Adaptation in Russian Climate Governance

Chapter

Abstract

This chapter presents and discusses the practices of Russian adaptation governance. Climate policy in the country has long considered a changing climate to be a natural phenomenon, not a human-caused problem, and it is only recently that this view has started to change on the official level. Hazardous events caused by the warming climate, such as floods and permafrost degradation, as well as the economic losses resulting from such events, are defined as major national and economic concerns. Most of the current governance efforts focus on emergency response; national plans for pro-active adaptation are only just in the making. The chapter discusses a pilot project to develop an adaptation strategy for the Murmansk region. Russian adaptation governance suffers from the same problems as Russian environmental governance in general: a lack of the material, intellectual and organisational resources needed to tackle the issues and implement concrete plans of action.

Keywords

Adaptation Governance Russia Murmansk Federal Regional Local 

References

  1. Adaptatsiya (2009). (Adaptation). Informatsionnyy portal “Global’noe izmenenie klimata”. http://www.climatechange.ru/node/371. Retrieved 2 Nov 2009.
  2. Barents observer (2009, Dec 9). Barents rescue 2009. http://www.barentsobserver.com/barents-rescue-2009-.4630842-116320.html. Retrieved 16 Aug 2010.
  3. Climate change doctrine signifies policy shift (2009). Oxford Analytica Daily Brief Service. http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=1739396601&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&. Retrieved 16 Aug 2010.Google Scholar
  4. Climate doctrine project (2009). Klimaticheskaya doktrina Rossiyskoy Federatsii. http://www.mnr.gov.ru/files/part/9500_project_climate_doktrine.doc. Retrieved 1 Aug 2011.
  5. Comprehensive climate strategy for the sustainable development of the Arctic regions of Russia in the circumstances of changing climate (CCS) (2009). Kompleksnye klimaticheskie strategii dlya ustoychivogo razvitiya regionov rossiyskoy Arktiki v usloviyakh izmeneniya klimata, Model’nyy primer Murmanskoy oblasti. Moskva: UNDP & RRETS. http://www.rusrec.ru/files/Murmansk_report_sm.pdf. Retrieved 16 Nov 2009.
  6. Crotty, J., & Crane, A. (2004). Transitions in environmental risk in a transitional economy: Management capability and community trust in Russia. Journal of Risk Research, 7(4), 413–429.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Didyk, V. (2010, Dec 14). Formation of local self-government and administrative reform in Russia: Aims and reality – case of the Murmansk region. Presentation at the BIPE workshop, Rovaniemi, Finland.Google Scholar
  8. Dobrolyubova, Yu. (2008). Vysokiy gradus rossiyskogo severa (More intense clime in the Russian North). Informatsionnoe agenstvo “Rosbalt-Sever” 17/05. http://www.rosbalt.ru/2008/05/17/484476.html. Retrieved 2 Oct 2009.
  9. Dobrolyubova, Yu. (2009). Tayushchaya krasota. Izmenenie klimata i yego posledstviya (Melting beauty. Climate change and its impact). Rossiyskiy regional’nyy ekologicheskiy tsentr Fond im. Genrikha Byollya. http://www.climatechange.ru/files/RREC_Boell_Melting_Beauty.pdf. Retrieved 1 Aug 2011.
  10. Dobrolyubova, Yu.C., & Zhukov, B.B. (2008). 10 samykh populyarnykh zabluzhdeniy o global’nom poteplenii i Kiotskom protokole (10 most popular misunderstandings about global warming and the Kyoto protocol). Russian Regional Environmental Centre: Moskva. http://www.rusrec.ru/files/RREC_Brochure_Top10.pdf. Retrieved 20 Dec 2009.
  11. Ekonomicheskoe obozrenie LOGOS-PRESS (2009). Vsemirnyy bank predosteregaet (The world bank warns).12.6, 22 (806). http://aafnet.integrum.ru/artefact3/ia/ia5.aspx?lv=6&si=AmHkak2R&qu=231&st=0&bi=7299&xi=&nd=1&tnd=0&srt=0&f=0. Retrieved 5 Dec 2009.
