Legality Versus Efficiency of Reform

  • Madeleine Martinek


Law is stable; the societies we are speaking of are progressive. The greater or less happiness of a people depends on the degree of promptitude with which the gulf is narrowed.


  1. Ahl B (2015) Zur Revision des Gesetzgebungsgesetzes der Volksrepublik China. ZChinR 22(3):241–251Google Scholar
  2. An C (安晨曦) (2015) Experimental legislation and categorization between experience and norm – a proposal from legislative perspective (在经验与规范之间:试验立法及其类型化、一种立法进路的提倡). Theory of Law Frontier (理论法前沿) (3):112–123Google Scholar
  3. Basedow J (2016) Boosting the economy: Special Economic Zones or nationwide deregulation? In: Basedow J, Kono T (eds) Special Economic Zones. Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, pp 3–22Google Scholar
  4. Bi Y (2015) Experimentalist approach of Chinese legislation model: from passive response to institutional design. The Theory and Practice of Legislation 3(2):141–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Blasek K (2015) Rule of law in China: a comparative approach. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  6. Bröhmer J (2012) Introduction to German constitutional law and the doctrine of basic rights. In: Bröhmer J, Hill C, Spitzkatz M (eds) 60 years German basic law: the German constitution and its court: landmark decisions of the federal constitutional court of Germany in the area of fundamental rights, 2nd edn. The Malaysian Current Law Journal Sdn Bhd, Ampang, pp 67–98Google Scholar
  7. Bu Y (2009) Einführung in das Recht Chinas. C.H.Beck, MünchenGoogle Scholar
  8. Bu Y (2015) Normenkollisionen und Normenkontrolle in China. RIW:781–790Google Scholar
  9. Bu Q (2017) The good samaritan in the Chinese society: morality vis-à-vis Law. Liverpool Law Review 38(2):135–157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Canaris C (1983) Systemdenken und Systembegriff in der Jurisprudenz, 2nd edn. Duncker & Humblot, BerlinCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Chang AN (常安) (2010) On the constitutional transformation under the background of reform in contemporary China (“摸着石头过河”与“可改可不改的不改”——改革背景下的当代中国宪法变迁). Science of Law (Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law) (法律科学(西北政法大学学报) (2):3–11Google Scholar
  12. Chen J (1999) Chinese law – towards an understanding of Chinese law, its nature and development. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, The HagueGoogle Scholar
  13. Chen J (陈俊) (2001) On the twofold legislative power of Special Economic Zones (经济特区双重立法权论要). Law Science (法学) (9):11–15Google Scholar
  14. Chen S (陈书全) (2012) A study on the trigger mechanism to begin a regular post-legislation assessment (论立法后评估常态化启动机制的构建). Modern Law Science (现代法学) 34(2):35–41Google Scholar
  15. Chen J (陈金钊) (2014) How to understand the relationship between the rule of law and reform? (如何理解法治与改革的关系?). Journal of Soochow University Law Edition (苏州大学学报(法学版)) (2):39–50Google Scholar
  16. Chen J (2015) Chinese law – context and transformation: revised and expanded edition. Brill Nijhoff, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  17. Cheng X (程雪阳) (2015) The logic of China’s reform from experimental points to legislation (从试点到立法的中国改革逻辑). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  18. Chibundu MO (1999) Globalizing the rule of law: some thoughts at and on the periphery. Ind. J. Global Legal Stud. 7(1):79–116Google Scholar
  19. China Daily (2015) Law revisions to limit local governments. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  20. China Financialyst (中国金融家) (2014) The fourth plenary session of the 18th Communist Party of China (CPC) Central Committee Announces Communiqué on comprehensively advancing rule of law (中国共产党第十八届中央委员会第四次全体会议公报全会通过《中共中央关于全面推进依法治国若干重大问题的决定》):10–13Google Scholar
  21. China News (中国新闻网) (2002) Hu Jintao emphasizing the establishment of constitutional consciousness and authority (胡锦涛强调进一步树立宪法意识与权威). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  22. Clarke D (1995) Justice and the legal system in China. In: Benewick R, Wingrowe P (eds) China in the 1990s. Macmillan, London, pp 83–93Google Scholar
  23. Clarke D (2015) China’s legal system and the fourth plenum. Asia Policy 20:10–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Cohen JA (2014) China’s new national constitution day: is it worth celebrating? China Brief XIV(22):3–7Google Scholar
  25. Corne PH (1997) Foreign investment in China: the administrative legal system. Hong Kong University Press, Hong KongGoogle Scholar
  26. Creemers R (2014) China Copyright and Media: CCP Central Committee decision concerning some major questions in comprehensively moving governing the Country according to the law forward. Accessed 22 Dec 2017
