Chlorination of Drinking Water – Scientific Evidence and Policy Implications

  • Madjid Mohseni
  • Edward A. McBean
  • Manuel J. Rodriguez
Chapter
Part of the Global Issues in Water Policy book series (GLOB, volume 17)

Abstract

Identification of the value of chlorine as an efficient oxidant and disinfectant resulted in its subsequent worldwide application for disinfecting water, and is considered one of most important discoveries of the early twentieth century, improving public health. The use of chlorine in various forms continued at worldwide scale, for subsequent decades, until the 1970s when it was identified that chlorine reacts with naturally occurring organic compounds, producing potentially harmful disinfection byproducts (DBPs). Regardless, despite widespread concerns around DBPs and the inclusion in drinking water guidelines and regulations for some DBPs, many communities (especially small and rural communities with limited resources) rely solely on chlorine as primary disinfectant. Also, the use of chlorine as a secondary disinfectant to ensure residual disinfectant in the distribution system is required in many parts of the world, including in Canada. Public resentment to having chlorine in their water is a challenge associated with the use of this disinfectant in drinking water supplies, especially in aboriginal communities, with many disliking the taste and odour of chlorine, making the policy around chlorination of water very difficult and complicated. While science supports the benefits of maintaining residual chlorine in water supplies, it warns of DBP formation and its potential impact to public health. Hence, resistance to implementation of policy due to public perception and resentment continues. The work presented will describe the role of science in shaping the policy and public opinion around the use of chlorine in drinking water supplies, with particular emphasis on small and rural communities.

