Alternative Solutions to Preserve the Sovereignty of Atoll Island States

  • Lilian Yamamoto
  • Miguel Esteban
Chapter
First Online:

Abstract

Atoll Island States could face the future challenge of attempting to preserve their statehood after completely losing their current territory and population. Discussions on how this problem could be solved often focus on attempts to preserve the elements of statehood required by the 1933 Montevideo Convention. Typically the solutions that have been proposed try to repair the lack of one of these elements, such as the possibility of another State ceding some territory, the building of artificial islands, or the merger with another State. However, there are historical and contemporary precedents of sovereign entities which have survived without all the elements required by the Montevideo Convention. The chapter will argue that since the recognition of a State as such requires a blend of both law and politics, the same will be necessary to assure the continuity of statehood of Atoll Island States. In order to discuss this continuity, the constitutive and declarative theories of statehood will be examined. Once an Atoll Island State has lost one of the elements of statehood required by the Montevideo Convention statehood continuity could rely on the constitutive theory, despite it generally being related to the birth of States. The recognition by other subjects of international law of the continuity of statehood of Atoll Island States can have a reparative function for the lack of territory and population. Thus, statehood continuity is not necessarily linked to the maintenance of all the elements of statehood required by the Montevideo Convention.

Keywords

Security Council Constitutive Theory Political Trusteeship Diplomatic Relation Permanent Population 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. Acquaviva G (2005) Subjects of international law: a power-based analysis. Vanderbilt J Int Law 38(2):345–396Google Scholar
  2. Agnew J (2004) Sovereignty regimes: territoriality and state authority in contemporary world politics. Ann Assoc Am Geogr 95(2):437–461CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Agnew J (2005) Territoriality and state authority in contemporary world politics. Ann Assoc Am Geogr 95(2):437–461CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Allen S (2008) International law and the resettlement of the (outer) Chagos Islands. Hum Rights Law Rev 8(4):683–702CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Anghie A (1999) Finding the peripheries: sovereignty and colonialism in nineteenth century international law. Harv Int Law J 40 (1):1–71. Available at http://teachers.colonelby.com/krichardson/grade%2012/carleton%20%20int%20law%20course/week%203/findingperipheries.pdf. Accessed 7 July 2012
  6. Barnett J, Adger WN (2003) Climate dangers and atoll countries. Clim Change 61:321–337CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Barnett J, Campbell J (2010) Climate change and small island states: power, knowledge and the South Pacific. Earthscan Ltd., London, UK. ISBN 978-1-84407-494-5Google Scholar
  8. Bathon M (2001) The atypical international status of the Holy See. Vanderbilt J Transnatl Law 34(3):597–632Google Scholar
  9. BBC (2012a) Maldives President Mohamed Nasheed resigns amid unrest, 7 February 2012. Available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16922570. Accessed 15 Aug 2012
  10. BBC (2012b) Somalia profile. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-14094632. Accessed 29 Mar 2012
  11. Beaulac S (2003) Vattel’s doctrine on territory transfers in international law and the cession of Louisiana to the United States of America. Louisiana Law Rev 63:1327–1359Google Scholar
  12. Benedikter T (2009) What is political autonomy about? Fundamental features of political autonomy. In: Benedikter T (ed) Solving ethnic conflict through self-government – a short guide to autonomy in Europe and South Asia. Eurac Research, Bolzano, Esperia srl, Lavis/Trento, pp 5–14. Available at http://www.eurac.edu/en/research/institutes/imr/Documents/Deliverable_No_9_Update_Set_educational_material.pdf. Accessed 15 June 2012
  13. Biswas S (2002) W(h)ither the Nation State? National and State Identity in the face of fragmentation and globalization. Glob Soc 16(2):175–198CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Boege V (2010) Challenges and pitfalls of resettlement measures: experiences in the Pacific Region. Paper presented at the ESF-UniBi-ZiF research conference on environmental change and migration: from vulnerabilities to capabilities, Bad Salzuflen, 5–9 December 2010. COMCAD Working Papers, No. 12Google Scholar
