Advertisement

Interrogating Colonialism: Bakassi, the Colonial Question and the Imperative of Exorcising the Ghost of Eurocentric International Law

  • Dakas C. J. Dakas
Chapter
Part of the Nigerian Yearbook of International Law book series (NYBIL, volume 2017)

Abstract

On 10 October 2002, the International Court of Justice at The Hague delivered judgement in the contentious case between Cameroon and Nigeria (Equatorial Guinea intervening) to the effect, inter alia, that ‘sovereignty over the Bakassi Peninsula lies with the Republic of Cameroon’. The Court further decided that ‘the Federal Republic of Nigeria is under an obligation expeditiously and without condition to withdraw its administration and its military and police forces from the territories which fall within the sovereignty of the Republic of Cameroon’.

On the face of it, this was simply an interstate territorial dispute involving two African States. This article argues, however, that in the circumstances of the case, colonialism was on trial. Properly analysed, and within the broad framework of colonial responsibility, at the heart of the case is British responsibility to the people of Bakassi and, by extension, Nigeria. Regrettably, the majority of the Court evaded this central issue and chose, instead, to engage in a spurious analysis whose end result was the transformation of a regime engendered by a treaty that, by its very provisions, established a protectorate into a colony or a so-called colonial protectorate! In the circumstances, the article underscores the imperative of critical legal scholarship that interrogates the colonial enterprise, with a view to purging international law of its colonial vestiges.

References

  1. Ajayi JFA (ed) (1989) Africa in the nineteenth century until the 1880sGoogle Scholar
  2. Anene JC (1970) The international boundaries of Nigeria, 1885–1960. pp 2–3Google Scholar
  3. Anghie A (1999) Finding the peripheries: sovereignty and colonialism in nineteenth-century international law. Harv Int Law J 40:1Google Scholar
  4. Asiwaju AI (ed) (1985) Partitioned Africans: ethnic relations across Africa’s international boundaries, 1884–1984. p 2Google Scholar
  5. Austin J (1998) In: Campbell D, Thomas P (eds) The province of jurisprudence determined. p 101Google Scholar
  6. Beer GL (1923) In: Gray LH (ed) African questions at the Paris Peace Conference. p 195Google Scholar
  7. Boahen AA (ed) (1985) General history of Africa: Africa under colonial domination, 1880–1935, vol VIIGoogle Scholar
  8. Bohannan P (1964) Africa and the AfricansGoogle Scholar
  9. Crowe SE (1970) The Berlin West Africa ConferenceGoogle Scholar
  10. Dakas DCJ (1999) The role of international law in the colonization of Africa: a review in light of recent calls for re-colonization. Afr Yearb Int Law 7:85Google Scholar
  11. Dakas DCJ (2003) International law on trial: Bakassi and the Eurocentricity of International LawGoogle Scholar
  12. Davidson B (1970) Black Mother: Africa – the years of trialGoogle Scholar
  13. Davidson B (1991a) African civilization revisitedGoogle Scholar
  14. Davidson B (1991b) Africa in historyGoogle Scholar
  15. Davidson B (1992) The Black Man’s burden: Africa and the curse of the nation-stateGoogle Scholar
  16. Elias TO (1988) In: Akinjide R (ed) Africa and the development of international law, 2nd rev. edn. pp 6–17Google Scholar
  17. Hacker A (1995) Two nations: Black and White, separate, hostile, unequal, rev. ednGoogle Scholar
  18. Harbeson JW, Rothchild D (eds) (1991) Africa in world politics. p 19Google Scholar
  19. Harris JE (1998) Africans and their history, 2nd rev. edn. p 9Google Scholar
  20. Huggins WN, Jackson JG (1973) An introduction to African civilizationsGoogle Scholar
  21. Hyde CC (1947) International law chiefly as interpreted and applied by the United States, vol I, 2nd rev. edn. p 357Google Scholar
  22. Jenks CW (1958) The common law of mankind. pp 69–74Google Scholar
  23. Jennings R (1997) The role of the International Court of Justice. Br Yearb Int Law 68:3Google Scholar
  24. Jennings R, Watts A (eds) (1992) Oppenheim’s international law, vol I, 9th edn. pp 267–269Google Scholar
  25. Kennedy D (1997) International law and the nineteenth century: history of an illusion. Quinnipiac Law Rev 17:99Google Scholar
  26. Lawrence TJ (1923) In: Winfield PH (ed) The principles of international law, 7th edn. p 69Google Scholar
  27. Lindley MF (1926) The acquisition and government of backward territory in international law: being a treatise on the law and practice relating to colonial expansion. p 21Google Scholar
  28. Makonnen Y (1983) International law and the new states of Africa: a study of the international legal problems of state succession in the newly independent states of Eastern Africa. pp 14–15Google Scholar
  29. Mamdani M (1996) Citizen and subject: contemporary Africa and the legacy of late colonialismGoogle Scholar
  30. Mensah-Brown AK (ed) (1975) African international legal historyGoogle Scholar
  31. Miller JC (ed) (1980) The African past speaksGoogle Scholar
  32. Mutua MW (1995a) Putting humpty dumpty back together again: the dilemmas of the post-colonial African state. Brook J Int Law 21:505Google Scholar
  33. Mutua MW (1995b) Why redraw the map of Africa: a legal and moral inquiry. Mich J Int Law 16:1113Google Scholar
  34. Offiong D (1980) Imperialism and dependencyGoogle Scholar
  35. Okoye M (1964) African responses. p 389Google Scholar
  36. Oppenheim L (1955) In: Lauterpacht H (ed) International law: a treatise, vol I, 8th edn. p 555Google Scholar
  37. Orentlicher DF (1998) Separation anxiety: international responses to ethno-separatist claims. Yale J Int Law 23(1):28–29Google Scholar
  38. Rodney W (1981) How Europe underdeveloped AfricaGoogle Scholar
  39. Schieffelin HM (ed) (1974) The people of AfricaGoogle Scholar
  40. Shaw M (1986) Title to territory in Africa: international legal issuesCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Thompson LA, Ferguson J (eds) (1969) Africa in classical antiquityGoogle Scholar
  42. Thruston AB (1900) African incidents: personal experiences in Egypt and Unyoro. pp 170–171Google Scholar
  43. Umozurike UO (1979) International law and colonialism in Africa. p 40Google Scholar
  44. Umozurike UO (1993) Introduction to international law. pp 7–8Google Scholar
  45. Westlake J (1894) Chapters on the principles of international law. p 149Google Scholar
  46. Wheaton H (1855) In: Lawrence WB (ed) Elements of international law, 6th edn. p 16Google Scholar
  47. Williams JF (ed) (1914) Memories of John WestlakeGoogle Scholar
  48. Wilmot P (1980) Ideology and national consciousness. p 189Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Dakas C. J. Dakas
    • 1
  1. 1.University of JosJosNigeria

Personalised recommendations