Advertisement

Disability Justice in an African Legal Philosophical Context

  • Oche OnaziEmail author
Chapter
Part of the Ius Gentium: Comparative Perspectives on Law and Justice book series (IUSGENT, volume 78)

Abstract

This chapter develops the central argument of the book. It proposes an African legal philosophy from a relational community ideal as a plausible and attractive way of defining disability justice. It argues that, although Africa’s rich customary and pluralist legal and intellectual heritage provides the most obvious foundation on which to define African legal philosophy, they are too heterogeneous and inherently descriptive to ground disability justice in necessary, sufficient, normative, general and universal terms. After demonstrating the difficulty with defining disability justice through Africa’s customary and pluralist heritage, the chapter outlines and defends a relational community conception of the ideal. Conceived as an African legal philosophy of disability justice, the proposal is offered as an alternative criterion for evaluating, criticising and modifying existing legal and political institutions, as well as for creating new ones to include and respond to the needs and dependencies of people with disabilities within the diverse communities across Africa.

Keywords

African legal philosophy Customary law Legal pluralism Community Relationships Obligations 

References

  1. Agbakoba J, Nwauche E (2006) African conceptions of justice, responsibility and punishment. Cambr Law Rev 37(73):33–84Google Scholar
  2. Ahiauzu N (2006) Ubuntu and the obligation to obey the law. Cambr Law Rev 37:17–36Google Scholar
  3. Allot A (1984) What is to be done with African Customary Law? The experience of problems and reforms in Anglophone Africa from 1950. J Afr Law 28(1/2):56–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Arowosegebe J (2017) Indigenous African jurisprudential thoughts on the concept of justice: a reconstruction through Yoruba proverbs. J Afr Law 61(2):155–170CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Ayinla L (2002) African philosophy of law: a critique. J Int Comp Law 6:147–168Google Scholar
  6. Bankowski Z (2001) Living lawfully: law in love and law in love. Springer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  7. Bederman D (2010) Custom as a source of law. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Behrens K (2014) An African relational environmentalism and moral considerability. Philos Asp Environ Probl 36(1):63–82Google Scholar
  9. Bell R (2002) Understanding African philosophy: a cross-cultural approach to classic and contemporary issues. Routledge, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  10. Bennett T (1991) The compatibility of African customary law and women’s rights. Acta Jurid 18:18–35Google Scholar
  11. Bennett T (2008) African customary law. In: The new oxford companion in law. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  12. Bennett T (2011) Ubuntu: an African equity. Potchefstroom Electron Law J 14(4):29–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bennett T et al (2012) African perspectives in tradition and justice. Intersentia, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  14. Bilchitz D et al (2017) Jurisprudence in an African context. Oxford University Press, South AfricaGoogle Scholar
  15. Bohler-Muller N (2007) Beyond legal metanarratives: the interrelationship between storytelling, ubuntu and care. Stellenbosch Law Rev 18:133–160Google Scholar
  16. Boisen C, Murray M (2016) Distributive justice debates in political and social thought: perspectives on finding a fair share. Routledge, New York and LondonGoogle Scholar
  17. Bond J (2010) Gender, discourse and customary law in Africa. South Calif Law Rev 83:509–574Google Scholar
  18. Boriane A (2000) A country unmasked: inside South Africa's Truth and Reconcilation Commission. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  19. Bujo B (2001) Foundations of an African ethic: beyond the universal claims of western morality. Crossroad Publishing Company, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  20. Chappell T (2014) Knowing what to do: imagination, virtue, and platonism in ethics. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Chiba M (1984) Cultural universality and particularity of jurisprudence. In: Marasinge M et al (eds) Essays in third world perspectives in jurisprudence. Malayan Law J, pp 302–326Google Scholar
  22. Chimakonam J (2017) African philosophy and global epistemic injustice. J Glob Ethics 13(2):120–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Christodoulidis E, Veitch S (eds) (2001) Lethe’s law: justice, law and ethics in reconciliation. Hart Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  24. Clark P (2011) The Gacaca courts, post-genocide justice and reconciliation in Rwanda: justice without lawyers. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  25. Cornell D (2014) Law and revolution in South Africa: ubuntu, dignity and the struggle for constitutional transformation. Fordham University Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Cornell D, Muvangua N (2012) uBuntu and the law: African ideals and postapartheid jurisprudence. Fordham University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  27. Cotterrell R (2003) The politics of jurisprudence: a critical introduction to legal philosophy. Oxford University Press, USAGoogle Scholar
