Advertisement

Are There Ethical Reasons to Preserve Biodiversity Against Local Communities?

  • Bila-Isia InogwabiniEmail author
Chapter
  • 40 Downloads
Part of the Environmental History book series (ENVHIS, volume 12)

Abstract

The chapter is about the conflict between preserving biodiversity and fulfilling the basic human needs of local communities residing within and near protected areas. The chapter argues that local human communities should be allowed to exploit resources within and near protected areas even if that exploitation by human local communities is harmful to biodiversity. A claim is made that all types of biodiversity are not of equal value and do not matter at the same level; there are differences in functions; some species or ecosystems matter more than others. As a defense for this view appeal is made to biological concepts such as trophic levels, keystone species, hotspot areas, and the species redundancy, which all hierarchize biodiversity in different degrees of importance. The chapter also claims that the most convincing argument in defense of biodiversity conservation is to appeal to instrumental values. Biodiversity matters more to humans for the services it provides to human well-being than for any other reasons. In this sense, the argument runs that there might be ethical reasons why harmful human activities by local communities should be allowed. Several strands of arguments, including the biological species redundancy, the ethical notion of the sacredness of human life (right to life), the distributive justice (jus soli, rights of the first occupants and environmental justice) are used in the support the main claim of the chapter that regardless of circumstances, human local communities should be allowed to use natural resources. The chapter finally discusses the possible reconciliation between human basic needs and biodiversity, arguing that partial (at least) reconciliations are possible in most cases through possible hierarchizing harms, accounting for scales, and identifying trade-offs by agreeing with local communities, in a participative process, on what can be extracted by local communities.

Keywords

Biodiversity conservation Human basic needs Local communities Distributive justice Reconciling incommensurable demands 

References

  1. Bosworth A, Chaipraditkul N, Cheng MM, Gupta A, Junmookda K, Kadam P, Macer D, Millet C, Sangaroonthong J, Waller A (2011) Ethics and biodiversity. Asia and Pacific Regional Bureau for Education UNESCO BangkokGoogle Scholar
  2. Callicott JB (1990) Whiter conservation ethics? Conserv Biol 4(1):15–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Callicott JB (1997) Defense of earth’s insights. Worldviews 1:167–182CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Cincotta RP, Wisnewski J, Engelman R (2000) Human population in the biodiversity hotspots. Nature. 404:990–992CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Colwell RK (2009) Biodiversity: concepts, patterns, and measurement. In: Levin SA, Carpenter SR, Godfray HCJ, Kinzig AP, Loreau M, Losos JB, Walker B, Wilcove DS (eds) The Princeton guide to ecology. Princeton University Press, pp 257–263Google Scholar
  6. Costanza R, Fisher B, Ali S, Beer C, Bond L, Boumans R, Danigelis NL, Dickinson J, Elliott C, Farley J, Gayer DE, Glenn LM, Hudspeth TR, MahoneyD F, McCahill L, McIntosh B, Reed B, Rizvi AT, Rizzo DM, Simpatico T, Snapp R (2007) Quality of life: an approach integrating opportunities, humanneeds and subjective well-being. Ecol Econ 61:267–276CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Curry P (2012) Ecological Ethics—A introduction. 2nd edn. Fully revised and expanded. PolityGoogle Scholar
  8. Desjardins JR (2006) Environmental ethics: an introduction to environmental philosophy. BelmontGoogle Scholar
  9. Donner W (2002) Callicott on intrinsic value and moral standing in environmental ethics. In: Ouderkirk W, Hill J (eds) Land. Callicott and Environmental Philosophy. State University of New York Press, Value, Community, pp 99–106Google Scholar
  10. Dworkin R (1993) Life’s dominion: an argument about abortion and euthanasia. Harper Collins PublishersGoogle Scholar
  11. Huggett RJ (1999) Ecosphere, biosphere, or Gaia? What to call the global ecosystem. Global Ecol Biogeogr 8(6):425–431CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Jepson P, Whittekar RJ (2002) Histories of protected areas: internationalisation of conservationist values and their Adoption in the Netherlands Indies (Indonesia). Environ Hist 3:129–172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Kohen A (2006) The problem of secular sacredness: Ronald Dworkin, Michael Perry, and Human Rights Foundationalism. J Human Rights 5:235–256CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Medail F, Quezel P (1999) Biodiversity hotspots in the mediterranean basin: setting global conservation priorities. Conserv Biol 13(6):1510–1513CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Mills SL, Soulé ME, Doak DF (1993) The keystone species concept in ecology and conservation: management and policy must explicitly consider complexity of interactions in natural systems. Bioscience 43(4):219–224CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Minteer BA, Miller TR (2011) The new conservation debate: ethical foundations, strategic trade-offs, and policy opportunities. Biol Conserv 144(3):945–947CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Morgan GJ (2009) The many dimensions of biodiversity. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 40:235–238CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Myers N, Mittermeier RA, Mittermeier CG, Da Fonseca GAB, Kent J (2000) Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403:853–858CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Naeem SC (1998) Species redundancy and ecosystem reliability. Conserv Biol 12(1):39–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Naess A (1995) The deep ecological movement: some philosophical aspects. In: Sessions G (ed) Deep ecology for the twenty-first century. Shambhala, pp 64–84Google Scholar
  21. Neem S, Bunker D, Hector A, Loreau M, Perrings C (2008) Biodiversity, ecosystem functioning and human wellbeing. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  22. Nelson TA, Boots B (2008). Detecting spatial hot spots in landscape ecology. Ecography 31:556–566 (The point cited was quoted from Ord and Getis 2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Odum E, Barrett GW (2004) Fundamentals of ecology. 5th edn. Cengage LearningGoogle Scholar
  24. Rawls J (1999) A theory of justice. Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
  25. Sarkar S (2014) “Ecology”, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring Edition), Zalta EN (Ed) http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/ecology/
  26. Stoecker R (2011) Three crucial turns on the road to an adequate understanding of human dignity. In: Kaufmann P, Kuch H, Neuhauser C, Webster E (eds) Humiliation. Human Dignity Violated, Degradation, Dehumanization, pp 7–17Google Scholar
  27. Takacs D (1996) The idea of biodiversity: Philosophies of Paradise. Johns Hopkins University PressGoogle Scholar
  28. Wilson EO (1990) Biophilia. Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar

Uncited References

  1. Barnes RFW, Majam JN, Asamoah-Boatang B, Agyei-Ohemeng J (2006) The survival of elephant dung piles in relation to forest canopy and slope in southern Ghana. Pachyderm 41:37–43Google Scholar
  2. Bauer H, Van Der Merwe S (2004) Inventory of free-ranging lions Panthera leo in Africa. Oryx 38(1):26–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Brugiere D (2005) Monkey community structure in the old growth forests of the Lope reserve, Gabon. Afr J Ecol 43:70–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Brugière D, Fleury MC (2000) Estimating primate densities using line transect and home range methods: comparative test with the black colobus monkey Colobus satanas. Primates 41:373–382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Brugière D, Gautier JP, Moungazi A, Gautier-Hion A (2002) Primate diet and Biomass in relation to vegetation composition and fruiting phenology in a Rain Forest in Gabon. Int J Primatol 23(5):999–1024CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Chapman CA (2000) Constraints on Group Size in Red Colobus and Red-tailed guenons: examining the generality of the ecological constraints model. Int J Primatol 21(4):565–595CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Chapman CA, Peres CA (2001) Primate conservation in the new millennium: the role of scientists. Evolution Anthropol 10:16–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Chapman CA, Lambert JE (2000) Habitat alteration and the conservation of African primates: a case study of Kibale National Park, Uganda. Am J Primatol 50:169–186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Chapman CA, Lawes MJ, Eeley HAC (2006) What hope for African primate diversity? Afr J Ecol 44:116–133CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Chapman CA, Chapman LJ, Cords M, Gathua JM, Gautier-Hion A, Lambert JE, Rode K, Tutin CE, White LJ (2002) Variation in the diets of cercopithecus species: differences within forests, among forests, and across species. In Glenn ME, Cords M (eds) The Guenons: Diversity and Adaptation in African Monkeys. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, pp 325–350Google Scholar
  11. Chapman CA, Balcomb SR, Gillepsie TR, Skorupa JP, Struhsaker TT (2000) Long-term effects of logging on African primate communities; a 28-year comparison from Kibale National Park. Uganda. Conservation Biology 14(1):207–217CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cords M (eds) The Guenons: Diversity and Adaptation in African Monkeys. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, pp 325–350Google Scholar
  13. Ellis CM (2001) The influential role of women in the commercial bushmeat trade in Cameroon. In: The Great Apes: Challenges for the 21st Century. Conference proceedings, Brookfield Zoo, pp 227–229Google Scholar
  14. Gautier-Hion A, Brugiere D (2005) Significance of Riparian Forests for the conservation of Central African Primates. Int J Primatol 26(3):515–523CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Gouvernement de la République du Zaïre (1984) Droit du Travail I: Code du Travail. Kinshasa Gombe, République Démocratique du Congo, Editions du CADICECGoogle Scholar
  16. Gouvernement de la République Démocratique du Congo (2004) Contrat social de l’innovation entre le gouvernement et les syndicats de l’administration publique et interprofessionnels. Mbudi 12 Février 2004Google Scholar
  17. Inogwabini BI (in preparation) The Ethno-botanical knowledge of Ngömbë, Democratic Republic of Congo: A preliminary assessmentGoogle Scholar
  18. Inogwabini BI (2008) Etudes des possibilités de transmission des maladies entre les animaux domestiques, les animaux sauvages et les populations humaines—protocole de collecte des données pour le programme Santé Animale. typescripted document submitted to WWF US and USAIDGoogle Scholar
  19. Inogwabini BI, Mputu (2010) Evaluation de la qualité de l’eau des rivières de basse altitude dans la zone de Malebo pendant la saison sèche: cas de Bambou. Lebomo et Bongo, Typescript report submitted to WWF and USAID CARPE KinshasaGoogle Scholar
