Evaluating a General Model of Adaptive Tutorial Dialogues
- Cite this paper as:
- Weerasinghe A., Mitrovic A., Thomson D., Mogin P., Martin B. (2011) Evaluating a General Model of Adaptive Tutorial Dialogues. In: Biswas G., Bull S., Kay J., Mitrovic A. (eds) Artificial Intelligence in Education. AIED 2011. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol 6738. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Tutorial dialogues are considered as one of the critical factors contributing to the effectiveness of human one-on-one tutoring. We discuss how we evaluated the effectiveness of a general model of adaptive tutorial dialogues in both an ill-defined and a well-defined task. The first study involved dialogues in database design, an ill-defined task. The control group participants received non-adaptive dialogues regardless of their knowledge level and explanation skills. The experimental group participants received adaptive dialogues that were customised based on their student models. The performance on pre- and post-tests indicate that the experimental group participants learned significantly more than their peers. The second study involved dialogues in data normalization, a well-defined task. The performance of the experimental group increased significantly between pre- and post-test, while the improvement of the control group was not significant. The studies show that the model is applicable to both ill- and well-defined tasks, and that they support learning effectively.
Keywordsadaptive tutorial dialogues constraint-based tutors Ill-defined tasks well-defined tasks
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.