  28. Cotterrell R (2014) Why jurisprudence is not legal philosophy. Jurisprudence 5(1):41–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Crowe J (2015) The limits of legal pluralism. Griffith Law Review 24(2):314–331CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Davies M (2005) The ethos of pluralism. Sydney Law Rev 27:87Google Scholar
  31. de Sousa Santos B (1987) Law: a map of misreading. Toward a postmodern conception of law. J Law Soc 14(3):279–302Google Scholar
  32. Demian M (2014) On the repugnancy of customary law. Comp Stud Soc Hist 56(2):508–536CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Diala A (2017) The concept of living customary law: a critique. J Legal Plur Unoff Law 49(2):143–165CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Douglas-Scott S (2013) Law after modernity. Hart Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  35. Douzinas C, Gearey A (2005) Critical jurisprudence: the political philosophy of justice. Hart Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  36. Driberg J (1934) The African conception of law. J Comp Legis Int Law 16(4):230–245Google Scholar
  37. Elegido J (1994) Jurisprudence. Spectrum Law Publishing, IbadamGoogle Scholar
  38. Elias T (1956) The nature of African customary law. University of Manchester, ManchesterGoogle Scholar
  39. Engle S (1988) Legal pluralism. Law Soc Rev 22(5):869–898CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Etieyibo E (2017) Ubuntu, cosmopolitanism, and distribution of natural resources. Philos Pap 46(1):139–162CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Etieyibo E, Omiegbe O (2016) Religion, culture and discrimination against persons with disabilities in Nigeria. Afr J Disabil 5(1):192Google Scholar
  42. Fenrich J et al (2011) The future of African customary law. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Flikschuh K (2016) The arc of personhood: Menkiti and Kant on becoming and being a person. J Am Philos Assoc 2(3):437–455CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Flikschuh K (2017) Should African thinkers engage in the global justice debate? Philos Pap 46(1):33–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Fombad C (2014) Gender equality in African customary law: has the male ultimogeniture rule any future in Botswana? J Afr Stud 52(3):475–494CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Gade C (2013) Restorative justice and South African truth and reconciliation process. South Afr J Philos 32(1):10–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Galanter M (1981) Justice in many rooms: courts, private ordering, and indigenous law. J Legal Plur 19:1–18Google Scholar
  48. Gearey A (2003) African Nietzsche: poetry, philosophy and African legal thinking. Cardozo Law Rev 24(3):903–953Google Scholar
  49. Gebeye B (2017a) Legal theory in Africa: between legal centralism and legal pluralism. Queen Mary Law J 37–38Google Scholar
  50. Gebeye B (2017b) Decoding legal pluralism in Africa. J Legal Plur Unoff Law 49(2):228–249CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Graness A (2015) Is the debate on ‘global justice’ a global one? Some considerations in view of modern philosophy in Africa. J Glob Ethics 11(1):126–140CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Graness A (2017) Concepts of justice in Africa: past and present. In: Ukpolo I (ed) Themes, issues, and problems in African philosophy. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, pp 305–331CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Griffiths J (1986) What is legal pluralism? J Legal Plur Unoff Law 24:1–56Google Scholar
  54. Griffiths J (2005) The idea of sociology of law and its relation to law and to sociology. Curr Legal Issues 49(8):63–64Google Scholar
  55. Groce N et al (2014) Inheritance, poverty, and disability. Disabil Soc 29(10):1554–1568CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Gross A (2004) Reconciliation in South Africa. Stanf J Int Law 40:40–107Google Scholar
  57. Grut L et al (2012) Disability and barriers in Kenya. In: Eide A, Ingstad B (eds) Disability and poverty: a global challenge. Bristol University Press, Bristol, pp 153–170Google Scholar
  58. Gyekye K (1995) An essay on African philosophical thought: the Akan conceptual scheme. Temple University Press, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  59. Gyekye K (1996) African cultural values: an introduction. Sankofa Publishing Company, AccraGoogle Scholar
