Is There a Human Right to Development?

  • Rumu Sarkar


The clash of ideals is the most apparent in the arena of human rights. The challenge of a new dialogue on human rights lies in a redefinition of the legal, economic, social, and cultural values by developing countries, and in seeking common ground with the developed world. Forging a new “right to development” within the discourse on international development law is helping to establish a new and highly significant legal jurisprudence on the subject.


  1. Agusti-Panaveda J (2008) Transforming weakness into virtue: a dialogue and context based approach to human rights at the World Bank. Hum Rights Glob Law Rev 2:23Google Scholar
  2. Alam S, Karim MS (2011) The linkage of development and environment: in search of an integrated approach to sustainable development. Geo Int Environ Law Rev 23:345, 354Google Scholar
  3. Alston P (1982) A third generation of solidarity rights: progressive development or obfuscation of international human rights law? Neth Int Law Rev 29:307, 321CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Alston P (1984) Conjuring up new human rights: a proposal for quality control. Am J Int Law 78Google Scholar
  5. Alston P (1990) U.S. ratification of the covenant on economic, social and cultural rights: the need for an entirely new strategy. Am J Int Law 84Google Scholar
  6. Arts K (2000) Integrating human rights into development cooperation: the case of the Lomé Convention. Kluwer Law InternationalGoogle Scholar
  7. Arts K (2016) The right to development in international law: new momentum thirty years down the line? Neth Int Law Rev 63Google Scholar
  8. Asamoah O (1966) The legal significance of the declarations of the General Assembly of the United Nations. Martinus NijhoffGoogle Scholar
  9. Bleicher S (1969) The legal significance of re-citation of general assembly resolutions. Am J Int Law 63:444, 445CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Boyd K (1999) Collective rights adjudication in U.S. courts: enforcing human rights at the corporate level. BYUL 1999:1139, 1151–1152Google Scholar
  11. Brietzke P (1985) Consorting with the Chameleon, or realizing the right to development. Calif West Int Law J 15:560, 586Google Scholar
  12. Brownlie I (1992) Basic documents on human rights, 3rd edn. Clarendon PressGoogle Scholar
  13. Buchheit L (1978) Secession: the legitimacy of self-determination, p 14Google Scholar
  14. Bulajie M (1988) Principles of international development law: the right to development as an inalienable human right. In: de Waart P, Peters P, Denters E (eds) International law and development. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, p 359Google Scholar
  15. Bunn I (2000) The right to development: implications for international economic law. Am Univ Int Law Rev 15:1425Google Scholar
  16. Cao L (1997) Book review, law and economic development: a new beginning? Tex Int Law J 32:545, 556Google Scholar
  17. Cass D (1992) Rethinking self-determination: a critical analysis of current international law theories. Syracuse J Int Law Corm 18:21, 23–24Google Scholar
  18. Cassesse A (1992) The general assembly: historical perspective 1945–1989. In: Alston P (ed) The United Nations and Human Rights: a critical appraisal, vol 25. Clarendon Paperbacks, p 31Google Scholar
  19. Charlesworth H, Chinkin C (1993) The gender of jus cogens. Hum Rights Q 15:63, 64–65Google Scholar
  20. Cobbah J (1987) African values and the human rights debate: an African perspective. Hum Rights Q 9:309, 323CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Cooper E (1996) Comment on ‘transitional constitutionalism’: politics and law in Russia since 1993. Wis Int Law J 14:531, 540Google Scholar
  22. Cossman B (1991) Reform, revolution or retrenchment? International human rights in the post-cold war era. Hum Int Law J 32:339, 345Google Scholar
  23. Darrow M, Arbour L (2009) The pillar of glass: human rights in the development operations of the United Nations. Am J Int Law 103:446CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. de Vey Mestdagh K (1981) The right to development. Sijthoff & Norordhoff International PublishersGoogle Scholar
  25. Dennis M, Stewart D (2004) Justiciability of economic, social and cultural rights: should there by an international complaints mechanism to adjudicate the rights to food, water, housing and health? ASIL 98Google Scholar