References

  1. Allen, M. J., Edberg, C. S., & Reasoner, D. J. (2004). Heterotrophic plate count bacteria – What is their significance in drinking water? International Journal of Food Microbiology, 92(3), 265–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Anderson, K. (2010, October). Aboriginal women, water and health: Reflections from eleven first nations, Inuit and Metis Grandmothers (p. 32). Atlantic Centre of Excellence for Women’s Health, Prairie Women’s Health Centre of Excellence.Google Scholar
  3. Bellar, T. A., Lichtenberg, J. J., & Kroner, R. C. (1974). The occurrence of organohalides in chlorinated drinking water. Journal of the American Water Works Association, 66(22), 703–706.Google Scholar
  4. Black, K., & McBean, E. (2016). Increased indigenous participation in decision-making: A Policy framework for the improvement of indigenous health. The International Indigenous Policy Journal, under review.Google Scholar
  5. Brisson, I., Levallois, P., Tremblay, H., Sérodes, J.-B., DeBlois, C., Charrois, J., Taguchi, V., Boyd, J., Li, X. F., & Rodriguez, M. J. (2013). Spatial and temporal occurrence of N-Nitrosamines in seven drinking water supply systems. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 185(9), 7693–7708.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Chambers, V. K., Creasey, J. D., & Joy, J. S. (1995). Modelling free and total chlorine decay in potable water distribution systems. Journal of Water Supply: Research & Technology – AQUA, 44(2), 60–69.Google Scholar
  7. Cornell, G., & Connell, G. F. (1997). Chlorination and chloramination handbook (Water disinfection series 1st ed., p. 174). Denver: AWWWA.Google Scholar
  8. Corston-Pine, E. (2015). Facilitator of First Nations. Guelph: University of Guelph, personal communication.Google Scholar
  9. Crittenden, J. C., Trussell, R., Hand, D., Howe, K., & Tchobanoglous, G. (2005a). Kinetics of disinfection. In Water treatment: Principles and design, MWH (2nd ed., pp. 1042–1067). Hoboken: Wiley.Google Scholar
  10. Crittenden, J. C., Trussell, R., Hand, D., Howe, K., & Tchobanoglous, G. (2005b). Taste and odor. In Water treatment: Principles and design, MWH (2nd ed., pp. 100–110). Hoboken: Wiley.Google Scholar
  11. Delisle, F.-J., Rochette, S., Pelletier, G., Asadzadehd, M., Tolson, B., & Rodriguez, M. J. (2015). Minimizing water residence time in Quebec City’s main distribution network using hybrid discrete dynamically dimensioned search (HD-DDS): Part II. Journal of Water Supply: Research & Technology – AQUA, 64(3), 378–390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Dharmarajah, H., Patania, N., Jacangelo, J., & Aieta, E. (1991, June 23–27). Empirical modeling of chlorine and chloramine residual decay. In: AWWA annual conference proceedings, Philadelphia.Google Scholar
  13. Dodds, L., King, W., Woolcott, C., & Pole, J. (1999). Trihalomethanes in public water supplies and adverse birth outcomes. Epidemiology, 10(3), 233–237.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Dore, M., Singh, R., Acharib, G., & Khaleghi-Moghadam, A. (2013). Cost scenarios for small drinking water treatment technologies. Desalination and Water Treatment, 51(16–18), 3628–3638.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Doria, M. F. (2010). Factors influencing public perception of drinking water quality. Water Policy, 12(1), 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Ekos Research Associates Inc. (2009, February 27). Water quality on-reserve quantitative research. Report to Health Canada, Ottawa, Canada. PWGSC contract number: H1011-08009/001/CY, POR registration number: 095-08.Google Scholar
  17. Ekos Research Associates Inc. (2011, March 25). Perceptions of drinking water quality in First Nations communities and general population. Report to Health Canada, Ottawa, Canada. PWGSC contract number: HT372-101292/001/CY, POR registration number: 087-10.Google Scholar
  18. Francisque, A., Rodriguez, M. J., Miranda-Moreno, L., Sadiq, R., & Proulx, F. (2009). Modeling of heterotrophic bacteria counts in a water distribution system. Water Research, 43(4), 1075–1087.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Golfinopoulos, S., Nikolaou, A., Uyak, V., Toroz, I., Rodriguez, M. J., & Sérodes, J.-B. (2007). Occurrence, fate and transport modeling of DBPs in drinking water. In A. Nikolaou, L. Rizzo, & H. Selcuk (Eds.), Advances in control of disinfection by-products in drinking water systems (pp. 129–162). Hauppauge: Nova.Google Scholar
  20. Guay, C., Rodriguez, M. J., & Sérodes, J.-B. (2005). Using ozonation and chloramination to reduce the formation of trihalomethanes and haloacetic acids in drinking water. Desalination, 176(1–3), 229–240.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Harvey, R., Murphy, H., McBean, E., & Gharabaghi, B. (2015). Using data mining to understand drinking water advisories in small water systems: A case study of Ontario First Nations drinking water supplies. Water Resources Management, 29(14), 5129–5139.Google Scholar
  22. Health Canada. (2013). Guidance for providing safe drinking water in areas of federal jurisdiction, Version 2. Water and Air Quality Bureau, Healthy Environments and Consumer Safety Branch, Health Canada, Ottawa, Catalogue No. H128-1/05-440-1E-PDF.Google Scholar
  23. Islam, N. (2015). Water quality management in small to medium sized distribution networks: Optimizing chlorine disinfection strategies (p. 207). Dissertation, University of British Columbia.Google Scholar
  24. Islam, N., Farahat, A., Al-Zahrani, M., Rodriguez, M. J., & Sadiq, R. (2015). Contaminant intrusion in water distribution networks: Review and proposal of an integrated model for decision making. Environmental Reviews, 23(3), 337–352.Google Scholar
  25. Leblanc, I. (2015). Special advisor for housing, infrastructure and emergency issues. Ottawa: Management at Assembly of First Nations, personal communication.Google Scholar
  26. Jadas-Hécart, A., El Moher, A., Stitou, M., Bouillot, P., & Legube, B. (1992). The chlorine demand of a treated water. Water Research, 26(8), 1073–1084.Google Scholar
