Advertisement

The European Court of Justice and Human Rights Law

  • Stefan KadelbachEmail author
Chapter

Abstract

This chapter deals with the role that the Court of Justice of the European Union (ECJ) plays in the protection of human rights within the EU and, in particular, its stance vis-à-vis the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) and reconstructs the changing role of the Convention. It starts by recalling the process of development of fundamental rights as a counterweight to intrusions into the individual rights by directly applicable EU law, in which the ECJ used the ECHR as a primary source of inspiration. In the course of this process, the ECJ responded to the competing jurisdiction on fundamental rights of member state constitutional and supreme courts, which had formulated claims of reserved jurisdiction. After the codification of ECJ’s jurisprudence by the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights and its entry into force as binding law, however, the contribution argues that a new phase has begun. Not only does the Court now tend to manifest its claim to exclusive jurisdiction on fundamental rights within the whole field of application of EU law vis-à-vis member states’ judiciaries. It also defends this claim against the European Court of Human Rights by rejecting the EU’s envisaged accession to the ECHR. A final section of the paper briefly looks at the ECJ’s jurisprudence on other international human rights treaties.

References

  1. Alston P, Weiler J (1998) An “Ever Closer Union” in need of a human rights policy. Eur J Int Law 9:658–723CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Anagnostaras G (2016) Mutual confidence is not blind trust! Fundamental rights protection and the execution of the European arrest warrant. Common Mark Law Rev 53:1675–1704Google Scholar
  3. Bernitz U (2015) The Åkerberg Fransson case. In: Nergelius J, Kristoffersson E (eds) Human rights in contemporary European law. Hart, Oxford, pp 191–210Google Scholar
  4. Besselink L (2014) The parameters of constitutional conflict after Melloni. Eur Law Rev 39:531–552Google Scholar
  5. Bogdandy A, Kottmann M, Antpöhler C, Dischen J, Hentrei S, Smrkolj M (2012) Reverse Solange – protecting the essence of fundamental rights against EU member states. Common Mark Law Rev 49:489–519Google Scholar
  6. Britz G (2015) Grundrechtsschutz durch das Bundesverfassungsgericht und den Europäischen Gerichtshof. Europäische Grundrechte-Zeitschrift 42:269–352Google Scholar
  7. Caligiuri A, Napoletano N (2010) The application of the ECHR in the domestic systems. Ital Yearb Int Law 20:125–115Google Scholar
  8. Callewaert J (2008) Unionisation and “Conventionisation” of Fundamental Rights in Europe. In: Wouters J, Nollkaemper PA, de Wet E (eds) The Europeanisation of international law – the status of international law in the EU and its member states. TMC Asser Instituut, The Hague, pp 109–136CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Callewaert J (2014) The accession of the European Union to the European Convention of Human Rights. Council of Europe, StrasbourgGoogle Scholar
  10. Canor I (2013) My brother’s keeper? Horizontal Solange. Common Mark Law Rev 50:383–422Google Scholar
  11. Coppel J, O’Neill A (1992) The European Court of Justice: taking rights seriously? Common Mark Law Rev 29:669–692Google Scholar
  12. Dawson M, Muir E (2011) Individual, institutional and collective vigilance in protecting fundamental rights in the EU: lessons from the Roma. Common Mark Law Rev 48:751–775Google Scholar
  13. de Boer N (2013) Addressing rights divergences under the charter: Melloni. Common Mark Law Rev 50:1083–1104Google Scholar
  14. De Búrca G (2013) After the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: the Court of Justice as a human rights adjudicator? Maastricht J Eur Comp Law 20:168–184CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. De Búrca G (2015) The drafting of the European Charter of Fundamental Rights. Eur Law Rev 40:799–810Google Scholar
  16. de Schutter O (2010) L’adhésion de l’Union européenne à la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme: feuille de route de la négociation. RTDH 83:535–571Google Scholar
  17. Douglas-Scott S (2006) A tale of two courts: Luxembourg, Strasbourg and the growing European Human Rights Acquis. Common Mark Law Rev 43:629–665Google Scholar
  18. Fontanelli F (2013) Hic Sunt Nationes: the elusive limits of the EU Charter and the German constitutional watchdog. Eur Const Law Rev 9:315–334Google Scholar
  19. Giegerich T (2013) Wirkungen und Rang der EMRK in den Rechtsordnungen der Mitgliedstaaten. In: Dörr O, Grote R, Marauhn T (eds) EMRK/GG Konkordanz-Kommentar, 2nd edn. Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, pp 57–98Google Scholar