  60. Gyekye K (1997) Tradition and modernity: philosophical reflections on the African person. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Hallen B, Sodipo J (1997) Knowledge, belief and witchcraft: analytic experiments in African Philosophy. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  62. Hegel G (1959) The philosophy of history (trans: Sibree J). Dover Publications, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  63. Himonga C et al (2013) Reflections on judicial views of ubuntu. Potchefstroom Electron Law J 16(5):370–615Google Scholar
  64. Himonga C et al (eds) (2014) African customary law in South Africa: post-apartheid and living law perspectives. Oxford University Press, South AfricaGoogle Scholar
  65. Hountondji P (1970) Comments on contemporary African philosophy. Diogenes 71:120–140Google Scholar
  66. Idowu W (2006) African jurisprudence and the reconciliation theory of law. Cambr Law Rev 37:1–16Google Scholar
  67. Kenneth K (2006) Labia elongation under African customary law: a violation of women’s rights. Int J Hum Rights 10(4):341–357CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Kirby C (2006) Rwanda’s gacaca courts: a preliminary critique. J Afr Law 50(2):94–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Kittay E (1999) Love’s labor: essays in women, equality and dependency. Routledge, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  70. Kroeze I (2002) Doing things with values II: the case of ubuntu. Stellenbosch Law Rev 13:252–264Google Scholar
  71. Ladd J (1998) The idea of community, an ethical exploration, part II: community as a system of social and moral interrelationships. J Value Inq 32:153–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Lauer H (2017) Global justice as process: applying normative ideals of indigenous African governance. Philos Pap 46(1):163–189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Livingston J (2005) Debility and the moral imagination in Botswana. Indiana University Press, BloomingtonGoogle Scholar
  74. Lotter H (1993) Justice for an unjust society. Rodopi B.V. Editions, AmsterdamGoogle Scholar
  75. Mabogo M (2004) Philosophy in South Africa under and after Apartheid. In: Wiredu K (ed) A companion to African philosophy. Blackwell Publishing Ltd., New York, pp 149–160Google Scholar
  76. Mamdani M (1996) Citizen and subject: contemporary Africa and the legacy of late colonialism. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  77. Mamdani M (2002) Amnesty or impunity? A preliminary critique of the report of the truth and reconciliation commission of South Africa Report (TRC). Ethics 32(3/4):32–59Google Scholar
  78. Mangena F (2015) Restorative justice’s deep roots in Africa. South Afr J Philos 34(1):1–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Masaka D (2017) ‘Global justice’ and the suppressed epistemologies of the indigenous people of Africa. Philos Pap 46(1):59–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Mawhinney E (2015) On restorative justice in post-genocide in South Africa and Rwanda. J Public Law Policy 36(2):21–52Google Scholar
  81. McCrary L (2017) Re-envisioning independence and community: critiques from the independent living movement and L’Arche. J Soc Philos 48(3):377–393CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Melissaris E (2009) Ubiquitous law: legal theory and the space for legal pluralism. Routledge, Ashgate, AldershotGoogle Scholar
  83. Menkiti I (1984) Person and community in African traditional thought. In: Wright R (ed) African philosophy: an introduction. University Press of America, New York, pp 171–181Google Scholar
  84. Menkiti I (2017) Africa and global justice. Philos Pap 46(1):13–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Menski W (2006) Comparative law in a global context: the legal systems of Asia and Africa. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Metz T (2011) An African theory of dignity and a relational conception of poverty. In: de Gruchy J (ed) The humanist imperative in South Africa. African Sun Media, Stellenbosch, pp 233–242Google Scholar
  87. Metz T (2012) An African theory of moral status: a relational alternative to individualism and holism. Ethical Theory Moral Pract 15:387–402CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Metz T (2013) The western ethic of care or an Afrocommunitarian ethic? Specifying the right relational morality. J Glob Ethics 9(1):77–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Metz T (2015) An African egalitarianism: bringing community to bear on equality. In: Hull G (ed) The equal society: essays on equality in theory and practice. Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, pp 185–208Google Scholar
  90. Metz T (2016a) An African theory of social justice. In: Boisen C, Murray M (eds) Distributive justice debates in political and social thought: perspectives on finding a fair share. Routledge, New York and London, pp 171–190Google Scholar
