Advertisement

Bridging Promises and (Dis)Illusions: Deliberative Democracy in an Evolutionary Perspective

  • Luigi PellizzoniEmail author
Chapter

Abstract

The participatory, and especially deliberative, turn is a major political phenomenon of last decades. Deliberative democracy has spread quickly, regardless of differences in institutional layouts and traditions. An equally fast-evolving debate has addressed its virtues and problems, gradually shifting from theory to practice and from a focus on deliberative arenas to a concern for their policy and institutional context, the latter being implicitly or explicitly referred to the emergence of new governance styles. More recently a different critical literature has emerged, which adopts a governmentality perspective to argue about the inclusion of participatory democracy in neoliberal forms of regulation. The chapter illustrates major points of contention between these two literatures and considers some attempts at merging them, with related problems. Finally, it addresses the potentials of evolutionary governance theory as a framework for bridging diverse approaches to the promises and perils of participation.

Keywords

Deliberative Democracy Deliberative Process Participatory Democracy Public Deliberation Governmentality Approach 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

References

  1. Ansell C, Gash A (2008) Collaborative governance in theory and practice. J Publ Admin Res Theor 18(4):543–571CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Barnes M, Newman J, Sullivan H (2007) Power, participation and political renewal. Policy Press, BristolGoogle Scholar
  3. Besson S, Martí JL (2006) Introduction. In: Besson S, Martí JL (eds) Deliberative democracy and its discontents. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp xiii–xxxiGoogle Scholar
  4. Bevir M (2007) The construction of governance. In: Bevir M, Trentmann F (eds) Governance, consumers and citizens. Palgrave MacMillan, New York, NY, pp 25–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bevir M (2010) Rethinking governmentality: towards genealogies of governance. Eur J Soc Theor 13(4):423–441CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bevir M (2011) Governance and governmentality after neoliberalism. Policy Politics 39(4):457–471CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bevir M, Trentmann F (2008) Civic choices: retrieving perspectives on rationality, consumption, and citizenship. In: Soper K, Trentmann F (eds) Citizenship and consumption. Palgrave MacMillan, Basingstoke, pp 19–33Google Scholar
  8. Blakeley G (2010) Governing ourselves: citizen participation and governance in Barcelona and Manchester. Int J Urban Reg Res 34(1):130–145CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Blatrix C (2009) La démocratie participative en representation. Sociétés Contemporaines 74:97–119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bobbio L (ed) (2013) La Qualità della Deliberazione. Processi Dialogici tra Cittadini. Carocci, RomaGoogle Scholar
  11. Bobbio L, Pomatto G (2007) Modelli di coinvolgimento dei cittadini nelle scelte pubbliche. Report for the Provincia Autonoma di TrentoGoogle Scholar
  12. Bohman J, Rehg W (eds) (1997) Deliberative democracy. MIT Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  13. Bröckling U, Krasmann S, Lemke T (eds) (2011) Governmentality. Current issues and future challenges. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  14. CEC (2001) European governance. A white paper. Commission of the European Communities, Com 2001(428), BrusselsGoogle Scholar
  15. Clarke J (2010) Enrolling ordinary people: governmental strategies and the avoidance of politics? Citizen Stud 14(6):637–650CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Crouch C (2004) Post democracy. Polity Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  17. D’Albergo E, Moini G (eds) (2007) Partecipazione, Movimenti e Politiche Pubbliche a Roma. Aracne, RomaGoogle Scholar
  18. Dardot P, Laval C (2009) La Nouvelle Raison du Monde. Essai sur la Société Néolibérale. La Découverte, ParisGoogle Scholar
  19. Dean M (1999) Governmentality. Power and rule in modern society. Sage, LondonGoogle Scholar
  20. Dryzek J (2001) Deliberative democracy and beyond. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  21. Dryzek J, List C (2003) Social choice theory and deliberative democracy: a reconciliation. Br J Polit Sci 33(1):1–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. EC (2000) The future of parliamentary democracy: transition and challenge in European Governance. Green Paper. AS/D(2000). European Commission, Brussels. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/governance/docs/doc3_en.pdf