  27. Kanitz, S., Franco, Y., Patrone, V., Caltabellotta, M., Raffo, E., Riggi, C., Timitilli, D., & Ravera, G. (1996). Association between drinking water disinfection and somatic parameters at birth. Environmental Health Perspectives, 104(5), 516–520.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Krasner, S. W., Weinberg, H. S., Richardson, S. D., Pastor, S. J., Chinn, R., Sclimenti, M. J., Onstad, G. D., & Thurston, A. D., Jr. (2006). Occurrence of a new generation of disinfection byproducts. Environmental Science & Technology, 40(23), 7175–7185.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Levallois, P., Gingras, S., Marcoux, S., Legay, C., Catto, C., Rodriguez, M. J., & Tardif, R. (2012). Maternal exposure to drinking water chlorination by-products and small-for-gestational age neonates. Epidemiology, 23(2), 267–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. McBean, E., Zhu, Z., & Zeng, W. (2008). Systems analysis models for disinfection by-product formation in chlorinated drinking water in ontario. Journal of Civil Engineering and Environmental Systems, 25(2), 127–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Montgomery, J. M., & Consulting Engineers. (1985). Water treatment principles and design. Walnut Creek: Wiley.Google Scholar
  32. Morris, R. D. (2007). The blue death, disease, disaster and the water we drink. New York: Harper Collins.Google Scholar
  33. Murphy, H. M, Corston-Pine, E., & McBean, E. A. (2015a). Insights and opportunities: Challenges of Canadian First Nations drinking water operators (pp. 20–21). Water Canada (January–February).Google Scholar
  34. Murphy, H. M., Corston-Pine, E., Post, Y., & McBean, E. A. (2015b). Insights and opportunities: challenges of Canadian First Nations drinking water operators. The International Indigenous Policy Journal, 6(3), 17.Google Scholar
  35. Murphy, H. M., Bhatti, M. A., Harvey. R., & McBean, E. A. (2015c). Using decision trees to predict drinking water advisories and understand vulnerabilities in small water systems. Journal of the American Water Works Association, Accepted for publication August 2015.Google Scholar
  36. Nagata, J., Valeggia, C., Smith, N., Barg, F., Guidera, M., & Bream, K. (2011). Criticism of chlorination: Determinants of drinking water beliefs and practices among the Tz’utujil Maya. Revista Panamericana Salud Pública, 29(1), 9–16.Google Scholar
  37. Nieuwenhuijsen, M. J., Toledano, M. B., Eaton, N. E., Fawell, J., & Elliott, P. (2000). Chlorination disinfection byproducts in water and their association with adverse reproductive outcomes: A review. Occupational & Environmental Medicine, 57(2), 73–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Norton, C. D., & LeChevallier, M. W. (1997). Chloramination: Its effect on distribution system water quality. Journal of the American Water Works Association, 89(7), 66–77.Google Scholar
  39. Piriou, P., Mackey, E. D., Suffet, I. H., & Bruchet, A. (2004). Chlorinous flavor perception in drinking water. Water Science and Technology, 49(9), 321–328.Google Scholar
  40. Richardson, S. D. (2002). The role of GC-MS and LC-MS in the discovery of drinking water disinfection by-products. Journal of Environmental Monitoring, 4(1), 1–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Rodriguez, M. J., Milot, J., Sérodes, J.-B., & Pacaud, A. (2002). Estimation of bench-scale chlorine decay in drinking water using nth-order kinetic and neural network models. Water Quality Research Journal of Canada, 37(3), 613–635.Google Scholar
  42. Rook, J. J. (1974). Formation of haloforms during chlorination of natural waters. Water Treatment Examination, 23(2), 234–243.Google Scholar
  43. Rossman, L. A., Clark, R. M., & Grayman, W. M. (1994). Modeling chlorine residuals in drinking water distribution systems. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 120(4), 803–820.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Ruddick, J. A., Villeneuve, D. C., Chi, I., & Valli, V. E. (1983). A teratological assessment of four trihalomethanes in the rat. Journal of Environmental Science and Health B, 18(3), 333–349.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Savitz, D. A., Andrews, K. W., & Pastore, L. M. (1995). Drinking water and pregnancy outcome in Central North Carolina: Source, amount and trihalomethane levels. Environmental Health Perspectives, 103(6), 592–596.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Scheili, A. (2015). Variabilité spatio-temporelle de la qualité de l’eau potable des petits réseaux : Facteurs explicatifs et développement d’outils de gestion (p. 215). Dissertation, Université Laval.Google Scholar
  47. Smith, H. V., Smith, A. L., Girdwood, R. W. A., & Carrington, E. G. (1990). The effect of free chlorine on the viability of Cryptosporidium sp. oocysts isolated from human faeces. In J. Badenoch (Ed.), Cryptosporidium in water supplies: Report of the group of experts (pp. 185–204). London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  48. Sterling, C. R., Korich, D. G., Madore, M. S., & Sinclair, N. A. (1989, November 12–16). Chlorine and ozone inactivation of Cryptosporidium oocysts. In: AWWA water quality technology conference and exposition proceedings, Philadelphia.Google Scholar
  49. Turgeon, S., Rodriguez, M. J., Thériault, M., & Levallois, P. (2004). Perception of drinking water in the Quebec City region (Canada): The influence of water quality and consumer location in the distribution system. Journal of Environmental Management, 70(4), 363–373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. US EPA. (1998, December 16). National primary drinking water regulations: Disinfectants and disinfection by-products; Final rule. Federal Register, vol 63, N°241.Google Scholar
  51. US EPA. (1991). Guidance manual for compliance with the filtration and disinfection requirements for public water systems using surface water sources. Washington, DC: United States Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 570391001.Google Scholar
  52. US EPA. (1999). Microbial and disinfection by-product rules – Simultaneous compliance guidance manual. Washington, DC: United States Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 815-R99-014.Google Scholar
  53. US EPA. (2000). The history of drinking water treatment. Washington, DC: United States Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 816-F-00-006.Google Scholar
  54. Wikipedia. (2015). Drinking water. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_water. Accessed 5 Oct 2015.
  55. Wilczak, A., Hoover, L. L., & Lai, H. H. (2003). Effects of treatment changes on chloramines demand and decay. Journal of the American Water Works Association, 95(7), 94–106.Google Scholar
  56. World Health Organization. (2005). Bromate in drinking water: Background document for development of WHO guidelines for drinking-water Quality. Geneva: World Health Organization, WHO/SDE/WSH/05.08/78.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Madjid Mohseni
    • 1
  • Edward A. McBean
    • 2
  • Manuel J. Rodriguez
    • 3
  1. 1.Department of Chemical & Biological EngineeringUniversity of British ColumbiaVancouverCanada
  2. 2.School of EngineeringUniversity of GuelphGuelphCanada
  3. 3.École supérieure d’aménagement du territoire et de développement régional (ÉSAD)Laval UniversityVille de QuébecCanada

Personalised recommendations