  91. Metz T (2016b) The nature of poverty as an unhuman condition. Res Publica 22(3):327–342CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Metz T (2017a) South Africa’s truth and reconciliation commission in light of Ubuntu: a comprehensive appraisal. In: Swart M, van Marle K (eds) The limits of transition: the South African truth and reconciliation commission 20 years on. Brill, Netherlands, pp 221–252Google Scholar
  93. Metz T (2017b) Replacing development: an Afro-communal approach to global justice. Philos Pap 46(1):111–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Metz T (2019) Distributive justice as a matter of love: a relational approach to liberty and property. In: Dalferth I (ed) Love and justice. Mohr Siebeck (forthcoming, author’s copy, unpublished manuscript)Google Scholar
  95. Metz T, Gaie J (2010) The African ethic of Ubuntu/Botho: implications for research on morality. J Moral Educ 39(3):273–290CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. Mokgoro Y (2012) uBuntu and the Law in South Africa. In: Cornell D, Muvangua N (eds) Ubuntu and the Law: African ideals and postapartheid jurisprudence. Fordham University Press, New York, pp 317–323Google Scholar
  97. Moore S (1973) Law and social change: the semi-autonomous field as an appropriate subject of study. Law Soc 7(4):719–746CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Mostert M (2016) Stigma as a barrier to the implementation of the convention on the rights of persons with disabilities in Africa. Afr Disabil Rights Yearbook 4:3–24Google Scholar
  99. Munsaka E, Charnley H (2013) We do not have chiefs who are disabled: disability, development and culture in a continuing complex emergency. Disabil Soc 28(6):756–769CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Murphy J (2014) The philosophy of customary law. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Murungi J (2004) The question of African jurisprudence: some hermeneutic reflections. In: Wiredu K (ed) A companion to African philosophy. Blackwell Publishing Ltd., New York, pp 396–403Google Scholar
  102. Murungi J (2013) An introduction to African legal philosophy. Lexington Books, Lanham, MDGoogle Scholar
  103. Mwalimu N (1986) The need for a functionalist jurisprudence for developing countries in Africa. Third World Legal Stud 5(4):39–52Google Scholar
  104. Naffine N (2013) Review essay: the liberal legal individual accused: the relational case. Can J Law Soc 29(1):123–132CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Ndulo M (2011) African customary law, customs, and women’s rights. Indiana J Glob Legal Stud 18(1):87–120CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  106. Nekam A (1996) Experiences in African customary law. Edinburgh University Press, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
  107. Nelsen T (2008) Inheritance and disinheritance: African customary law and constitutional rights. J Relig 88:466CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  108. Nwakeze PC (1987) A critique of Olufemi Taiwo’s criticism of “legal positivism and African legal tradition”. Int Philos Q 1:101–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  109. Nyerere J (1968) Ujamaa: essays on socialism. Oxford University Press, Dar es SalaamGoogle Scholar
  110. Okafor F (1984) Legal positivism and the African legal tradition. Int Philos Q 24(2):157–164CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  111. Okafor F (2006) From praxis to theory: a discourse on the philosophy of African law. Cambr Law Rev 37:38–39Google Scholar
  112. Okeja U (2017) Introduction: globalizing or transcending global justice? Philos Pap 46(1):1–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  113. Oladosu J (2001) Choosing legal theory on cultural grounds: an African case for legal positivism. West Afr Rev 2(2)Google Scholar
  114. Onazi O (2013) Human rights from community: a rights-based approach to development. Edinburgh University Press, EdinburghCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  115. Onazi O (2014) Before rights and responsibilities: an African ethos of citizenship. In: Onazi O (ed) African legal theory and contemporary problems: critical essays. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 53–172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  116. Onyango P (2013) African customary law: an introduction. Law African Publishing Ltd., NairobiGoogle Scholar
  117. Oruka O (1989) The philosophy of foreign aid: a question of the right to a human minimum. Praxis Int 8(4):465–475Google Scholar
  118. Oruka O (1997) Practical philosophy: in search of an ethical minimum. East African Educational Publishers, NairobiGoogle Scholar
  119. Park A (2010) Community-based restorative transitional justice in Sierra Leone. Contemp Justice Rev 13(1):95–119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  120. Perreau-Saussine A, Murphy J (2007) The nature of customary law: legal, historical and philosophical perspectives. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  121. Quashigah K (2016) Justice in the traditional African society within the modern constitutional set-up. Jurisprudence 7(1):93–110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  122. Ramose M (2001) An African perspective on justice and race. Polylog: Forum Intercult Philos 3. https://them.polylog.org/3/frm-en.htm. Accessed 29 Jan 2019
