Paternalism in Psychiatry: Anorexia Nervosa, Decision-Making Capacity, and Compulsory Treatment
Decision-making capacity or mental competence is one of the most intensively discussed concepts in contemporary bioethics and medical ethics. In this paper I argue that anorexia nervosa, an eating disorder primarily afflicting adolescent girls and young women, seriously challenges what I label the traditional account of decision-making capacity. In light of these results, it may in addition be necessary to rethink a certain popular type of paternalistic argumentation that grounds the justification of compulsory treatment, for example of anorexic persons who refuse treatment, on a lack of decision-making capacity.
KeywordsAnorexia Nervosa Eating Disorder Traditional Account Mental Time Travel Semantic Argument
I thank audiences in Hamburg, Lübeck and Bochum for extremely helpful comments. Special thanks are due to Jochen Vollmann, Adrian Viens, Thomas Schramme, Iara Cury and Michael Dunn.
- American Psychiatric Association. 1996. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-IV), 4th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Publications.Google Scholar
- Beauchamp, Tom L. 2009. The concept of paternalism in biomedical ethics. Jahrbuch für Wissenschaft und Ethik 14: 77–92.Google Scholar
- Bortolotti, Lisa. 2010. Delusions and other irrational beliefs. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Charland, Louis C. 1998a. Is Mr. Spock mentally competent: Competence to consent and emotion. Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology 5(1): 67–95.Google Scholar
- Charland, Louis C. 2011. Decision-making capacity. In The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Summer 2011 Edition), ed. Edward N. Zalta. http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2011/entries/decision-capacity/.
- Culver, Charles M., and Bernard Gert. 2004. Competence. In The philosophy of psychiatry: A companion, ed. Jennifer Radden, 258–270. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Feinberg, Joel. 1986. Harm to self. The moral limits of the criminal law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Grisso, Thomas, and Paul S. Appelbaum. 1998. Assessing competence to consent to treatment. A guide for physicians and other health professionals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Grisso, Thomas, Paul S. Appelbaum, E.P. Mulvey, and K. Fletcher. 1995. The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. II. Measures and abilities related to competence to consent to treatment. Law and Human Behavior 19: 126–148.Google Scholar
- Hope, Tony, Jacinta Tan, Anne Stewart, and Ray Fitzpatrick. 2011. Anorexia nervosa and the language of authenticity. Hastings Center Report 41(6): 19–29.Google Scholar
- Tan, Jacinta, Anne Stewart, and Tony Hope. 2010. Decision-making as a broader concept. Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology 16(4): 345–349.Google Scholar