Advertisement

Psychodynamic Therapy: A Cross-Cultural and Generational Failure

  • Kathryn Anne Nel
  • Saraswathie Govender
Chapter
  • 32 Downloads

Abstract

One of the main deficiencies in terms of using therapeutic and theoretical models in psychology on the African continent is the fact that it stems from individualistic theories with western philosophical underpinnings. It became clear to the authors that in a diverse, African cultural setting, because of its theoretical underpinnings, this type of therapy has little efficacy. In one institution in South Africa, the ‘golden hour’, where if the client does not speak, the therapist does not speak, is still taught as an element of psychodynamic therapy. This is all well and good for middle-aged to elderly persons from a western cultural background (baby boomers) but is doomed to failure in an African setting as their sociocultural history is not related to western historical traditions. However, it is taught in many institutions in the country and is widely practised, as until 25 years ago, the African majority was ruled (through Apartheid) by a small white minority, who held western practices in high esteem. Change in teaching psychologists has been slow; thus African culture is nominally or not utilised when teaching therapeutic principles. We would also assert that this is frequently true for many of the ‘cut and paste’ generation or postmillennials as well. There will be much criticism about these assertions; however, this chapter aims to show how failures and misunderstandings brought about by using psychodynamic therapy cause much confusion and typically doomed to failure. A brief overview of the key points in Klein’s, Winnicott’s and Fairbairn’s work will be provided. This will be followed by an illustration of African collectivism and caregiving which relates to contemporary society and a sketch of millennial clients from other backgrounds and how these do not relate to psychodynamic concepts. Case study examples outlining how psychodynamic therapy failed in these settings will also be given.

Keywords

Mistakes Errors Failure African Collectivism Culture Individualism Psychodynamic Western therapeutic and theoretical models in psychology on the African continent 

References

  1. Aziz, R., Salam, A., & El-Soud, F.A. (2012). Caregivers burden from caring with impaired elderly: A cross-sectional study in rural Egypt. Italian Journal of Public Health, 9(4), 1–10.Google Scholar
  2. Barlow K. (2004). Critiquing the “Good Enough” Mother: A Perspective Based on the Murik of Papua New Guinea. Ethos, 32(4), 514–537.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bejtkovy, J. (2016). The current generations: the Baby Boomers, X, Y and Z in the context of Human Capital Management of the 21st century in selected corporations in the Czech Republic. Littera Scripta [online] 9(2), 25–45Google Scholar
  4. Burton, E.S. (2016). Ronald Fairburn. Retrieved from https://psychoanalysis.org.uk/our-authors-and-theorists/ronald-fairbairn
  5. Dalal, A.S. (2001). A greater psychology. New York: NY: Library of Congress.Google Scholar
  6. Fairbairn, W. R. D. (1952). An object-relations theory of the personality. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
  7. Kelly, Y., Zilanawala, A., Booker, C., & Sacker, A. (2018). Social media use and mental health: findings from the UK millennium cohort study. EClinical Medicine, 6, 59–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Main, D. (2017). Who are the millennials? Retrieved from https://www.livescience.com/38061-millennials-generation-y.html
  9. Makhubela, M. (2016). From psychology in Africa to African psychology: going nowhere slowly. PINS, 52, 1–18.Google Scholar
  10. Mcleod, S. (2017). Psychodynamic approach. Retrieved from https://www.simplypsychology.org/psychodynamic.html
  11. Mitchell, S.A. & Black, M.J. (1995). Freud and beyond. New York, N.J., Basic Books.Google Scholar
  12. Pharr, J.R., Francis, C.D., Terry, C., & Clark, M.C. (2014). Culture, caregiving and health: Exploring the influence of culture on family caregiver experiences. Journal of Public Health, 1–8.Google Scholar
  13. Pyke, K.D. & Bengtson, V. (1996). Caring more less: collectivistic systems of family eldercare. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 58(2), 371–392.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Reher, D.S. (1998). Family ties in Western Europe. Persistent contrasts. Population and Development Review, 24(2), 203–234.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Reyers, M.L. (2018). Cultural moderators of the influence of environmental affordances and provisions on children’s subjective well-being. Research, 12 (1), 71–98.Google Scholar
  16. Rodman, F.R. (2004). Winnicott life and work. USA: Da Capo Press.Google Scholar
  17. Rubens, R.L. (n.d.). Fairburn’s structural theory. Retrieved from http://www.columbia.edu/~rr322/FAIRBAIRN.html
  18. Sampson, T. & Roger, M. (2014). Applying a mental health recovery approach for people from diverse backgrounds: The case of collectivism and individualism paradigms. Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation and Mental Health, 1(!), 7–13.Google Scholar
  19. Stein, J. (2013). Millennials the me-me generation. Retrieved from https://time.com/247/millennials-the-me-me-me-generation/
  20. Tabaka, M. (2018). Some see millennials as lazy and entitled: yet they may be the most successful generation of our time. Retrieved from https://www.inc.com/marla-tabaka/some-see-millennials-as-lazy-entitled-yet-they-may-be-most-successful-generation-of-our-time.html
  21. Winnicott, D. W. (1958). Through paediatrics to psychoanalysis. London: Hogarth.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kathryn Anne Nel
    • 1
  • Saraswathie Govender
    • 1
  1. 1.University of LimpopoSovengaSouth Africa

Personalised recommendations