A City of Workers, a City for Workers? Remaking Beijing Urban Space in the Early PRC

  • Fabio Lanza
Chapter
First Online:

Abstract

In 1950s’ Beijing, planners conjured up a city that could fulfill three different but inseparable functions: it should be a productive city, with a sizable industrial proletariat; it should serve as the host of a vast bureaucracy; and it should be remade into a more perfect urban structure, in which the people’s needs could be satisfied and themselves remade into new socialist individuals. This chapter traces the increasing distance between the projects of the planners and practices at street level, where the needs of bureaucracy and production led to scattered urban development and to continuing forms of oppression. I argue that these contradictions—reflected in Beijing’s urban structure—were intrinsic to the very project of Maoist modernization.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. Beijing jiansheshishu bianji weiyuanhui bianjibu. (1987a). Guojia jiwei duiyu Beijing shiwei ‘Guanyu gaijian Beijingshi guihua cao’an’ yijian xiang zhongyang de baogao [Suggestions to the central government by the National Planning Commission about the draft plan by the Municipal Committee ‘On the reconstruction and expansion of the city of Beijing’] (October 16, 1954). In Jianguo yilai de Beijing chengshi jianshe ziliao. Diyijuan, chengshi guihua [Documents on the construction of Beijing since Liberation. Vol. 1 City Planning] (pp. 180–191). Beijing: Beijing jiansheshishu bianji weiyuanhui bianjibu.Google Scholar
  2. Beijing jiansheshishu bianji weiyuanhui bianjibu. (1987b). Sulian zhuanjia Balannikefu guanyu Beijingshi jianglai fazhan jihua de wenti baogao [Report by the Soviet expert Balanikov on plans for the future development of Beijing]. In Jianguo yilai de Beijing chengshi jianshe ziliao. Diyijuan, chengshi guihua [Documents on the construction of Beijing since Liberation. Vol. 1 City Planning] (pp. 110–111). Beijing: Beijing jiansheshishu bianji weiyuanhui bianjibu.Google Scholar
  3. Bray, D. (2005). Social Space and Governance in Urban China. The Danwei System from Origins to Reform. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
  4. Dillon, N. (2015). Radical Inequalities. China’s Revolutionary Welfare State in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Lefebvre, H. (1991). The Production of Space (Donald Nicholson-Smith, Trans.). Oxford, UK; Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  6. Li, D. X. (2006). Chengshi renmin gongshe yundong yanjiu [Research on the Urban People’s Communes Movement]. Changsha: Hunan Renmin Chubanshe.Google Scholar
  7. Liu, S. Q. (1958, September 25). Guodu dao gongchanzhuyi de jige tiaojian [Some Conditions for the Transition to Communism]. Renmin Ribao.Google Scholar
  8. MacFarquhar, R. (1983). The Origins of the Cultural Revolution 2: The Great Leap Forward, 1958–1960. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
  9. Postone, M. (1998). Rethinking Marx in a Postmarxist World. In C. Camic (Ed.), Reclaiming the Sociological Classics. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell Publishers.Google Scholar
  10. Ross, K. (1988). The Emergence of Social Space. Rimbaud and the Paris Commune. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Shih, C.-C. (1962). Urban Commune Experiments in Communist China. Communist China Problem Research Series. Hong Kong: Union Research Institute.Google Scholar
  12. Sit, V. F. S. (1995). Beijing. The Nature and Planning of a Chinese Capital City. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  13. Wu, Y. C. (2014). The Cultural Revolutions at the Margins. Chinese Socialism in Crisis. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  14. Yeh, W.-H. (1997). Republican Origins of the Danwei: The Case of Shanghai’s Bank of China. In X. Lü & E. Perry (Eds.), Danwei: The Changing Chinese Workplace in Historical and Comparative Perspective (pp. 60–88). Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.Google Scholar