  123. Renteln A (2004) The cultural defense. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  124. Roberts S (1998) Against legal pluralism: some contemporary reflections on the broadening of the legal domain. J Legal Plur 42:92–106Google Scholar
  125. Sanders M (2007) Ambiguities of witnessing: law and literature in the time of a truth commission. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CAGoogle Scholar
  126. Shutte A (2001) Ubuntu: an ethic for the new South Africa. Cluster Publications, Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  127. Silvers A (1998) Formal justice. In: Silvers A et al (eds) Disability, difference, discrimination. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Inc., Lanham, MD, pp 13–145Google Scholar
  128. Snyder F (1984) Customary law and the economy. J Afr Law 281(2):34CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  129. Taiwo O (1984) Legal positivism and the African legal tradition: a reply. Int Philos Q 25(2):197–200CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  130. Tamanaha B (2000) A non-essentialist version of legal pluralism. J Law Soc 27(2):296–321CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  131. Tamanaha B (2008) Understanding legal pluralism: past to present, local to global. Sydney Law Rev 30:375–411Google Scholar
  132. Tangwa G (2000) The traditional African perception of a person: some implications for bioethics. Hastings Cent Rep 30(5):39–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  133. Toufayan M (2014) When British justice (in African colonies) points two ways: on dualism, hybridity, and the genealogy of juridical negritude in Taslim Olawale Elias. In: Onazi O (ed) African legal theory and contemporary problems. Critical essays. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 31–70Google Scholar
  134. Tutu D (1999) No future without forgiveness: a personal overview of South Africa’s truth and reconciliation commission. Random House, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  135. Twining W (2010) Normative and legal pluralism: a global perspective. Duke J Int Const Law 20:413–517Google Scholar
  136. Uchechukwu E (2002) Post-colonialism, gender, customary injustice: widows in African societies. Hum Rights Q 24:424–486CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  137. Van der Walt Y (2006) Law as sacrifice: towards a post-apartheid theory of law. Routledge, AbindonGoogle Scholar
  138. Vanier J (1995) The heart of L’Arche: a spirituality for everyday. Novalis, TrontoGoogle Scholar
  139. von Benda-Beckmann F (2002) Who is afraid of legal pluralism? J Legal Plur 47:37–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  140. Walker N (2002) The idea of constitutional pluralism. Mod Law Rev 65:317–359CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  141. Walker N (2016) Constitutional pluralism revisited. European Law Journal 22(3):333–355CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  142. Warren A (2000) Moral status: obligations to person and other living things. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  143. Weil S (1987) Are we struggling for justice? (trans: Barabas M). Philos Investig 10(1):1–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  144. Weil S (2005) Human personality. In: Miles S (ed) Simone Weil: an anthology. Penguin Books, London, pp 70–98Google Scholar
  145. Weil S (2009) Waiting for god (trans: Craufurd E). Harper Collins Publishers, LondonGoogle Scholar
  146. White C (1965) African customary law: the problem of concept and definition. J Afr Law 9(2):86–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  147. William I, Oke M (2008) Multiculturalism, legal pluralism and the separability thesis: a postmodern critique of ‘an African case for legal pluralism’. Law Soc Justice Glob Dev 2Google Scholar
  148. Wiredu K (1992) The moral foundations of an African culture. In: Wiredu K, Gyekye K (eds) Person and community: Ghanaian philosophical studies. The Council for Research in Values and Philosophy, Washington, DC, pp 193–206Google Scholar
  149. Witney S (2011) Dependency relations: corporeal vulnerability and norms of personhood in Hobbes and Kittay. Hypatia 26(3):554–574CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  150. Woodman R (1996) Legal pluralism and the search for justice. J Afr Stud 40(2):152–167Google Scholar
  151. Woodman G, Obilade A (1995) African law and legal theory. Dartmouth Publishing Co Ltd., AldershotGoogle Scholar
  152. Yamamoto E (1997) Race apologies. J Gend Race Justice 1:47–88Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of SouthamptonSouthamptonUK

Personalised recommendations