  23. Elster J (ed) (1998) Deliberative democracy. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  24. Felt U, Wynne B (eds) (2007) Taking European knowledge society seriously. Report for the European Commission. Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, LuxembourgGoogle Scholar
  25. Fischer F (2010) Participatory governance. Jerusalem Papers in Regulation and Governance. Working Paper No 24Google Scholar
  26. Floridia A (2008) Democrazia deliberativa e processi decisionali: la legge della Regione Toscana sulla partecipazione. Stato e Mercato 82:83–110Google Scholar
  27. Floridia A (2013) Partecipazione, deliberazione e politiche pubbliche: soltanto inefficacia o manipolazione? Uno schema analitico e un caso di studio. Paper presented at the XXVII conference of the Italian association for political science (SISP), Florence, 12–14 SeptemberGoogle Scholar
  28. Foucault M (1980) The confession of the flesh (1977). In: Gordon C (ed) Power/knowledge selected interviews and other writings. Pantheon Books, New York, NY, pp 194–228Google Scholar
  29. Foucault M (1991) Governmentality (lecture at the Collège de France, February 1978). In: Burchell G, Gordon C, Miller P (eds) The Foucault effect. Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead, pp 87–104Google Scholar
  30. Foucault M (1997a) The ethics of the concern for the self as a practice of freedom. In: Rabinow P (ed) Ethics, subjectivity and truth, vol 1, Essential works. Penguin, London, pp 281–301Google Scholar
  31. Foucault M (1997b) What is critique? In: Lotringer S (ed) The politics of truth. Semiotext(e), Los Angeles, pp 41–82Google Scholar
  32. Freschi AC, Mete V (2009) The political meanings of institutional deliberative experiments. Findings on the Italian case. Sociologica 2–3 [online]. Available at: http://www.sociologica.mulino.it/journal/article/index/Article/Journal:ARTICLE:342
  33. Fuller C (2013) Urban politics and the social practices of critique and justification: conceptual insights from French pragmatism. Prog Hum Geogr 37(5):639–657CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Fung A (2004) Empowered participation. Reinventing urban democracy. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJGoogle Scholar
  35. Fung A (2006) Varieties of participation in complex governance. Publ Admin Rev December:66–75, special issueCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Fung A, Wright EO (eds) (2003) Deepening democracy: innovations in empowered participatory governance. Verso, New York, NYGoogle Scholar
  37. Gastil J, Levine P (2005) The deliberative democracy handbook: strategies for effective civic engagement in the 21st century. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CAGoogle Scholar
  38. Goodin R (2000) Democratic deliberation within. Philos Publ Aff 29(1):79–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Goodin R, Dryzek J (2006) Deliberative impacts: the macro-political uptake of mini-publics. Polit Soc 34(2):219–244CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Goven J (2006) Dialogue, governance and biotechnology: acknowledging the context of the conversation. Integr Assess J 6(2):99–116Google Scholar
  41. Guarneiros-Meza V, Geddes M (2010) Local governance and participation under neoliberalism: comparative perspectives. Int J Urban Reg Res 34(1):115–119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Habermas J (1996) Between facts and norms. MIT Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  43. Hagendijk R, Irwin A (2006) Public deliberation and governance: engaging with science and technology in contemporary Europe. Minerva 44:167–184CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Hajer M, Wagenaar H (eds) (2003) Deliberative policy analysis. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  45. Held D (2006) Models of democracy. Polity Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  46. Hendriks C (2006) When the forum meets interests politics: strategic uses of public deliberation. Polit Soc 34(4):571–602CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Hobson K (2009) On a governmentality analytics of the ‘deliberative turn’: material conditions, rationalities and the deliberating subject. Space Polity 13(3):175–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Irwin A, Jensen TE, Jones KE (2013) The good, the bad and the perfect: criticizing engagement practice. Soc Stud Sci 43(1):118–135CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Jessop B (2002) Liberalism, neo-Liberalism and urban governance: a state theoretical perspective. Antipode 34(3):452–472CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Lanzara GF, Lupo G (2013) Processi deliberativi e arene politiche locali: come le dinamiche politico-istituzionali influenzano la deliberazione. In: Bobbio L (ed) La Qualità della Deliberazione. Studio sui Processi Dialogici tra Cittadini. Carocci, Roma, pp 213–249Google Scholar
