How to Unmask the Anti-vaccination “Experts”

  • Andrea Grignolio


“Talk to the mothers of ill children, look at the suffering in their faces, there are very many cases that science ignores”. When you hear words like that, you had better start to worry; they are typical of those who, having recourse to the instrumental use of the emotions and supposed limits of the scientific method, advocate alternative therapeutic treatments to traditional medicine. Concern ought to start from the observation that these treatments are ineffective because something like “alternative medicine”, as opposed to “traditional medicine”, does not exist. Rather, medicine exists, with its data, its evidence, standard protocols and its rules of validation for drugs and therapies which even includes the use of experimental protocols for innovative therapies, the efficacy of which, partially shown, requires further proof. Outside this form of medicine there is no other medicine, simply there is nothing. This is why the expression “alternative treatments” is used, to clarify the fact that they have nothing to do with confirmed or experimental clinical therapies. The advocates of alternative treatments, in general, refuse these arguments, accusing doctors and scientists of being without a “mental openness” but this is another false argument: mental openness consists not of accepting opinions only because they are alternative to consolidated theories but remaining open to all the hypotheses or criticisms possible, on condition that they are based on data that can be proven. Mental openness is measured on facts, never on personal opinions—otherwise the risk is that of returning to magic or to witchcraft. Let’s look at the reasons why.