  15. Bradley R (1999) Diego Garcia-Britain in the dock. IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin Spring 82–88. https://www.dur.ac.uk/resources/ibru/publications/full/bsb7-1_bradley.pdf. Accessed 16 May 2012
  16. Burkett M (2011) The nation ex-situ, on climate change, deterritorialized nationhood and the post-climate era. Clim Law 2:345–374Google Scholar
  17. Campbell J et al. (2005) Community relocation as an option for adaptation to the effects of climate change and climate variability in Pacific Island countries (Asia Pacific Network for Global change research). http://www.sprep.org/att/irc/ecopies/pacific_region/643.pdf. Accessed 7 Mar 2012
  18. Caron D (1990) When law makes climate change worse: rethinking the law of baselines in light of a rising sea level. Ecol Law Q 17:621–653Google Scholar
  19. Connel J, Brown RPC (2005) Remittances in the Pacific, an overview, Asian Development Bank. Available at http://apgml.org/frameworks/docs/8/ADB_remittances-pacific_Mar2005.pdf. Accessed 13 June 2012
  20. Convention on the Cession of Danish West Indies (1917) Between the United States and Denmark, January 25, 1917. Available on the Internet at http://www.doi.gov/oia/about/upload/vitreaty.pdf. Accessed 22 Aug 2011
  21. Crawford J (2006) The creation of states in international law. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  22. Displacement Solutions (2009) Climate-change displaced people and housing, land and property rights. Preliminary strategies for rights-based planning and programming to resolve climate-induced displacement. http://displacementsolutions.org/files/documents/DS_Climate_change_strategies.pdf. Accessed 4 Nov 2012
  23. Edwards JB (2011) A small rock sample with a big impact’ Phosphate mining and the relocation of the Banabans to northern Fiji in 1945: lessons for climate change-forced displacement, Mining and mining policy in the Pacific: history, challenges and perspectives, Nouméa, 21–25 November 2011Google Scholar
  24. Eggers AK (2007) Sharpening the cutting edge of International Human Rights Law: unresolved issues of war crimes tribunals: when is a state a state? The case for recognition of Somaliland. Boston College Int Comp Law Rev 30(12):211–222Google Scholar
  25. Emanueli C (2003) State Succession, then and now, with special reference to the Louisiana purchase (1803). Louisiana Law Rev 63(4):1277–1291Google Scholar
  26. Encyclopedia Britannica (2012) Banaba. Available at http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/51280/Banaba. Accessed 23 Mar 2012
  28. Farley BR (2010) Calling a state a state: Somaliland and international recognition. Emory Int Rev 24:777–820Google Scholar
  29. Ferris E et al. (2011) On the front line of climate change and displacement learning from and with Pacific Island countries, The Brooking Institute –project on international displacement. Available at internet at http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/reports/2011/9/idp%20climate%20change/09_idp_climate_change.pdf. Accessed 16 Dec 2012
  30. Gagain M (2012) Climate change, sea level rise, and artificial islands: saving the Maldives’s statehood and maritime claims though the ‘constitution of the oceans’. Colo J Int Environ Law Policy 23(1):77–120Google Scholar
  31. Grant TD (1997) Between diversity and disorder: a review of Jorri C. Duursma, fragmentation and the international relations of micro-states: self-determination and statehood. Am Univ Int Law Rev 12(4):629–686Google Scholar
  32. Grant TD (1999) Defining statehood: the Montevideo Convention and its discontents. Columbia J Transnatl Law 37(2):403–457Google Scholar
  33. Grant TD (2000) States newly admitted to the United Nations. Columbia J Int Law 39(1):177–192Google Scholar
  34. Hayashi M (2010) The adverse impacts of sea level rise on the rights of islands and island states over their surrounding sea areas: procedural options of international legal measures for mitigating impacts. In: Proceedings of international seminar on Islands and Oceans, Ocean Policy Research Foundation, Tokyo, 2010, pp 103–111Google Scholar
  35. Hindmarsh G (2002) One minority people – a report on the Banabans-formerly of Banama (Ocean Island) who were relocated to Rabi Island in Fiji. Available at http://www.banaban.info/Minpeople.pdf. Accessed 10 June 2012