  20. Kingdon J (1987) The Kingdom Field Guide to African Mammals. Academic PressGoogle Scholar
  21. Koyo JP, Foteu R (Undated) Harmonization of forest policies and programmes in Central Africa. http://www.fao.org/docrep/009/a0970e/a0970e11.htm
  22. Liu W, Li Y, Shaw KS, Learn GH, Plenderleith LJ, Malenke JA, Sundararaman SA, Ramirez MA, Crystal PA, Smith AG, Bibollet-Ruche F (2013) African origin of the malaria parasite Plasmodium vivax. Nat Commun 5(3346):1–10.  https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms4346
  23. Magnuson L (2005) Conservation of African monkeys. Int J Primatol 26(3):511–513CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. McGraw S (1994) Census, habitat preference, and polyspecific associations of six monkeys in the Lomako Forest, Zaire. Am J Primatol 34:296–307CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Mittermeier RA, Valladares-Pádua C, Rylands AB, Eudey AA, Butynski TM, Ganzhorn JU, Kormos R, Aguiar JM, Walker S (2006) Primates in Peril: The World’s 25 Most Endangered Primates, 2004–2006. Primate Conserv 20:1–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Mittermeier RA, Rylands AB, Konstant WR (2004) IUCN/SSC Primate Specialist Group Report 2001–2004. International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)Google Scholar
  27. N’sosso D (1997) Problématique de Gestion de L’EIéphant d’Afrique dans la Réserve de Faune de Conkouati, au Kouilou (Congo). Pachyderm 23:50–58Google Scholar
  28. Oates JF, Whitesides GH, Davies AG, Waterman PG, Green SM, Dasilva GL, Mole S (1990) Determinants of variation in tropical forest primate biomass: New evidence from West Africa. Ecology 71:328–343CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Plato, 360 B.C.E. Timaeus and Critias. Translated by Lee D (1972) Penguin Books Ltd.Google Scholar
  30. Pope Paul VI (1967) Populorum Progressio: Encyclical Letter of His Holiness on the Human Development. VaticanGoogle Scholar
  31. Straede S, Helles F (2000) Park-people conflict resolution in Royal Chitwan National Park, Nepal: buying time at high cost? Environmental Conservation 27:368–381CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Thomas S (1991) Population densities and patterns of habitat use among anthropoid primates of the Ituri Forest, Zaire. Biotropica 23:68–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Tutin CEG, White LJT (1999) The recent evolutionary past of primate communities: Likely environmental impacts during the past three millennia. In Fleagle JG, Janson C, Reed KE (eds) Primate communities. Cambridge University Press, pp 220–236Google Scholar
  34. Uehara S, Ihobe H (1998) Distribution and abundance of diurnal mammals, especially monkeys, at Kasoje, Mahale Mountains, Tanzania. Anthropol Sci 106:349–369CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Walker EP, Warnick F, Hamlet SE, Lange KI, Davis MA, Uible HE, Wright PF, Paradiso JL (1964) Mammals of the world, Volume II. The Johns Hopkins PressGoogle Scholar
  36. White LJT (1994) Biomass of rain forest mammals in the Lope´ Reserve, Gabon. J Animal Ecol 63:499–512CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. White F (1983) The vegetation of Africa: a descriptive memoire to accompany the UNESCO vegetation map of Africa (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization)/AETFA (Association pour l’Etude Taxonomique de la Flore d’Afrique Tropicale). ParisGoogle Scholar
  38. Whitesides GH, Oates JF, Green SM, Kluberdanz RP (1988) Estimating primate densities from transects in a West African rain forest: a comparison of techniques. J Animal Ecol 57:345–367CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) (Undated) Congo Basin Forest Partnership: a unifying Force at Work in the Congo Basin. Available on the website http://www.worldwildlife.org/what/wherewework/congo/WWFBinaryitem8854.pdf

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Center for Research and Communication in Sustainable Development (CERED)The Jesuit Loyola University of CongoKinshasaCongo, Republic

Personalised recommendations