Water Institutional Reforms in Tajikistan

Abstract

This chapter presents the case study on Tajikistan. Its structure is similar to the one on Kyrgyzstan: First, the key political actors in water governance will be described (7.1). Then an overview of the perceptions of the problem will be given and the general policy objectives presented (7.2). The subsequent subchapters deal with the various reforms: the formulation of a policy (7.3.1), the reform of the general legal framework (7.3.2), the introduction of irrigation service fees (7.3.3), and the transfer of irrigation management (7.3.4). In the following discussion of the water institutional reforms, the influence of the neopatrimonial institutional context on the above-mentioned processes and outcomes will be analyzed (chapter 7.4). The final subchapter will summarize the findings of the case study (ch. 7.3.5).

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. 196.
    Author’s interview with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003; with a senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004.Google Scholar
  2. 197.
    Author’s interview with official at the department for foreign investments of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/28/2005.Google Scholar
  3. 198.
    Author’s interview with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003.Google Scholar
  4. 200.
    These are the agencies LoPremo, KTTPremo, Dumo, KTPremo, GBAOPremo, SE “TSHVS” (MIWM, UNDP, EC-IFAS 2006:71).Google Scholar
  5. 201.
    Author’s interview with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003; with the director of the OblVodKhoz Sughd, Khudjand, 09/02/2004.Google Scholar
  6. 202.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003 and with a senior official the OblVodKhoz Sughd, Khudjand, 10/11/2005.Google Scholar
  7. 203.
    Author’s interview with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003.Google Scholar
  8. 204.
    Author’s interview with the director of the OblVodKhoz Sughd, Khudjand, 09/02/2004.Google Scholar
  9. 205.
    Author’s interview with the director of the RaiVodKhoz, Aini, 08/30/2004.Google Scholar
  10. 206.
  11. 207.
    Author’s interview with two officials at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003 and with one senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003; with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003.Google Scholar
  12. 208.
    Author’s interview with director of the NIIGiM, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004.Google Scholar
  13. 209.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003; with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003; with a senior official of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/10/2003.Google Scholar
  14. 210.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003; with an official of a tsentr ispolnenyia of the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/14/2003.Google Scholar
  15. 211.
    Author’s interview with a senior official of the State Land Committee, Dushanbe, 11/01/2005.Google Scholar
  16. 212.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the Ministry of Energetics, Dushanbe, 08/24/2004.Google Scholar
  17. 213.
    Author’s interview with the director of the IWP, Dushanbe, 10/15/2003.Google Scholar
  18. 214.
    University instructors earn about 20 somoni (less than 5 euro) per month. Therefore, they often have additional jobs. Author’s interview with two university professors, Dushanbe, 09/08/2004.Google Scholar
  19. 215.
    Author’s interview with the director of the IWP, Dushanbe, 10/15/2003; with the director of the NIIGiM, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004.Google Scholar
  20. 216.
    Author’s interview with a former senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/23/2004; with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003.Google Scholar
  21. 217.
    Other laws, which will not be presented in detail but that affect water management, are the Law on Mineral Resources, Law on Energetics, Land Code, Law on Payment for Land, Law On State Sanitary Inspection, Forest Code, Law On Veterinary Inspection, Law on Protection and Use of Fauna, Civil Code, Criminal Code, and the annual state budget (Kholmatov 2003: 153).Google Scholar
  22. 218.
    Author’s interview with two officials of the Environmental Ministry, Dushanbe, 10/07/2003; with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003.Google Scholar
  23. 220.
    Author’s interview with a senior official of the MinVodKhoz, 10/10/2003.Google Scholar
  24. 222.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003.Google Scholar
  25. 223.
    Author’s interviews with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003; with two officials of the Environmental Ministry, Dushanbe, 10/07/2003; with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003.Google Scholar
  26. 224.
    Author’s interviews with a senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003; with two officials of the Environmental Ministry, Dushanbe, 10/07/2003; with a senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004; with a professor at a research institute, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004. Only a few experts point out weaknesses. Still, this must not be misinterpreted to indicate that everyone is content with the Code. It may also be a signal of the lower openness of the political system in Tajikistan. In general, it seems that there is no fundamental discontent.Google Scholar
  27. 226.
    Author’s interview with an NGO representative, Dushanbe, 08/25/2004; with a professor of an academic institute, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004; with the director of a RaiVodKhoz, Sughd oblast, 09/01/04.Google Scholar
  28. 229.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004.Google Scholar
  29. 230.
    For example, there is a conflict at the Kairakum reservoir: The dam is in the budget of the OblVodKhoz, while the attached GES is listed in the budget of the Ministry of Energetics. All the costs for dam maintenance have to be covered by the OblVodKhoz, while the Ministry of Energetics does not contribute even though it uses the dam to produce energy, which is perceived as unjust by water officials. Author’s interview with the director of the Sughd OblVodKhoz, Khudjand, 09/02/2004.Google Scholar
  30. 234.