  1. Arenz, S. et al. (2003), Der Masernausbruch in Coburg: Was lässt sich daraus lernen? Dtsch Arztebl International, 100 (49), A-3245 (I used the data shown in hte artilce in English by Ernst, 2011).Google Scholar
  2. Batzing-Feigenbaum, J. et al. (2010), Spotlight on Measles 2010: Preliminary Report of An Ongoing Measles Outbreak in A Subpopulation with Low Vaccination Coverage in Berlin, Germany, January-March 2010, “Euro Surveill”, 15 (13).Google Scholar
  3. Betsch C., Brewer N.T. et al. (2012), Opportunities and challenges of Web 2.0 for vaccination decisions, “Vaccine”, 30, pp. 3727–3733CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Blume, S. (2006), Anti-Vaccination Movements and Their Interpretations, “Social Science & Medicine”, 62 (3), pp. 628–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Brown, E. (2011), ‘Pox parties’: Coming to a mailbox near you?, “Los Angeles Times”, Nov. 04, 2011.Google Scholar
  6. Conforti, M., G. Corbellini e G. Gazzaniga (2012), Dalla cura alla scienza. Malattia, salute e società nel mondo occidentale, Milano, EncycloMedia.Google Scholar
  7. Davidovitch, N. (2004), Homeopathy and Anti-Vaccinationism at the Turn of the Twentieth Century, in R.D. Johnston (ed), The Politics of Healing: Histories of Alternative Medicine in Twentieth-Century North America, Routledge, New York, p. 11–28.Google Scholar
  8. Dube, E., Vivion, M. et al. (2013), How do Midwives and Physicians Discuss Childhood Vaccination with Parents?, “J Clin Med”, 2 (4), 242–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Duffell E, Attitudes of parents towards measles and immunisation after a measles outbreak in an anthroposophical community. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2001 Sep;55(9):685–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Ernst, E. (1995), Homoeopaths and Chiropractors Are Sceptical About Immunisation, “BMJ” 311(7008), p. 811.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Ernst, E. (2001), Rise in Popularity of Complementary and Alternative Medicine: Reasons and Consequences for Vaccination, “Vaccine”, 20 suppl. 1, S90–93, discussion S89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Ernst, E. (2011), Anthroposophy: A Risk Factor for Noncompliance with Measles Immunization, “The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal”, 30(3), pp. 187–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Galanakis, E. et al. (2013), Ethics of Mandatory Vaccination for Healthcare Workers, “Euro Surveill”, 18 (45), p. 20.627.Google Scholar
  14. Galanakis, E. et al. (2014), The Issue of Mandatory Vaccination for Healthcare Workers in Europe, Expert Rev Vaccines, 13 (2), pp. 277–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Gallant, D. M., Vollman, A. R. et al. (2009), Influenza vaccination by registered nurses: a personal decision, "Can J Infect Control”, 24 (1), 18–22.Google Scholar
  16. Gentilcore, D. (2006). Medical Charlatanism in Early Modern Italy, Oxford University Press, Oxford, New York.Google Scholar
  17. Ghianni, T., Swapping chicken pox-infected lollipops illegal, “Reuters Health News”, Nov 12, 2011.Google Scholar
  18. Gnadinger, M., M. Gassner and G. Bachmann (2009), Attitudes Towards Vaccination: Users of Complementary and Alternative Medicine Versus Non-Users, “Swiss Medical Weekly”, 139 (13–14), p. 212; author’s reply on p. 212.Google Scholar
  19. Goldhaber-Fiebert JD, Lipsitch et al. (2010), Quantifying child mortality reductions related to measles vaccination, PLoS ONE, e13842.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Hanratty, B. et al. (2000), UK Measles Outbreak In Non-Immune Anthroposophic Communities: The Implications for The Elimination of Measles from Europe, “Epidemiol Infect”, 125 (2), pp. 377–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Kahan, D.M. (2012), Cultural Cognition As a Conception of the Cultural Theory of Risk, in Handbook of Risk Theory Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk, S. Roeser, B.V. Springer, “Science+Business Media”, New York, pp. 725–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Kahan, D.M. (2014), Vaccine Risk Perceptions and Ad Hoc Risk Communication: An Empirical Assessment, CCP Risk Perception Studies Report No. 17, “Yale Law & Economics Research Paper”, 491, pp. 1–82.Google Scholar
  23. Kata, A. (2010), A Postmodern Pandora’s Box: Anti-Vaccination Misinformation on the Internet, “Vaccine”, 28 (7), pp. 1709–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Knight, B. (2015), Measles death in Germany prompts calls for mandatory vaccinations, “The Guardian”, 23 February, 2015.Google Scholar
  25. Kriwy, P. (2011), Similarity of Parents and Physicians in the Decision to Vaccinate Children Against Measles, Mumps And Rubella, “International Journal of Public Health”, 57(2), pp. 333–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. La Torre, G. et al. (2009), Behaviours Regarding Preventive Measures Against Pandemic H1n1 Influenza Among Italian Healthcare Workers, October 2009, “Euro Surveill”, 14 (49).Google Scholar
  27. Martin M, Badalyan V, Vaccination practices among physicians and their children. Open Journal of Pediatrics 2 (2012) 228–235.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. McBride DL (2015), Measles Vaccination Associated With Lower Mortality Risk From Other Childhood Infections, J Pediatr Nurs, 30, 802–3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Mina, M.J. et al. (2014), Long-Term Measles-Induced Immunomodulation Increases Overall Childhood Infectious Disease Mortality, “Science”, 348 (6235), pp. 694–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Nyhan, B. et al. (2014), Effective Messages in Vaccine Promotion: A Randomized Trial, “Pediatrics”, 133 (4), pp. e835–842.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Posfay-Barbe, K.M. et al., How Do Physicians Immunize Their Own Children? Differences Among Pediatricians and Nonpediatricians, “Pediatrics”, 2005, 116 (5), pp. e623–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Rieder, M.J. and J.L. Robinson (2015), Nosodes’ Are No Substitute For Vaccines, “Paediatr Child Health”, 20(4), pp. 219–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Roggendorf H, Mankertz A, Kundt R, Roggendorf M., Spotlight on measles 2010: measles outbreak in a mainly unvaccinated community in Essen, Germany, March-June 2010. Euro Surveill. 2010 Jul 1;15(26). pii: 19605.Google Scholar
  34. Ryser, A. J., Heininger U. (2015), Comparative acceptance of pertussis and influenza immunization among health-care personnel, "Vaccine”, 33 (41), 5350–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Schmid, D. et al. (2010), Measles Outbreak Linked to A Minority Group In Austria, 2008, “Epidemiol Infect”, 138 (3), pp. 415–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Schmidt, K. and E. Ernst (2002), Aspects of MMR. Survey Shows that Some Homoeopaths and Chiropractors Advise Against MMR, “BMJ”, 325 (7364), p. 597.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Schonberger, K. et al. (2009), Risk Factors for Delayed or Missed Measles Vaccination In Young Children, “Bundesgesundheitsblatt Gesundheitsforschung Gesundheitsschutz”, 52 (11), pp. 1045–51.Google Scholar
  38. Simpson, N., S. Lenton and R. Randall (1995), Parental Refusal to Have Children Immunised: Extent And Reasons. “British Medical Journal”, 310 (6974), p. 227.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Sobo, E.J. (2015), Social Cultivation of Vaccine Refusal and Delay among Waldorf (Steiner) School Parents, "Medical Anthropology Quarterly", 29 (3), pp. 381–399.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Van den Hof, S. et al. (2006), Measles Epidemic in The Netherlands, 1999-2000, “The Journal of Infectious Diseases”, 1876, pp. 1483–86.Google Scholar
  41. Van Der Weyden, M.B., et al. (2005), The 2005 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, “Medical Journal of Australia”, 183 (11–12), pp. 612–14.Google Scholar
  42. Van Velzen, E. et al. (2008), Measles Outbreak in An Anthroposophic Community in The Hague, The Netherlands, June-July, “Euro Surveill”, 13, p. 31.Google Scholar
  43. Wicker, S., Rose, M. A. (2011), Health care workers and pertussis: an underestimated issue, "Med Klin” (Munich), 105 (12), 882–6.Google Scholar
  44. Zhang J, While AE, Norman IJ, Nurses’ knowledge and risk perception towards seasonal influenza and vaccination and their vaccination behaviours: a cross-sectional survey. Int J Nurs Stud. 2011 Oct;48(10):1281–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Zuzak, T.J. et al. (2008), Attitudes Towards Vaccination: Users of Complementary and Alternative Medicine Versus Non-Users, “Swiss Medical Weekly”, 138 (47–48), pp. 713–18.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Andrea Grignolio
    • 1
  1. 1.Unit and Museum of History of Medicine, Department of Experimental MedicineSapienza University of RomeRomeItaly

Personalised recommendations