Evaluating New Technologies pp 93-117
Facts or Fiction? A Critique on Vision Assessment as a Tool for Technology Assessment
This essay questions the concept of vision assessment as an appropriate tool for technology assessment on methodological, anthropological and ethical levels, and shows its epistemic neighbourhood to the scenario-techniques. In general, the central idea of a “future technology” is critically analyzed, backed with central examples drawn from nanotechnology, human doping techniques, and social neuroscience. Main concepts that are used for critique are (a) feasibility and desirability, (b) discourse and debate, and (c) vision and utopia. In addition, the essay reflects on the new genre of pop science, a mixture of science and popular writing on which the concept of vision assessment heavily depends.
KeywordsVision assessment Pop science Social neuroscience Doping Nanotechnology Technology assessment Utopia Imagination Desirability Discourse
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.