Archive Materials

  1. BMA 001-005-00122/1 Shiwei baosong beijingshi diyiqi chengshi jianshe jihua yaodian de baogao [Report by the Party Committee Recommending the Crucial Points of Beijing First Urban Construction Plan] (October, 1954).Google Scholar
  2. BMA 001-005-00168 Shiwei renmin zhengfu dangzu guanyu yijiuwusi nian shizheng jianshe gongcheng shexing qingkuang de baogao [1954 Report by the CCP Group in the Municipal Government Concerning the Process of Building the Municipal Administration] (January 3, 1955).Google Scholar
  3. BMA 001-006-01703/11 Xuanwu quwei jiegongwei guanyu chunshu gongshe fuwuzhan gongzuo wenti ji jinhou yijian de baogao [Report by the Xuanwu District Neighborhood Work Committee on the Problems of the Service Centers of the Chunshu Commune and Suggestions for the Future] (June 6, 1960).Google Scholar
  4. BMA 001-006-01703/12 Chunshu gongshe diyi dadui fuwuzhan de qinkuang [The Situation at the First Brigade Service Center at the Chunshu Commune] (April 23, 1960).Google Scholar
  5. BMA 001-006-01703/13 Chongwenqu guanyi jiedao banshichu zuzhiqilai de qingkuang he chengli renmin gongshe riqi de qingshi baogao [Report by the Chongwen District About the Organization of Sub-district Offices and the Date of Establishment of the People’s Commune] (April 8, 1960).Google Scholar
  6. BMA 001-006-01703/18 Chaoyang quwei guanyu zai Jiuxianqiao diqu chengli yi dagongchang wei zhongxin de chengshi renmin gongshe [The Chaoyang District Committee on Establishing a Factory-Based Urban People’s Commune at Jiuxianqiao] (April 8, 1960).Google Scholar
  7. BMA 001-006-01703/20 Guanyu Shijingshan Zhongsuyouhao renmin gongshe jinyibu kuoda he tigao wentide qingshi baogao [Report Asking for Instruction on Improving and Expanding the Soviet-China Friendship Commune at Shijingshan] (March 21, 1960).Google Scholar
  8. BMA 001-006-01703/6 Zhongong Xuanwu quwei guanyu Dazhalan jiedao banshichu jianli renmin gongshe wenti de qingshi [Request for Instruction from the Xuanwu District Party Committee About the Dazhalan Neighborhood Office Establishing a People’s Commune] (April 8, 1960).Google Scholar
  9. BMA 001-009-00303 He Zhang, “Guanyu zai Beijing jianshe gongye de chubu yijian (cao’an)” [Initial Suggestions Concerning Industrial Construction in Beijing (Draft)] (September 4, 1954).Google Scholar
  10. BMA 001-009-00303/1 Guanyu jinzhi zai chengnei xinshe gongchang de cailiao [Material Concerning the Prohibition of Building New Factories Within the City Walls] (1954).Google Scholar
  11. BMA 001-009-00372/1 Guanyu chengshi jianshe he chengshi guihua de jige wenti [Some Problems in City Construction and City Planning] (April 4, 1956).Google Scholar
  12. BMA 001-009-00372/2 Chengshi guihua de qianti—shoudu fazhan de fangxiang wenti [The Preconditions of City Planning—The Problem of the Direction in the Development of the Capital] (1956).Google Scholar
  13. BMA 001-009-0345 Shiwei youguan shizheng jianshe yu chengshi jianshe wenti de wenjian zhaiyao [Summary of the Documents by the Beijing Party Committee Concerning the Problems of City Government and Urban Construction] (May 18, 1955).Google Scholar
  14. BMA 001-028-00029/3 Guanyu chengshi gongshe tuoyou zuzhi zuotanhui de qingkuang fanying [Reactions at the Forum on the Organization of Childcare in the Urban Communes] (September 16, 1961).Google Scholar
  15. BMA 001-028-00029/5 Guanyu chengshi gongshe xitong shengchanfuwu renyuan dui fa bubiao de fanying [Reactions of the Service and Production Employees of the Urban Communes to the Distribution of Cloth Rations] (November 28, 1961).Google Scholar
  16. BMA 001-028-00036/12 “Zhonggong Beijing shiwei chengshi gongshe gongzuo xiaozu” [Urban Commune Working Group of the Beijing Party Committee], “Guanyu chengshi renmin gongshe de jiben qingkuang” [On the Basic Situation of the Urban People’s Communes] (June 4, 1962).Google Scholar
  17. BMA 001-028-00036/13 Guanyu chengshi renmin gongshe xiuli fuwu xingye jilei, fenpei cunzai de wenti jijiejue yijian [The Problems of Distribution and Accumulation That Still Exist in the Industry, Service, and Repair Sectors in the Urban People’s Communes and Some Suggestions on How to Solve Them] (January 1962).Google Scholar