  27. Crouzatier-Durand F (2003) Reflexions sur le concept d’expérimentation législative. Revue française de droit constitutionnel 4(56):675–695CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Cui L (崔丽) (2004) The committee of legal work of the NPCSC establishes the division of check and filing of laws and regulations (全国人大常委会法工委设立法规审查备案室). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  29. Dan Q (单其满) (2015) The revision of the Legislation Law: an important step in promoting ruling the country by law (《立法法》修订:全面推进依法治国的重要一步). Chinese & Foreign Entrepreneurs (中外企业家) (28):160–161Google Scholar
  30. Deng L (邓玲) (2003) On the system of authorized legislation of our country (我国的授权立法制度). Journal of Hebei Institute of Technology (河北理工学院学报) 3(4):60–63Google Scholar
  31. Ding L (丁零露) (2010) On the improvement of the system of delegated legislation (论授权立法制度的改进). Legal System and Society (法制与社会) (8):23–24Google Scholar
  32. Ding W (2013) Building a new legal environment in China (Shanghai) pilot free trade zone. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  33. Dowdle MW (2002) Of parliaments, pragmatism, and the dynamics of constitutional development: the curious case of China. N.Y.U. J. Int’l L. & Pol. 35(1):1–200Google Scholar
  34. Dzodin H (2014) Nationwide good Samaritan law needed. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  35. Engisch K (1935) Die Einheit der Rechtsordnung. Carl Winter Universitätsverlag, HeidelbergGoogle Scholar
  36. Fan J (范经云) (2013) On the principles of legislation in Special Economic Zones (浅议我国经济特区立法的基本原则). Chinese Journal of Law (法学研究) (2):27–29Google Scholar
  37. Felix D (1998) Einheit der Rechtsordnung. Mohr Siebeck, TübingenGoogle Scholar
  38. Feng C (2016) China’s socialist rule of law: a critical appraisal of the relationship between the Communist Party and comprehensive law reform. In: Garrick J, Bennett YC (eds) China’s socialist rule of law reforms under Xi Jinping. Routledge, London, pp 45–58Google Scholar
  39. Franzius C (2008) Die Abweichungsgesetzgebung. NVwZ:492–499Google Scholar
  40. Gao Q, Zhang W, Tian F (2015) The road to the rule of law in modern China. Springer, HeidelbergCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Ginsburg T, Simpser A (2014) Introduction: constitutions in authoritarian systems. In: Ginsburg T, Simpser A (eds) Constitutions in authoritarian systems. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 1–17Google Scholar
  42. Grimm D (2007) Proportionality in Canadian and German constitutional jurisprudence. U. Toronto L. J. 57(2):383–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Gröpl C (2015) Staatsrecht I: Staatsgrundlagen, Staatsorganisation, Verfassungsprozess, 7th edn. C.H.Beck, MünchenGoogle Scholar
  44. Guan W (关文诗) (2015) Core analysis of the delegated legislative power of China’s Special Economic Zones (浅析我国经济特区授权立法). Legality Vision (法制博览) (20):237–238Google Scholar
  45. Guo S (2013) Chinese politics and government: power, ideology, and organization. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  46. Guo R (2015) Legislation Law revision sparks heated debate. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  47. Hainan People’s Congress (海南人大) (2013) The legal protection of “good people” – who has to suffer? – Analysis of “Shenzhen Good Samaritan Law” (立法保护“好人”是谁的悲哀——解读《深圳经济特区救助人权益保护规定》):49–50Google Scholar
  48. Han D (韩大元) (1997) Social transformation and social adaptability of the constitution – comments on Mr. Hao and Mr. Tong’s debate on “Good Violation of the Constitution” (社会变革与宪法的社会适应性——评郝、童两先生关于“良性违宪”的争论). Law Sci (法学) (5):19–20Google Scholar
  49. Hand KJ (2011) Resolving constitutional disputes in contemporary China. University of Pennsylvania East Asia Law Review 7(1):51–159Google Scholar
  50. Hand KJ (2013) Understanding China’s system for addressing legislative conflicts: capacity challenges and the search for legislative harmony. Columbia Journal of Asian Law 26(1):140–265Google Scholar
  51. Hand KJ (2016) An assessment of socialist constitutional supervision models and prospects for a constitutional supervision committee in China: the constitution as commander? In: Garrick J, Bennett YC (eds) China’s socialist rule of law reforms under Xi Jinping. Routledge, London, pp 30–44Google Scholar
  52. Hao T (郝铁川) (1996) On benign unconstitutionality (论良性违宪). Chinese Journal of Law (法学研究) (4):89–91Google Scholar
  53. Harding A (2011) The Indian Special Economic Zones act 2005: implications for modelling the law and governance of SEZs. In: Carter C, Harding A (eds) Special Economic Zones in Asian market economies. Routledge, London, pp 156–171Google Scholar
  54. Heilmann S (2008a) From local experiments to national policy: the origins of China’s distinctive policy process. The China Journal 59:1–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Heilmann S (2008b) Policy experimentation in China’s economic rise. St Comp Int Dev 43(1):1–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Heilmann S (2009) Maximum tinkering under uncertainty: unorthodox lessons from China. Modern China 35(4):450–462CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Heilmann S, Schulte-Kulkmann N, Shih L (2004) Gesetzgebung in der VR China 1998 bis 2003: Einführung und Übersicht über ausgewählte Rechtsnormen. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  58. Höpfner C (2008) Die systemkonforme Auslegung: Zur Auflösung einfachgesetzlicher, verfassungsrechtlicher und europarechtlicher Widersprüche im Recht. Mohr Siebeck, TübingenGoogle Scholar
  59. Horsley JP (2009) Public participation in the People’s Republic: developing a more participatory governance model in China. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  60. Huang J (黄進) (2012a) To enable the legislative power of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone to play a greater role – in commemoration of the 20th Anniversary of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone being granted legislative power (讓深圳經濟特區立法權發揮更大的作用——纪念深圳經濟特區獲授立法權 20 周年). China Law (中国法律) (4):6–7Google Scholar
  61. Huang Z (黄喆) (2012b) On the achievements, deficiencies and improvements of legislation in Shenzhen Special Economic Zone (论深圳经济特区立法的成果、不足及完善). Journal of Jianghan University (Social Science Edition) (江汉大学学报(社会科学版)) 29(5):99–102Google Scholar
  62. Huang X (黄小玲), Lu J (吕进科) (2015) The change from “comparatively large city” to “city with subordinate districts” - Qu Jia’s proposal has been approved (“较大的市”改为“设区的市” 瞿佳的建议被采纳). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  63. Huang W (黄卫平), Zheng C (郑超) (2010) The political significance of the establishment and development of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone (深圳经济特区建立与发展的政治意义). Theoretical Horizon (理论视野) (5):33–37Google Scholar
  64. Ipsen J (2017) Staatsrecht I: Staatsorganisationsrecht, 29th edn. Franz Vahlen, MünchenGoogle Scholar
  65. Jiang P (姜朋) (2013) One legal issue of Special Economic Zones’ legislative power (經濟特區立法權問題評析). China Law (中国法律) (2):31–33Google Scholar
  66. Jiang M (姜明安) (2014a) On the constitutionalism with Chinese characteristics (论中国特色宪政). Academics (学术界) (2):5–18Google Scholar
  67. Jiang Y (2014b) Openness, economic growth and regional disparities: the case of China. Springer, HeidelbergCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Jiang M (姜明安) (2015) Improvement and perfection of the legislative system - seven highlights of the Legislation Law (改进和完善立法体制 :《立法法》呈现七大亮点). Administration Reform (行政管理改革) (4):23–27Google Scholar
  69. Jones WC (1985) The constitution of the People’s Republic of China. Wash. U. L. Q. 63(4):707–735Google Scholar
  70. Keller P (1994) Sources of order in Chinese law. Am. J. Comp. L. 42(4):711–759CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Kellogg TE (2009) Constitutionalism with Chinese characteristics? Constitutional development and civil litigation in China. ICON 7(2):215–246Google Scholar
  72. Kerber W, Eckardt M (2007) Policy learning in Europe: the open method of coordination and laboratory federalism. Journal of European Public Policy 14(2):227–247CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Kischel U (1994) Delegation of legislative power to agencies: a comparative analysis of United States and German Law. Administrative Law Review 46(2):213–256Google Scholar
  74. Krusekopf C (2011) Special economic zones and improved environmental management in China. In: Carter C, Harding A (eds) Special Economic Zones in Asian market economies. Routledge, London, pp 84–107Google Scholar
  75. Kui S (2003) Is it the the beginning of the era of the rule of the constitution? Reinterpreting China’s “first constitutional case”. Pacific Rim Law & Policy Journal 12(1):199–232Google Scholar
  76. Lai C (2017) China acts to protect Good Samaritans, in a move that could help tackle ‘bystander effect’. Accessed 10 Dec 2017
  77. Li Y (2000) The law-making law: a solution to the problems in the Chinese legislative system? HKLJ 30:120–140Google Scholar
  78. Li Z (2010) Die Möglichkeit der föderativen Gleichheit in China: Vor dem Hintergrund der deutschen Erfahrung. Dr. Kovač, HamburgGoogle Scholar
  79. Li C (李朝波) (2011) The legislation of Special Economic Zones (经济特区立法). In: Ruan R, Zhao Y (eds) On the theory and practice of local legislation (地方立法的理论与实践), 2nd edn. Social Science Academic Press (China) (社会科学文献出版社), Beijing, pp 143–165Google Scholar
  80. Li M (2013) Research on industrial research security theory. Springer, HeidelbergCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Li S (李舒瑜) (2015) This year starts the post-legislative evaluation of the zone’s regulations on environmental protection (今年将开展特区环保条例立法后评估工作). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  82. Li S (李舒瑜) (2016) The revision of the “Regulations of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone on Environmental Protection” is to be included into this year’s legislative plan (《深圳经济特区环境保护条例》修订拟纳入今年立法计划). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  83. Li H (2017a) The history and recent development of the codification of Chinese civil law - is China ready for an advanced civil code in the 21st century? In: Bu Y (ed) Die Kodifikation des Zivilgesetzbuches der VR China. LIT, Berlin, pp 1–16Google Scholar
  84. Li J (黎娟) (2017b) Theoretical construction and empirical analysis of “Experimental Legislation” - Focusing on Article 13 of “Legislation Law” in China (“试验性立法”的理论建构与实证分析———以我国《立法法》第13 条为中心). Political Science and Law (政治与法律) (7):84–94Google Scholar
  85. Li G (李广辉), Li H (李红) (2005) Entry into WTO and the legislation in SEZs in China (加入对中国经济特区立法之影响). Shantou University Journal (Humanities & Social Sciences Bimonthly) (汕头大学学报(人文社会科学版)) 21(1):54–59Google Scholar
  86. Li B (李步云), Liu S (刘士平) (2004). Hunan Social Science (湖南社会科学) (5):34–38Google Scholar
  87. Li Y (李媛), Zhang S (张书铭) (2014) Investigation and research report on the systematization of post-legislative evaluation (立法后评估制度化调研报告). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  88. Lin GC (2009) Developing China: land, politics and social conditions. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  89. Lin Y (2015) Constitutional evolution through legislation: the quiet transformation of China’s constitution. ICON 13(1):61–89Google Scholar
  90. Lin Y, Ginsburg T (2015) Constitutional interpretation in lawmaking: China’s invisible constitutional enforcement mechanism. Am. J. Comp. L. 63(2):467–492CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Lindner JF (2007) Experimentelle Rechtsetzung durch Rechtsverordnung - Am Beispiel des Hochschulrechts. DÖV (23):1003–1009Google Scholar
  92. Liu D (2013) Stellung und Funktion des Bundesverfassungsgerichts: Verfassungsgerichtsbarkeit und ihre Perspektiven in China. Peter Lang, Frankfurt am MainCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Liu S (刘松山) (2014) Some suggestions for revising the Legislation Law (修改《立法法》的若干建议). SJTU Law Review (交大法学) (3):18–25Google Scholar
  94. Liu Z (刘志刚) (2015a) Constitutional analysis to the Legislation Law amendment (Draft) (《立法法》修改的宪法学分析). Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology (Social Science Edition) (哈尔滨工业大学学报(社会科学版)) 17(1):39–45Google Scholar
  95. Liu Z (刘志刚) (2015b) The analysis of the validity of stopping the law implementation (暂时停止法律实施决定的正当性分析). Journal of Soochow University Law Edition (苏州大学学报(法学版)) (4):54–66Google Scholar
  96. Liu Y (柳砚涛), Liu H (刘宏渭) (2004) On the analysis of the principle of authority for legislation (立法授权原则探析). Legal Forum (法学论坛) 19(4):41–46Google Scholar
  97. Liu Z (刘志刚), Zhang H (张晗) (2017) Legislative power differentiation between municipalities directly under the Central Government and the Central Government (直辖市与中央的立法权限划分). Journal of Guizhou Minzu University - Philosophy and Social Sciences (贵州民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版)) (2):139–163Google Scholar
  98. Lu S (鲁生) (2011) There is no local legislative competence to exempt rescue operations from liability (救助行为免责,地方立法没有豁免权). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  99. Lubman S (2000) Bird in a cage: Chinese law reform after twenty years. Nw. J. Int’l L. & Bus. 20(3):383–424Google Scholar
  100. Maaß V (2001) Experimentierklauseln für die Verwaltung und ihre verfassungsrechtlichen Grenzen: Zugleich ein Beitrag zu § 7a BerlHG. Duncker & Humblot, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  101. Mader L (1988) Experimentelle Gesetzgebung. In: Grimm D, Maihofer W (eds) Gesetzgebungstheorie und Rechtspolitik. Westdeutscher Verlag GmbH, Opladen, pp 211–221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Mader L (2001) Evaluating the effects: a contribution to the quality of legislation. Statute Law Review 22(2):119–131CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  103. Maine SHS (1887) Ancient law: its connection with the early history of society and its relation to modern ideas, 11th edn. John Murray, LondonGoogle Scholar
  104. Maxeiner J (2007) Legal certainty and legal methods: a European alternative to American legal indeterminacy? Tul. J. Int’l & Comp. L. 15(2):541–607Google Scholar
  105. Mei X (梅旭成) (2013) A brief talk on problems and reforms of legislative power of China’s Special Economic Zones (浅谈我国经济特区立法权存在的问题与改革思路). Legal System and Economics (法制与经济) (10):63–64Google Scholar
  106. Michael L (2006) Der experimentelle Bundesstaat. JZ:884–890CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Morris RJ (2010) China’s Marbury: Qi Yuling v. Chen Xiaoqi – the once and future trial of both education & constitutionalization. Tsinghua China Law Review 2(2):273–316Google Scholar
  108. Nathan AJ (1985) Chinese democracy. University of California Press, BerkelyGoogle Scholar
  109. National People’s Congress Website (中国人大网) (2015) Explanations on the draft of the Legislation Law of the People’s Republic of China (关于《中华人民共和国立法法修正案(草案)》的说明). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  110. Ossenbühl F (2007) Vorrang und Vorbehalt des Gesetzes. In: Isensee J, Kirchhof P (eds) Handbuch des Staatsrechts: Bd. V - Rechtsquellen, Organisation, Finanzen, 3rd edn. C.F. Müller, Heidelberg, pp 183–222Google Scholar
  111. Otto J (2002) Toward an analytical framework: real legal certainty and its explanatory factors. In: Chen J, Li Y, Otto J (eds) Implementation of law in the People’s Republic of China. Kluwer Law International, The Hague, pp 23–34Google Scholar
  112. Paler L (2005) China’s Legislation Law and the making of a more orderly and representative legislative system. The China Quarterly 182:301–318CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  113. Pang L (庞凌) (2015) Pondering over the right to deviate resulting from delegated legislative power of SEZs (关于经济特区授权立法变通权规定的思考). Study & Exploration (学习与探索) (1):74–78Google Scholar
  114. Pelzer N (2014) Victims of victims: will good samaritan laws put things right? Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  115. Popelier P (2008) Five paradoxes on legal certainty and the lawmaker. Legisprudence 2(1):47–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  116. Pünder H (2009) Democratic legitimation of delegated legislation – a comparative view on the American, British and German Law. Int’l & Comp. L. Q. 58(2):353–378CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  117. Qian N (钱宁峰) (2015) The suspension of laws: the new normality of the delegated legislation model (立法后中止实施:授权立法模式的新常态). Political Science and Law (政治与法律) (7):55–63Google Scholar
  118. Qian H (钱弘道), Du W (杜维超) (2015) On experimentalism rule of law: a methodological approach of China Practical School of Rule of Law (论实验主义法治——中国法治实验学派的一种方法论进路). Journal of Zhejiang University (Humanities and Social Sciences Online Edition) (浙江大学学报 (人文社会科学版网络版)):2–15Google Scholar
  119. Qin Q (秦前红) (2005) The changes of Chinese legislative mode from a constitutional perspective (宪政视野下的中国立法模式变迁). China Legal Science (中国法学) (3):42–48Google Scholar
  120. Qin Z (秦蓁) (2009) Summary of the situation of delegated legislative power of Special Economic Zones (经济特区授权立法有关情况综述). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  121. Qin Q (秦强) (2010) On the relationship between the National People’s Congress’ authority and the authority of its Standing Committee (论全国人大与全国人大常委会的职权关系). Research System of the National People’s Congress (人大制度研究) (12):12–19Google Scholar
  122. Ranchordás S (2013) The whys and woes of experimental legislation. The Theory and Practice of Legislation 1(3):415–440Google Scholar
  123. Ranchordás S (2014) Constitutional sunsets and experimental legislation: a comparative perspective. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, CheltenhamCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  124. Ranchordás S (2015) Sunset clauses and experimental regulations: blessing or curse for legal certainty? Statute Law Review 36(1):28–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  125. Rao L (饶龙飞), Chen J (陈建晖) (2016) Basis of constitutional norms of principle of proportionality (比例原则的中国宪法规范依据). Journal of Shandong University of Science and Technology (Social Sciences) (山东科技大学学报(社会科学版)) (4):37–45Google Scholar
  126. Shi S-J (2009) The territorial politics of social protection in China: local governments as an emerging locomotive of policy learning and diffusion. Paper presented at the annual conference of the ISA, RC 19, “Social Policies: Local Experiments, Travelling Ideas”, August, 2009, Montreal, Canada, pp 20–22. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  127. Sigley G (2013) From revolution to government, from contradictions to harmony: urban community policing in post-Deng China. In: Lippert RK, Walby K (eds) Policing cities: urban securitization and regulation in a twenty-first century world. Routledge, London, pp 29–42Google Scholar
  128. Sina News (新闻中心) (2013) Shenzhen legislation prevents kind helpers from being falsely accused (深圳立法防止好心施救者反遭诬陷). Accessed 25 Dec 2017
  129. Singh MP (2001) German administrative law in common law perspective. Springer, BerlinCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  130. Sodan H (1999) Das Prinzip der Widerspruchsfreiheit der Rechtsordnung. JZ:864–873Google Scholar
  131. Song F (宋方青) (2000) On the new legislative pattern of China’s Special Economic Zones – with concurrent comments on the provisions of the Legislation Law of the PRC on the legislation for special economic zones (论中国经济特区立法的新格局——兼评“立法法”有关经济特区立法的规定). Modern Law Science (现代法学) 22(6):126–130Google Scholar
  132. Song F (宋方青) (2004) Expanding the space for legislation: reflections on issues regarding delegated legislation for Special Economic Zones (拓展立法空间: 经济特区授权立法若干关系思考). Contemporary Law Review (当代法学) 18(6):55–61Google Scholar
  133. Song M (宋明), Peng X (彭箫剑) (2015) Improving the evaluation system of legislation of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone (论深圳经济特区立法评估制度的完善). Southern Journal (南方论刊) (5):45–48Google Scholar
  134. Stern K (2011) Idee und Elemente eines Systems der Grundrechte. In: Isensee J, Kirchhof P (eds) Handbuch des Staatsrechts: Bd. IX – Allgemeine Grundrechtslehren, 3rd edn. C.F. Müller, Heidelberg, pp 57–120Google Scholar
  135. Stettner R (1989) Verfassungsbindungen des experimentierenden Gesetzgebers. NVwZ:806–812Google Scholar
  136. Sun H (孙洪波) (2007) On the legal theory basis of the authorized legislation (论授权立法的法理性基础). Journal of Jilin Public Security Academy (吉林公安高等专科学教学报) 22(5):85–89Google Scholar
  137. Sun S (孙首灿) (2015a) The constitutionality exploration and analysis of delegated legislation decision (授权立法决定的合宪性探析). Administration and Law (行政与法) (9):62–69Google Scholar
  138. Sun X (孙晓丹) (2015b) On the legislative changes of “Post Licensing Legislation Era” (“后授权立法时代” 之立法变迁). Journal of Zhengzhou Institute of Aeronautical Industry Management (Social Science Edition) (郑州航空工业管理学院学报(社会科学版)) 34(6):111–115Google Scholar
  139. Szyszczak E (2006) Experimental governance: the open method of coordination. European Law Journal 12(4):486–502CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  140. Tan B (谭波), Huang Y (黄琰) (2013) On the reform path of legislation of Special Economic Zones (论我国经济特区立法的改革路径). Journal of Jianghan University (Social Science Edition) (江汉大学学报(社会科学版)) 30(3):50–54Google Scholar
  141. Tang M (2014) Does China need “Good Samaritan” laws to save “Yue Yue”? Cornell Int’l L J. 47(1):205–231Google Scholar
  142. The Economist (2013) The search for civic virtues – the unkindness of strangers: a soul-searching debate rages about apathy towards those in need. Accessed 23 Dec 2017
  143. Tian Q (2004) China develops its West: motivation, stategy and prospect. Journal of Contemporary China 13(41):611–636CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  144. Tridimas T (2006) The general principles of EU law, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  145. Umbach DC (1984) Das Wesentliche an der Wesentlichkeitstheorie. In: Zeidler W, Maunz T, Roellecke G (eds) Festschrift Hans Joachim Faller. C.H.Beck, München, pp 111–131Google Scholar
  146. van Aeken K (2011) From vision to reality: ex post evaluation of legislation. Legisprudence 5(1):41–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  147. Vanberg G (2005) The politics of constitutionality review in Germany. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  148. Wan Q (万其刚) (1996) Delegated legislation of contemporary China (论当代中国的授权立法). Research of contemporary chinese history (当代中国史研究) (5):40–48Google Scholar
  149. Wang J (王建学) (2008) On the legalization of local experimental system (论我国地方试验制度的法治化). In: China Law Society Research Association, 2008 Annual Conference on Constitutional Law (ed) Collected works of the China Law Society Research Association, 2008 Annual Conference on Constitutional Law (中国法学会宪法学研究会2008年年会论文集). Sichuan University Press (四川大学出版社), Chengdu, pp 502–506Google Scholar
  150. Wang W (2010) Super-national treatment: a misconception or a creation with Chinese characteristics. Front. Law China 5(3):376–396CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  151. Wang Y (王艳波) (2014) The legislation of Special Economic Zones and its derogation from laws (经济特区立法对法律的变通). Master thesis, Xiamen University. Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  152. Wang C (王春业) (2015a) On giving all cities with subordinate districts the local legislative power (论赋予设区市的地方立法权). Journal of Beijing Administrative College (北京行政学院学报) (3):109–116Google Scholar
  153. Wang K (王坤驰) (2015b) Core analysis of “benign unconstitutionality” (浅析“良性违宪”). Journal of Changchun Education Institute (长春教育学院学报) 31(24):7–9Google Scholar
  154. Wang Y (2015c) The application of administrative innovation and the principle of law reservation. Studies in Sociology of Science - CSCanada 6(6):5–11Google Scholar
  155. Wang J (王建学) (2017) The decision to authorize experimental points for local reform should follow the principle of proportionality (授权地方改革试点决定应遵循比例原则). Law Science (法学) (5):39–49Google Scholar
  156. Wang X (汪习根), Liao Y (廖奕) (2004) On the legal unity in the rule of law society (论法治社会的法律统一). Law and Social Development (法制与社会发展) (5):110–119Google Scholar
  157. Wei Changhao (2017) 2017 NPC Session: Schoolchildren, Heroes, Good Samaritans & Draft Civil Law (UPDATED). Accessed 10 Dec 2017
  158. Wei S, Vanhullebusch M (2015) Where is the Alchemy? The experiment of the Shanghai Free trade zone in freeing the foreign investment regime in China. Eur Bus Org Law Rev 16(2):321–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  159. Werthwein S (2009) Das Persönlichkeitsrecht im Privatrecht der VR China. De Gruyter, BerlinCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  160. Wolff L (2011) Law and flexibility: rule of law limits of a Rhetorical Silver Bullet. The Journal Jurisprudence 11:549–567Google Scholar
  161. Wu W (1999) Pioneering economic reform in China’s Special Economic Zones. Ashgate, AldershotGoogle Scholar
  162. Wu P (吴鹏) (2007) The system of delegated legislation to Special Economic Zone should be abolished (经济特区授权立法法制度应被废除). Journal of Yunnan University Law Edition (云南大学学报法学版) 20(1):1–5Google Scholar
  163. Wu X (2014) From assimilation to autonomy: realizing ethnic minority rights in China’s national autonomous regions. Chinese Journal of International Law 13(1):55–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  164. Wu Z, Li J (eds) (2015) Analyzing the legislation law of the People’s Republic of China (中华人民共和国立法法解读). Law Press China (法制出版社), BeijingGoogle Scholar
  165. Xiamen Municipal Bureau of Legislative Affairs (厦门市法制局) (2015) Suggestions on derogation power of legislation of Special Economic Zones (经济特区立法变通权刍议). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  166. Xi Z (曦中) (1998) Reflections on “Good Violation of the Constitution” (对“良性违宪”的反思). Law Rev (法学评论) (4):26–33Google Scholar
  167. Xie Y (解永照), He X (何晓斌) (2015) Debate and explanation on a “law based reform” – basic thoughts on benign unconstitutionality (“改革于法有据”的争论及其破解 --基于良性违宪的思考). Theoretical Exploration (理论探索) (4):113–118Google Scholar
  168. Yan C (严存生) (2002) Research in the legitimacy of law (法的合法性问题研究). Law Science (Journal of Northwest Institute of Political Science and Law) (法律科学(西北政法学院学报)) (3):3–14Google Scholar
  169. Yang L (杨龙芳) (2004) The legislative innovation in Shenzhen SEZ: its history, features and prospect (论深圳经济特区: 地方立法创新的历史,特色与前景). Journal of Shenzhen University (深圳大学学报) 21(2):5–9Google Scholar
  170. Yang D (杨登峰) (2014) Path of rule of law of regional reform – on the legal path of Shanghai Pilot Free Trade Zone (区域改革的法治之路——析上海自贸区先行先试的法治路径). Research on Rule of Law (法治研究) (12):43–50Google Scholar
  171. Yang L (杨浏), Yang Y (杨一凡) (2016) How the reform of the legislation law influences the districted cities (论立法法修改给设区的市带来的影响). Legality Vision (法制博览) (2):119–120Google Scholar
  172. Ye H, Qin Q (2014) Reservation of law, legislation and human rights protection. China Legal Science (中国法学):93–117Google Scholar
  173. Yin D (尹德贵) (2015a) The delegated legislation from the perspective of comprehensively deepining reform (全面深化改革视野下的授权立法). Academic Exchange (学术交流) (4):83–87Google Scholar
  174. Yin P (2015b) A law for the law: the legal system gets a new suit of armor. Accessed 22 Dec 2017
  175. Ying S (2015) On revision of legislation law of People’s Republic of China. China Law (中国法学) (1):51–53Google Scholar
  176. You C (游春亮) (2016) Shenzhen precedent: the involvement of lawyers in post-legislative evaluation (深圳开先河由律师参与立法后评估). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  177. Yu K (2008) Globalization and changes in China’s Governance. Brill, LeidenCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  178. Yu L (余凌云) (2009) Basic principles of administrative law (行政法的基本原则). In: Ying S (ed) Administrative law and administrative litigation law (行政法与行政诉讼法学), 2nd edn. Law Press China (法律出版社), Beijing, pp 27–45Google Scholar
  179. Yue Zhang M, Stening BW (2010) China 2.0: the transformation of an emerging superpower… and the new opportunities. John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte. Ltd., SingaporeGoogle Scholar
  180. Zeng X (曾祥华) (2004) On the conflicts by the delegated legislation and its solution (试论授权立法的法律冲突及其解决途径). Journal of Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology (Social Science Edition) (西安建筑科技大学学报(社会科学版)) 23(2):30–36Google Scholar
  181. Zeng DZ (2010) How do Special Economic Zones and industrial clusters drive China’s rapid development? In: Zeng DZ (ed) Building engines for growth and competitiveness in China: experience with Special Economic Zones and industrial clusters. World Bank Publications, Washington DC, pp 1–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  182. Zeng Z (曾正宏) (2016) Understanding the legislative power of Shenzhen Special Economic Zone (深圳特区立法权再认识). Accessed 23 Dec 2017