  26. Donnelly J (1984) The ‘right to development’: how not to link human rights and development. In: Welch C, Meltzer R (eds) Human rights and development in Africa. SUNY Press, pp 261–262Google Scholar
  27. Donnelly J (1985) In search of the unicorn: the jurisprudence and politics of the right to development. Calif West Int Law J 15:473, 474Google Scholar
  28. Donnelly J (1990) Human rights and western liberalism. In: An-Na’im A, Deng F (eds) Human rights in Africa: cross-cultural perspectives. Brookings Institute, p 31Google Scholar
  29. Ellis M (1985) The new international economic order and general assembly resolutions: the debate over the legal effects of general assembly resolutions revisited. Calif West Int Law J 15:647, 652–653Google Scholar
  30. Espiell HG (1981) The right of development as a human right. Tex Int Law J 16:189, 192Google Scholar
  31. Falk R (1966) On the quasi-legislative competence of the general assembly. Am J Int Law 60:782CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Gittleman R (1984) The Banjul Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights: a legal analysis. In: Welch C, Meltzer R (eds) Human rights and development in Africa. SUNY PressGoogle Scholar
  33. Gunther K (1992) The domestic policy function of a right of peoples to development: popular participation a new hope for development and a challenge for the discipline. In: Chowdhury SR, Denters E, de Waart P (eds) The right to development in international law. Kluwer Law International, pp 61, 78Google Scholar
  34. Haque I, Burdescu R (2004) Monterrey consensus on financing for development: response sought from international economic law. Boston Coll Int Comp Law Rev 27:219, 243Google Scholar
  35. Hill M (1995) What the principle of self-determination means today. ILSA J Int Comp Law 1:119, 121Google Scholar
  36. Hodgson D (2003) Individual duty within a human rights discourse. Ashgate Publishing, pp 15–16Google Scholar
  37. Humphrey (1973) The international law of human rights in the middle of the twentieth century. In: Bos M (ed) The present state of international law. KluwerGoogle Scholar
  38. Kiwanuka R (1988) The meaning of ‘people’ in the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. Am J Int Law 82:80, 81Google Scholar
  39. Knox J (2008) Horizontal human rights law. ASIL 102:1Google Scholar
  40. Knox J (2015) Human rights, environmental protection and the sustainable development goals. Wash Int Law J 24:517Google Scholar
  41. Kunig P (1982) The protection of human rights by international law in Africa. German Yearb Int Law 25:138, 156–159Google Scholar
  42. Kunz J (1953) The nature of customary international law. Am J Int Law 47:662, 665, 667Google Scholar
  43. Laplante L (2007) On the indivisibility of rights: truth commissions, reparations and the right to development. Yale Hum Rights Dev Law J 10:141, 151Google Scholar
  44. Lauterpacht H (1950) International law and human rights. Shoe String PressGoogle Scholar
  45. Lauterpacht H (1958) The development of international law by the international court. Frederick A. Prager, p 191Google Scholar
  46. Leube K (2017) Can the European Union be held accountable for financing development projects that violate human rights? Geo J Int Law 48:1243Google Scholar
  47. Lillich RB, Newman (1979) International human rights. Scott ForesmanGoogle Scholar
  48. Locke J (1952) An essay concerning the true original extent and end of civil government. In: Hutchins R (ed) Great books of the western world, vol 35. Encyclopedia Britannica, pp 61, 55–58Google Scholar
  49. Locke J (1988) In: Laslett P (ed) Two treatises of government. Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
  50. M’Baye K (1972) Le Droit au Developpement comme un droit de l’Homme. Revue Des Droits de L’Homme 5:503, 505Google Scholar
  51. MacNaughton G (2015) Human rights education for all: a proposal for the post-2015 development agenda. Wash Int Law J 23:537Google Scholar
  52. Magraw DB (1990) Legal treatment of developing countries: differential, contextual, and absolute norms. Colo J Int Environ Law Policy 1:69, 73Google Scholar
  53. Marks S (1981) Emerging human rights: a new generation for the 1980’s? Rutgers Law Rev 33:435, 441Google Scholar
  54. Morgan-Foster J (2005) Third generation rights: what Islamic law can teach the international human rights movement. Yale Hum Rights Dev Law J 8:67, 72Google Scholar
  55. Mutua MW (1995) The Banjul Charter and the African cultural fingerprint: an evaluation of the language of duties. Va J Int Law 35:339, 342Google Scholar