  36. Jakarta Post (2010) Government approves plan to rent Tabuhan Island to Maldives investor, April 1, 2010. Available at http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2010/04/01/govt-approves-plan-rent-tabuhan-island-maldives-investor.html. Accessed 8 Feb 2011
  37. Jennings RY (1963) The acquisition of territory in International Law. Manchester University Press, ManchesterGoogle Scholar
  38. Kelman I (2006) Island security and disaster diplomacy in the context of climate change. Les Cahiers de la Sécurité 63:61–94. English version available at http://www.disasterdiplomacy.org/kelman2006cce.pdf. Accessed 20 Dec 2012
  39. Kelman I (2008) Island evacuation. Forced Migr Rev 31:20–21Google Scholar
  40. Kempf W (2011) Translocal entwinements: toward a history of Rabi as a Plantation Island in Colonial Fiji, Göttingen: GOEDOC, Dokumenten- und Publikationsserver der Georg-August-Universität. Available at http://webdoc.sub.gwdg.de/pub/mon/2011/kempf.pdf. Accessed 25 Dec 2012
  41. Kitaguchi M et al. (2004) Economic vulnerabilities – Banabans-Japanese relations, Islands of the World VIII. International conference, Changing Islands- Changing Worlds, 1–7 November 2004, Kinmen Island, Taiwan, pp 842–851Google Scholar
  42. Kreijen G (2004) State failure, sovereignty and effectiveness: legal lessons from the decolonization of sub-Sahara Africa. Koninklyke Brill NV, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  43. Kumar S et al. (2006) Poverty and deprivation amongst ethnic minorities in Fiji: the case of Ni Solomoni and Rabi Islanders. Fijian Stud 4(1):125–142Google Scholar
  44. Lacey M (2006) The Signs Say Somaliland, but the World Says Somali. The New York Times, 5th June 2006. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/06/05/world/africa/05somaliland.html?_r=1. Accessed 29 Mar 2012
  45. Maas A, Carius A (2012) Territorial integrity and sovereignty: climate change and security in the Pacific and beyond. In: Scheffran J et al. (eds) Climate change, human security and violent conflict, Springer, Heidelberg, pp 651–665Google Scholar
  46. Maclellan N (2009) The future is here: climate change in the Pacific. Oxfam report. www.oxfam.org.au/climate-change. Accessed 23 Dec 2011
  47. Martens K (2006) The position of the Holy See and Vatican City State in international relations. Univ Detroit Mercy Law Rev 83:729–760Google Scholar
  48. Martin SF (2010) Climate change and international migration, by the German Marshall Fund of the United States. Available at http://www.ehs.unu.edu/file/get/7103. Accessed 10 Dec 2012
  49. McAdam J (2011) Refusing refuge in the Pacific: (de)constructing climate-induced displacement in International Law. In: Piguet E et al. (eds) Migration, environment and climate change. UNESCO, Paris, pp 102–137Google Scholar
  50. McAdam J (2012) Climate change, forced migration, and international law. Oxford University Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. McConnell F (2009a) Governments-in-exile: statehood, statelessness and the reconfiguration of territory and sovereignty. Geogr Compass 3(5):1902–1919CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. McConnell F (2009b) Democracy-in-exile: the “uniqueness” and limitations of exile in Tibetan Democracy. Sociol Bull 58(1):115–144Google Scholar
  53. Mimura et al. (2007) Small islands. Climate change impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the 4th Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  54. Nauvel C (2006) A return from exile in sight? The Chagossians and their struggle. Northwestern J Int Hum Rights 5(1):96–126Google Scholar
  55. Oppenheim L (1905) International law- a treatise, volume I-Peace Longmans, Green and Co. LondonGoogle Scholar
  56. Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat (2012) http://www.forumsec.org/pages.cfm/about-us/member-countries/#tuvalu. Accessed 10 May 2012
  57. Raič D (2002) Statehood and the law of self-determination. Martinus Nijhoff, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  58. Rakova U (2009) How-to guide for environmental refugees. Ourworld 2.0. http://ourworld.unu.edu/en/how-to-guide-for-environmental-refugees/. Accessed 23 Aug 2009
  59. Randeep R (2008) Paradise almost lost: Maldives seek to buy a new homeland. The Guardian, November 10, 2008. Available at http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2008/nov/10/maldives-climate-change. Accessed 8 Feb 2011