  12. EMERCOM (2003). Arctic rescue. Initiative proposed by the EMERCOM of Russia. http://eppr.arctic-council.org/pdf/ArcticRescue.pdf. Retrieved 16 Aug 2010.
  13. EMERCOM (2010). EMERCOM of Russia. http://www.mchs.gov.ru/en/. Retrieved 16 Aug 2010.
  14. Emerson, C. (2007). Russia has reasons to turn up the heat in the Arctic. Financial Times Apr 16, 2010, p. 9.Google Scholar
  15. Final statement of the participants of the international conference “Adaptation to climate change and its role in ensuring sustainable development of regions” (2008). http://www.rusrec.ru/files/Final%20statement_eng.doc. Retrieved 12 Dec 2009.
  16. Forbes, B., & Stammler, F. (2009). Arctic climate change discourse: The contrasting politics of research agendas in the West and Russia. Polar Research, 28, 28–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Gavrilov, V. (2007). Voyny iz-za tepla. Eksperty OON predrekayut global’nye konflikty na pochve izmeneniya klimata (War on heat. UN experts predict global conflicts caused by climate change). RBK daily. Rossiyskaya akademiya nauk. http://www.ras.ru/digest/showdnews.aspx?_language=ru&id=0765f7f1-654d-4644-8b41-b01fcca117c6. Retrieved 22 Nov 2009.
  18. Heusala, A-L. (2005). The transitions of local administration culture in Russia. Kikimora Publications A:12. Helsinki: Gummerus.Google Scholar
  19. Ivanova, M. (2009). Byt’ bolee razumnymi (To be smarter). Nezavisimaya gazeta. Rossiyskaya akademiya nauk 29/9. http://www.ras.ru/digest/showdnews.aspx?_language=ru&id=35195740-74ed-428e-bfe5-9d9d9d1188c3. Retrieved 2 Aug 2011.
  20. Kireeva, A. (2009). Prezidium pravitel’stva RF rassmotrel Klimaticheskuyu doktrinu RF (RF Government Presidium working on the climate doctrine of Russian Federation). Klimat. Bellona 07/05-2009. http://www.bellona.ru/articles_ru/articles_2009/1241686219.67. Retrieved 8 Dec 2009.
  21. Keskitalo, E. C., & Kulyasova, A. (2009). Local adaptation to climate change in fishing villages and forest settlements in Northwest Russia. In S. Nystén-Haarala (Ed.), The changing governance of renewable natural resources in Northwest Russia (pp. 227–243). Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  22. Klimenko, B. (2005). Global’nye izmeneniya klimata: Chto zhdet Rossiyu (Global warming: What is in store for Russia?). Polit.Ru. http://www.polit.ru/analytics/2005/01/12/klim.html. Retrieved 22 Oct 2009.
  23. Kokorin, A. (2009). V Rosii prinyata Klimaticheskaya doktrina (Climate doctrine adopted in Russia). WWF 24/4. http://www.wwf.ru/resources/news/article/4996. Retrieved 1 Dec 2009.
  24. Kokorin, A. O., & Safonov, G. V. (2007). Chto budet posle kiotskogo protokola? (What comes after the Kyoto Protocol?) Mezhdunarodnoe soglashenie ob ogranichenii vybrosov parnikovykh gazov posle 2012 g. Vsemirnyy fond dikoy prirody, WWF Rossii. http://climategroup.org.ua/upl/WWFpost-2012ru.pdf. Retrieved 27 Nov 2009.
  25. Kommersant (2006). Besformennoe bespokoystvo: problemy okruzhayushchey sredy volnuyut zhiteley razvivayushchikhsya stran, no ne vosprinimayutsya kak problema politicheskaya (Formless concern: environmental problems disturb people in developing countries, but are not perceived as a political problem). 28.4.2006. www.kommesant.ru/Doc-rss/670504. Retrieved 1 Dec 2009.