  51. Lemke T (2003) Foucault, governmentality and critique. Rethink Marxism 14(3):49–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Lemke T (2007) An indigestible meal? Foucault, governmentality and state theory. Distinktion: Scand J Soc Theor 15:43–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Levidov L (2007) European public participation as risk governance: enhancing public accountability for agro-biotechnology policy? East Asian Sci Technol Soc 1:19–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Lewanski R (2013) Institutionalizing deliberative democracy: the ‘Tuscany laboratory’. Journal of Public Deliberation 9(1), article 10. Available at: http://www.publicdeliberation.net/jpd/vol9/iss1/art10
  55. Lezaun J, Soneryd L (2007) Consulting citizens: technologies of elicitation and the mobility of publics. Public Underst Sci 16:279–297CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Lövbrand E, Pielke R Jr, Beck S (2011) A democratic paradox in studies of science and technology. Sci Technol Hum Val 36(4):474–496CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Malpass A, Barnett C, Clarke N, Cloke P (2007) Problematizing choice: responsible consumers and sceptical citizens. In: Bevir M, Trentmann F (eds) Governance, consumers and citizens. Palgrave MacMillan, New York, NY, pp 231–256Google Scholar
  58. Mansbridge J, Bohman J, Chambers S, Estlund D, Føllesdal A, Fung A, Lafont C, Manin B, Martí JL (2010) The place of self-interest and the role of power in deliberative democracy. J Polit Philos 18(1):64–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Marres N, Lezaun J (2011) Materials and devices of the public: an introduction. Econ Soc 40(4):489–509CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. McKee K (2009) Post-Foucauldian governmentality: what does it offer critical social policy analysis? Crit Soc Policy 29:465–486CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Melo M, Baiocchi G (2006) Deliberative democracy and local governance: towards a new agenda. Int J Urban Reg Res 30(3):587–600CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Moini G (2012) Teoria critica della partecipazione. Un approccio sociologico. Angeli, MilanoGoogle Scholar
  63. Mouffe C (2005) On the political. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  64. Mutz D (2008) Is deliberative democracy a falsifiable theory? Annu Rev Polit Sci 11:521–538CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Nealon J (2008) Foucault beyond Foucault. Power and its intensification since 1984. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CAGoogle Scholar
  66. Newman J (2005) Participative governance and the remaking of the public sphere. In: Newman J (ed) Remaking governance. Peoples, politics and the public sphere. Policy Press, Bristol, pp 119–138Google Scholar
  67. Newman J, Clarke J (2009) Public, politics and power. Sage, LondonGoogle Scholar
  68. Niemeyer S, Dryzek J (2007) The ends of deliberation: meta-consensus and inter-subjective rationality as ideal outcomes. Swiss Polit Sci Rev 13(4):497–526CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Owen D (1999) Orientation and enlightenment: an essay on critique and genealogy. In: Ashenden S, Owen D (eds) Foucault contra Habermas. Sage, London, pp 21–44Google Scholar
  70. Papadopoulos Y, Warin P (eds) (2007) Innovative, participatory and deliberative procedures in policy making: democratic and effective? Eur J Polit Res 46(4), special issueGoogle Scholar
  71. Parkinson J (2006) Deliberating in the real world. Problems of legitimacy in deliberative democracy. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Parkinson J, Mansbridge J (eds) (2012) Deliberative systems. Deliberative democracy at the large scale. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  73. Pateman C (1970) Participation and democratic theory. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Pellizzoni L (2012) In search of community. Political consumerism, governmentality and immunization. Eur J Soc Theor 15(2):221–241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Pellizzoni L (2013) Une idée sur le déclin? Evaluer la nouvelle critique de la délibération publique. Participations 2:87–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Pestre D (2008) Challenges for the democratic management of technoscience: governance, participation and the political today. Sci Cult 17(2):101–119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Purcell M (2008) Recapturing democracy. Neoliberalization and the struggle for alternative urban futures. Routledge, New York, NYGoogle Scholar
  78. Raman S, Tutton R (2010) Life, science, and biopower. Sci Technol Hum Val 35(5):711–734CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Rancière J (1998) Disagreement. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MNGoogle Scholar
  80. Revel M, Blatrix C, Blondiaux L, Fourniau J-M, Heriard-Dubreuil B, Lefebvre R (2007) Le Débat Public: Une Experience Française de Démocratie Participative. La Découverte, ParisGoogle Scholar
  81. Richardson L (2011) Cross-fertilisation of governance and governmentality in practical policy making on behaviour change. Policy Polit 39(4):533–546CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Roff RJ (2007) Shopping for change? Neoliberalizing activism and the limits to eating non-GMO. Agric Hum Val 24:511–522CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Rose N (1999) Powers of freedom. Reframing political thought. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Rose N (2007) The politics of life itself. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJGoogle Scholar
  85. Rosenberg S (2005) The empirical study of deliberative democracy: setting a research agenda. Acta Politica 40(2):212–224CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Rosenberg S (2007) Rethinking democratic deliberation: the limits and potential of citizen participation. Polity 39(3):335–360CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Sending OJ, Neumann I (2006) Governance to governmentality: analyzing NGOs, states, and power. Int Stud Quart 50:651–672CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Silver H, Scott A, Kazepov Y (2010) Participation in urban contention and deliberation. Int J Urban Reg Res 34(3):453–477CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Sintomer Y, Allegretti G (2009) I Bilanci Partecipativi in Europa. Nuove Esperienze Democratiche nel Vecchio Continente. Ediesse, RomaGoogle Scholar
  90. Sintomer Y, De Maillard J (2007) The limits to local participation and deliberation in the French ‘politique de la ville’. Eur J Polit Res 46:503–529CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Sørensen E, Torfing J (2005) Network governance and post-liberal democracy. Admin Theor Praxis 27(5):197–237Google Scholar
  92. Steiner J (2012) The foundations of deliberative democracy. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Steiner J, Bachtiger A, Sporndli M, Steenbergen M (2004) Deliberative politics in action: analyzing parliamentary discourse. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  94. Thompson D (2008) Deliberative democratic theory and empirical political science. Annu Rev Polit Sci 11:497–520CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  95. Tickell A, Peck J (2003) Making global rules: globalization or neoliberalization? In: Peck J, Yeung HW (eds) Remaking the global economy. Sage, London, pp 163–181Google Scholar
  96. Tsouvalis J, Waterton C (2012) Building ‘participation’ upon critique: the Loweswater Care Project, Cumbria, UK. Environ Model Software 36:111–121CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Urbinati N (2010) Unpolitical democracy. Polit Theor 38(1):65–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Van Assche K, Beunen R, Duineveld M (2013) Evolutionary governance theory. An introduction. Springer, HeidelbergGoogle Scholar
  99. Van Eeten M (2001) The challenge ahead for deliberative democracy. Sci Publ Policy 28(6):423–426CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Van Mill D (1996) The possibility of rational outcomes from democratic discourse and procedures. J Polit 58(3):735–752Google Scholar
  101. Williams R (1977) Marxism and literature. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  102. Wynne B (2007) Public participation in science and technology: performing and obscuring a political-conceptual category mistake. East Asian Sci Technol Soc 1:99–110Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Political and Social ScienceUniversity of TriesteTriesteItaly

Personalised recommendations