  60. Rayfuse R (2009) Whither Tuvalu? International law and disappearing states, University of New South Wales Faculty of Learch Series, Research Paper No. 2009-9Google Scholar
  61. Rayfuse R (2010) International law and disappearing States: utilizing maritime entitlements to overcome the statehood dilemma, University of New South Wales Faculty of Law Research Series, paper 52Google Scholar
  62. Reardon S (2012) Pacific island to buy piece of Fiji as climate plan. Available on the internet at http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn21581-pacific-island-to-buy-piece-of-fiji-as-climate-plan.html. Accessed 21 Mar 2012
  63. Renaud F et al. (2007) Control, adapt or flee- how to face environmental migration? Intersections, Interdisciplinary Security Connections Publication Series of UNU-EHS, No. 5/2007Google Scholar
  64. Secretariat of the Pacific Community (2007) Kiribati 2005, Volume 2: analytical report. Census available at http://www.spc.int/prism/country/KI/stats/Census2005/reports/KIR%20Report%202005%20-%20Volume%20II%20-%20FINAL.pdf. Accessed 16 Sept 2012
  65. Sigragh KR, King S (2004) Essentially being Banaban in today’s world: the role of Banaban Law “TE RII NI BANABA” (Backbone of Banaba). In: A changing world, islands of the world VIII conference, Kinmen Island, 1–7 November 2004, pp 1032–1050. Available at internet at http://www.banaban.info/ISISA2004Paper-Ken.pdf. Accessed 16 Dec 2012
  66. Soons HA (1990) The effects of a rising sea level on maritime limits and boundaries. Netherlands Int Law Rev 37(2):207–232CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Stahl S (2010) Unprotected ground: the plight of vanishing island nations. New York Int Law Rev 23(1)Google Scholar
  68. Teaiwa KM (2005) Our sea of phosphate: the diaspora of Ocean Island. In: Harvey G, Thompson CD Jr (eds) Indigenous diasporas and dislocations: Unsettling Western Fixations. Ashgate, London, pp 169–192Google Scholar
  69. The Sovereign Military Hospitaller Order of Saint John of Jerusalem Official Website (2008) http://www.orderofmalta.org/site/struttura.asp?idlingua=5. Accessed 1 Aug 2008
  70. Treaty concerning the Cession of Louisiana to United States (1803) 20 October 1803. Available on the internet at http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/american_originals/louistxt.html. Accessed 22 Aug 2011
  71. Treaty concerning the Cession of the Russian possessions in North America by his Majesty the Emperor of all the Russians to the United States of America (1867) June 20, 1867. Available on the Internet at http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llsl&fileName=015/llsl015.db&recNum=572. Accessed 22 Aug 2011
  72. UN High Commissioner for Refugees (2009) Climate change and statelessness: an overview. In: 6th session of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Long-Term Cooperative Action (AWG-LCA 6) under the UNFCCC, Bonn, 1–12 June 2009Google Scholar
  73. UN High Commissioner for Refugees (2011) Climate change and the risk of statelessness: the situation of low-lying island states, PPLA/2011/04. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/refworld/docid/4e09a4ba2.html. Accessed 18 Apr 2012
  74. United Nations (2012) The UN and decolonization history, International Trusteeship System. http://www.un.org/en/decolonization/its.shtml. Accessed 25 May 2013
  75. Vattel E (1758) The law of nations or the principles of natural law, book one, chapter five. Available on the Internet at http://www.lonang.com/exlibris/vattel/vatt-105.htm. Accessed 22 Aug 2011
  76. Wilde R (2009) From trusteeship to self-determination and back again: the role of the Hague regulations in the evolution of international trusteeship, and the framework of rights and duties of occupying powers. Loyola Los Angeles Int Comp Law Rev 31:85–142Google Scholar
  77. Worster WT (2009) Law, politics, and the conception of the state in state recognition theory. Boston Univ Int Law J 27(115):115–170Google Scholar
  78. Yamamoto L, Esteban M (2010) Sovereignty issues of the disappearance of island states. Ocean Coastal Management J 53:1–10, doi:  10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2009.10.003 Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  • Lilian Yamamoto
    • 1
  • Miguel Esteban
    • 2
  1. 1.LondrinaBrazil
  2. 2.Graduate School of Frontier SciencesThe University of TokyoChibaJapan

Personalised recommendations