  20. Grabenwarter C (2015) Konkurrenz und Kooperation zwischen dem Europäischen Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte, dem Europäischen Gerichtshof und dem Bundesverfassungsgericht. In: Schuman E (ed) Hierarchie, Kooperation und Integration im Europäischen Rechtsraum. De Gruyter, Berlin, pp 129–154Google Scholar
  21. Gragl P (2014) A giant leap for European human rights? Common Mark Law Rev 51:13–58Google Scholar
  22. Halberstam D (2015) “It’s the Autonomy, Stupid!” A modest defense of opinion 2/13 on EU accession to the ECHR, and the way forward. Ger Law J 16:105–146CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Halberstam D, Stein E (2009) The United Nations, the European Union and the king of Sweden. Common Mark Law Rev 46:13–72Google Scholar
  24. Harmathy A (2001) Constitutional questions of the preparation of Hungary to accession to the EU. In: Kellermann A, de Zwaan J, Czuczai J (eds) EU enlargement: the constitutional impact at EU and national level. TMC Asser Instituut, The Hague, pp 315–326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Hofmann R (2004) The German federal constitutional court and public international law: new decisions new approaches? Ger Yearb Int Law 47:9–38Google Scholar
  26. Holoubek M (2014) Ein Grundrechtskatalog für Europa. In: Becker U, Hatje A, Potacs M, Wunderlich N (eds) Verfassung und Verwaltung in Europa. Festschrift für Jürgen Schwarze zum 70. Geburtstag. Nomos, Baden-Baden, pp 109–140Google Scholar
  27. Huber P (2011) Auslegung und Anwendung der Charta der Grundrechte. Neue Juristische Wochenschrift 64:2385–2390Google Scholar
  28. Jacqué J (2011) The accession of the European Union to the European Convention on Human Rights and fundamental freedoms. Common Mark Law Rev 48:995–1023Google Scholar
  29. Jacqué J (2015) Pride and/or Prejudice? Les lectures possible de l’avis 2/13 de la Cour de justice. Cahiers de droit europeen 51:19–46Google Scholar
  30. Janik C (2010) Die EMRK und internationale Organisationen – Ausdehnung und Restriktion der equivalent protection-Formel in der neuen Rechtsprechung des EGMR. Heidelberg J Int Law 70:127–117Google Scholar
  31. Keller H, Stone Sweet A (eds) (2008) A Europe of rights: the impact of the ECHR on national legal systems. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  32. Krüger H, Polakiewicz J (2001) Proposals for a coherent human rights protection system in Europe. Human Rights Law J 22:1–13Google Scholar
  33. Kühling J (2011) Fundamental rights. In: von Bogdandy A, Bast J (eds) Principles of European constitutional law, 2nd edn. Hart, Oxford, pp 479–451Google Scholar
  34. Kumm M (1999) Who is the final arbiter of constitutionality in Europe? Common Mark Law Rev 36:351–338Google Scholar
  35. Lamont R (2014) Article 24. In: Peers S, Hervery T, Kenner J, Ward A (eds) The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. A commentary. Hart, Oxford, pp 661–692Google Scholar
  36. Lavranos N (2008) The Solange-method as a tool for regulating competing jurisdictions among international courts and tribunals. Loyola Los Angeles Int Comp Law Rev 30:275–334Google Scholar
  37. Lenaerts K (2012) Exploring the limits of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. Eur Const Law Rev 8:375–403Google Scholar
  38. Lenaerts K, de Smijter E (2001) A “Bill of Rights” for the European Union. Common Mark Law Rev 38:273–300CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lock T (2011) Walking on the tightrope: the draft ECHR accession agreement and the autonomy of the EU legal order. Common Mark Law Rev 48:1025–1054Google Scholar
  40. Lukas K (2015) The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights and the European Social Charter – an alliance for social rights? Eur Yearb Human Rights 15:153–164Google Scholar
  41. Maganaris E (1998) The principle of supremacy of community law – the Greek challenge. Eur Law Rev 23:179–182Google Scholar
  42. Malenovský J (2015) Comment tirer parti de l’avis 2/13 de la Cour de l’Union européenne sur l’adhésion à la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme. RGDIP 119:705–742Google Scholar
  43. Masing J (2015) Einheit und Vielfalt des Europäischen Grundrechtsschutzes. JuristenZeitung 70:477–487CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Merli F (2007) Rechtsprechungskonkurrenz zwischen nationalen Verfassungsgerichten, Europäischem Gerichtshof und Europäischem Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte. Veröffentlichungen der Vereinigung der Deutschen Staatsrechtslehrer 66:392–422Google Scholar
