daly, K. (2007). Indigenous sentencing courts: Towards a theoretical and jurisprudential model. Sydney Law Review, 29(3), 416–443.Google Scholar
  60. Marchetti, E., & Daly, K. (2012). Innovative justice processes. In M. Marmo, W. de Lint, & D. Palmer (Eds.), Crime and justice: A guide to criminology (pp. 455–481). Sydney: Thompson Reuters.Google Scholar
  61. Marchetti, E., & Ransley, J. (2015). Applying the critical lens to judicial officers and legal practitioners involved in sentencing indigenous offenders: Will anyone or anything do? University of New South Wales Law Journal, 37(1), 1–33.Google Scholar
  62. Methven, E. (2014). A very expensive lesson: Counting the costs of penalty notices for anti-social behaviour. Current Issues in Criminal Justice, 26(2), 249–257.Google Scholar
  63. Moreton-Robinson, A. (2003). I still call Australia home: Indigenous belonging and place in a white postcolonising society. In S. Ahmed, C. Cataneda, A. M. Fortier, & M. Shellyey (Eds.), Uproot-ings/regroupings: Questions of postcoloniality, home and place (pp. 23–40). Oxford: Berg.Google Scholar
  64. Morgan, A., & Louis, E. (2010). Evaluation of the Queensland Murri Court: Final report. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.Google Scholar
  65. O’Shane, P. (1992). Aborigines and the criminal justice system. In C. Cunneen (Ed.), Aboriginal perspectives on criminal justice. Sydney: Institute of Criminology, University of Sydney.Google Scholar
  66. Pilkington, J. (2009). Aboriginal communities and the Police’s Taskforce Themis: Case studies in remote aboriginal community policing in the Northern Territory. Darwin: North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency and Central Australian Legal Aid Service.Google Scholar
  67. Pugliese, J. (2007). The event-trauma of the carceral post-human. Social Semiotics, 17(1), 63–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Quinn, J. R. (2016, March 17). Cultivating sympathy and reconciliation: The importance of sympathetic response in the uptake of transitional justice. Paper presented to the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, Atlanta.Google Scholar
  69. Regan, P. (2010). Unsettling the settler within Indian residential schools, truth telling, and reconciliation in Canada. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
  70. Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody. (1991). Final report. Canberra: Australian Government Publisher.Google Scholar
  71. Sherwood, J. (2013). Colonisation—It’s bad for your health: The context of Aboriginal health. Contemporary Nurse, 46(1), 28–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Snowball, L., & Weatherburn, D. (2006). Indigenous over-representation in prison: The role of offender characteristics. Contemporary Issues in Crime and Justice: Crime and Justice Bulletin, 99, 1–20.Google Scholar
  73. Snowball, L., & Weatherburn, D. (2007). Does racial bias in sentencing contribute to indigenous overrepresentation in prison? Australian and New Journal Criminology, 40(3), 272–290.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Steele, L., Dowse, L., & Trofimovs, J. (2016). Who is diverted?: Moving beyond diagnosed impairment towards a social and political analysis of diversion. Sydney Law Review, 38(2), 179–206.Google Scholar
  75. Sutherland, J. (2002). Colonialism, crime, and dispute resolution: A critical analysis of Canada’s aboriginal justice strategy. Online article.
  76. Thomas, B. (1999). Circle sentencing: Involving aboriginal communities in the sentencing process. Discussion Paper. Sydney: New South Wales Aboriginal Justice Advisory Council.Google Scholar
  77. Thorpe, B. (1992). Aboriginal employment and unemployment: Colonised labour. In C. Williams & B. Thorpe (Eds.), Beyond industrial sociology: The work of men and women (pp. 88–107). Sydney: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
  78. Wahlquist, C. (2016, February 25). ‘It’s the same story’: How Australia and Canada are twinning on bad outcomes for Indigenous people. The Guardian,
  79. Watson, J. (1995). “We couldn’t tolerate any more”: The Palm Island Strike of 1957. Labour History, 69, 149–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of TechnologySydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations