A Collection of Lower Bounds for Online Matching on the Line
In the online matching on the line problem, the task is to match a set of requests R online to a given set of servers S. The distance metric between any two points in \(R\,\cup \,S\) is a line metric and the objective for the online algorithm is to minimize the sum of distances between matched server-request pairs. This problem is well-studied and – despite recent improvements – there is still a large gap between the best known lower and upper bounds: The best known deterministic algorithm for the problem is \(O(\log ^2n)\)-competitive, while the best known deterministic lower bound is 9.001. The lower and upper bounds for randomized algorithms are 4.5 and \(O(\log n)\) respectively.
We prove that any deterministic online algorithm which in each round: (i) bases the matching decision only on information local to the current request, and (ii) is symmetric (in the sense that the decision corresponding to the mirror image of some instance I is the mirror image of the decision corresponding to instance I), must be \(\varOmega (\log n)\)-competitive. We then extend the result by showing that it also holds when relaxing the symmetry property so that the algorithm might prefer one side over the other, but only up to some degree. This proves a barrier of \(\varOmega (\log n)\) on the competitive ratio for a large class of “natural” algorithms. This class includes all deterministic online algorithms found in the literature so far.
Furthermore, we show that our result can be extended to randomized algorithms that locally induce a symmetric distribution over the chosen servers. The \(\varOmega (\log n)\)-barrier on the competitive ratio holds for this class of algorithms as well.
- 1.Antoniadis, A., Barcelo, N., Nugent, M., Pruhs, K., Scquizzato, M.: A o(n)-competitive deterministic algorithm for online matching on a line. In: Proceedings of 12th International Workshop Approximations and Online Algorithms (WAOA), pp. 11–22 (2014)Google Scholar
- 3.Chung, C., Pruhs, K., Uthaisombut, P.: The online transportation problem: on the exponential boost of one extra server. In: Laber, E.S., Bornstein, C., Nogueira, L.T., Faria, L. (eds.) LATIN 2008. LNCS, vol. 4957, pp. 228–239. Springer, Heidelberg (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-78773-0_20 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 11.Meyerson, A., Nanavati, A., Poplawski, L.J.: Randomized online algorithms for minimum metric bipartite matching. In: Proceedings of 17th Symposium Discrete Algorithms (SODA), pp. 954–959 (2006)Google Scholar
- 12.Nayyar, K., Raghvendra, S.: An input sensintive online algorithm for the metric bipartite matching problem. In: FOCS (2017, to appear). http://ieee-focs.org/FOCS-2017-Papers/3464a505.pdf
- 13.Raghvendra, S.: A robust and optimal online algorithm for minimum metric bipartite matching. In: Approximation, Randomization, and Combinatorial Optimization, APPROX/RANDOM, pp. 18:1–18:16 (2016)Google Scholar