  45. Nergelius J (2015) The accession of the EU to the European Convention on Human Rights – a critical analysis of the opinion of the European Court of Justice. Swed Inst Eur Policy Stud 2015(3)Google Scholar
  46. Nowag J (2016) EU law, constitutional identity, and human dignity: a toxic mix? Bundesverfassungsgericht: Mr R. Common Mark Law Rev 53:1441–1454Google Scholar
  47. Peers S (2015) The EU’s accession to the ECHR: the dream becomes a nightmare. Ger Law J 16:213–222CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Pernice I (2002) The charter of fundamental rights in the constitution of the European Union. WHI Paper 14/02, Available via http://www.whi-berlin.eu/documents/whi-paper1402.pdf. Accessed 16 Mar 2017
  49. Pernice I (2015) L’adhésion de l’Union européenne à la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme est suspendue. Cahiers de droit europeen 51:47–72Google Scholar
  50. Polakiewicz J (2015a) The EU’s accession to the European Convention on Human Rights: a matter of coherence and consistency. In: Morano-Foadi S, Vickers L (eds) Fundamental rights in the EU. A matter for two courts. Hart, Oxford, pp xvii–xxviiGoogle Scholar
  51. Polakiewicz J (2015b) The future of fundamental rights protection without accession. Speech at Maastricht University 26 June 2015Google Scholar
  52. Reinbacher T, Wendel M (2016) Menschenwürde und Europäischer Haftbefehl – Zum ebenenübergreifenden Schutz grundrechtlicher Elementargarantien im europäischen Auslieferungsverfahren. EuGRZ 43:333–343Google Scholar
  53. Ritleng D (2013) De l’articulation des systèmes de protection des droits fondamentaux dans l’Union. RTDeur 267–292Google Scholar
  54. Sabel C, Gerstenberg O (2010) Constitutionalising an overlapping consensus: the ECJ and the emergence of a coordinate constitutional order. Eur Law J 16:511–550CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Sarmiento D (2013) Who’s afraid of the charter? The Court of Justice, National Courts and the new framework of fundamental rights protection in Europe. Common Mark Law Rev 50:1267–1304Google Scholar
  56. Schermers H (1978) The European communities under the European Convention of Human Rights. Leg Issues Econ Integr 5:1–8Google Scholar
  57. Schilling T (2011) Der Beitritt der EU zur EMRK – Verhandlungen und Modalitäten: Fast eine Polemik. Humboldt Forum Recht 8:83–99Google Scholar
  58. Schmahl S (2016) Der Beitritt der EU zur Europäischen Menschenrechtskonvention: Wo liegt das Problem? JuristenZeitung 71:921–928CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Tomuschat C (2010) The effects of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights according to the German constitutional court. Ger Law J 9:513–526CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Tomuschat C (2015) Der Streit um die Auslegungshoheit: Die Autonomie der EU als Heiliger Gral. EuGRZ 42:133–139Google Scholar
  61. Torres Perez A (2014) Melloni in three acts: from dialogue to monologue. Eur Const Law Rev 10:308–331Google Scholar
  62. Toth A (1997) The European Union and human rights: the way forward. Common Mark Law Rev 34:491–529CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. van Bockel B, Wattel P (2013) New Wine into Old Wineskins: the scope of the charter of fundamental rights of the EU after Åkerberg Fransson. Eur Law Rev 38:866–883Google Scholar
  64. van den Berghe F (2010) The EU and issues of human rights protection. Eur Law J 16:112–157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Volkmann U (2015) Doppelt genäht hält besser?. In: Geis ME, Winkler M, Bickenbach C (eds) Von der Kultur der Verfassung. Festschrift für Friedhelm Hufen zum 70. Geburtstag. Beck, Munich, pp 127–136Google Scholar
  66. von Ungern-Sternberg A (2013) Normative Wirkungen von Präjudizien nach der Rechtsprechung des Bundesverfassungsgerichts. Archiv des öffentlichen Rechts 138:1–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Walter C, Vordermayer M (2015) Verfassungsidentität als Instrument richterlicher Selbstbeschränkung in transnationalen Integrationsprozessen. Jahrbuch des öffentlichen Rechts 63:129–166Google Scholar
  68. Weiler J, Lockhart N (1995) “Taking Rights Seriously” seriously: the European Court and its fundamental rights jurisprudence. Common Mark Law Rev 32:51–94 and 579–627Google Scholar
  69. Weiß W (2011) Human rights in the EU: rethinking the role of the European Convention on Human Rights after Lisbon. Eur Const Law Rev 7:64–95Google Scholar
  70. Weiß W (2015) The EU human rights Regime Post Lisbon: turning the CJEU into a human rights court? In: Morano Foadi S, Vuckers L (eds) Fundamental rights in the EU – a matter for two courts. Hart, Oxford, pp 69–89Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Goethe UniversityFrankfurt am MainGermany

Personalised recommendations