Invariance Properties of Quantifiers and Multiagent Information Exchange
The paper presents two case studies of multi-agent information exchange involving generalized quantifiers. We focus on scenarios in which agents successfully converge to knowledge on the basis of the information about the knowledge of others, so-called Muddy Children puzzle  and Top Hat puzzle. We investigate the relationship between certain invariance properties of quantifiers and the successful convergence to knowledge in such situations. We generalize the scenarios to account for public announcements with arbitrary quantifiers. We show that the Muddy Children puzzle is solvable for any number of agents if and only if the quantifier in the announcement is positively active (satisfies a version of the variety condition). In order to get the characterization result, we propose a new concise logical modeling of the puzzle based on the number triangle representation of generalized quantifiers. In a similar vein, we also study the Top Hat puzzle. We observe that in this case an announcement needs to satisfy stronger conditions in order to guarantee solvability. Hence, we introduce a new property, called bounded thickness, and show that the solvability of the Top Hat puzzle for arbitrary number of agents is equivalent to the announcement being 1-thick.
Keywordsgeneralized quantifiers number triangle invariance properties Muddy Children Puzzle Top Hat Puzzle epistemic logic
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 3.Gierasimczuk, N., Szymanik, J.: A note on a generalization of the muddy children puzzle. In: Proceedings of the 13th Conference on Theoretical Aspects of Rationality and Knowledge (TARK 2011), Groningen, The Netherlands, July 12-14. ACM, New York (2011)Google Scholar
- 4.Gierasimczuk, N.: Knowing One’s Limits. Logical analysis of inductive inference. PhD thesis, Universiteit van Amsterdam (2010)Google Scholar
- 7.Peters, S., Westerståhl, D.: Quantifiers in Language and Logic. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2006)Google Scholar
- 11.Tiede, H.J.: Identifiability in the limit of context-free generalized quantifiers. Journal of Language and Computation 1, 93–102 (1999)Google Scholar
- 14.Jain, S., Osherson, D., Royer, J.S., Sharma, A.: Systems that Learn. MIT Press, Chicago (1999)Google Scholar