  18. BMA 001-028-00036/15 “Shiwei chengshi renmin gongshe gongzuo xiaozu” [Urban Commune Working Group of the Beijing Party Committee], “Guanyu shaoshu chengshi renmin gongshe qiangxing jiesan shitang wenti de baogao” [Report on the Problem of Some Communes Forcibly Dismantling the Canteens] (June 11, 1962).Google Scholar
  19. BMA 001-028-00036/17 Shiwei chengshi gongshe gongzuozu, “Chengshi renmin gongshe gongye bu neng yifengchui—guanyu Beixinqiao renmin gongshe gongye de qingkuang diaocha [The Industrial Production of the Urban People’s Communes Cannot Be Eliminated in One Fell Swoop—A Survey of the Industry at the Beixinqiao People’s Commune] (September 6, 1962).Google Scholar
  20. BMA 001-028-00036/6 Jidong linghuo, fangbian yonghu de dianduchang (Beixinqiao gongshe gongye diaocha cailiao zhi er) [A Flexible, Easy to Manage Electroplating Factory (Document no. 2 About the Survey of the Industry of Beixinqiao Commune)] (October 4, 1962).Google Scholar
  21. BMA 001-028-00036/8 Beixinqiao gongshe gongye de laodongli qingkuang fenxi (Beixinqiao gongshe gongye diaocha cailiao zhi si) [An Analysis of the Situation of the Labor Force in the Industry at Beixinqiao Commune (Document No. 4 on the Industry at Beixinqiao Commune)] (November 19, 1962).Google Scholar
  22. BMA 001-028-00036/9 Guanyu Jiuxianqiao renmin gongshe de diaocha baogao (caogao) [Report on a Survey of the Jiuxianqiao People’s Commune (Draft)] (January 18, 1962).Google Scholar
  23. BMA 002-003-00205/1 Zhengwuyuan [State Administrative Council], “Guanyu jiejue Beijingshi zhengfu ge jiguan dangpai yu qunzhong tuanti zhufang wenti de tongbao” [Report About Solving the Housing Problem for Beijing Government Agencies, Parties and Mass Organizations] (April 28, 1951).Google Scholar
  24. BMA 002-006-00308/2 Beijingshi wunianlai shizheng jianshe fazhan jiankuang [Brief Introduction to the Development of the Municipal Administration in Beijing in the Last Five Years] (March 1954).Google Scholar
  25. BMA 002-006-00308/5 Fangdichan guanliju [Housing Management Bureau], “Beijingshi fangdichan guanli gongzuo jiben zongjie yu jinhou de gongzuo yijian” [Basic Summary of the Management of Housing in Beijing and Ideas for Future Work] (June 7, 1954).Google Scholar
  26. BMA 047-001-00064/3 Tong Zheng, “Beijing de chengshi buju he jianshe zhong de liangge jiben maodun (caogao)” [Two Fundamental Contradictions in the Construction and Layout of the City of Beijing (Draft)] (August 4, 1959).Google Scholar
  27. BMA 047-001-00155 Guanyu Beijing chengshi jianshe de xianzhuang diaocha baogao [Report on an Investigation of the Present Situation of Beijing Urban Construction] (August, 31, 1961).Google Scholar
  28. BMA 100-001-00659/11 Gongqingtuan Xuanwu quwei hui, [Xuanwu district committee of the Communist Youth League] “Woqu gongshe tuan ganbu zai Beijing shituanxiao xuexi zhong baoluchu de jige wenti” [Some Questions That Emerged When Our District’s League Cadres Were Studying at the League School in Beijing] (September 16, 1960).Google Scholar
  29. BMA 100-001-00659/6 Qingkuang jianbao 3 hao [Briefing on Current the Situation No. 3] (July 19, 1960).Google Scholar
  30. BMA 101-001-00782/5 Zhigong jiashu chengle shehui caifu de chuangzaozhe: Shijingshan Zhongsu youhao renmin gongshe jieshao [Workers’ Spouses Have Become the Creators of Social Wealth: A Description of the Shijingshan China-Soviet Friendship People’s Commune] (1960).Google Scholar
  31. BMA 133-010-00462 Chengshi renmin gongshe yicixing diaocha [A Survey of the Urban People’s Communes] (April 30, 1960).Google Scholar
  32. BMA 133-010-00463 Chengshi renmin gongshe jiben qingkuang diaocha [A Survey of the Basic Situation of the Urban People’s Communes] (November 1960).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Fabio Lanza
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of HistoryUniversity of ArizonaTucsonUSA

Personalised recommendations