  26. Kompleksnyy plan realizatsii Klimaticheskoy doktriny (2011). Comprehensive plan of implementing the Russian Federation’s climate doctrine for the period until 2020). government.ru/media/2011/4/29/40950/file/730R_pril.doc. Retrieved 3 Aug 2011.
  27. Kontseptsiya dolgosrochnogo sotsial’no-ekonomicheskogo razvitiya RF na period do 2020 g (2008). The Russian Federation’s concept of socio-economic development of the region until 2020. http://www.rusnanonet.ru/download/nano/conception_2020.pdf . Retrieved 24 Aug 2008.
  28. Korppoo, A. (2008, Nov 24). Russia and the post-2012 climate regime: Foreign rather than ­environmental policy. UPI briefing paper 23. http://www.upi-fiia.fi/en/publication/61/. Retrieved 10 June 2011.
  29. Korppoo, A. (2009, June 5). The Russian debate on climate doctrine: Emerging issues on the road to Copenhagen. UPI briefing paper 33. http://www.fiia.fi/en/publication/79/the_russian_debate_on_climate_doctrine/. Retrieved 10 June 2011.
  30. Krechetnikov, A. (2009). Rossiyane o global’nom poteplenii: nam by Vashi zaboty (Russians on global warming: Could we have your worries?). BBC. Russkaya sluzhba.13/10. http://www.bbc.co.uk/russian/russia/2009/10/091012_russia_climate_change_attitude.shtml. Retrieved 1 Nov 2009.
  31. Lafel’d, S., & Rote, Yu. (2007). Rossiya: Energeticheskaya politika i uglerodnyy rynok (Russia: Energy policy and carbon markets). 3C climate change consulting GmbH. http://www.wwf.ru/data/pub/russiaandcarbonmarket_rus.pdf. Retrieved 1 Aug 2011.
  32. Lynch, A. C. (2005). How Russia is not ruled. Reflections on Russian political development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Materialy konferentsii i kruglogo stola po voprosam adaptatsii k izmeneniyu klimata Murmanskoy oblasti (2008). Conference papers for the roundtable on adaptation and climate change in the Murmansk region. RRETS. http://www.rusrec.ru/ru/news/1513. Retrieved 11 Oct 2009.
  34. Medvedev, Yu. (2009). Klimaticheskiy triller: Chelovek ne vinovat v global’nom poteplenii (Climate thriller: man is not guilty of global warming). Rossiyskaya gazeta 04/08. http://www.rg.ru/printable/2009/08/04/poteplenie.html; http://www.rg.ru/2009/08/04/poteplenie.html. Retrieved 12 Nov 2009.
  35. Oldfield, J. D. (2005). Russian nature: Exploring the environmental consequences of societal change. Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  36. Ozharovskiy, A. (2009). Razgovor s prezidentom o climate (A conversation with the president on climate). Klimat Kiotskiy protocol. Bellona 20/04-2009. http://www.bellona.ru/comments/Medvedev-climate. Retrieved 5 Dec 2009.
  37. Parshev, A. R. (2006). Pochemu Rossiya ne Amerika (Why Russia is not America.). Krymskiy most-9D, Forum. http://lib.ru/POLITOLOG/PARSHEW/parshew.txt. Retrieved 16 Jan 2010.
  38. Porfiriev, B. (2001). Institutional and legislative issues in emergency management policy in Russia. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 88, 145–167.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Problemy malochislennykh narodov Rossiyskogo Severa (2007). Narodonaselenie (Settling). 31/03. http://aafnet.integrum.ru.login.ezproxy.ulapland.fi/artefact3/ia/ia5.aspx?lv=6&si=AhYJph2R&qu=221&st=0&bi=5600&xi=&nd=1&tnd=0&srt=0&f=0. Retrieved 22 Nov 2009.