  183. Zhang X (1998) Economic legislation in the Pearl River Delta. In: Cheng JY (ed) The Guangdong development model and its challenges. City University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong, pp 111–146Google Scholar
  184. Zhang Q (张千帆) (2007) Constitutional variability and local experiments (宪法变通与地方试验). Chinese Journal of Law (法学研究) (1):63–73Google Scholar
  185. Zhang Q (2010) A constitution without constitutionalism? The paths of constitutional development in China. ICON 8(4):950–976Google Scholar
  186. Zhang D (张殿军) (2011a) On comparative research on versatile legislation between National Autonomous Region and Economic Special Zone (民族自治地方变通立法与经济特区变通立法比较研究). Journal of Ningxia Communist Party Institute (宁夏党校学报) 13(2):49–52Google Scholar
  187. Zhang W (张慰) (2011b) Analysis and critique of materiality theory - inspection based on German Public Law Theory (“重要性理论”之梳理与批判——基于德国公法学理论的检视). Administrative Law Review (行政法学研究) (2):113–124Google Scholar
  188. Zhang L (张铃爽) (2012a) The lack of fairness in China’s delegated legislation (我国授权立法的公正缺失). Legal and Economy (法制与经济) (3):182Google Scholar
  189. Zhang Q (2012b) The constitution of China: a contextual analysis. Hart Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  190. Zhang Q (张琼辉) (2014) Explicit delegated legislation body and limits of authority (明确授权立法主体和权限). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  191. Zhang C (张灿灿) (2015a) Questions on “the liability of rescue operations” answered by Jiang Ming’an for an interview in the Procuratorate Daily (姜明安教授就“紧急现场救护行为法律责任”问题接受检察日报记者采访). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  192. Zhang Q (2015b) Legalising central-local relations in China. In: Harding A, Sidel M (eds) Central-local relations in Asian constitutional systems. Hart Publishing, Oxford, pp 17–36Google Scholar
  193. Zhang X (2015c) Die Änderung des Gesetzgebungsgesetzes der VRCh und die “neue Normalität” der Gesetzgebung in China. VRÜ 48(4):443–468CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  194. Zhang D (张德淼), Liu Q (刘琦) (2016) Evaluation system of post-legislation: its scientificity and limitations (立法后评估制度的科学性及其限度). Journal of Hunan University of Science & Technology (Social Science Edition) (湖南科技大学学报(社会科学版)) 19(1):49–54Google Scholar
  195. Zhang X (张小玲), Mi Y (米燕) (2015) The revised legislation law: Shenzhen legislative power might be restricted (立法法修订:深圳市立法权限或将被收窄). Accessed 20 Dec 2017
  196. Zhao J-B (2010) Harmonious society and the changes in concepts of local legislation. Canadian Social Science 6(3):158–164Google Scholar
  197. Zheng LL (郑丽利) (2017) On the legality of delegated legislation (论授权立法的合法性). Journal of Harbin University (哈尔滨学院学报) 38(8):53–56Google Scholar
  198. Zheng P, Scase R (2013) Emerging business ventures under market socialism: entrepreneurship in China. Routledge, AbingdonGoogle Scholar
  199. Zhong X (钟晓渝) (2000) Improving the legislation and the legislative system of Special Economic Zones (完善经济特区立法权与立法体制). Theory and Practice of SEZs (特区理论与实践) (12):37–39Google Scholar
  200. Zhong X (钟晓渝) (2012) Shenzhen: legislation and development (完善特区立法与经济特区的文莱发展). Journal of Shenzhen Polytechnic (深圳职业技术学院学报) 11(6):3–8Google Scholar
  201. Zhou Y (周佑勇) (2004) Restrictions and safeguards of human rights in a state of emergencies (紧急状态下的人权限制与保障). Juridical Science Journal (法学杂志) (4):21–22Google Scholar
  202. Zhou Q (周浅) (2015) The local legislative power from the perspective of the new legislation law (新《立法法》视角下的地方立法权). Legality Vision (法制博览):140–141Google Scholar
  203. Zhou Y (周宇骏) (2017) The authorized legislation of local state power organs: problems and motivations (论地方国家权力机关的授权立法: 问题与理据). Journal of Fujian Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition) (福建师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)) (2):39–56Google Scholar
  204. Zhu G (2010) Constitutional review in China: an unaccomplished project or a mirage? Suffolk University Law Review 43(3):625–653Google Scholar
  205. Zhu G (2012) The composite state of China under “One Country, multiple systems”: theoretical construction and methodological considerations. ICON 10(1):272–297Google Scholar
  206. Zhu H (朱汉卿) (2016) On the basic category and legal regulation of the authorized legislation from the perspective of the new “legislation law” (新立法法视域下的授权立法基本范畴研究及其法律规制 及其法律规制). Journal of Jianghan University (Social Science Edition) (江汉大学学报(社会科学版)) 33(5):24–36Google Scholar
  207. Zhu Y (朱应平), Xu B (徐柏芳) (1999) Flagrant violation of legislation, no correction so far (公然违法立法,迄今未见纠正). Law Science (法学) (5):6–7Google Scholar
  208. Zou K (2006) China’s legal reform: towards the rule of law. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, LeidenGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Madeleine Martinek
    • 1
  1. 1.BerlinGermany

Personalised recommendations