  56. Mutua MW (1996) The ideology of human rights. Va J Int Law 36:589Google Scholar
  57. Nanda V (1985) The right to development under international law-challenges ahead. Calif West Int Law J 15:431, 436Google Scholar
  58. Norberg N (2006) The US Supreme Court affirms the Filartiga paradigm. J Int Crim Just 4:387CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Olawuyi D (2015) The emergence of a rights-based approach to governance in Africa: false start or new dawn? Sustain Dev Law Policy 15:13Google Scholar
  60. Olowu D (2004) Human development challenges in Africa: a rights based approach. San Diego Int Law J 50:179, 188Google Scholar
  61. Paul J (1995) The United Nations and the creation of an international law of development. Harv Int Law J 36:307Google Scholar
  62. Peter Mutharika A (1995) The role of international law in the twenty-first century: an African perspective. Fordham Int Law J 18:1706, 1717Google Scholar
  63. Rajagopal B (1993) Crossing the Rubicon: synthesizing the soft international law of the IMF and human rights. Boston Univ Int Law J 11:81, 95Google Scholar
  64. Rousseau JJ (1964) The social contract. In: Hirschfeld C (ed) Classics of western thought 111. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Inc., p 183Google Scholar
  65. Schachter O (1985) International law in theory and practice: general course in public international law. Martinus NijhoffGoogle Scholar
  66. Sen A (1999) Development as freedom. Alfred A. Knopf, p 8Google Scholar
  67. Seppänen S (2017) From substance to absence: argumentative strategies in the implementation of the human rights-based approaches to development. N Y Univ J Int Law Policy 49:389Google Scholar
  68. Sha Alam M (2001) Enforcement of international human rights law by domestic courts in the United States. Ann Surv Int Comp Law 10:27, 30Google Scholar
  69. Shelbourne D (2001) The principle of duty: an. essay on the foundations of the civic order. Sinclair-Stevenson, p 11Google Scholar
  70. Shelton D (2006) Normative hierarchy in international law. Am J Int Law 100:291, 297Google Scholar
  71. Simma B, Alston P (1992) The sources of human rights law: custom, jus cogens, and general principles. Aust Yearb Int Law 12:82, 88Google Scholar
  72. Simpson G (1996) The diffusion of sovereignty: self-determination in the postcolonial age. Stan J Int Law 32:255, 256, 268–269Google Scholar
  73. Sohn L (1978) The shaping of international law. Ga J Int Comp Law 8:1Google Scholar
  74. Sohn L (1982) The new international law: protection of the rights of individuals rather than states. Am Univ Law Rev 32:1, 48Google Scholar
  75. Swanson J (1991) The emergence of new rights in the African Charter. N Y Law School J Int Comp Law 12:307Google Scholar
  76. Totaro M (2008) Legal positivism, constructivism, and international human rights law: the case of participatory development. Va J Int Law 48:714, 737Google Scholar
  77. Umozurike UO (1983) The African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. Am J Int Law 77:902, 907CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Uriz G (2001) To lend or not to lend: oil, human rights and the world bank’s internal contradictions. Harv Hum Rights J 14:197Google Scholar
  79. Vasak K (1977) A 30-year struggle. UNESCO Courier. November, p 29Google Scholar
  80. Vierdag EW (1978) The legal nature of rights granted by the international covenant on economic, social and cultural rights. Neth Yearb Int Law 9:69CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Viljoen F, Louw L (2007) State compliance with the recommendations of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, 1994–2004. Am J Int Law 101:2CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Welch C Jr (1992) The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights: a five-year report and assessment. Hum Rights Q 14:43, 60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Wilson J (1996) Ethnic groups and the right to self-determination. Conn J Int Law 11:433, 460Google Scholar
  84. Young-Anawaty A (1980) Human rights and the ACP-EEC Lomé II Convention: business as usual at the EEC. N Y Univ J Int Law Policy 13:63Google Scholar
  85. Zimmerman A, Baumler J (2010) Current challenges facing the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights. KAS Int Rep 7:38, 49Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  • Rumu Sarkar
    • 1
  1. 1.General CounselMillennium PartnersCharlottesvilleUSA

Personalised recommendations