  40. Razuvaev, P. (2006). Bor’ba. Krasnyy Sever (Struggle, Beautiful North). 25/09. http://aafnet.integrum.ru.login.ezproxy.ulapland.fi/artefact3/ia/ia5.aspx?lv=6&si=AhYJph2R&qu=241&st=0&bi=6831&xi=&nd=3&tnd=0&srt=0&f=0. Retrieved 22 Oct 2009.
  41. Riabova, L. (2010, December). State policy in the Russian North, its social outcomes and needs for change. Presentation at the BIPE workshop, Rovaniemi, Finland.Google Scholar
  42. Review of international experience in adaptation of cities to the climate change and further perspectives for developing adaptive strategies for Moscow City (2009). Obzor mezhdunarodnogo opyta v oblasti bol’shikh gorodov k klimaticheskim izmeneniyam i perspektivy razrabotki strategii adaptatsii dlya goroda Moskvy. Proekt “Klimaticheskie strategii dlya rossiyskikh megapolisov”. Fond strategicheskikh programm Ministerstva inostrannykh del Velikobritanii. http://russian-city-climate.ru/adaptation_review.pdf. Retrieved 1 Aug 2011.
  43. Ria “Novosti”. Goryachaya liniya (2009). Rossiya dolzhna kak mozhno skoree nachat’ adaptatsiyu ekonomiki k izmeneniyu klimata (Russia should start to adapt the economy to climate change as soon as possible). VB. 24/06. http://aafnet.integrum.ru.login.ezproxy.ulapland.fi/artefact3/ia/ia5.aspx?lv=6&si=fuEiFb2R&qu=231&st=0&bi=1198&xi=&nd=1&tnd=0&srt=0&f=0. Retrieved 1 Dec 2009.
  44. Roshydromet (2005). Strategic prediction for the period of up to 2010–2015 of climate change expected in Russia and its impact on sectors of the Russian national economy (Strategicheskiy prognoz izmeneniy klimata Rossiyskoy Federatsii na period do 2010–2015 gg i ikh vliyaniya na otrasli ekonomiki Rossii). http://www.meteorf.ru/rgm3d.aspx?RgmFolderID=8fa3a439-2cb4-4d09-b567-36fd11f3f414&RgmDocID=71a57c11-f042-47d7-89b1-7b1c57933f50. Retrieved 26 Jan 2010.
  45. Roshydromet (2008). Assessment report on climate change and its consequences in Russian Federation (Otsenochnyy doklad ob izmeneniyakh klimata i ikh posledstviyakh na territorii Rossiyskoy Federatsii). General summary. Moscow. http://www.meteorf.ru/default_doc.aspx?RgmFolderID=a4e36ec1-c49d-461c-8b4f-167d20cb27d8&RgmDocID=7bd005e1-a689-485c-9b95-aa0a71dcc2be. Retrieved 26 Jan 2010.
  46. Rowe, E. W. (2009). Who is to blame? Agency, causality, responsibility and the role of experts in Russian framings of global climate change. Europe-Asia Studies, 61(4), 593–619.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Russia’s Arctic strategy (2008). Vyezdnoe soveshchanie po strategicheskomu planirovaniyu “O zashchite natsional’nykh interesov Rossiyskoy Federatsii v Arktike” 13.9.2008. http://www.scrf.gov.ru/news/349.html. Retrieved 7 Nov 2009.
  48. Russian progress report (2007). Doklad ob ochevidnom progresse v vypolnenii obyazatel’stv Rossiyskoy Federatsii po Kiotskomu protokolu. Moskva. http://unfcc.int/resource/doc/dpr/rus1.pdf . Retrieved 15 Nov 2009.