    Author’s interview with a senior official of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/10/2003; with a professor at an academic institute, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004.Google Scholar
  31. 235.
    Author’s interview with the vice-minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003.Google Scholar
  32. 236.
    Vice-director of MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003: 8–9%; senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/10/2003: until 2000: 15–18%; 2000: over 20%, 2001: 40%, 2002: 56%; senior official at the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003: about 50%; director of a RaiVodKhoz, Sughd oblast, 09/01/2003: about 30%; director of the Sughd OblVodKhoz, Khudjand, 09/02/2004: 50–60%.Google Scholar
  33. 237.
    Author’s interview with the director of a RaiVodKhoz, Sughd oblast, 09/01/2003.Google Scholar
  34. 238.
    Author’s interview with a senior official of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004.Google Scholar
  35. 239.
    Author’s interview with the director of the RaiVodKhoz, Aini, 08/30/2004.Google Scholar
  36. 240.
    Author’s interview with Vice-Minister of the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 10/09/2004.Google Scholar
  37. 241.
    Author’s interview with two officials of the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003; with two officials of the Environmental Ministry, Dushanbe, 10/07/2003.Google Scholar
  38. 243.
    Author’s interview with a representative of the World Bank, Dushanbe, 10/21/2003; with a senior official at MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004.Google Scholar
  39. 245.
    Author’s interview with two officials of the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/09/2003.Google Scholar
  40. 246.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004; with a senior official of the CFPS, Dushanbe, 10/13/2003.Google Scholar
  41. 247.
    Sometimes WUAs are established after rehabilitation to maitain the new technique; sometimes the establishment of the WUA is a precondition before rehabilitation starts. The registration costs are often either covered fully or partly by the donor. Occasionally farmers have to cover the costs fully themselves (ACTED 2005, Winrock International 2005).Google Scholar
  42. 250.
    For a detailed list see Sehring 2006: 53–55.Google Scholar
  43. 254.
    Author’s interview with the WUA specialist of the GAA, Aini, 09/27/2005.Google Scholar
  44. 255.
    Author’s interview with a WUA representative, Iskodar, 09/27/2005.Google Scholar
  45. 260.
    Author’s interview with a GAA staff member, Aini, 09/29/2005.Google Scholar
  46. 261.
    Author’s interview with the director of the mahalla committee, Iskodar, 09/30/2005Google Scholar
  47. 262.
    Author’s interview with two representatives of a Jamoat Support Center, Khatlon Oblast, 10/19/2005; with two representatives of a WUA support center, Sughd oblast, 09/01/2004.Google Scholar
  48. 263.
    For an exemplary curriculum see Rakhmatilloev 2003: 107.Google Scholar
  49. 264.
    Author’s interview with director of RaiVodKhoz, Sughd oblast, 09/01/2004.Google Scholar
  50. 265.
    Also with the new Law On WUAs, the legal situation remains ambiguous: In 2007, a new Law on Public Associations was approved and its relevance for WUAs is unclear. Email communication with project officer of INGO, 06/21/2007. And it was also clear before the WUA law was issued that it will not provide clear rules for all WUAs, as not all WUAs which were established by donors fit into the prescriptions of the law (Winrock International 2005: 7).Google Scholar
  51. 266.
    Author’s interviews with an NGO representative, Khudjand, 10/07/2005; with an INGO representative, Khudjand, 10703/2005.Google Scholar
  52. 267.
    Author’s interview with an INGO representative, Khudjand, 10703/2005.Google Scholar
  53. 268.
    Author’s interview with the director of a RaiVodKhoz, Sughd oblast, 09/01/2004.Google Scholar
  54. 269.
    Author’s interviews with a local INGO representative, Khudjand, 10/14/2003; with an NGO director, Khudjand, 09/03/2004; with a local senior official at a donor agency, Khudjand, 10/04/2005; with a local NGO director, Dushanbe 08/25/2004.Google Scholar
  55. 270.
    Author’s interview with a local NGO representative, Khudjand, 10/07/2005.Google Scholar
  56. 271.
    Author’s interview with a local NGO representative, Khudjand, 10/07/2005.Google Scholar
  57. 272.
    Author’s interview with an NGO director, Dushanbe, 08/25/2004.Google Scholar
  58. 276.
    Similar statements were made by two other senior official at the MinVodKhoz, Dushanbe, 08/20/2004; an NGO representative, Khudjand, 09/03/2003; and a professor at an academic institute, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004.Google Scholar
  59. 277.
    Author’s interview with a senior official of the State Land Committee, Dushanbe, 11/01/2005.Google Scholar
  60. 278.
    Author’s interview with a professor of an academic institute, Dushanbe, 09/07/2004.Google Scholar
  61. 281.
    According to IOM, since 2000 about 632,000 men from Tajikistan have worked abroad as migrant laborers (that is almost 10% of the entire population). 84% work in Russia. (AAH 2003: 17).Google Scholar
  62. 282.
    Author’s interview with a local representative of a donor agency, Khudjand, 10/04/2005.Google Scholar
  63. 283.
    Author’s interview with a local representative of an INGO, Khudjand, 10/03/2005.Google Scholar
  64. 284.
    Author’s interview with the director of a RaiVodKhoz, Khatlon oblast, 10/20/2005.Google Scholar
  65. 285.
    Author’s interview with a senior official at the OblVodKhoz, Khudjand, 10/11/2005.Google Scholar
  66. 286.
    Author’s interview with two senior officials of a WUA support center, Sughd oblast, 09/01/2005.Google Scholar
  67. 288.
    Author’s interview with a senior official of the OblVodKhoz, Khudjand, 10/11/2005.Google Scholar
  68. 289.
    Author’s interview with the director of the OblVodKhoz, Khudjand, 09/02/2004.Google Scholar
  69. 290.
    There are also exceptions. The IWRM Fergana project (of SDC, IWMI and NIZ-MKVK) e.g. involves the Sughd OblVodKhoz (Author’s interview with director of OblVodKhoz, Khudjand, 09/02/2004).Google Scholar
  70. 291.
    Author’s interview with an NGO representative, Dushanbe, 08/25/2004, with a RaiVodKhoz director, Sughd Oblast, 09/01/2004.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften | GWV Fachverlage GmbH, Wiesbaden 2009

Personalised recommendations