  49. Shestopalov, M. (2008). Vektor ustremleniy – Arktika: problemy ustoychivogo razvitiya arkticheskoy zony Rossii (The direction of aspirations – The Arctic: Challenges for sustainable development of the Russian Arctic). Geopolitika i geostrategiya 10/11. http://aafnet.integrum.ru.login.ezproxy.ulapland.fi/artefact3/ia/ia5.aspx?lv=6&si=TOfEdM2R&qu=221&st=0&bi=5480&xi=&nd=1&tnd=0&srt=0&f=0. Retrieved 22 Nov 2009.
  50. Sheyermeer, K. (2009). Perestroyka i vechnaya merzlota: Moskva nachinaet proyavlyat’ interes k izmeneniyam klimata (Perestroika and permafrost: Moscow begins to show interest in climate change). Inoforum 28/5. http://inoforum.ru/inostrannaya_pressa/perestrojka_i_vechnaya_merzlota_moskva_nachinaet_proyavlyat_interes_k_izmeneniyam_klimata. Retrieved 27 Oct 2009.
  51. Smol’yakova, T. (2009). Priroda nakazhet rublem: Yesli segodnya ne brat’ v raschet izmeneniya klimata, zavtra eto privedet k snizheniyu VVP (Nature will punish the ruble: If we do not take into account climate change today, tomorrow it will cause the GDP to decrease). Rossiyskaya gazeta Ekonomika “ Ekologiya” 4938 (112) 23/06. http://www.rg.ru/printable/2009/06/23/trutnev.html. Retrieved 11 Dec 2009.
  52. Tennberg, M. (2007). International environmental cooperation in Northwest Russia: An assessment of performance. Polar Record, 43(226), 231–238.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Tennberg, M. (2009). Regional governance, path-dependency and capacity-building in international environmental cooperation. In S. Nystén-Haarala (Ed.), Changing governance of ­renewable natural resources in Northwest Russia (pp. 245–257). Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  54. Terez, E. I. (2004). Ustoychivoe razvitie i problemy izmeneniya global’nogo klimata zemli (Sustainable development and problems of global warming). Mezhdistsiplinarnaya ­ploshchadka poteplenie.ru. Tavricheskiy natsional’nyy universitet im. Vernadskogo, 17(56), 181–205. http://www.poteplenie.ru/doc/terez.htm. Retrieved 15 Oct 2009.Google Scholar
  55. Toschenko, Z., & Tsikov, T. (2006). The formation of democracy and self-governance in Russia. In S. Szücs & L. Strömberg (Eds.), Local elites, political capital and democratic development governing leaders in seven European countries (pp. 234–255). Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.Google Scholar
  56. Treyvish, A. (2003). Nasha strana samaya kholodnaya v mire (Our country is the coldest in the world). Znanie-sila. 5/03, Sankt Peterburgu trista let: I eto vse Rossiya. http://www.znanie-sila.ru/online/issue2print_2159.html. Retrieved 8 Dec 2009.
  57. Tynkkynen, N. (2008). Constructing the environmental regime between Europe and Russia. Conditions for social learning. http://acta.uta.fi/pdf/978-951-44-7268-8.pdf. Retrieved 16 Aug 2010.
  58. Uyazvimost’ i adaptatsiya (2009). Vulnerability and adaptation. Informatsionnyy portal “Global’noe izmenenie klimata”. http://www.climatechange.ru/node/3. Retrieved 5 Dec 2009.
  59. Volodin, E. (2009). Dostovernost’ prognoza budushchikh izmeneniy (Reliability of the prediction of future changes). http://83.149.207.89/GCM_DATA_PLOTTING/documents/forecast.pdf. Retrieved 1 Aug 2011.
  60. Yanitzky, O. N. (2000). Russian greens in a risk society: A structural analysis. Kikimora Publications B:11. Helsinki.Google Scholar
  61. ZumBrunnen, C. (2009). Climate change in the Russian North: Threats real and potential. In E. W. Rowe (Ed.), Russia and the North (pp. 53–85). Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V.  2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Arctic CentreUniversity of LaplandRovaniemiFinland

Personalised recommendations